I distinguish between two conceptually different kinds of physical space: a space of ordinary material bodies, which is the space of points at which I could imaginably place (say) the tip of my finger, or the center of a billiard-ball, and a space of elementary physical determinables, which is the smallest space of points such that stipulating what is happening at each one of those points, at every time, amounts to an exhaustive physical history of the universe. In all classical physical theories, these two spaces happen to coincide – and what we mean by calling a theory “classical”, and all we mean by calling a theory “classical”, is (I will argue) precisely that these two spaces coincide. But once the distinction between these two spaces in on the table, it becomes clear that there is no logical or conceptual reason why they must coincide – and it turns out (and this is the main topic of the present paper) that a very simple way of pulling them apart from one another gives us quantum mechanics.
I distinguish between two conceptually different kinds of physical space: a space of ordinary material bodies, which is the space of points at which I could imaginably place (say) the tip of my finger, or the center of a billiard-ball, and a space of elementary physical determinables, which is the smallest space of points such that stipulating what is happening at each one of those points, at every time, amounts to an exhaustive physical history of the universe. In all classical physical theories, these two spaces happen to coincide – and what we mean by calling a theory “classical”, and all we mean by calling a theory “classical”, is (I will argue) precisely that these two spaces coincide. But once the distinction between these two spaces in on the table, it becomes clear that there is no logical or conceptual reason why they must coincide – and it turns out (and this is the main topic of the present paper) that a very simple way of pulling them apart from one another gives us quantum mechanics.
I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.
Physics is not just mathematics. This seems trivial, but poses difficult and interesting questions. In this paper we analyse a particular discrepancy between non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM) and `classical' (Newtonian) space and time (NST). We also suggest, but not discuss, the case of the relativistic QM. In this work, we are more concerned with the notion of space and its mathematical representation. The mathematics entails that any two spatially separated objects are necessarily \ita{different}, which implies that they are \ita{discernible} (in classical logic, identity is defined by means of indiscernibility) --- we say that the space is T2, or "Hausdorff". But when enters QM, sometimes the systems need to be taken as \ita{completely indistinguishable}, so that there is no way to tell which system is which, and this holds even in the case of fermions. But in the NST setting, it seems that we can always give an \ita{identity} to them by means of their individuation, which seems to be contra the physical situation, where individuation (isolation) does not entail identity (as we argue in this paper). Here we discuss this topic by considering a case study (that of two potentially infinite wells) and conclude that, taking into account the quantum case, that is, when physics enter the discussion, even NST cannot be used to say that the systems do have identity. This case study seems to be relevant for a more detailed discussion on the interplay between physical theories (such as quantum theory) and their underlying mathematics (and logic), in a simple way apparently never realized before.
In the course of lectures on quantum mechanics delivered for the undergraduate students of this university I have encountered a number of examples of more or less novelty and interest, which I want here in a series of papers to present before a wider circle. Since the familiarity with all kinds of problems leads eventually to a better understanding of quantum mechanics, just as we have been possessed with the complete master of classical mechanics only through the numerous exercises in schools, it would, I hope, be of some service for a future development of quantum theory. Some of matters I present are of older date and some of recent date.
{N,n} QM contains two major parts: the Bohr formula-based part and the Schrodinger equation-based part. 1) For the Bohr formula-based part, after combining all results from the previous SunQM series papers, a {N,n//6} QM Structure (Master) Periodic Table (with N = -23..15, n = 1..12) is established. A summarized result of the {N,n//6} QM structure has been given for each region of this (Master) Periodic Table, including the cosmic {N,n//6} QM (at N > 5), the Solar {N,n//6} QM (at N= 5..-5), the chemical bond dominated world (at N= -2..-11), the atomic and nuclear {N,n//6} QM (at N= -12..-15), and the elementary particles and sub-quark {N,n//6} QM (at N ≤ -16). The common properties (that across all regions of the Master Period Table) has been discussed. For example, by adding many short-life intermediate states (n’ = 1..6^6) in between the major quantum state n=1..5, we can transform a quantum description (with n=1..5} into a (continuous) classical physics description (with n’ = 1..6^6). 2) For the Schrodinger equation-based part, we summarized that how to use {N,n//6} QM plus non-Born probability (NBP) plus Simultaneous-Multi-Eigen-Description (SMED) to describe a planet (or an atom in this planet) that orbiting around Sun, and a photon that propagating away (or towards to) a (Bohr) atom (and it can also be used for a 180° scattering). We further discussed the possibility to extend this description for any kind of movement (elliptical/parabolic/hyperbolic orbiting, scattering, etc.), with any inclination/eccentricity/precession. We also discussed how to use Schrodinger equation/solution for the N-body movement description. We pointed out that there is a conceptual difference between the {N,n} QM and the traditional QM in describing the H-atom’s electron orbit: while the probability (i.e., the Born probability) is the foundation of the traditional QM, the single trajectory (i.e., NBP peak’s time-dependent trajectory) is the foundation of the {N,n} QM (although this single trajectory will pick one of the many possible tracks based on the probability). 3) In the cosmic {N,n//6} QM, we explored the possibility that those super large cosmic “great walls” with distances ~ 9E+9 light-years from Earth are the (~ 9E+9 years old) self-images of our own Milky Way galaxy and be viewed at different angles. If this is correct, then our universe may should be a positive curved 3D space, with the circumference of ~ 9E+9 light-years. This means, just like we are practically living in the 2D spherical space on the surface of a 3D ball something (i.e., a planet), we may practically live in the 3D spherical space on the surface of a 4D ball something. 4) We pointed out that the wave mechanics is equally powerful as that of particle mechanics in solving a QM problem, and a particle mechanics based holographic-description and SMED is waiting to be developed. 5) Because the Bohr formula rn = r1 * n^2 correlates to the (free-fall) accelerated distance formula d = (1/2) *g *t^2 and Newton formula F = m * a, we believed that Bohr formula is the Number-One important formula in physics. We believed that all these results make {N,n} QM theory becomes one of the most (roughly) completed and (roughly) self-consistent theories in physics.
How do we describe the state of a quantum mechanical physical system in a mathematically precise way? How do we ascribe physical properties to this system? How does the system evolve in time? How do its properties change when it interacts with another system or a force? How do we measure and determine its properties? These are the questions whose answers are encoded in the laws of quantum mechanics to be set down in this chapter. They have been inscribed in this form after nearly half a century of experimental observations, theoretical modeling, and intellectual gymnastics to tie up the two in a satisfactory and robust structure.