Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

High-Fidelity Entangling Gates with Trapped-Ions

Ting Rei Tan

Published Jan 1, 2016• 2 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum entangling logic gates are key ingredients for the implementation of a quantum information processing device. In this thesis, we focus on experimental implementations of three types of entangling geometric-phase gates with trapped ions, which rely on the effective spin-spin interactions generated with state-dependent forces. First, a mixed-species entangling gate is demonstrated using a 9Be+ and a 25Mg+ ion to create a Bell state with a fidelity of 0.979(1). Combined with single-qubit gates, we use this mixed-species gate to implement controlled-NOT and SWAP gates. Second, we implement a high-fidelity universal gate set with 9Be+ ions. Single-qubit gates with error per gate of 3.8(1)x10-5 are achieved. By creating a Bell state with a deterministic two-qubit entangling gate, we deduce a gate error as low as 8(4)x10-4. Third, a novel two-qubit entangling gate with dynamical decoupling built-in is demonstrated with a fidelity of 0.974(4). This gate is robust against qubit dephasing errors and offers simplifications in experimental implementation compared to some other gates with trapped ions. Errors in the above implementations are evaluated and methods to further reduce imperfections are discussed. In a separate experiment, correlated measurements made on pairs of ions violate a "chained" Bell inequality obeyed by any local-realistic theory. The lowest chained Bell inequality parameter determined from our measurements is 0.296(12), this value is significantly lower than 0.586, the minimum value derived from a perfect Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Horne (CHSH) Bell inequality experiment. Furthermore, our CHSH Bell inequality results provide a device-independent certification of the deterministically created Bell states.

Related papers

Demonstration of a Dressed-State Phase Gate for Trapped Ions

Ting Rei Tan, John Gaebler, R. Bowler +4 more

We demonstrate a trapped-ion entangling-gate scheme proposed by Bermudez et al. [Phys. Rev. A 85, 040302 (2012)]. Simultaneous excitation of a strong carrier and a single-sideband transition enables deterministic creation of entangled states. The method works for magnetic field-insensitive states, is robust against thermal excitations, includes dynamical decoupling from qubit dephasing errors, and provides simplifications in experimental implementation compared to some other entangling gates with trapped ions. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 0.974(4) and identify the main sources of error.

arXiv:1301.3786•Physical Review Letters•Jun 26, 2013•72 citations

Robust high fidelity microwave near-field entangling quantum logic gate

Giorgio Zarantonello

Trapped ions, together with superconducting qubits, are one of the two leading hardware platforms for scalable quantum information processing. The development of quantum computers represents a major technological breakthrough comparable to the introduction of classical computing. The benefits of this technology are currently limited by the technical capability to perform high fidelity entangling operations on the qubits. When gate fidelities surpass the fault-tolerance threshold it becomes possible, through error correction, to increase the system size to an arbitrary number of qubits. In this cumulative thesis we address some of the issues in the scalability of the trapped-ion quantum computer based on microwave near-fields. In this approach, gate operations on one or multiple ions are driven by an oscillating magnetic field generated by a current flowing through a conductor. In the first part of this work we discuss the design of traps toward the implementation of large scale systems. We introduce the basic design of a surface-electrode ion trap with embedded microwave conductors. The oscillating magnetic field required to perform the operations is generated by a single optimized conductor. We discuss the simulation and characterization of the magnetic field pattern, which is fixed by the microwave conductor design. In addition, we demonstrate the capability to simulate, fabricate and characterize a multilayer surface ion trap. Multilayer traps are a key aspect for scalability since they are necessary to achieve large system sizes, with many `ion registers', where the registers are interconnected by physically transporting ions between them. In the second part of this thesis we demonstrate the implementation of a two-qubit entangling gate and we explore the possibilities offered by quantum control methods to improve its fidelity. We perform an entangling gate on two 9Be+ ions and measure a Bell state fidelity of 98.2(1.2)%. Error characterization shows that the gate result is limited by technical issues connected to the ions' motional states. To reduce these errors we apply amplitude modulation of the gate microwave drive. After stabilization of the ions' radial modes, we obtain an amplitude modulated gate with infidelity in the 10^-3 range. The result is confirmed by analyzing the data using three different methods. Using additional dynamic decoupling techniques, these results could bring microwave near-field gates past the fault-tolerance threshold.

•Jan 1, 2020•1 citation

High-fidelity mixed species entanglement of trapped ions

K. Thirumalai

Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.

•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

Quantum information processing with two trapped cadmium ions.

