Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Simulation-Based Secure Functional Encryption in the Random Oracle Model.

Vincenzo Iovino, Karol Żebrowski

Published Jan 1, 2014• 6 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

One of the main lines of research in functional encryption (FE) has consisted in studying the security notions for FE and their achievability. This study was initiated by [Boneh et al. { TCC’11, O’Neill { ePrint’10] where it was rst shown that for FE the indistinguishabilitybased (IND) security notion is not sucient in the sense that there are FE schemes that are provably IND-Secure but concretely insecure. For this reason, researchers investigated the achievability of Simulation-based (SIM) security, a stronger notion of security. Unfortunately, the above-mentioned works and others [e.g., Agrawal et al. { CRYPTO’13] have shown strong impossibility results for SIM-Security. One way to overcome these impossibility results was rst

Related papers

On the Power of Random Oracles.

Iftach Haitner, Eran Omri, Hila Zarosim

In the random oracle model, the parties are given oracle access to a random member of a (typically huge) function family, and are assumed to have unbounded computational power (though they can only make a bounded number of oracle queries). This model provides powerful properties that allow proving the security of many protocols, even such that cannot be proved secure in the standard model (under any hardness assumption). The random oracle model is also used to show that a given cryptographic primitive cannot be used in a black-box way to construct another primitive; in their seminal work, Impagliazzo and Rudich [STOC ’89] showed that in the random function model – when the function family is the set of all functions – it is impossible to construct (secure) key-agreement protocols, yielding that key-agreement cannot be black-box reduced to one-way functions. Their work has a long line of followup works (Simon [EC ’98], Gertner et al. [STOC ’00] and Gennaro et al. [SICOMP ’05], to name a few), showing that given oracle access to a certain type of function family (e.g., the family that “implements ” public-key encryption) is not sufficient for building a given cryptographic primitive (e.g., oblivious transfer). Yet, in the more general sense, the following fundamental question remained open: What is the exact power of the random oracle model, and more specifically, of the random function model? We make progress towards answering the above question, showing that any (no private input) semi-honest two-party functionality that can be securely implemented in the random function model, can be securely implemented information theoretically (where parties are assumed to be all powerful, and no oracle is given). We further generalize the above result to function families that provide some natural combinatorial property. To exhibit the power of our result, we use the recent information theoretic impossibility result of McGregor et al. [FOCS ’10], to show the existence of functionalities (e.g., inner product) that cannot be computed both accurately and in a differentially private manner in the random function model; yielding that protocols for computing these functionalities cannot be black-box reduced to the existence of one-way functions.

Electronic colloquium on computational complexity•Jan 1, 2012•3 citations

Semantically-Secure Functional Encryption: Possibility Results, Impossibility Results and the Quest for a General Definition.

Mihir Bellare, Adam O’Neill

This paper explains that SS1-secure functional encryption (FE) as defined by Boneh, Sahai and Waters implicitly incorporates security under key-revealing selective opening attacks (SOA-K). This connection helps intuitively explain their impossibility results and also allows us to prove stronger ones. To fill this gap and move us closer to the (laudable) goal of a general and achievable notion of FE security, we seek and provide two “sans SOA-K ” definitions of FE security that we call SS2 and SS3. We prove various possibility results about these definitions. We view our work as a first step towards the challenging goal of a general, meaningful and achievable notion of FE security. 1

•Jan 1, 2012•5 citations

Impossibility of Simulation Secure Functional Encryption Even with Random Oracles

Shashank Agrawal, Venkata Koppula, Brent R. Waters

Lecture notes in computer science•Jan 1, 2018•10 citations

Simulation-Secure Functional Encryption in the Bounded Storage Model

Mohammed Barhoush, Louis Salvail

Functional encryption (FE) is a versatile paradigm that enables fine-grained access control over encrypted data. Despite its potential, achieving the gold standard of simulation-based security for FE is impossible in full generality. Known impossibility results demonstrate that simulation security cannot be attained if an adversary in the security experiment is permitted either an unbounded number of functional key queries or an unbounded number of challenge ciphertexts. In this work, we circumvent these fundamental barriers by considering two distinct memory-restricted settings: the Bounded Quantum Storage Model and the Bounded Classical Storage Model. In these settings, the plain model impossibility results no longer apply, allowing us to obtain new positive results. Specifically, we construct two adaptively simulation-secure FE schemes in the Bounded Quantum Storage Model: 1) Many functional key scheme: A construction supporting many functional key queries and a single challenge ciphertext, assuming only the existence of one-way functions. 2) Many ciphertext scheme: An information-theoretic secure construction supporting a single non-adaptive functional key, many challenge ciphertexts, and many adaptive functional key queries. Furthermore, we demonstrate that both schemes can be ported to the Bounded Classical Storage Model, assuming the existence of disappearing grey-box obfuscation.

arXiv:2309.06702•Sep 13, 2023•1 citation

Functional Encryption: New Perspectives and Lower Bounds.

Shweta Agrawal, S. Gorbunov, Vinod Vaikuntanathan +1 more

Functional encryption is an emerging paradigm for public-key encryption that enables finegrained control of access to encrypted data. In this work, we present new perspectives on security definitions for functional encryption, as well as new lower bounds on what can be achieved. Our main contributions are as follows: • We show a lower bound for functional encryption that satisfies a weak (non-adaptive) simulation-based security notion, via pseudo-random functions. This is the first lower bound that exploits unbounded collusions in an essential way. • We put forth and discuss a simulation-based notion of security for functional encryption, with an unbounded simulator (called USIM). We show that this notion interpolates indistinguishability and simulation-based security notions, and has strong correlations to results and barriers in the zero-knowledge and multi-party computation literature.

