Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Challenges in Post-Quantum Security Reductions

Patrick Struck

Published Jan 1, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.18420/cdm-2018-29-03

Related papers

Post-quantum Security in Blockchain Layer-2 Solutions: Challenges and Approaches

Nouhaila Hanbali, Ahmed El-Yahyaoui

Lecture notes in networks and systems•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

How to Prove Post-quantum Security for Succinct Non-interactive Reductions

Alessandro Chiesa, Zijing Di, Zihan Hu +1 more

Lecture notes in computer science•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation

A Note on Quantum Security for Post-Quantum Cryptography

Fang Song

Shor's quantum factoring algorithm and a few other efficient quantum algorithms break many classical crypto-systems. In response, people proposed post-quantum cryptography based on computational problems that are believed hard even for quantum computers. However, security of these schemes against \emph{quantum} attacks is elusive. This is because existing security analysis (almost) only deals with classical attackers and arguing security in the presence of quantum adversaries is challenging due to unique quantum features such as no-cloning. This work proposes a general framework to study which classical security proofs can be restored in the quantum setting. Basically, we split a security proof into (a sequence of) classical security reductions, and investigate what security reductions are "quantum-friendly". We characterize sufficient conditions such that a classical reduction can be "lifted" to the quantum setting. We then apply our lifting theorems to post-quantum signature schemes. We are able to show that the classical generic construction of hash-tree based signatures from one-way functions and and a more efficient variant proposed in~\cite{BDH11} carry over to the quantum setting. Namely, assuming existence of (classical) one-way functions that are resistant to efficient quantum inversion algorithms, there exists a quantum-secure signature scheme. We note that the scheme in~\cite{BDH11} is a promising (post-quantum) candidate to be implemented in practice and our result further justifies it. Finally we demonstrate the generality of our framework by showing that several existing works (Full-Domain hash in the quantum random-oracle model~\cite{Zha12ibe} and the simple hybrid arguments framework in~\cite{HSS11}) can be reformulated under our unified framework.

arXiv:1409.2187•Sep 8, 2014•10 citations

Quantum Computing: Implications for Security

ROBERT M. SLADE

•Mar 17, 2008•0 citations

A Survey on Security Reductions in Post-Quantum Cryptography

Thomas Attema, Ronald Cramer, Serge Fehr +3 more

It is obviously necessary that the security of post-quantum cryptographic schemes is based on computational problems that are hard to solve even with a quantum computer (unlike, e.g., factoring). Examples of such computational problems appear in the theory of lattices or in coding theory. However, this is not sufficient: also the security proof, which comes in the form of an algorithmic reduction that turns any hypothetical attacker into an algorithm that solves the considered hard computational problem, needs to be valid when considering quantum computing as the model of computation. In this work, we provide an overview of the hurdles one typically encounters when proving the security of post-quantum cryptographic schemes, and we elaborate on some of the mathematical techniques that have been developed in order to overcome these hurdles (to some extent). We also analyze the caveat that even when a security proof can be established (by reducing the security to a quantum-hard computational problem), the reduction often suffers from a larger reduction loss, compared to when proving classical security, which negatively affects the concrete security. In the second part of this work, we offer a survey of the respective reduction losses in (1) generic transformations that are often used in the design of cryptographic schemes (like the Fiat-Shamir and Fujisaki-Okamoto transformations), and (2) some concrete cryptographic schemes (with a focus on those standardized by NIST), when considering classical and when considering post-quantum security. Finally, we investigate how these reduction losses translate into bit security, the standard measure of the concrete security of a cryptographic scheme (or of the hardness of an underlying computational problem). A natural question is how the bit security is affected by the different reduction losses we encountered. Surprisingly, we observe that a better or worse reduction (in terms of the reduction loss) is not always reflected as such in the bit security. We explain this phenomenon by the fact that the bit security is oblivious to the actual advantage–time function, and instead considers a worst-case behavior of that function. Thus, by exploiting the actual advantage–time function there is potential to get more accurate (i.e., less conservative) estimates for the concrete security.

IACR Communications in Cryptology•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Computing: Implications for Security

Robert Slade

Auerbach Publications eBooks•Mar 17, 2008•0 citations
Shor's quantum factoring algorithm and a few other efficient quantum algorithms break many classical crypto-systems. In response, people proposed post-quantum cryptography based on computational problems that are believed hard even for quantum computers. However, security of these schemes against \emph{quantum} attacks is elusive. This is because existing security analysis (almost) only deals with classical attackers and arguing security in the presence of quantum adversaries is challenging due to unique quantum features such as no-cloning. This work proposes a general framework to study which classical security proofs can be restored in the quantum setting. Basically, we split a security proof into (a sequence of) classical security reductions, and investigate what security reductions are "quantum-friendly". We characterize sufficient conditions such that a classical reduction can be "lifted" to the quantum setting. We then apply our lifting theorems to post-quantum signature schemes. We are able to show that the classical generic construction of hash-tree based signatures from one-way functions and and a more efficient variant proposed in~\cite{BDH11} carry over to the quantum setting. Namely, assuming existence of (classical) one-way functions that are resistant to efficient quantum inversion algorithms, there exists a quantum-secure signature scheme. We note that the scheme in~\cite{BDH11} is a promising (post-quantum) candidate to be implemented in practice and our result further justifies it. Finally we demonstrate the generality of our framework by showing that several existing works (Full-Domain hash in the quantum random-oracle model~\cite{Zha12ibe} and the simple hybrid arguments framework in~\cite{HSS11}) can be reformulated under our unified framework.
It is obviously necessary that the security of post-quantum cryptographic schemes is based on computational problems that are hard to solve even with a quantum computer (unlike, e.g., factoring). Examples of such computational problems appear in the theory of lattices or in coding theory. However, this is not sufficient: also the security proof, which comes in the form of an algorithmic reduction that turns any hypothetical attacker into an algorithm that solves the considered hard computational problem, needs to be valid when considering quantum computing as the model of computation. In this work, we provide an overview of the hurdles one typically encounters when proving the security of post-quantum cryptographic schemes, and we elaborate on some of the mathematical techniques that have been developed in order to overcome these hurdles (to some extent). We also analyze the caveat that even when a security proof can be established (by reducing the security to a quantum-hard computational problem), the reduction often suffers from a larger reduction loss, compared to when proving classical security, which negatively affects the concrete security. In the second part of this work, we offer a survey of the respective reduction losses in (1) generic transformations that are often used in the design of cryptographic schemes (like the Fiat-Shamir and Fujisaki-Okamoto transformations), and (2) some concrete cryptographic schemes (with a focus on those standardized by NIST), when considering classical and when considering post-quantum security. Finally, we investigate how these reduction losses translate into bit security, the standard measure of the concrete security of a cryptographic scheme (or of the hardness of an underlying computational problem). A natural question is how the bit security is affected by the different reduction losses we encountered. Surprisingly, we observe that a better or worse reduction (in terms of the reduction loss) is not always reflected as such in the bit security. We explain this phenomenon by the fact that the bit security is oblivious to the actual advantage–time function, and instead considers a worst-case behavior of that function. Thus, by exploiting the actual advantage–time function there is potential to get more accurate (i.e., less conservative) estimates for the concrete security.