Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Reply to ``Comments on `There is No Axiomatic System for the Quantum Theory'''

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

Published Sep 1, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Jose Acacio de Barros discusses as follows [{Jose Acacio de Barros, Int. J. Theor. Phys. {\bf 50}, 1828 (2011)}]. Nagata claims to derive inconsistencies from quantum mechanics [{K. Nagata, Int. J. Theor. Phys. {\bf 48}, 3532 (2009)}]. Jose Acacio de Barros considers that the inconsistencies do not come from quantum mechanics, but from extra assumptions about the reality of observables. Here we discuss the fact that there is a contradiction within the quantum theory. We discuss the fact that only one expected value in a spin-1/2 pure state $\langle\sigma_x\rangle$ rules out the reality of the observable. We do not accept extra assumptions about the reality of observables. We use the actually measured results of quantum measurements (raw data). We use a single Pauli observable. We stress that we can use the quantum theory even if we give up the axiomatic system for the quantum theory.

Related papers

Reply to “Comments on ‘There Is No Axiomatic System for the Quantum Theory’”

Koji Nagata

Barros discusses that [Jose Acacio de Barros, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 50, 1828 (2011)] Nagata derives inconsistencies from quantum mechanics [K. Nagata, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 48, 3532 (2009)]. Barros considers that the inconsistencies do not come from quantum mechanics, but from extra assumptions about the reality of observables. Here we discuss the fact that there is a contradiction within the quantum theory. We discuss the fact that only one expected value in a spin-1/2 pure state 〈σx〉rules out the reality of the observable. We do not accept extra assumptions about the reality of observables. We use the actually measured results of quantum measurements (raw data). We use a single Pauli observable. We stress that we can use the quantum theory even if we give up the axiomatic system for the quantum theory.

Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2014•1 citation

Reply to “Comment on ‘All quantum observables in a hidden-variable model must commute simultaneously’” [Phys. Rev. A73, 066101 (2006)]

James D. Malley, Arthur I. Fine

Nagata [Phys. Rev. A 73, 066101 (2006)] questions whether a general no-go theorem of Malley [Phys. Rev. A 69, 022118 (2004)] applies to local hidden variables and outlines a ``counterexample.'' In fact this is not a counterexample at all, but in seeing why it fails we clarify the significance of Malley's result and its relation to other no-go theorems.

Physical Review A•Jun 14, 2006•2 citations

Comment on “Nonlocality, counterfactuals, and quantum mechanics”

Henry Pierce Stapp

A recent proof [H. P. Stapp, Am. J. Phys. 65, 300 (1997)], formulated in the symbolic language of modal logic, claims to show that contemporary quantum theory, viewed as a set of rules that allow us to calculate statistical predictions among certain kinds of observations, cannot be imbedded in any rational framework that conforms to the principles that (1) the experimenters' choices of which experiments they will perform can be considered to be free choices, (2) outcomes of measurements are unique, and (3) the free choices just mentioned have no backward-in-time effects of any kind. This claim is similar to Bell's theorem, but much stronger, because no reality assumption alien to quantum philosophy is used. The paper being commented on [W. Unruh, Phys. Rev. A 59, 126 (1999)] argues that some such reality assumption has been ``smuggled'' in. That argument is examined here and shown, I believe, to be defective.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1999•11 citations

Reply to ``Comment on `Similarity between quantum mechanics and thermodynamics: Entropy, temperature, and Carnot cycle' ''

Sumiyoshi Abe

In their Comment on the paper [Abe and Okuyama, Phys. Rev. E 83, 021121 (2011)], González-Díaz and Díaz-Solórzano discuss that the initial state of the quantum-mechanical analog of the Carnot cycle should be not in a pure state but in a mixed state due to a projective measurement of the system energy. Here, first the Comment is shown to miss the point. Then, second, multiple projective measurements are discussed as a generalization of the Comment, although they are not relevant to the work commented.

Physical Review E•May 26, 2015•1 citation

Comments

Bernard d’Espagnat

This chapter discusses some comments, and the rules of quantum mechanics. The quantum mechanics is universally valid for all the ensembles to which the more general formalism just alluded to is applicable. Any ensemble of systems the specification of which involves no reference to the results of future measurements that are to be performed on these systems obeys the quantum rules. One of the views most often expressed by the supporters of the "Copenhagen interpretation" is that quantum mechanics is a complete theory. The main motivation for the assumption is that the splitting of ensemble and subensembles cannot be made in any straightforward manner. However, this assumption implies the existence of particular, hitherto unknown forces, and it is therefore quite generally considered as unattractive. Thus the probabilities, or statistical distributions, that conventional quantum mechanics introduces into physics are inherently different from those found in classical mechanics, for example, in the kinetic theory of gases.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

Can Von Neumann’s Theory Meet Quantum Computation?

