Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

New Ways to Think

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Published Apr 25, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Bohr brought to the challenge the conviction that no single picture could express the entire content of any domain of experience. He therefore did not privilege waves or particles but sought a way to have them both. Heisenberg bridled at this. He was not so fond as his boss of admitting waves associated with his rival Schrödinger. Their discussion grew heated. Bohr left to go skiing, and Heisenberg pre-empted him by inventing the uncertainty principle. Bohr responded with ‘complementarity’, and aired his new philosophy in a lecture at Lake Como. He talked for an hour, inaudibly, in lengthy ‘Bohrish’ sentences hard to unscramble when read and impossible when only heard. We must use both wave and particle descriptions, he claimed, but we must also remember that in the quantum domain they are merely symbolic, applicable only when limited by acts of observation, which can be described using only classical concepts.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780192846105.003.0005

Related papers

Entanglement limits duality and vice versa

Xiao‐Feng Qian, A. Nick Vamivakas, Joseph H. Eberly

Ninety years ago in 1927, at an international congress in Como, Italy, Niels Bohr gave an address which is recognized as the first instance in which the term "complementarity", as a physical concept, was spoken publicly [1], revealing Bohr's own thinking about Louis de Broglie's "duality". Bohr had very slowly accepted duality as a principle of physics: close observation of any quantum object will reveal either wave-like or particle-like behavior, one or the other of two fundamental and complementary features. Little disagreement exists today about complementarity's importance and broad applicability in quantum science. Book-length scholarly examinations even provide speculations about the relevance of complementarity in fields as different from physics as biology, psychology and social anthropology, connections which were apparently of interest to Bohr himself (see Jammer [2], Murdoch [3] and Whitaker [4]). Confusion evident in Como following his talk was not eliminated by Bohr's article [1], and complementarity has been subjected to nine decades of repeated examination ever since with no agreed resolution. Semi-popular treatments [5] as well as expert examinations [6-9] show that the topic cannot be avoided, and complementarity retains its central place in the interpretation of quantum mechanics. However, recent approaches by our group [10-13] and others [14-20] to the underlying notion of coherence now allow us to present a universal formulation of complementarity that may signal the end to the confusion. We demonstrate a new relationship that constrains the behavior of an electromagnetic field (quantum or classical) in the fundamental context of two-slit experiments. We show that entanglement is the ingredient needed to complete Bohr's formulation of complementarity, debated for decades because of its incompleteness.

arXiv:1803.04611•Optica•Jul 30, 2018•91 citations

The Bohr Atom

Anthony Craig Fischer-Cripps

The new quantum theory was a mathematical description of the way in which an electron behaves when bounded by some kind of potential – such as being in an electric field, acting as a harmonic oscillator or simply being confined to a certain area of space. This mathematical description was then interpreted to be a description of the electron as being probabilistic. It was Schrödinger’s wave equation, together with de Broglie’s concept of a matter wave, that led to various important concepts like the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, an explanation of the emission and absorption of photons in atoms, quantum tunnelling and so on. This chapter explains what Schrödinger did – the marriage of waves and particles.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 20, 2019•0 citations

Heisenberg, Bohr, Robertson, and the Uncertainty Principle

Jim Baggott

From the outset, Heisenberg had resolved to eliminate classical space-time pictures involving particles and waves from the quantum mechanics of the atom. He had wanted to focus instead on the properties actually observed and recorded in laboratory experiments, such as the positions and intensities of spectral lines. Alone in Copenhagen in February 1927, he now pondered on the significance and meaning of such experimental observables. Feeling the need to introduce at least some form of ‘visualizability’, he asked himself some fundamental questions, such as: What do we actually mean when we talk about the position of an electron? He went on to discover the uncertainty principle: the product of the ‘uncertainties’ in certain pairs of variables—called complementary variables—such as position and momentum cannot be smaller than Planck’s constant h (now h / 4π‎).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 10, 2020•1 citation

