Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

4. Enthusiastic resignation

J. L. Heilbron

Published Jan 23, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

‘Enthusiastic resignation’ describes Bohr’s work with Wolfgang Pauli and Werner Heisenberg. ‘Resignation’ refers to their realization that the electron orbits that had served as the basis of Bohr’s theory had only ‘symbolic’ value. They took the correspondence principle as a guide to translating symbols describing the orbits, like position and momentum, into symbols specifying the values of observable products of atoms, like the frequency and intensity of spectral lines. Heisenberg’s breakthrough in the summer of 1925, based on a particulate view of matter, provided a basis for a coherent description of the phenomena to which atomic electrons give rise. Almost simultaneously, Erwin Schrödinger found another route to the same mathematical solution, based on a wave picture of matter, which avoided discontinuity and made calculations easier. In answering Schrödinger’s challenge, Heisenberg invented the Uncertainty Principle and Bohr worked out a more general reconciliation of the quantum puzzles, which he called ‘complementarity’.

DOI
10.1093/actrade/9780198819264.003.0004

Related papers

Heisenberg, Bohr, Robertson, and the Uncertainty Principle

Jim Baggott

From the outset, Heisenberg had resolved to eliminate classical space-time pictures involving particles and waves from the quantum mechanics of the atom. He had wanted to focus instead on the properties actually observed and recorded in laboratory experiments, such as the positions and intensities of spectral lines. Alone in Copenhagen in February 1927, he now pondered on the significance and meaning of such experimental observables. Feeling the need to introduce at least some form of ‘visualizability’, he asked himself some fundamental questions, such as: What do we actually mean when we talk about the position of an electron? He went on to discover the uncertainty principle: the product of the ‘uncertainties’ in certain pairs of variables—called complementary variables—such as position and momentum cannot be smaller than Planck’s constant h (now h / 4π‎).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 10, 2020•1 citation

New Ways to Calculate

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract In June 1925 Heisenberg made the breakthrough that would lead to matrix mechanics. The theory was abstract, offered no means for visualizing the mechanics of the atom, and its application required a lot of heavy lifting. Erwin Schrödinger subsequently made the breakthrough that would lead to wave mechanics, building on Louis de Broglie’s association of a wave with an electron. In Schrödinger’s wave equation the quantum numbers of the hydrogen atom arise naturally. He argued that his ‘wavefunction’ offered a realistic description of the electron in an atom, and sought to eliminate Bohr’s discontinuous quantum jumps. But in the spring of 1926, Max Born offered an enduring alternative. The modulus-square of the wavefunction is a measure of probability in an unvisualizable microphysics. In an intense debate with Bohr, Schrödinger demanded a theory based on logical concepts free from contradictions. Bohr was left to ponder what this might mean.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

Niels Bohr's Discussions with Albert Einstein, Werner Heisenberg, and Erwin Schrödinger: The Origins of the Principles of Uncertainty and Complementarity

In this paper, the main outlines of the discussions between Niels Bohr with Albert Einstein, Werner Heisenberg, and Erwin Schrödinger during 1920–1927 are treated. From the formulation of quantum mechanics in 1925–1926 and wave mechanics in 1926, there emerged Born's statistical interpretation of the wave function in summer 1926, and on the basis of the quantum mechanical transformation theory — formulated in fall 1926 by Dirac, London, and Jordan–Heisenberg formulated the uncertainty principle in early 1927. At the Volta Conference in Como in September 1927 and at the fifth Solvay Conference in Brussels the following month, Bohr publicly enunciated his complementarity principle, which had been developing in his mind for several years. The Bohr–Einstein discussions about the consistency and completeness of quantum mechanics and of physical theory as such — formally begun in October 1927 at the fifth Solvay Conference and carried on at the sixth Solvay Conference in October 1930 — were continued during the next decades. All these aspects are briefly summarized.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2001•1 citation