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

Recently, it is shown that there is a crucial contradiction within von Neumann's theory [K.Nagata and T. Nakamura, Int.J. Theor.Phys.49, 162 (2010)].We derive a proposition concerning a quantum expected value under the assumption of the existence of the directions in a spin-1/2 system.The quantum predictions within the formalism of von Neumann's projective measurement cannot coexist with the proposition concerning the existence of the directions.Therefore, we have to give up either the existence of the directions or the formalism of von Neumann's projective measurement.Hence, there is a crucial contradiction within von Neumann's theory.We discuss that this crucial contradiction makes the theoretical formulation of Deutsch's algorithm questionable.Especially, we systematically describe our assertion based on more mathematical analysis using raw data.Our discussion, here, improves previously published argumentations very much.

OALib•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations
Jose Acacio de Barros discusses as follows [{Jose Acacio de Barros, Int. J. Theor. Phys. {\bf 50}, 1828 (2011)}]. Nagata claims to derive inconsistencies from quantum mechanics [{K. Nagata, Int. J. Theor. Phys. {\bf 48}, 3532 (2009)}]. Jose Acacio de Barros considers that the inconsistencies do not come from quantum mechanics, but from extra assumptions about the reality of observables. Here we discuss the fact that there is a contradiction within the quantum theory. We discuss the fact that only one expected value in a spin-1/2 pure state ⟨σx⟩\langle\sigma_x\rangle⟨σx​⟩ rules out the reality of the observable. We do not accept extra assumptions about the reality of observables. We use the actually measured results of quantum measurements (raw data). We use a single Pauli observable. We stress that we can use the quantum theory even if we give up the axiomatic system for the quantum theory.
Barros discusses that [Jose Acacio de Barros, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 50, 1828 (2011)] Nagata derives inconsistencies from quantum mechanics [K. Nagata, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 48, 3532 (2009)]. Barros considers that the inconsistencies do not come from quantum mechanics, but from extra assumptions about the reality of observables. Here we discuss the fact that there is a contradiction within the quantum theory. We discuss the fact that only one expected value in a spin-1/2 pure state 〈σx〉rules out the reality of the observable. We do not accept extra assumptions about the reality of observables. We use the actually measured results of quantum measurements (raw data). We use a single Pauli observable. We stress that we can use the quantum theory even if we give up the axiomatic system for the quantum theory.
A recent proof [H. P. Stapp, Am. J. Phys. 65, 300 (1997)], formulated in the symbolic language of modal logic, claims to show that contemporary quantum theory, viewed as a set of rules that allow us to calculate statistical predictions among certain kinds of observations, cannot be imbedded in any rational framework that conforms to the principles that (1) the experimenters' choices of which experiments they will perform can be considered to be free choices, (2) outcomes of measurements are unique, and (3) the free choices just mentioned have no backward-in-time effects of any kind. This claim is similar to Bell's theorem, but much stronger, because no reality assumption alien to quantum philosophy is used. The paper being commented on [W. Unruh, Phys. Rev. A 59, 126 (1999)] argues that some such reality assumption has been ``smuggled'' in. That argument is examined here and shown, I believe, to be defective.
In their Comment on the paper [Abe and Okuyama, Phys. Rev. E 83, 021121 (2011)], González-Díaz and Díaz-Solórzano discuss that the initial state of the quantum-mechanical analog of the Carnot cycle should be not in a pure state but in a mixed state due to a projective measurement of the system energy. Here, first the Comment is shown to miss the point. Then, second, multiple projective measurements are discussed as a generalization of the Comment, although they are not relevant to the work commented.
This chapter discusses some comments, and the rules of quantum mechanics. The quantum mechanics is universally valid for all the ensembles to which the more general formalism just alluded to is applicable. Any ensemble of systems the specification of which involves no reference to the results of future measurements that are to be performed on these systems obeys the quantum rules. One of the views most often expressed by the supporters of the "Copenhagen interpretation" is that quantum mechanics is a complete theory. The main motivation for the assumption is that the splitting of ensemble and subensembles cannot be made in any straightforward manner. However, this assumption implies the existence of particular, hitherto unknown forces, and it is therefore quite generally considered as unattractive. Thus the probabilities, or statistical distributions, that conventional quantum mechanics introduces into physics are inherently different from those found in classical mechanics, for example, in the kinetic theory of gases.
Recently, it is shown that there is a crucial contradiction within von Neumann's theory [K.Nagata and T. Nakamura, Int.J. Theor.Phys.49, 162 (2010)].We derive a proposition concerning a quantum expected value under the assumption of the existence of the directions in a spin-1/2 system.The quantum predictions within the formalism of von Neumann's projective measurement cannot coexist with the proposition concerning the existence of the directions.Therefore, we have to give up either the existence of the directions or the formalism of von Neumann's projective measurement.Hence, there is a crucial contradiction within von Neumann's theory.We discuss that this crucial contradiction makes the theoretical formulation of Deutsch's algorithm questionable.Especially, we systematically describe our assertion based on more mathematical analysis using raw data.Our discussion, here, improves previously published argumentations very much.