New Ways to Calculate

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract In June 1925 Heisenberg made the breakthrough that would lead to matrix mechanics. The theory was abstract, offered no means for visualizing the mechanics of the atom, and its application required a lot of heavy lifting. Erwin Schrödinger subsequently made the breakthrough that would lead to wave mechanics, building on Louis de Broglie’s association of a wave with an electron. In Schrödinger’s wave equation the quantum numbers of the hydrogen atom arise naturally. He argued that his ‘wavefunction’ offered a realistic description of the electron in an atom, and sought to eliminate Bohr’s discontinuous quantum jumps. But in the spring of 1926, Max Born offered an enduring alternative. The modulus-square of the wavefunction is a measure of probability in an unvisualizable microphysics. In an intense debate with Bohr, Schrödinger demanded a theory based on logical concepts free from contradictions. Bohr was left to ponder what this might mean.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle and Bohr’s Complementarity (1927)

S. Brandt

Abstract In his memoirs Heisenberg reports on his first encounter with Einstein in April 1926. He had been invited to present his work on quantum mechanics in the prestigious Berlin colloquium and after the talk they walked together to Einstein’s apartment. Einstein began the conversation by criticizing Heisenberg’s postulate that quantum mechanics must be based exclusively on quantities which are in principle observable (Episode 37). Astonished, Heisenberg remarked that he thought, just that had been Einstein’s approach in special relativity when giving up the concept of absolute time, Einstein replied [1]: ‘Probably I did use this kind of reasoning, but it is nonsense all the same [… ] In reality the opposite happens. It is the theory which decides what we can observe.’

