Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

EPJ Web of Conferences

Locality and nonlocality in the interaction-free measurement

Daniel Rohrlich, Yakir Aharonov, Tomer Landsberger

Published Jan 1, 2018• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present a paradox involving a particle and a mirror. They exchange a nonlocal quantity, modular angular momentum Lz mod 2ћ, but there seems to be no local interaction between them that allows such an exchange. We demonstrate that the particle and mirror do interact locally via a weak local current 〈Lz mod 2ћ〉w. In this sense, we transform the “interaction-free measurement” of Elitzur and Vaidman, in which two local quantities (the positions of a photon and a bomb in the two arms of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer) interact nonlocally, into a thought experiment in which two nonlocal quantities (the weak modular angular momentum of the particle and of the mirror) interact locally.

DOI
10.1051/epjconf/201818202105

Related papers

What Is Nonlocal in Counterfactual Quantum Communication?

Yakir Aharonov, Daniel Rohrlich

We revisit the "counterfactual quantum communication" of Salih et al. [1], who claim that an observer "Bob" can send one bit of information to a second observer "Alice" without any physical particle traveling between them. We show that a locally conserved, massless current-specifically, a current of modular angular momentum, L_{z} mod 2ℏ-carries the one bit of information. We integrate the flux of L_{z} mod 2ℏ from Bob to Alice and show that it equals one of the two eigenvalues of L_{z} mod 2ℏ, either 0 or ℏ, thus precisely accounting for the one bit of information he sends her. We previously [2] obtained this result using weak values of L_{z} mod ℏ; here we do not use weak values.

arXiv:2011.11667•Physical Review Letters•Dec 21, 2020•23 citations

Realization of an interaction-free measurement of the presence of an object in a light beam

E. H. du Marchie van Voorthuysen

The gedanken experiment of Elitzur and Vaidman showing wave-particle duality was realized as a demonstration at a scientific exposition. Presence or absence of a mirror in one arm of an interferometer was measured while detecting one photon at a time. A reasonable fraction of events was ‘‘interaction-free,’’ which means that the conclusion that there was a mirror in the beam could be drawn from the signal of a photon that had not interacted with the mirror. The demonstration was found to be thought-provoking.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1996•35 citations

Many-body manifestation of interaction-free measurement: The Elitzur-Vaidman bomb

Oded Zilberberg, Alessandro Romito, Yuval Gefen

We consider an implementation of the Elitzur-Vaidman bomb experiment in a dc-biased electronic Mach-Zehnder interferometer with a leakage port on one of its arms playing the role of a ``lousy bomb.'' Many-body correlations tend to screen out manifestations of interaction-free measurement. Analyzing the correlations between the current at the interferometer's drains and at the leakage port, we identify the limit where the originally proposed single-particle effect is recovered. Specifically, we find that in the regime of sufficiently diluted injected electron beam and short measurement times, effects of quantum-mechanical wave-particle duality emerge in the cross-current correlations.

arXiv:1512.01086•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 9, 2016•5 citations

Experimental realization of interaction-free measurements

Harald Weinfurter, Paul G. Kwiat, Thomas Herzog +2 more

Recently, it has been pointed out that it is possible to make a quantum-mechanical interaction-free measurement (IFM), in which the existence of an object in a given region of space may be determined seemingly without interacting with it.1,2 In the embodiment first proposed by Elitzur and Vaidman,3 a standard Michelson interferometer is aligned so that incident single photons (obtained in our experiment by using parametric downconversion; see Fig. 1) must exit by the same port in which they entered, in the absence of any object within the interferometer. The presence of an object (e.g., the mirror leading to detector DB) in one of the arms completely changes the possible outcomes because the constructive interference is interrupted. Now it is possible that the photon will exit from the other exit port, to detector DIfm. By detecting the photon in this case, one can claim with certainty that an object was within the interferometer, even though the photon could not have interacted with it. If the beam splitter has a very low reflectivity, then the fraction of IFMs approaches 1/2.

