Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

High-fidelity mixed species entanglement of trapped ions

K. Thirumalai

Published Jan 1, 2019• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.

DOI
10.5287/ora-0zk8zavqp

Related papers

Entanglement between nodes of a quantum network

L. J. Stephenson

Quantum devices are rapidly gaining momentum as a technology that will induce a paradigm shift in computing, communication and cryptography. Trapped ion qubits are one of the leading candidates for implementing a quantum computer, having previously demonstrated all of the required criteria. Local gate fidelities between ions exceed those for all other platforms, but the total number of ions in a trap is limited by unavoidable issues – one possibility for scaling the ion trap quantum processor is to create entanglement between ions in separate traps via single photons. The work in this thesis demonstrates the generation of remote entanglement between ions at high fidelity and rate, paving the way towards protocols using multiple entangled pairs for computations. We describe the construction from scratch of a twin-trap apparatus designed to entangle separated ions. We demonstrate the entanglement of strontium ions in traps separated by ∼ 2 m by swapping entanglement from single photons emitted by the 88Sr+ ions. A novel photon collection geometry is used, maximising the entanglement between the ion and photon without impeding optical access for standard ion trap laser beam geometries. The Bell state fidelity of the ion-photon state, which is itself a valuable entanglement resource for blind computation, is at least 97.70(12) % in either trap, with entangled pairs detected at a rate of at least 3.98 × 103 s−1. The remote ion-ion Bell state fidelity is 94.0(5) %, and is generated at a rate of 182 s−1, representing the highest fidelity remote entanglement reported in ions by a large margin, at a rate more than an order of magnitude faster than previous experiments. The two identical trap systems are designed with capabilities beyond those demonstrated here. We can co-trap 88Sr+ and 43Ca+ in a microfabricated trap suitable for local ion transport operations, opening up the possibility of performing distillation of remote entanglement in the same apparatus. Entanglement distillation can be used to make remote entanglement with similar fidelity to local operations, and would represent a significant step towards a fully scalable ion trap quantum computer architecture.

•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

Distributed quantum computing across a two-node trapped-ion quantum network

Main, Dougal

Distributed quantum computing (DQC) combines the computing power of multiple networked quantum processing modules, ideally enabling the execution of large quantum circuits without compromising performance or connectivity. Photonic networks are well-suited as a versatile and reconfigurable interconnect layer for DQC; remote entanglement shared between matter qubits across the network enables all-to-all logical connectivity via quantum gate teleportation (QGT). For a scalable DQC architecture, the QGT implementation must be deterministic and repeatable; until now, no demonstration has satisfied these requirements. In this thesis, we report the first experimental demonstration of distributed quantum computing across a quantum network of two photonically interconnected trapped-ion modules. Our experimental apparatus comprises two trapped-ion modules, separated by ∼ 2 m, each co-trapping one 43Ca+ ion and one 88Sr+ ion. The 43Ca+ ions provide a robust quantum memory for the modules, while the 88Sr+ ions provide an interface to the optical quantum network, enabling the remote entanglement of 88Sr+ ions in separate modules. Using local mixed-species operations, we demonstrate the enhanced functionality of the mixed-species trapped-ion quantum network by creating more complex remotely entangled states. These include remote 88Sr+- 43Ca+ and 43Ca+-43Ca+ entanglement, as well as 3- and 4-qubit mixed-species GHZ states. Additionally, we demonstrate the storage of remote entanglement in the 43Ca+ ions for up to 10 s. Utilising these techniques, we demonstrate the distribution of quantum computations across the mixed-species trapped-ion quantum network. Using heralded remote entanglement between the 88Sr+ ions, we deterministically teleport controlled Z gates between two 43Ca+ ions in separate modules, achieving a fidelity of 86 %. We then implement distributed iSWAP and SWAP circuits, compiled with 2 and 3 instances of QGT, respectively, demonstrating the ability to distribute arbitrary two-qubit operations. Finally, we execute Grover’s search algorithm – the first implementation of a distributed quantum algorithm comprising multiple non-local two-qubit gates – and measure a success rate of 71 %. These results represent a significant step towards realising a large-scale distributed quantum computer.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Mixed-Species Ion Chains for Quantum Networks