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 1992•0 citations

Bohr

Henry Krips

Abstract Bohr took it as the key fact of QT that neither of the models for describing the behaviour of systems offered by classical physics— neither the ‘particle picture’ nor the ‘wave picture’—fitted q-systems in all aspects of their behaviour. More particularly he took these two pictures to be ‘complementary’—when one fitted the other one did not. This failure of fit was seen by Bohr as usually only partial however, as a degree of’imprecision of fit’ rather than a total failure of fit; and it is in terms of this notion that Bohr was then able to give expression to his principle of complementarity, viz. that the degrees of imprecision of fit of the wave and particle pictures are reciprocally related: to the extent that one of the pictures fits well, the other fits badly. In this chapter I shall discuss these notions in the context of a more general discussion of Bohr’s philosophy of Quantum Theory.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 20, 1992•0 citations
Abstract Bohr brought to the challenge the conviction that no single picture could express the entire content of any domain of experience. He therefore did not privilege waves or particles but sought a way to have them both. Heisenberg bridled at this. He was not so fond as his boss of admitting waves associated with his rival Schrödinger. Their discussion grew heated. Bohr left to go skiing, and Heisenberg pre-empted him by inventing the uncertainty principle. Bohr responded with ‘complementarity’, and aired his new philosophy in a lecture at Lake Como. He talked for an hour, inaudibly, in lengthy ‘Bohrish’ sentences hard to unscramble when read and impossible when only heard. We must use both wave and particle descriptions, he claimed, but we must also remember that in the quantum domain they are merely symbolic, applicable only when limited by acts of observation, which can be described using only classical concepts.
Ninety years ago in 1927, at an international congress in Como, Italy, Niels Bohr gave an address which is recognized as the first instance in which the term "complementarity", as a physical concept, was spoken publicly [1], revealing Bohr's own thinking about Louis de Broglie's "duality". Bohr had very slowly accepted duality as a principle of physics: close observation of any quantum object will reveal either wave-like or particle-like behavior, one or the other of two fundamental and complementary features. Little disagreement exists today about complementarity's importance and broad applicability in quantum science. Book-length scholarly examinations even provide speculations about the relevance of complementarity in fields as different from physics as biology, psychology and social anthropology, connections which were apparently of interest to Bohr himself (see Jammer [2], Murdoch [3] and Whitaker [4]). Confusion evident in Como following his talk was not eliminated by Bohr's article [1], and complementarity has been subjected to nine decades of repeated examination ever since with no agreed resolution. Semi-popular treatments [5] as well as expert examinations [6-9] show that the topic cannot be avoided, and complementarity retains its central place in the interpretation of quantum mechanics. However, recent approaches by our group [10-13] and others [14-20] to the underlying notion of coherence now allow us to present a universal formulation of complementarity that may signal the end to the confusion. We demonstrate a new relationship that constrains the behavior of an electromagnetic field (quantum or classical) in the fundamental context of two-slit experiments. We show that entanglement is the ingredient needed to complete Bohr's formulation of complementarity, debated for decades because of its incompleteness.
The new quantum theory was a mathematical description of the way in which an electron behaves when bounded by some kind of potential – such as being in an electric field, acting as a harmonic oscillator or simply being confined to a certain area of space. This mathematical description was then interpreted to be a description of the electron as being probabilistic. It was Schrödinger’s wave equation, together with de Broglie’s concept of a matter wave, that led to various important concepts like the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, an explanation of the emission and absorption of photons in atoms, quantum tunnelling and so on. This chapter explains what Schrödinger did – the marriage of waves and particles.
From the outset, Heisenberg had resolved to eliminate classical space-time pictures involving particles and waves from the quantum mechanics of the atom. He had wanted to focus instead on the properties actually observed and recorded in laboratory experiments, such as the positions and intensities of spectral lines. Alone in Copenhagen in February 1927, he now pondered on the significance and meaning of such experimental observables. Feeling the need to introduce at least some form of ‘visualizability’, he asked himself some fundamental questions, such as: What do we actually mean when we talk about the position of an electron? He went on to discover the uncertainty principle: the product of the ‘uncertainties’ in certain pairs of variables—called complementary variables—such as position and momentum cannot be smaller than Planck’s constant h (now h / 4π‎).
Abstract In June 1925 Heisenberg made the breakthrough that would lead to matrix mechanics. The theory was abstract, offered no means for visualizing the mechanics of the atom, and its application required a lot of heavy lifting. Erwin Schrödinger subsequently made the breakthrough that would lead to wave mechanics, building on Louis de Broglie’s association of a wave with an electron. In Schrödinger’s wave equation the quantum numbers of the hydrogen atom arise naturally. He argued that his ‘wavefunction’ offered a realistic description of the electron in an atom, and sought to eliminate Bohr’s discontinuous quantum jumps. But in the spring of 1926, Max Born offered an enduring alternative. The modulus-square of the wavefunction is a measure of probability in an unvisualizable microphysics. In an intense debate with Bohr, Schrödinger demanded a theory based on logical concepts free from contradictions. Bohr was left to ponder what this might mean.
Abstract In his memoirs Heisenberg reports on his first encounter with Einstein in April 1926. He had been invited to present his work on quantum mechanics in the prestigious Berlin colloquium and after the talk they walked together to Einstein’s apartment. Einstein began the conversation by criticizing Heisenberg’s postulate that quantum mechanics must be based exclusively on quantities which are in principle observable (Episode 37). Astonished, Heisenberg remarked that he thought, just that had been Einstein’s approach in special relativity when giving up the concept of absolute time, Einstein replied [1]: ‘Probably I did use this kind of reasoning, but it is nonsense all the same [… ] In reality the opposite happens. It is the theory which decides what we can observe.’
Abstract Bohr took it as the key fact of QT that neither of the models for describing the behaviour of systems offered by classical physics— neither the ‘particle picture’ nor the ‘wave picture’—fitted q-systems in all aspects of their behaviour. More particularly he took these two pictures to be ‘complementary’—when one fitted the other one did not. This failure of fit was seen by Bohr as usually only partial however, as a degree of’imprecision of fit’ rather than a total failure of fit; and it is in terms of this notion that Bohr was then able to give expression to his principle of complementarity, viz. that the degrees of imprecision of fit of the wave and particle pictures are reciprocally related: to the extent that one of the pictures fits well, the other fits badly. In this chapter I shall discuss these notions in the context of a more general discussion of Bohr’s philosophy of Quantum Theory.