Quantum Electronics and Laser Science Conference•May 22, 1995•8 citations

On the Paradoxical Aspects of New Quantum Experiments

Lev Vaidman A

I shall discuss two recently suggested quantum experiments. These experiments lead to paradoxical situations. I will argue that in the framework of a particular Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum theory the paradoxes do not arise. The first experiment is the “interaction-free measurement” (Elitzur and Vaidman 1993). The experimental group at Innsbruck headed by Prof. Zeilinger is working now on its realization. Before describing the experiment let me discuss a general question: “How do we know that there is an object in a region of space?” The simplest case is when the object itself causes some physical changes outside the region: i) The object is charged, so there is a field outside. We can measure this field. ii) The object yields a potential outside. Aharonov and Bohm have taught us that potential even without field leads to a measurable effect. iii) The objects radiates photons or other particles.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1994•31 citations

Interaction-Free Measurements, Hardy's Paradox and Bell's Theorem

José Daniel Marrero Falcón

Since the beginning of the last century, the mechanics of the quanta rapidly took an enigmatic character, surrounded by both advocates and detractors who were, simultaneously, amazed and horrified by its implications. From the “ultraviolet catastrophe” to the recent “quantum field theory”, the development of this cornerstone of physics has always been accompanied by one word: paradox. The dialectical engine of quantum mechanics is the contradiction between how our macroscopic mind “wants” the world to behave and how it actually does. Quanta have not only posed a challenge to unfortunate (or not) cats but also to theoretical physicists, who continue to debate its various interpretations. In this Bachelor Thesis, we study one of these paradoxes: “Hardy’s paradox” highlights two of the greater enigmas in the interpretation of the quantum theory. On the one hand, the wave-particle duality, fundamental for the functioning of the Mach-Zehnder interferometer on which it is based, and, on the other, nonlocality. In order to analyse it, we depart from the “interaction free measurements”, proposed by A. C. Elitzur and L. Vaidman, placing all the needed “thought experiments” in the context of the two state vector formalism developed by Y. Aharonov and collaborators. Additionally, supported by Feynman’s formalism, we solve this seemingly paradoxical situation caused by a counterfactual interpretation. Nonlocality has always been a source of debate in this context and was famously discussed by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen. The quantitative response to this discussion, Bell’s inequalities, places the debate at the laboratory, shifting from a philosophical to an experimental matter. The renowned inequalities can be summarized in Bell’s theorem, which we will prove without the need of inequalities, through Hardy’s setup.

Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas•Jun 5, 2024•0 citations
We present a paradox involving a particle and a mirror. They exchange a nonlocal quantity, modular angular momentum Lz mod 2ћ, but there seems to be no local interaction between them that allows such an exchange. We demonstrate that the particle and mirror do interact locally via a weak local current 〈Lz mod 2ћ〉w. In this sense, we transform the “interaction-free measurement” of Elitzur and Vaidman, in which two local quantities (the positions of a photon and a bomb in the two arms of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer) interact nonlocally, into a thought experiment in which two nonlocal quantities (the weak modular angular momentum of the particle and of the mirror) interact locally.
We revisit the "counterfactual quantum communication" of Salih et al. [1], who claim that an observer "Bob" can send one bit of information to a second observer "Alice" without any physical particle traveling between them. We show that a locally conserved, massless current-specifically, a current of modular angular momentum, L_{z} mod 2ℏ-carries the one bit of information. We integrate the flux of L_{z} mod 2ℏ from Bob to Alice and show that it equals one of the two eigenvalues of L_{z} mod 2ℏ, either 0 or ℏ, thus precisely accounting for the one bit of information he sends her. We previously [2] obtained this result using weak values of L_{z} mod ℏ; here we do not use weak values.
The gedanken experiment of Elitzur and Vaidman showing wave-particle duality was realized as a demonstration at a scientific exposition. Presence or absence of a mirror in one arm of an interferometer was measured while detecting one photon at a time. A reasonable fraction of events was ‘‘interaction-free,’’ which means that the conclusion that there was a mirror in the beam could be drawn from the signal of a photon that had not interacted with the mirror. The demonstration was found to be thought-provoking.
We consider an implementation of the Elitzur-Vaidman bomb experiment in a dc-biased electronic Mach-Zehnder interferometer with a leakage port on one of its arms playing the role of a ``lousy bomb.'' Many-body correlations tend to screen out manifestations of interaction-free measurement. Analyzing the correlations between the current at the interferometer's drains and at the leakage port, we identify the limit where the originally proposed single-particle effect is recovered. Specifically, we find that in the regime of sufficiently diluted injected electron beam and short measurement times, effects of quantum-mechanical wave-particle duality emerge in the cross-current correlations.
Recently, it has been pointed out that it is possible to make a quantum-mechanical interaction-free measurement (IFM), in which the existence of an object in a given region of space may be determined seemingly without interacting with it.1,2 In the embodiment first proposed by Elitzur and Vaidman,3 a standard Michelson interferometer is aligned so that incident single photons (obtained in our experiment by using parametric downconversion; see Fig. 1) must exit by the same port in which they entered, in the absence of any object within the interferometer. The presence of an object (e.g., the mirror leading to detector DB) in one of the arms completely changes the possible outcomes because the constructive interference is interrupted. Now it is possible that the photon will exit from the other exit port, to detector DIfm. By detecting the photon in this case, one can claim with certainty that an object was within the interferometer, even though the photon could not have interacted with it. If the beam splitter has a very low reflectivity, then the fraction of IFMs approaches 1/2.
I shall discuss two recently suggested quantum experiments. These experiments lead to paradoxical situations. I will argue that in the framework of a particular Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum theory the paradoxes do not arise. The first experiment is the “interaction-free measurement” (Elitzur and Vaidman 1993). The experimental group at Innsbruck headed by Prof. Zeilinger is working now on its realization. Before describing the experiment let me discuss a general question: “How do we know that there is an object in a region of space?” The simplest case is when the object itself causes some physical changes outside the region: i) The object is charged, so there is a field outside. We can measure this field. ii) The object yields a potential outside. Aharonov and Bohm have taught us that potential even without field leads to a measurable effect. iii) The objects radiates photons or other particles.
Since the beginning of the last century, the mechanics of the quanta rapidly took an enigmatic character, surrounded by both advocates and detractors who were, simultaneously, amazed and horrified by its implications. From the “ultraviolet catastrophe” to the recent “quantum field theory”, the development of this cornerstone of physics has always been accompanied by one word: paradox. The dialectical engine of quantum mechanics is the contradiction between how our macroscopic mind “wants” the world to behave and how it actually does. Quanta have not only posed a challenge to unfortunate (or not) cats but also to theoretical physicists, who continue to debate its various interpretations. In this Bachelor Thesis, we study one of these paradoxes: “Hardy’s paradox” highlights two of the greater enigmas in the interpretation of the quantum theory. On the one hand, the wave-particle duality, fundamental for the functioning of the Mach-Zehnder interferometer on which it is based, and, on the other, nonlocality. In order to analyse it, we depart from the “interaction free measurements”, proposed by A. C. Elitzur and L. Vaidman, placing all the needed “thought experiments” in the context of the two state vector formalism developed by Y. Aharonov and collaborators. Additionally, supported by Feynman’s formalism, we solve this seemingly paradoxical situation caused by a counterfactual interpretation. Nonlocality has always been a source of debate in this context and was famously discussed by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen. The quantitative response to this discussion, Bell’s inequalities, places the debate at the laboratory, shifting from a philosophical to an experimental matter. The renowned inequalities can be summarized in Bell’s theorem, which we will prove without the need of inequalities, through Hardy’s setup.