Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Theoretical and Computational Science

A Century Old Dispute over Quantum Theory; Ontology of ?Forbidden Experiments?, and the Quantum Theory of Motion

Y. Hazony

Published Jan 1, 2015• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The concept of ‘Non-permissible experiments’ permeated the literature by Merzbacher as an articulation of Heisenberg’s Rules. Ample experiments in Modern Physics deem forbidden, but never the less, they do not violate the uncertainty relations. In contrast, recent ultrasonic time-of-flight experiments in condensed-matter channels, encounter violation of the uncertainty principle. Accordingly these agree with the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation of quantum mechanics, which does not support the uncertainty relations, and elaborated by the quantum theory of motion. This theory is expanded to account for ultrasound-phononic dispersion in condensed-matter channels.

DOI
10.4172/jtco.1000121

Related papers

Consistent Interpretation of Quantum and Classical Mechanics

Andrew Das Arulsamy

Interpreting quantum mechanics is a hard problem basically because it means explaining why and how the mathematics exploited to formulate wave-particle duality are related to observations or reality in classical physics (due to Newtonian mechanics, special relativity, gravity and entropy). Here, we first prove the limitation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle by invoking the wave-particle duality and apply it to revise and/or extend the Copenhagen postulates. In particular, even though the said uncertainty exists due to non-commuting operators, but these operators do not commute simply because one of the operators is well-defined in classical physics (particle-like), while the other is wave-like (well-defined in quantum mechanics), or the eigenvalue is not at all defined in classical physics. We also construct a new quantum mechanical postulate (Postulate 9) to deduce why the forbidden gap between discrete energy levels should exist in atoms, molecules and condensed matter phases. In fact, we tackle all the problems arising from the Copenhagen interpretation without violating established experiments and without proposing ideas that violate physical reality.

•May 15, 2023•0 citations

Bell's Theorem: A Critique

M. R. Clover

By implicitly assuming that all possible Bell-measurements occur simultaneously, all proofs of Bell's Theorem violate Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. This assumption is made in the original form of Bell's inequality, in Wigner's probability inequalities, and in the ``nonlocality without inequalities'' arguments. The introduction of time into derivations of these variants of Bell's theorem results in extra terms related to the time order of the measurements used in constructing correlation coefficients. Since the same locality assumptions are made in the Heisenberg-compliant derivations of this paper, only time-independent classical local hidden variable theories are forbidden by violations of the original Bell inequalities; time-dependent quantum local hidden variable theories can satisfy this new bound and agree with experiment. We further point out that factorizable wavefunctions have been used to describe some EPR experiments and can be used to describe others. These will generate local de Broglie-Bohm trajectories in the description of the data. This second, independent, line of argument also shows that violation of Bell's inequality is only evidence that Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle cannot be ignored.

arXiv:quant-ph/0502016•Feb 1, 2005•10 citations

On the multifarious relations between experiments and interpretations in quantum mechanics

Osvaldo Pessoa

This paper explores how experiments influence the reception of interpretations of quantum mechanics, and also other relations between experiments and interpretations in that field. We start by surveying the struggle of different schools of philosophy of science in the 19th and early 20th centuries to adapt to the scientific advances, and then give a brief overview of realist and antirealist interpretations in quantum mechanics. Eight different types of relations between interpretations and experiments are then examined, with case studies from the history of quantum mechanics. (1) Many interpretations agree with all of the predictions of the instrumentalist interpretation, which is a good strategy for survival. (2) Some interpretations make different predictions that are not testable. (3) Other interpretations constitute ‘a different theory’ and are testable, although sometimes this is not anticipated by the interpretation. (4) Some interpretations have generated many variations, by adjustment of parameters or hypotheses, and part of these variations have been tested and ruled out by experiment. (5) At times experiments reinforce an interpretation. (6) Some experiments lead to a refinement of the interpretation. (7) There are experiments that suggest the creation of an interpretation. (8) And there are cases in which experiments are suggested by an interpretation, while not affecting its rivals.