Ksenia Sosnova

Quantum computing promises solutions to some of the world's most important problems that classical computers have failed to address. The trapped-ion-based quantum computing platform has a lot of advantages for doing so: ions are perfectly identical and near-perfectly isolated, feature long coherent times, and allow high-fidelity individual laser-controlled operations. One of the greatest remaining obstacles in trapped-ion-based quantum computing is the issue of scalability. The approach that we take to address this issue is a modular architecture: separate ion traps, each with a manageable number of ions, are interconnected via photonic links. To avoid photon-generated crosstalk between qubits and utilize advantages of different kinds of ions for each role, we use two distinct species - ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ as memory qubits and ¹³⁸Ba⁺ as communication qubits. The qubits based on ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ are defined within the hyperfine "clock" states characterized by a very long coherence time while ¹³⁸Ba⁺ ions feature visible-range wavelength emission lines. Current optical and fiber technologies are more efficient in this range than at shorter wavelengths. We present a theoretical description and experimental demonstration of the key elements of a quantum network based on the mixed-species paradigm. The first one is entanglement between an atomic qubit and the polarization degree of freedom of a pure single photon. We observe a value of the second-order correlation function g⁽²⁾(0) = (8.1 ± 2.3)⨉10⁻⁵ without background subtraction, which is consistent with the lowest reported value in any system. Next, we show mixed-species entangling gates with two ions using the Mølmer-Sørensen and Cirac-Zoller protocols. Finally, we theoretically generalize mixed-species entangling gates to long ion chains and characterize the roles of normal modes there. In addition, we explore sympathetic cooling efficiency in such mixed-species crystals. Besides these developments, we demonstrate new techniques for manipulating states within the D₃⸝₂-manifold of zero-nuclear-spin ions - a part of a protected qubit scheme promising seconds-long coherence times proposed by Aharon et al. in 2013. As a next step, we provide a detailed description of the protocols for three- and four-node networks with mixed species, along with a novel design for the third trap with in-vacuum optics to optimize light collection.

•Jan 1, 2020•2 citations

A Modular Quantum System of Trapped Atomic Ions

David Hucul

Scaling up controlled quantum systems to involve large numbers of qubits remains one of the outstanding challenges of quantum information science. One path toward scalability is the use of a modular architecture where adjacent qubits may be entangled with applied electromagnetic fields, and remote qubits may be entangled using photon interference. Trapped atomic ion qubits are one of the most promising platforms for scaling up quantum systems by combining long coherence times with high fidelity entangling operations between proximate and remote qubits. In this thesis, I present experimental progress on combining entanglement between remote atomic ions separated by 1 meter with near-eld entanglement between atomic ions in the same ion trap. I describe the experimental improvements to increase the remote entanglement rate by orders of magnitude to nearly 5 per second. This is the first experimental demonstration where the remote entanglement rate exceeds the decoherence rate of the entangled qubits. The flexibility of creating remote entanglement through photon interference is demonstrated by using the interference of distinguishable photons without sacrificing remote entanglement rate or fidelity. Next I describe the use of master clock in combination with a frequency comb to lock the phases of all laser-induced interactions between remote ion traps while removing optical phase stability requirements. The combination of both types of entanglement gates to create a small quantum network are described. Finally, I present ways to mitigate cross talk between photonic and memory qubits by using different trapped ion species. I show preliminary work on performing state detection of nuclear spin 0 ions by using entanglement between atomic ion spin and photon polarization. These control techniques may be important for building a large-scale modular quantum system.

•Jan 1, 2015•2 citations

Progress towards a three-node ion-trap quantum network

George Toh, Jameson P. O'Reilly, Sagnik Saha +4 more

Trapped ions are one of the leading platforms for quantum computation and networking, with long coherence times and high fidelity qubit operation. We exploit these attributes to build a quantum network with the use of three trapped ion modules connected via photonic links. In each of these systems, we have ions of different species for use as memory or communication qubits. Our newest module contains two high NA=0.8 objectives, each covering 20% of the solid angle of photons emitted from the ion, making it suitable for use as the middle node of the network. Photons are collected from each chamber, and we generate remote entanglement between each pair of nodes by interfering the photons on a beamsplitter. This heralds entanglement of the communication ions in the pair of network nodes, which we then swap onto the memory qubits. I will discuss our progress towards creating a Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state between the memory ions in the three nodes.

Quantum Computing, Communication, and Simulation•Mar 8, 2023•3 citations

Remote and Local Entanglement of Ions using Photons and Phonons

David Hayes

The scaling of controlled quantum systems to large numbers of degrees of freedom is one of the long term goals of experimental quantum information science. Trapped-ion systems are one of the most promising platforms for building a quantum information processor with enough complexity to enable novel computational power, but face serious challenges in scaling up to the necessary numbers of qubits. In this thesis, I present both technical and operational advancements in the control of trapped-ion systems and their juxtaposition with photonic modes used for quantum networking. After reviewing the basic physics behind ion trapping, I then describe in detail a new method of implementing Raman transitions in atomic systems using optical frequency combs. Several dierent experimental setups along with simple theoretical models are reviewed and the system is shown to be capable of full control of the qubit-oscillator system. Two-ion entangling operations using optical frequency combs are demonstrated along with an extension of the operation designed to suppress certain experimental errors. I then give an overview of how spatially separated ions can be entangled using a photonic interconnect. Experimental results show that pulsed excitation of trapped ions provide an excellent single photon source that can be used as a heralded entangling gate between macroscopically separated systems. This heralded entangling gate is used to show a violation of a Bell inequality while keeping the detection loophole closed and can be used a source private random numbers. Finally, the coherent Coulomb force-based gates are combined with the probabilistic photon-based gates in a proof of concept experiment that shows the feasibility of a distributed ion-photon network.

