Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

Causality in Physics: Revision of the Regularity View

John P. Losee

Published Jul 28, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

During the early decades of the twentieth century, there was general agreement among scientists and philosophers interested in physics that causal relatedness is a matter of uniformity of sequence and the regularity in question is between states of (relatively isolated) systems. Moritz Schlick pointed out that the starting point of inquiry in physics is the measurement of quantities rather than the description of events. These quantities are values of the state of a physical system. Physicists have found that the horizontal component of the motion of such systems can be predicted if the masses, positions, and velocities of the bodies are specified. Hence, they take mass, position, and velocity to be the state variables of the system and ignore color, chemical composition, and other factors. A causal relation for this system is a functional relationship that describes the spatiotemporal variation of its state. The law of conservation of momentum qualifies as a causal relation.

DOI
10.4324/9781315135533-14

Related papers

Causality and the Three Levels of Language in Quantum Mechanics

John P. Losee

The observational level of language in quantum mechanics records the results of manipulating instruments. The regularity-between-states view of causality has several advantages over theories that begin with distinct events and seek to elaborate conditions under which one event is a cause of a second event. The regularity-between-states view provides a unified treatment of deterministic and indeterministic generalizations. In addition, by linking causal relatedness to functional relations between states of isolated systems, one can sidestep questions about nonlocality, action-at-a-distance, and backward causation. What counts for causal relatedness is the success of inferences made about changes in the states of physical systems. α-Particles of given energy and direction, incident upon a sheet of aluminum, are absorbed at varying distances inside the sheet. The law governing this absorption is a statistical law, but since the state description is accomplished without reference to probabilities, this law also is a deterministic law.

Routledge eBooks•Jul 28, 2017•0 citations

RANDOMNESS AND CAUSALITY IN QUANTUM PHYSICS Eleven famous quantum experiments

Pier Sandro Scano

Quantum Physics is usually defined as a theory that affirms a primary role of randomness and probability. Eleven well-known quantum experiments are examined and the result is the coexistence of both random and causal type behaviour. We need both to describe experiments. Quantum Mechanics states the general overcoming of causality and this statement constitutes an unlimited generalization, not supported by experience. Determinism and indeterminism are philosophical systems, that universalize causality or chance. The crucial point is the difference between epistemic and intrinsic randomness. In the first aspect, randomness does not have a fundamental meaning, in the second, randomness of the individual event is explained, but the detection of high stable regularities remains to be explained. The article addresses the question of entanglement and various aspects of probability theory, including the law of large numbers, arriving at the thesis that many relevant questions are unresolved. A causal description is in quantum mechanics impossible in principle, given its assumptions. In order not to contradict experience, both points of view are necessary, causal and random. This is the state of the research, to return to and start again from.

•Oct 16, 2024•0 citations

Causation, Symmetry and Quantum Physics: Space-like Causality and Conserved Quantities

L. S. F. Olavo, Ademir Eugenio de Santana, Samuel J. Simon

This work addresses the problem of causation in physics, as for quantum fields, the fundamental theory describing elementary particle physics. Three basic elements are used as methodological concepts: a) the notion of mass-point and the notion of a field (as quantum field) describing a physical system (both concepts are used in physics to characterize elementary particles); b) the notion of state of a mass-point and of a field; c) the notion of causality among states, which are defined by symmetries. Then time and space changes include a space-like causality. These elements are discussed by using the definition of measurement, associated with the notion of symmetry. The derived results give rise to a generalization of the concept of causality, since a mechanical system includes mass-points, fields, and systems composed of mass-points and fields, together. In addition, conserved quantities, founding some causality theories, are generalized due to the notion of symmetry associated with causality.