Patricia J. Lee

Quantum information processing combines information theory with laws of quantum mechanics to provide an interesting new study that promises significant technological advances in the field of computation. The quest for a physical quantum information processor not only tests the limits of quantum mechanics but also motivates the development of new control techniques for quantum systems. This thesis documents the implementation of the necessary components of a quantum computer in a new atomic ion species, while demonstrating an entangling procedure that is uniquely insensitive to certain types of phase noise. Quantum bits are stored in the ground state hyperfine levels of individual trapped cadmium ions, and the collective vibration of the ions in the trap potential form a quantum databus through which information can be transferred. Quantum state measurements and initialization processes are accomplished through optical pumping, and quantum logic operations are performed through interactions with applied electromagnetic fields. The spin-dependent force, which is the underlying principle of many entanglement schemes for trapped ions, is investigated in detail in a series of Schrodinger cat experiments that generates entangled wavepackets well separated in the momentum-position phase space (alpha = 6). Phase control of the interaction in the gate scheme proposed by Molmer and Sorensen results in phase coherence between single-qubit rotations and a robust two-qubit entangling logic gate that can operate on magnetic-field insensitive clock qubits at finite temperature. The coherence time of the clock qubit (∼ 1s) is long compared to the gate time (∼ 100mus). Finally, quantum state tomography is performed on two ions, featuring a set of universal quantum logic gates that is sufficient for any quantum computation, with an entangling gate fidelity of 0.83. The combination of the tools developed here is sufficient to perform universal quantum computation. With the advent of scalable, multi-zone ion trap structures, the concept of a quantum computation device may become reality in the not so distant future.

•Jan 1, 2006•4 citations

A small trapped-ion quantum register

D. Kielpinski

We review experiments performed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology on entanglement, Bell's inequality and decoherence-free subspaces (DFSs) in a quantum register of trapped 9 Be + ions. The group of Dr David Wineland has demonstrated entanglement of up to four ions using the technique of Mølmer and Sørensen. This method produces the state (|↓↓ ⟩ + |↑↑ ⟩)/√2 for two ions and the state (|↓↓↓↓ ⟩ + |↑↑↑↑ ⟩)/√2 for four ions. The entanglement was generated deterministically in each shot of the experiment. Measurements on the two-ion entangled state violate Bell's inequality at the 8σ level. Because of the high detector efficiency of the apparatus, this experiment closes the detector loophole for Bell's inequality measurements for the first time. This measurement is also the first violation of Bell's inequality by massive particles that does not implicitly assume results from quantum mechanics. The group also demonstrated measurement of an interferometric phase with precision better than the shot-noise limit using a two-ion entangled state. A large-scale version of this scheme could improve the signal-to-noise ratio of atomic clocks by orders of magnitude. Further experiments demonstrated reversible encoding of an arbitrary qubit, originally contained in one ion, into a DFS of two ions. The DFS-encoded qubit resists applied collective dephasing noise and retains coherence under ambient conditions 3.6 times longer than does an unencoded qubit. The encoding method, which uses single-ion gates and the two-ion entangling gate, demonstrates all the elements required for two-qubit universal quantum logic. Finally, we describe an architecture for a large-scale ion trap quantum computer. By performing logic gates on small numbers of ions trapped in separate regions of the array, we take advantage of existing techniques for manipulating small trapped-ion quantum registers while enabling massively parallel gate operation. Encoding the quantum information in the DFS removes decoherence associated with ion transport and imperfect clock synchronization.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Apr 11, 2003•11 citations

Robust quantum logic for trapped ion quantum computers

A. E. Webb

This thesis describes experimental work on implementing single and two qubit gates in ¹7¹Yb+ ions using methods suitable for a large scale quantum computer. By combining a magnetic field gradient with microwave and radiofrequency radiation, the spin and motional states of the ions are coupled which allows multi-qubit operations to be performed, as well as providing individual addressing of ions in frequency space. A dressed state qubit is used which exhibits an increase of over two orders of magnitude in the coherence time for a qubit that it is sensitive to the magnetic field gradient. Using this system, single qubit gates are characterised using the technique of randomised benchmarking, resulting in a measured average error per gate of 9(3)x10¯4. A new type of two qubit gate is experimentally demonstrated, which in comparison to a standard two qubit gate shows significantly increased resilience to two major sources of gate infidelity: heating of the motional mode of the ions during gate operations, and incorrectly set gate field frequencies. These types of errors are expected to become increasingly important with the move towards quantum processors with large numbers of qubits. Using this same technique, a two qubit gate is also demonstrated at a higher initial temperature with a significantly improved fidelity compared to standard methods. These gate techniques are used to demonstrate work towards implementing positiondependent quantum logic, a method which could remove the correlation between the number of ions and the number of gate fields required in a large scale quantum computing architecture. A method to move the dressed state qubit through a magnetic field gradient while preserving quantum information is demonstrated, as well as a method to optimise the phase of a two qubit gate of unknown phase in order to implement a CNOT logic gate. This provides a path forwards to demonstrating a CNOT gate using position-dependent quantum logic.