•Jan 1, 2012•2 citations
Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.
Quantum devices are rapidly gaining momentum as a technology that will induce a paradigm shift in computing, communication and cryptography. Trapped ion qubits are one of the leading candidates for implementing a quantum computer, having previously demonstrated all of the required criteria. Local gate fidelities between ions exceed those for all other platforms, but the total number of ions in a trap is limited by unavoidable issues – one possibility for scaling the ion trap quantum processor is to create entanglement between ions in separate traps via single photons. The work in this thesis demonstrates the generation of remote entanglement between ions at high fidelity and rate, paving the way towards protocols using multiple entangled pairs for computations. We describe the construction from scratch of a twin-trap apparatus designed to entangle separated ions. We demonstrate the entanglement of strontium ions in traps separated by ∼ 2 m by swapping entanglement from single photons emitted by the 88Sr+ ions. A novel photon collection geometry is used, maximising the entanglement between the ion and photon without impeding optical access for standard ion trap laser beam geometries. The Bell state fidelity of the ion-photon state, which is itself a valuable entanglement resource for blind computation, is at least 97.70(12) % in either trap, with entangled pairs detected at a rate of at least 3.98 × 103 s−1. The remote ion-ion Bell state fidelity is 94.0(5) %, and is generated at a rate of 182 s−1, representing the highest fidelity remote entanglement reported in ions by a large margin, at a rate more than an order of magnitude faster than previous experiments. The two identical trap systems are designed with capabilities beyond those demonstrated here. We can co-trap 88Sr+ and 43Ca+ in a microfabricated trap suitable for local ion transport operations, opening up the possibility of performing distillation of remote entanglement in the same apparatus. Entanglement distillation can be used to make remote entanglement with similar fidelity to local operations, and would represent a significant step towards a fully scalable ion trap quantum computer architecture.
Distributed quantum computing (DQC) combines the computing power of multiple networked quantum processing modules, ideally enabling the execution of large quantum circuits without compromising performance or connectivity. Photonic networks are well-suited as a versatile and reconfigurable interconnect layer for DQC; remote entanglement shared between matter qubits across the network enables all-to-all logical connectivity via quantum gate teleportation (QGT). For a scalable DQC architecture, the QGT implementation must be deterministic and repeatable; until now, no demonstration has satisfied these requirements. In this thesis, we report the first experimental demonstration of distributed quantum computing across a quantum network of two photonically interconnected trapped-ion modules. Our experimental apparatus comprises two trapped-ion modules, separated by ∼ 2 m, each co-trapping one 43Ca+ ion and one 88Sr+ ion. The 43Ca+ ions provide a robust quantum memory for the modules, while the 88Sr+ ions provide an interface to the optical quantum network, enabling the remote entanglement of 88Sr+ ions in separate modules. Using local mixed-species operations, we demonstrate the enhanced functionality of the mixed-species trapped-ion quantum network by creating more complex remotely entangled states. These include remote 88Sr+- 43Ca+ and 43Ca+-43Ca+ entanglement, as well as 3- and 4-qubit mixed-species GHZ states. Additionally, we demonstrate the storage of remote entanglement in the 43Ca+ ions for up to 10 s. Utilising these techniques, we demonstrate the distribution of quantum computations across the mixed-species trapped-ion quantum network. Using heralded remote entanglement between the 88Sr+ ions, we deterministically teleport controlled Z gates between two 43Ca+ ions in separate modules, achieving a fidelity of 86 %. We then implement distributed iSWAP and SWAP circuits, compiled with 2 and 3 instances of QGT, respectively, demonstrating the ability to distribute arbitrary two-qubit operations. Finally, we execute Grover’s search algorithm – the first implementation of a distributed quantum algorithm comprising multiple non-local two-qubit gates – and measure a success rate of 71 %. These results represent a significant step towards realising a large-scale distributed quantum computer.
Quantum computing promises solutions to some of the world's most important problems that classical computers have failed to address. The trapped-ion-based quantum computing platform has a lot of advantages for doing so: ions are perfectly identical and near-perfectly isolated, feature long coherent times, and allow high-fidelity individual laser-controlled operations. One of the greatest remaining obstacles in trapped-ion-based quantum computing is the issue of scalability. The approach that we take to address this issue is a modular architecture: separate ion traps, each with a manageable number of ions, are interconnected via photonic links. To avoid photon-generated crosstalk between qubits and utilize advantages of different kinds of ions for each role, we use two distinct species - ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ as memory qubits and ¹³⁸Ba⁺ as communication qubits. The qubits based on ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ are defined within the hyperfine "clock" states characterized by a very long coherence time while ¹³⁸Ba⁺ ions feature visible-range wavelength emission lines. Current optical and fiber technologies are more efficient in this range than at shorter wavelengths. We present a theoretical