The observational level of language in quantum mechanics records the results of manipulating instruments. The regularity-between-states view of causality has several advantages over theories that begin with distinct events and seek to elaborate conditions under which one event is a cause of a second event. The regularity-between-states view provides a unified treatment of deterministic and indeterministic generalizations. In addition, by linking causal relatedness to functional relations between states of isolated systems, one can sidestep questions about nonlocality, action-at-a-distance, and backward causation. What counts for causal relatedness is the success of inferences made about changes in the states of physical systems. α-Particles of given energy and direction, incident upon a sheet of aluminum, are absorbed at varying distances inside the sheet. The law governing this absorption is a statistical law, but since the state description is accomplished without reference to probabilities, this law also is a deterministic law.
The observational level of language in quantum mechanics records the results of manipulating instruments. The regularity-between-states view of causality has several advantages over theories that begin with distinct events and seek to elaborate conditions under which one event is a cause of a second event. The regularity-between-states view provides a unified treatment of deterministic and indeterministic generalizations. In addition, by linking causal relatedness to functional relations between states of isolated systems, one can sidestep questions about nonlocality, action-at-a-distance, and backward causation. What counts for causal relatedness is the success of inferences made about changes in the states of physical systems. α-Particles of given energy and direction, incident upon a sheet of aluminum, are absorbed at varying distances inside the sheet. The law governing this absorption is a statistical law, but since the state description is accomplished without reference to probabilities, this law also is a deterministic law.
The regularity-between-states view is a viable interpretation of causal relatedness for systems discussed in classical physics. Ambiguities arose, however, upon application of this view to quantum mechanical systems. The sketch of this theory is based primarily on the work of Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg. Heisenberg pointed out that applications of the quantum theory involve translations from a level of language in which observations are recorded, into a theoretical level, and back again. A quantum mechanical interpretation of an experiment typically is a three-stage process: translation of an initial experimental situation into a probability function, mathematical analysis of the variation of this function with time, and translation of the results of calculation into a prediction of the results of a new measurement to be made of the system. The principle of complementarity stipulates that pictorial-level interpretations of quantum phenomena in wave language and particle language are of equivalent importance.
During the early decades of the twentieth century, there was general agreement among scientists and philosophers interested in physics that causal relatedness is a matter of uniformity of sequence and the regularity in question is between states of (relatively isolated) systems. Moritz Schlick pointed out that the starting point of inquiry in physics is the measurement of quantities rather than the description of events. These quantities are values of the state of a physical system. Physicists have found that the horizontal component of the motion of such systems can be predicted if the masses, positions, and velocities of the bodies are specified. Hence, they take mass, position, and velocity to be the state variables of the system and ignore color, chemical composition, and other factors. A causal relation for this system is a functional relationship that describes the spatiotemporal variation of its state. The law of conservation of momentum qualifies as a causal relation.
Quantum Physics is usually defined as a theory that affirms a primary role of randomness and probability. Eleven well-known quantum experiments are examined and the result is the coexistence of both random and causal type behaviour. We need both to describe experiments. Quantum Mechanics states the general overcoming of causality and this statement constitutes an unlimited generalization, not supported by experience. Determinism and indeterminism are philosophical systems, that universalize causality or chance. The crucial point is the difference between epistemic and intrinsic randomness. In the first aspect, randomness does not have a fundamental meaning, in the second, randomness of the individual event is explained, but the detection of high stable regularities remains to be explained. The article addresses the question of entanglement and various aspects of probability theory, including the law of large numbers, arriving at the thesis that many relevant questions are unresolved. A causal description is in quantum mechanics impossible in principle, given its assumptions. In order not to contradict experience, both points of view are necessary, causal and random. This is the state of the research, to return to and start again from.
For Kant causality is an a priori category of the understanding, a necessary condition for the possibility of any experience. Later Wittgenstein’s philosophy rejects transcendentalism. We can only speak of causes and effects if in some basic situations, or ‘language games’, we already treat some things as causes of what happens. Since the notion of cause becomes meaningful only within a language game, it is not unambiguous. Quantum causal language games presuppose the use of quantum theory. We treat the latter as Wittgenstein’s grammar of a quantum form of life’, or rule (norm), anchored in its applications — quantum phenomena as language games. Quantum correlations are often interpreted as a manifestation of the nonlocality of quantum mechanics. This is a view of quantum phenomena from the perspective of classical physics. Our contextual point of view rejects the nonlocality of quantum theory in the sense of instantaneous causal influence at a distance. But it does not admit its locality in the sense of classical causality either. We introduce the notion of quantum causality which allows us to treat quantum correlations as local, but context-dependent. Their formal cause is an entangled wave function. Any particular quantum correlation, identifiable in a context of its observation as a result of the wave function reduction, post factum can be treated as a classical causal correlation. From the point of view of the proposed contextual quantum realism, epistemology is secondary, and ontology is sensitive to context. Quantum correlations exist (are real) before application of the theory, independently of their identification (description, measurement), but have no identity, which appears only as a result of application of the theory and their identification in the context. In other words, they are real, but not pre-determined, not autonomous.
The paper is concentrated on the special changes of the conception of causalityfrom quantum mechanics to quantum information meaning as a background the revolution implemented by the former to classical physics and science after Max Born’s probabilistic reinterpretation of wave function. Those changes can be enumerated so: (1) quantum information describes the general case of the relation of two wave functions, and particularly, the causal amendment of a single one; (2) it keeps the physical description to be causal by the conservation of quantum information and in accordance with Born’s interpretation; (3) it introduces inverse causality, “backwards in time”, observable “forwards in time” as the fundamentally random probability density distribution of all possible measurements of any physical quantity in quantum mechanics; (4) it involves a kind of “bidirectional causality” unifying (4.1) the classical determinism of cause and effect, (4.2) the probabilistic causality of quantum mechanics, and (4.3) the reversibility of any coherent state; (5) it identifies determinism with the function successor in Peano arithmetic, and its proper generalized causality with the information function successor in Hilbert arithmetic.
In the early years of the twentieth century, Ernest Rutherford undertook pioneering studies of radioactive decay sequences. Kinetic molecular theory and the theory of radioactive decay both are based on statistical considerations. On the regularity-between-states view of causality, each stage of the decay process is in a cause-effect relation to its successor stage. The decay of thorium, qua ensemble of atoms, qualifies as a causal process on the regularity-between-states view. Regularities had been established that link the heating of elements and the occurrence of lines in their spectra. The causal relations at stake are regularities of transition between electron states, and to establish these regularities is to enable explanatory arguments to be given of atomic spectra. The correspondence principle provided a link between discontinuous transitions within the atom to continuous motions adequately described by classical physics. However, Neils Bohr's theory of the atom retained both quantum and classical aspects. Quantum mechanics and classical mechanics both feature causal laws.