Oxford University Press eBooks
4. Enthusiastic resignation
J. L. Heilbron
Abstract
‘Enthusiastic resignation’ describes Bohr’s work with Wolfgang Pauli and Werner Heisenberg. ‘Resignation’ refers to their realization that the electron orbits that had served as the basis of Bohr’s theory had only ‘symbolic’ value. They took the correspondence principle as a guide to translating symbols describing the orbits, like position and momentum, into symbols specifying the values of observable products of atoms, like the frequency and intensity of spectral lines. Heisenberg’s breakthrough in the summer of 1925, based on a particulate view of matter, provided a basis for a coherent description of the phenomena to which atomic electrons give rise. Almost simultaneously, Erwin Schrödinger found another route to the same mathematical solution, based on a wave picture of matter, which avoided discontinuity and made calculations easier. In answering Schrödinger’s challenge, Heisenberg invented the Uncertainty Principle and Bohr worked out a more general reconciliation of the quantum puzzles, which he called ‘complementarity’.