Enseignement

CERN

In an attempt to give an exact mathematical formulation of Bohr*s Correspondence Principle, Heisenberg (June 1925) discovered the rules governing the behaviour of quantum-theoretical magnitudes.In fall 1925 Born, Heisenberg and Jordan and, independently, Dirac, formulated consistent algebraic schemes of quantum mechanics.Early in 1926 Schrodinger developed wave mechanics.In quick succession were discovered : Bora's probability interpretation of the wave function, the transformation theory of Dirac, Jordan and E. London, Heisenberg's uncertainty relations and Bohr's principle of complementarity.By September 1927 the basis of a complete theory of atomic phenomena had been established.Aspects of this development, in which Heisenberg played a central role, will be presented as a tribute to his memory.

•Jan 1, 1976•0 citations

Werner Heisenberg and the Birth of Quantum Mechanics

In an attempt to give an exact mathematical formulation of Bohr's Correspondence Principle, Heisenberg (June 1925) discovered the rules governing the behaviour of quantum-theoretical magnitudes. In fall 1925 Born, Heisenberg and Jordan and, independently, Dirac, formulated consistent algebraic schemes of quantum mechanics. Early in 1926 Schrödinger developed wave mechanics. In quick succession were discovered: Born's probability interpretation of the wave function, the transformation theory of Dirac, Jordan and F. London, Heisenberg's Uncertainty Relations and Bohr's Principle of Complementarity. By September 1927 the basis of a complete theory of atomic phenomena had been established. Aspects of this development, in which Heisenberg played a central role, are presented here as a tribute to his memory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2001•0 citations