•Jun 21, 2019•0 citations
Quantum entangling logic gates are key ingredients for the implementation of a quantum information processing device. In this thesis, we focus on experimental implementations of three types of entangling geometric-phase gates with trapped ions, which rely on the effective spin-spin interactions generated with state-dependent forces. First, a mixed-species entangling gate is demonstrated using a 9Be+ and a 25Mg+ ion to create a Bell state with a fidelity of 0.979(1). Combined with single-qubit gates, we use this mixed-species gate to implement controlled-NOT and SWAP gates. Second, we implement a high-fidelity universal gate set with 9Be+ ions. Single-qubit gates with error per gate of 3.8(1)x10-5 are achieved. By creating a Bell state with a deterministic two-qubit entangling gate, we deduce a gate error as low as 8(4)x10-4. Third, a novel two-qubit entangling gate with dynamical decoupling built-in is demonstrated with a fidelity of 0.974(4). This gate is robust against qubit dephasing errors and offers simplifications in experimental implementation compared to some other gates with trapped ions. Errors in the above implementations are evaluated and methods to further reduce imperfections are discussed. In a separate experiment, correlated measurements made on pairs of ions violate a "chained" Bell inequality obeyed by any local-realistic theory. The lowest chained Bell inequality parameter determined from our measurements is 0.296(12), this value is significantly lower than 0.586, the minimum value derived from a perfect Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Horne (CHSH) Bell inequality experiment. Furthermore, our CHSH Bell inequality results provide a device-independent certification of the deterministically created Bell states.
We demonstrate a trapped-ion entangling-gate scheme proposed by Bermudez et al. [Phys. Rev. A 85, 040302 (2012)]. Simultaneous excitation of a strong carrier and a single-sideband transition enables deterministic creation of entangled states. The method works for magnetic field-insensitive states, is robust against thermal excitations, includes dynamical decoupling from qubit dephasing errors, and provides simplifications in experimental implementation compared to some other entangling gates with trapped ions. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 0.974(4) and identify the main sources of error.
Trapped ions, together with superconducting qubits, are one of the two leading hardware platforms for scalable quantum information processing. The development of quantum computers represents a major technological breakthrough comparable to the introduction of classical computing. The benefits of this technology are currently limited by the technical capability to perform high fidelity entangling operations on the qubits. When gate fidelities surpass the fault-tolerance threshold it becomes possible, through error correction, to increase the system size to an arbitrary number of qubits. In this cumulative thesis we address some of the issues in the scalability of the trapped-ion quantum computer based on microwave near-fields. In this approach, gate operations on one or multiple ions are driven by an oscillating magnetic field generated by a current flowing through a conductor. In the first part of this work we discuss the design of traps toward the implementation of large scale systems. We introduce the basic design of a surface-electrode ion trap with embedded microwave conductors. The oscillating magnetic field required to perform the operations is generated by a single optimized conductor. We discuss the simulation and characterization of the magnetic field pattern, which is fixed by the microwave conductor design. In addition, we demonstrate the capability to simulate, fabricate and characterize a multilayer surface ion trap. Multilayer traps are a key aspect for scalability since they are necessary to achieve large system sizes, with many `ion registers', where the registers are interconnected by physically transporting ions between them. In the second part of this thesis we demonstrate the implementation of a two-qubit entangling gate and we explore the possibilities offered by quantum control methods to improve its fidelity. We perform an entangling gate on two 9Be+ ions and measure a Bell state fidelity of 98.2(1.2)%. Error characterization shows that the gate result is limited by technical issues connected to the ions' motional states. To reduce these errors we apply amplitude modulation of the gate microwave drive. After stabilization of the ions' radial modes, we obtain an amplitude modulated gate with infidelity in the 10^-3 range. The result is confirmed by analyzing the data using three different methods. Using additional dynamic decoupling techniques, these results could bring microwave near-field gates past the fault-tolerance threshold.
Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.