•Jan 1, 2012•7 citations

A survey on functional encryption

Carla Mascia, Massimiliano Sala, Irène Villa

Functional Encryption (FE) expands traditional public-key encryption in two different ways: it supports fine-grained access control and allows learning a function of the encrypted data. In this paper, we review all FE classes, describing their functionalities and main characteristics. In particular, we mention several schemes for each class, providing their security assumptions and comparing their properties. To our knowledge, this is the first survey that encompasses the entire FE family.

arXiv:2106.06306•Advances in Mathematics of Communications•Oct 27, 2021•19 citations
One of the main lines of research in functional encryption (FE) has consisted in studying the security notions for FE and their achievability. This study was initiated by [Boneh et al. { TCC’11, O’Neill { ePrint’10] where it was rst shown that for FE the indistinguishabilitybased (IND) security notion is not sucient in the sense that there are FE schemes that are provably IND-Secure but concretely insecure. For this reason, researchers investigated the achievability of Simulation-based (SIM) security, a stronger notion of security. Unfortunately, the above-mentioned works and others [e.g., Agrawal et al. { CRYPTO’13] have shown strong impossibility results for SIM-Security. One way to overcome these impossibility results was rst
In the random oracle model, the parties are given oracle access to a random member of a (typically huge) function family, and are assumed to have unbounded computational power (though they can only make a bounded number of oracle queries). This model provides powerful properties that allow proving the security of many protocols, even such that cannot be proved secure in the standard model (under any hardness assumption). The random oracle model is also used to show that a given cryptographic primitive cannot be used in a black-box way to construct another primitive; in their seminal work, Impagliazzo and Rudich [STOC ’89] showed that in the random function model – when the function family is the set of all functions – it is impossible to construct (secure) key-agreement protocols, yielding that key-agreement cannot be black-box reduced to one-way functions. Their work has a long line of followup works (Simon [EC ’98], Gertner et al. [STOC ’00] and Gennaro et al. [SICOMP ’05], to name a few), showing that given oracle access to a certain type of function family (e.g., the family that “implements ” public-key encryption) is not sufficient for building a given cryptographic primitive (e.g., oblivious transfer). Yet, in the more general sense, the following fundamental question remained open: What is the exact power of the random oracle model, and more specifically, of the random function model? We make progress towards answering the above question, showing that any (no private input) semi-honest two-party functionality that can be securely implemented in the random function model, can be securely implemented information theoretically (where parties are assumed to be all powerful, and no oracle is given). We further generalize the above result to function families that provide some natural combinatorial property. To exhibit the power of our result, we use the recent information theoretic impossibility result of McGregor et al. [FOCS ’10], to show the existence of functionalities (e.g., inner product) that cannot be computed both accurately and in a differentially private manner in the random function model; yielding that protocols for computing these functionalities cannot be black-box reduced to the existence of one-way functions.
This paper explains that SS1-secure functional encryption (FE) as defined by Boneh, Sahai and Waters implicitly incorporates security under key-revealing selective opening attacks (SOA-K). This connection helps intuitively explain their impossibility results and also allows us to prove stronger ones. To fill this gap and move us closer to the (laudable) goal of a general and achievable notion of FE security, we seek and provide two “sans SOA-K ” definitions of FE security that we call SS2 and SS3. We prove various possibility results about these definitions. We view our work as a first step towards the challenging goal of a general, meaningful and achievable notion of FE security. 1
Functional encryption (FE) is a versatile paradigm that enables fine-grained access control over encrypted data. Despite its potential, achieving the gold standard of simulation-based security for FE is impossible in full generality. Known impossibility results demonstrate that simulation security cannot be attained if an adversary in the security experiment is permitted either an unbounded number of functional key queries or an unbounded number of challenge ciphertexts. In this work, we circumvent these fundamental barriers by considering two distinct memory-restricted settings: the Bounded Quantum Storage Model and the Bounded Classical Storage Model. In these settings, the plain model impossibility results no longer apply, allowing us to obtain new positive results. Specifically, we construct two adaptively simulation-secure FE schemes in the Bounded Quantum Storage Model: 1) Many functional key scheme: A construction supporting many functional key queries and a single challenge ciphertext, assuming only the existence of one-way functions. 2) Many ciphertext scheme: An information-theoretic secure construction supporting a single non-adaptive functional key, many challenge ciphertexts, and many adaptive functional key queries. Furthermore, we demonstrate that both schemes can be ported to the Bounded Classical Storage Model, assuming the existence of disappearing grey-box obfuscation.
Functional encryption is an emerging paradigm for public-key encryption that enables finegrained control of access to encrypted data. In this work, we present new perspectives on security definitions for functional encryption, as well as new lower bounds on what can be achieved. Our main contributions are as follows: • We show a lower bound for functional encryption that satisfies a weak (non-adaptive) simulation-based security notion, via pseudo-random functions. This is the first lower bound that exploits unbounded collusions in an essential way. • We put forth and discuss a simulation-based notion of security for functional encryption, with an unbounded simulator (called USIM). We show that this notion interpolates indistinguishability and simulation-based security notions, and has strong correlations to results and barriers in the zero-knowledge and multi-party computation literature.