New Ways to Think

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract Bohr brought to the challenge the conviction that no single picture could express the entire content of any domain of experience. He therefore did not privilege waves or particles but sought a way to have them both. Heisenberg bridled at this. He was not so fond as his boss of admitting waves associated with his rival Schrödinger. Their discussion grew heated. Bohr left to go skiing, and Heisenberg pre-empted him by inventing the uncertainty principle. Bohr responded with ‘complementarity’, and aired his new philosophy in a lecture at Lake Como. He talked for an hour, inaudibly, in lengthy ‘Bohrish’ sentences hard to unscramble when read and impossible when only heard. We must use both wave and particle descriptions, he claimed, but we must also remember that in the quantum domain they are merely symbolic, applicable only when limited by acts of observation, which can be described using only classical concepts.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations
‘Enthusiastic resignation’ describes Bohr’s work with Wolfgang Pauli and Werner Heisenberg. ‘Resignation’ refers to their realization that the electron orbits that had served as the basis of Bohr’s theory had only ‘symbolic’ value. They took the correspondence principle as a guide to translating symbols describing the orbits, like position and momentum, into symbols specifying the values of observable products of atoms, like the frequency and intensity of spectral lines. Heisenberg’s breakthrough in the summer of 1925, based on a particulate view of matter, provided a basis for a coherent description of the phenomena to which atomic electrons give rise. Almost simultaneously, Erwin Schrödinger found another route to the same mathematical solution, based on a wave picture of matter, which avoided discontinuity and made calculations easier. In answering Schrödinger’s challenge, Heisenberg invented the Uncertainty Principle and Bohr worked out a more general reconciliation of the quantum puzzles, which he called ‘complementarity’.
From the outset, Heisenberg had resolved to eliminate classical space-time pictures involving particles and waves from the quantum mechanics of the atom. He had wanted to focus instead on the properties actually observed and recorded in laboratory experiments, such as the positions and intensities of spectral lines. Alone in Copenhagen in February 1927, he now pondered on the significance and meaning of such experimental observables. Feeling the need to introduce at least some form of ‘visualizability’, he asked himself some fundamental questions, such as: What do we actually mean when we talk about the position of an electron? He went on to discover the uncertainty principle: the product of the ‘uncertainties’ in certain pairs of variables—called complementary variables—such as position and momentum cannot be smaller than Planck’s constant h (now h / 4π‎).
Abstract In June 1925 Heisenberg made the breakthrough that would lead to matrix mechanics. The theory was abstract, offered no means for visualizing the mechanics of the atom, and its application required a lot of heavy lifting. Erwin Schrödinger subsequently made the breakthrough that would lead to wave mechanics, building on Louis de Broglie’s association of a wave with an electron. In Schrödinger’s wave equation the quantum numbers of the hydrogen atom arise naturally. He argued that his ‘wavefunction’ offered a realistic description of the electron in an atom, and sought to eliminate Bohr’s discontinuous quantum jumps. But in the spring of 1926, Max Born offered an enduring alternative. The modulus-square of the wavefunction is a measure of probability in an unvisualizable microphysics. In an intense debate with Bohr, Schrödinger demanded a theory based on logical concepts free from contradictions. Bohr was left to ponder what this might mean.
In this paper, the main outlines of the discussions between Niels Bohr with Albert Einstein, Werner Heisenberg, and Erwin Schrödinger during 1920–1927 are treated. From the formulation of quantum mechanics in 1925–1926 and wave mechanics in 1926, there emerged Born's statistical interpretation of the wave function in summer 1926, and on the basis of the quantum mechanical transformation theory — formulated in fall 1926 by Dirac, London, and Jordan–Heisenberg formulated the uncertainty principle in early 1927. At the Volta Conference in Como in September 1927 and at the fifth Solvay Conference in Brussels the following month, Bohr publicly enunciated his complementarity principle, which had been developing in his mind for several years. The Bohr–Einstein discussions about the consistency and completeness of quantum mechanics and of physical theory as such — formally begun in October 1927 at the fifth Solvay Conference and carried on at the sixth Solvay Conference in October 1930 — were continued during the next decades. All these aspects are briefly summarized.
In an attempt to give an exact mathematical formulation of Bohr*s Correspondence Principle, Heisenberg (June 1925) discovered the rules governing the behaviour of quantum-theoretical magnitudes.In fall 1925 Born, Heisenberg and Jordan and, independently, Dirac, formulated consistent algebraic schemes of quantum mechanics.Early in 1926 Schrodinger developed wave mechanics.In quick succession were discovered : Bora's probability interpretation of the wave function, the transformation theory of Dirac, Jordan and E. London, Heisenberg's uncertainty relations and Bohr's principle of complementarity.By September 1927 the basis of a complete theory of atomic phenomena had been established.Aspects of this development, in which Heisenberg played a central role, will be presented as a tribute to his memory.
In an attempt to give an exact mathematical formulation of Bohr's Correspondence Principle, Heisenberg (June 1925) discovered the rules governing the behaviour of quantum-theoretical magnitudes. In fall 1925 Born, Heisenberg and Jordan and, independently, Dirac, formulated consistent algebraic schemes of quantum mechanics. Early in 1926 Schrödinger developed wave mechanics. In quick succession were discovered: Born's probability interpretation of the wave function, the transformation theory of Dirac, Jordan and F. London, Heisenberg's Uncertainty Relations and Bohr's Principle of Complementarity. By September 1927 the basis of a complete theory of atomic phenomena had been established. Aspects of this development, in which Heisenberg played a central role, are presented here as a tribute to his memory.
Abstract Bohr brought to the challenge the conviction that no single picture could express the entire content of any domain of experience. He therefore did not privilege waves or particles but sought a way to have them both. Heisenberg bridled at this. He was not so fond as his boss of admitting waves associated with his rival Schrödinger. Their discussion grew heated. Bohr left to go skiing, and Heisenberg pre-empted him by inventing the uncertainty principle. Bohr responded with ‘complementarity’, and aired his new philosophy in a lecture at Lake Como. He talked for an hour, inaudibly, in lengthy ‘Bohrish’ sentences hard to unscramble when read and impossible when only heard. We must use both wave and particle descriptions, he claimed, but we must also remember that in the quantum domain they are merely symbolic, applicable only when limited by acts of observation, which can be described using only classical concepts.