Revista Portuguesa de Filosofia•Jan 31, 2022•0 citations

Heisenberg and the Problem of Causality

Manuel Cruz Ortiz de Landázuri

The discovery of quantum physics opened a broad debate on the epistemological status of the principle of causality. In this article, I analyze the problem of causality in Heisenberg by distinguishing two levels of philosophical explanation in his thought. As a philosopher of science, his understanding of causality is closely linked to Moritz Schlick, although he will later adopt a neo-Kantian view of the a priori. As a philosopher of nature, Heisenberg recovers the notion of potency to understand the wave function. My thesis is that this notion of potency could have allowed him to elaborate a realistic and nondeterministic theory of causality, but the identification of causality and determinism (in Schlick’s line) did not lead him to such a conclusion.

HOPOS The Journal of the International Society for the History of Philosophy of Science•Dec 16, 2024•0 citations

The road to quantum mechanics

James T. Cushing

The theory of relativity is essentially the culmination of classical physics. Although revisions in our concepts of space and time are necessitated by both the special and general theories of relativity, the notion of causality, in which a cause precedes its effect, remains intact in the relativistic formulations of electrodynamics and mechanics and of gravitation. An upper limit is set on the speed of bodies, and of the propagation of energy, and physical quantities are often defined operationally, but once we adjust ourselves to these new rules, our representations of physical processes proceed pretty much as they did in classical physics. On the other hand, quantum theory seems to require a much more profound philosophical revision of our thought patterns. Even the viability of the usual meaning of a causal connection between one event and another is there called into question.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 29, 1998•0 citations

Schlick and Popper on Causality and Quantum Physics: Origins and Perspectives of the Debate

Manuel Cruz Ortiz de Landázuri

In this article I will focus on the debate on the causality principle that originated in the light of quantum mechanics concerning Moritz Schlick and Karl Popper. The discovery of quantum mechanics led to a broad debate on the interpretation of the principle of causality. Schlick proposed that it should be understood as an empirically verifiable postulate, and therefore with limits regarding causal indeterminacy in quantum physics. This approach had an influence on some scientists, especially Werner Heisenberg. However, Popper would develop a different way of understanding science because of the role played by unverifiable elements in theories that can nevertheless be falsified. It is precisely the discussion around the principle of causality that opens up different ways of understanding science. I will first try to analyse Schlick’s argument in the context of the debate that was taking place in the late 1920s in the light of the new quantum mechanics; secondly, I will look at the reception that Schlick’s idea of causality had in Heisenberg and the Copenhagen Interpretation; thirdly, I will analyse Popper’s argument against Schlick’s interpretation; finally, I will try to see the resonances of this debate in Heisenberg and other physicists.

