Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas
Interaction-Free Measurements, Hardy's Paradox and Bell's Theorem
José Daniel Marrero Falcón
Abstract
Since the beginning of the last century, the mechanics of the quanta rapidly took an enigmatic character, surrounded by both advocates and detractors who were, simultaneously, amazed and horrified by its implications. From the “ultraviolet catastrophe” to the recent “quantum field theory”, the development of this cornerstone of physics has always been accompanied by one word: paradox. The dialectical engine of quantum mechanics is the contradiction between how our macroscopic mind “wants” the world to behave and how it actually does. Quanta have not only posed a challenge to unfortunate (or not) cats but also to theoretical physicists, who continue to debate its various interpretations. In this Bachelor Thesis, we study one of these paradoxes: “Hardy’s paradox” highlights two of the greater enigmas in the interpretation of the quantum theory. On the one hand, the wave-particle duality, fundamental for the functioning of the Mach-Zehnder interferometer on which it is based, and, on the other, nonlocality. In order to analyse it, we depart from the “interaction free measurements”, proposed by A. C. Elitzur and L. Vaidman, placing all the needed “thought experiments” in the context of the two state vector formalism developed by Y. Aharonov and collaborators. Additionally, supported by Feynman’s formalism, we solve this seemingly paradoxical situation caused by a counterfactual interpretation. Nonlocality has always been a source of debate in this context and was famously discussed by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen. The quantitative response to this discussion, Bell’s inequalities, places the debate at the laboratory, shifting from a philosophical to an experimental matter. The renowned inequalities can be summarized in Bell’s theorem, which we will prove without the need of inequalities, through Hardy’s setup.