description and experimental demonstration of the key elements of a quantum network based on the mixed-species paradigm. The first one is entanglement between an atomic qubit and the polarization degree of freedom of a pure single photon. We observe a value of the second-order correlation function g⁽²⁾(0) = (8.1 ± 2.3)⨉10⁻⁵ without background subtraction, which is consistent with the lowest reported value in any system. Next, we show mixed-species entangling gates with two ions using the Mølmer-Sørensen and Cirac-Zoller protocols. Finally, we theoretically generalize mixed-species entangling gates to long ion chains and characterize the roles of normal modes there. In addition, we explore sympathetic cooling efficiency in such mixed-species crystals. Besides these developments, we demonstrate new techniques for manipulating states within the D₃⸝₂-manifold of zero-nuclear-spin ions - a part of a protected qubit scheme promising seconds-long coherence times proposed by Aharon et al. in 2013. As a next step, we provide a detailed description of the protocols for three- and four-node networks with mixed species, along with a novel design for the third trap with in-vacuum optics to optimize light collection.
Scaling up controlled quantum systems to involve large numbers of qubits remains one of the outstanding challenges of quantum information science. One path toward scalability is the use of a modular architecture where adjacent qubits may be entangled with applied electromagnetic fields, and remote qubits may be entangled using photon interference. Trapped atomic ion qubits are one of the most promising platforms for scaling up quantum systems by combining long coherence times with high fidelity entangling operations between proximate and remote qubits. In this thesis, I present experimental progress on combining entanglement between remote atomic ions separated by 1 meter with near-eld entanglement between atomic ions in the same ion trap. I describe the experimental improvements to increase the remote entanglement rate by orders of magnitude to nearly 5 per second. This is the first experimental demonstration where the remote entanglement rate exceeds the decoherence rate of the entangled qubits. The flexibility of creating remote entanglement through photon interference is demonstrated by using the interference of distinguishable photons without sacrificing remote entanglement rate or fidelity. Next I describe the use of master clock in combination with a frequency comb to lock the phases of all laser-induced interactions between remote ion traps while removing optical phase stability requirements. The combination of both types of entanglement gates to create a small quantum network are described. Finally, I present ways to mitigate cross talk between photonic and memory qubits by using different trapped ion species. I show preliminary work on performing state detection of nuclear spin 0 ions by using entanglement between atomic ion spin and photon polarization. These control techniques may be important for building a large-scale modular quantum system.
Trapped ions are one of the leading platforms for quantum computation and networking, with long coherence times and high fidelity qubit operation. We exploit these attributes to build a quantum network with the use of three trapped ion modules connected via photonic links. In each of these systems, we have ions of different species for use as memory or communication qubits. Our newest module contains two high NA=0.8 objectives, each covering 20% of the solid angle of photons emitted from the ion, making it suitable for use as the middle node of the network. Photons are collected from each chamber, and we generate remote entanglement between each pair of nodes by interfering the photons on a beamsplitter. This heralds entanglement of the communication ions in the pair of network nodes, which we then swap onto the memory qubits. I will discuss our progress towards creating a Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state between the memory ions in the three nodes.
The scaling of controlled quantum systems to large numbers of degrees of freedom is one of the long term goals of experimental quantum information science. Trapped-ion systems are one of the most promising platforms for building a quantum information processor with enough complexity to enable novel computational power, but face serious challenges in scaling up to the necessary numbers of qubits. In this thesis, I present both technical and operational advancements in the control of trapped-ion systems and their juxtaposition with photonic modes used for quantum networking. After reviewing the basic physics behind ion trapping, I then describe in detail a new method of implementing Raman transitions in atomic systems using optical frequency combs. Several dierent experimental setups along with simple theoretical models are reviewed and the system is shown to be capable of full control of the qubit-oscillator system. Two-ion entangling operations using optical frequency combs are demonstrated along with an extension of the operation designed to suppress certain experimental errors. I then give an overview of how spatially separated ions can be entangled using a photonic interconnect. Experimental results show that pulsed excitation of trapped ions provide an excellent single photon source that can be used as a heralded entangling gate between macroscopically separated systems. This heralded entangling gate is used to show a violation of a Bell inequality while keeping the detection loophole closed and can be used a source private random numbers. Finally, the coherent Coulomb force-based gates are combined with the probabilistic photon-based gates in a proof of concept experiment that shows the feasibility of a distributed ion-photon network.