International Studies in the Philosophy of Science•Jul 2, 2024•0 citations
During the early decades of the twentieth century, there was general agreement among scientists and philosophers interested in physics that causal relatedness is a matter of uniformity of sequence and the regularity in question is between states of (relatively isolated) systems. Moritz Schlick pointed out that the starting point of inquiry in physics is the measurement of quantities rather than the description of events. These quantities are values of the state of a physical system. Physicists have found that the horizontal component of the motion of such systems can be predicted if the masses, positions, and velocities of the bodies are specified. Hence, they take mass, position, and velocity to be the state variables of the system and ignore color, chemical composition, and other factors. A causal relation for this system is a functional relationship that describes the spatiotemporal variation of its state. The law of conservation of momentum qualifies as a causal relation.
The observational level of language in quantum mechanics records the results of manipulating instruments. The regularity-between-states view of causality has several advantages over theories that begin with distinct events and seek to elaborate conditions under which one event is a cause of a second event. The regularity-between-states view provides a unified treatment of deterministic and indeterministic generalizations. In addition, by linking causal relatedness to functional relations between states of isolated systems, one can sidestep questions about nonlocality, action-at-a-distance, and backward causation. What counts for causal relatedness is the success of inferences made about changes in the states of physical systems. α-Particles of given energy and direction, incident upon a sheet of aluminum, are absorbed at varying distances inside the sheet. The law governing this absorption is a statistical law, but since the state description is accomplished without reference to probabilities, this law also is a deterministic law.
Quantum Physics is usually defined as a theory that affirms a primary role of randomness and probability. Eleven well-known quantum experiments are examined and the result is the coexistence of both random and causal type behaviour. We need both to describe experiments. Quantum Mechanics states the general overcoming of causality and this statement constitutes an unlimited generalization, not supported by experience. Determinism and indeterminism are philosophical systems, that universalize causality or chance. The crucial point is the difference between epistemic and intrinsic randomness. In the first aspect, randomness does not have a fundamental meaning, in the second, randomness of the individual event is explained, but the detection of high stable regularities remains to be explained. The article addresses the question of entanglement and various aspects of probability theory, including the law of large numbers, arriving at the thesis that many relevant questions are unresolved. A causal description is in quantum mechanics impossible in principle, given its assumptions. In order not to contradict experience, both points of view are necessary, causal and random. This is the state of the research, to return to and start again from.
This work addresses the problem of causation in physics, as for quantum fields, the fundamental theory describing elementary particle physics. Three basic elements are used as methodological concepts: a) the notion of mass-point and the notion of a field (as quantum field) describing a physical system (both concepts are used in physics to characterize elementary particles); b) the notion of state of a mass-point and of a field; c) the notion of causality among states, which are defined by symmetries. Then time and space changes include a space-like causality. These elements are discussed by using the definition of measurement, associated with the notion of symmetry. The derived results give rise to a generalization of the concept of causality, since a mechanical system includes mass-points, fields, and systems composed of mass-points and fields, together. In addition, conserved quantities, founding some causality theories, are generalized due to the notion of symmetry associated with causality.
The discovery of quantum physics opened a broad debate on the epistemological status of the principle of causality. In this article, I analyze the problem of causality in Heisenberg by distinguishing two levels of philosophical explanation in his thought. As a philosopher of science, his understanding of causality is closely linked to Moritz Schlick, although he will later adopt a neo-Kantian view of the a priori. As a philosopher of nature, Heisenberg recovers the notion of potency to understand the wave function. My thesis is that this notion of potency could have allowed him to elaborate a realistic and nondeterministic theory of causality, but the identification of causality and determinism (in Schlick’s line) did not lead him to such a conclusion.
The theory of relativity is essentially the culmination of classical physics. Although revisions in our concepts of space and time are necessitated by both the special and general theories of relativity, the notion of causality, in which a cause precedes its effect, remains intact in the relativistic formulations of electrodynamics and mechanics and of gravitation. An upper limit is set on the speed of bodies, and of the propagation of energy, and physical quantities are often defined operationally, but once we adjust ourselves to these new rules, our representations of physical processes proceed pretty much as they did in classical physics. On the other hand, quantum theory seems to require a much more profound philosophical revision of our thought patterns. Even the viability of the usual meaning of a causal connection between one event and another is there called into question.
In this article I will focus on the debate on the causality principle that originated in the light of quantum mechanics concerning Moritz Schlick and Karl Popper. The discovery of quantum mechanics led to a broad debate on the interpretation of the principle of causality. Schlick proposed that it should be understood as an empirically verifiable postulate, and therefore with limits regarding causal indeterminacy in quantum physics. This approach had an influence on some scientists, especially Werner Heisenberg. However, Popper would develop a different way of understanding science because of the role played by unverifiable elements in theories that can nevertheless be falsified. It is precisely the discussion around the principle of causality that opens up different ways of understanding science. I will first try to analyse Schlick’s argument in the context of the debate that was taking place in the late 1920s in the light of the new quantum mechanics; secondly, I will look at the reception that Schlick’s idea of causality had in Heisenberg and the Copenhagen Interpretation; thirdly, I will analyse Popper’s argument against Schlick’s interpretation; finally, I will try to see the resonances of this debate in Heisenberg and other physicists.