Quantum information processing combines information theory with laws of quantum mechanics to provide an interesting new study that promises significant technological advances in the field of computation. The quest for a physical quantum information processor not only tests the limits of quantum mechanics but also motivates the development of new control techniques for quantum systems. This thesis documents the implementation of the necessary components of a quantum computer in a new atomic ion species, while demonstrating an entangling procedure that is uniquely insensitive to certain types of phase noise. Quantum bits are stored in the ground state hyperfine levels of individual trapped cadmium ions, and the collective vibration of the ions in the trap potential form a quantum databus through which information can be transferred. Quantum state measurements and initialization processes are accomplished through optical pumping, and quantum logic operations are performed through interactions with applied electromagnetic fields. The spin-dependent force, which is the underlying principle of many entanglement schemes for trapped ions, is investigated in detail in a series of Schrodinger cat experiments that generates entangled wavepackets well separated in the momentum-position phase space (alpha = 6). Phase control of the interaction in the gate scheme proposed by Molmer and Sorensen results in phase coherence between single-qubit rotations and a robust two-qubit entangling logic gate that can operate on magnetic-field insensitive clock qubits at finite temperature. The coherence time of the clock qubit (∼ 1s) is long compared to the gate time (∼ 100mus). Finally, quantum state tomography is performed on two ions, featuring a set of universal quantum logic gates that is sufficient for any quantum computation, with an entangling gate fidelity of 0.83. The combination of the tools developed here is sufficient to perform universal quantum computation. With the advent of scalable, multi-zone ion trap structures, the concept of a quantum computation device may become reality in the not so distant future.
We review experiments performed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology on entanglement, Bell's inequality and decoherence-free subspaces (DFSs) in a quantum register of trapped 9 Be + ions. The group of Dr David Wineland has demonstrated entanglement of up to four ions using the technique of Mølmer and Sørensen. This method produces the state (|↓↓ ⟩ + |↑↑ ⟩)/√2 for two ions and the state (|↓↓↓↓ ⟩ + |↑↑↑↑ ⟩)/√2 for four ions. The entanglement was generated deterministically in each shot of the experiment. Measurements on the two-ion entangled state violate Bell's inequality at the 8σ level. Because of the high detector efficiency of the apparatus, this experiment closes the detector loophole for Bell's inequality measurements for the first time. This measurement is also the first violation of Bell's inequality by massive particles that does not implicitly assume results from quantum mechanics. The group also demonstrated measurement of an interferometric phase with precision better than the shot-noise limit using a two-ion entangled state. A large-scale version of this scheme could improve the signal-to-noise ratio of atomic clocks by orders of magnitude. Further experiments demonstrated reversible encoding of an arbitrary qubit, originally contained in one ion, into a DFS of two ions. The DFS-encoded qubit resists applied collective dephasing noise and retains coherence under ambient conditions 3.6 times longer than does an unencoded qubit. The encoding method, which uses single-ion gates and the two-ion entangling gate, demonstrates all the elements required for two-qubit universal quantum logic. Finally, we describe an architecture for a large-scale ion trap quantum computer. By performing logic gates on small numbers of ions trapped in separate regions of the array, we take advantage of existing techniques for manipulating small trapped-ion quantum registers while enabling massively parallel gate operation. Encoding the quantum information in the DFS removes decoherence associated with ion transport and imperfect clock synchronization.
This thesis describes experimental work on implementing single and two qubit gates in ¹7¹Yb+ ions using methods suitable for a large scale quantum computer. By combining a magnetic field gradient with microwave and radiofrequency radiation, the spin and motional states of the ions are coupled which allows multi-qubit operations to be performed, as well as providing individual addressing of ions in frequency space. A dressed state qubit is used which exhibits an increase of over two orders of magnitude in the coherence time for a qubit that it is sensitive to the magnetic field gradient. Using this system, single qubit gates are characterised using the technique of randomised benchmarking, resulting in a measured average error per gate of 9(3)x10¯4. A new type of two qubit gate is experimentally demonstrated, which in comparison to a standard two qubit gate shows significantly increased resilience to two major sources of gate infidelity: heating of the motional mode of the ions during gate operations, and incorrectly set gate field frequencies. These types of errors are expected to become increasingly important with the move towards quantum processors with large numbers of qubits. Using this same technique, a two qubit gate is also demonstrated at a higher initial temperature with a significantly improved fidelity compared to standard methods. These gate techniques are used to demonstrate work towards implementing positiondependent quantum logic, a method which could remove the correlation between the number of ions and the number of gate fields required in a large scale quantum computing architecture. A method to move the dressed state qubit through a magnetic field gradient while preserving quantum information is demonstrated, as well as a method to optimise the phase of a two qubit gate of unknown phase in order to implement a CNOT logic gate. This provides a path forwards to demonstrating a CNOT gate using position-dependent quantum logic.