The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

The Logic of Quantum Mechanics

Garrett Birkhoff, John von Neumann

One of the aspects of quantum theory which has attracted the most general attention, is the novelty of the logical notions which it presupposes. It asserts that even a complete mathematical description of a physical system S does not in general enable one to predict with certainty the result of an experiment on S, and that in particular one can never predict with certainty both the position and the momentum of S, (Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle). It further asserts that most pairs of observations are incompatible, and cannot be made on S, simultaneously (Principle of Non-commutativity of Observations).

Annals of Mathematics•Oct 1, 1936•2,843 citations

Matter Waves – Uncertainty Relations

Ibrahima Sakho

This chapter makes readers to gain knowledge on the properties of de Broglie's plane waves and on the physical contents of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. It makes the connection between light wave–particle duality and matter wave–particle duality, and distinguishes between light wave dispersion relation and matter wave dispersion relation. The chapter also provides an interpretation of the experiments of Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer, and explains the physical contents of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. Heisenberg's spatial uncertainty relations express the inequalities, indicating the higher precision limit attainable during simultaneous measurements of position and momentum variables. The variables satisfying Heisenberg's uncertainty relations are known as complementary variables. Heisenberg's microscope is in fact a thought experiment. It was elaborated by Heisenberg, as an argument in support of his uncertainty principle. This microscope is constituted of an objective lens and an eyepiece.

Wiley eBooks•Oct 11, 2019•0 citations

Quantum Limits in Nanomechanical Systems

Elias P. Gyftopoulos

In two articles, the authors claim that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle limits the precision of simultaneous measurements of the position and velocity of a particle and refer to experimental evidence that supports their claim. It is true that ever since the inception of quantum mechanics, the uncertainty relation that corresponds to a pair of observables represented by non-commuting operators is interpreted by many scientists and engineers, including Heisenberg himself, as a limitation on the accuracy with which observables can be measured. However, such a limitation cannot be deduced from the postulates and theorems of quantum thermodynamics.

arXiv:0707.1638•Jul 11, 2007•1 citation
The concept of ‘Non-permissible experiments’ permeated the literature by Merzbacher as an articulation of Heisenberg’s Rules. Ample experiments in Modern Physics deem forbidden, but never the less, they do not violate the uncertainty relations. In contrast, recent ultrasonic time-of-flight experiments in condensed-matter channels, encounter violation of the uncertainty principle. Accordingly these agree with the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation of quantum mechanics, which does not support the uncertainty relations, and elaborated by the quantum theory of motion. This theory is expanded to account for ultrasound-phononic dispersion in condensed-matter channels.
Interpreting quantum mechanics is a hard problem basically because it means explaining why and how the mathematics exploited to formulate wave-particle duality are related to observations or reality in classical physics (due to Newtonian mechanics, special relativity, gravity and entropy). Here, we first prove the limitation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle by invoking the wave-particle duality and apply it to revise and/or extend the Copenhagen postulates. In particular, even though the said uncertainty exists due to non-commuting operators, but these operators do not commute simply because one of the operators is well-defined in classical physics (particle-like), while the other is wave-like (well-defined in quantum mechanics), or the eigenvalue is not at all defined in classical physics. We also construct a new quantum mechanical postulate (Postulate 9) to deduce why the forbidden gap between discrete energy levels should exist in atoms, molecules and condensed matter phases. In fact, we tackle all the problems arising from the Copenhagen interpretation without violating established experiments and without proposing ideas that violate physical reality.
By implicitly assuming that all possible Bell-measurements occur simultaneously, all proofs of Bell's Theorem violate Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. This assumption is made in the original form of Bell's inequality, in Wigner's probability inequalities, and in the ``nonlocality without inequalities'' arguments. The introduction of time into derivations of these variants of Bell's theorem results in extra terms related to the time order of the measurements used in constructing correlation coefficients. Since the same locality assumptions are made in the Heisenberg-compliant derivations of this paper, only time-independent classical local hidden variable theories are forbidden by violations of the original Bell inequalities; time-dependent quantum local hidden variable theories can satisfy this new bound and agree with experiment. We further point out that factorizable wavefunctions have been used to describe some EPR experiments and can be used to describe others. These will generate local de Broglie-Bohm trajectories in the description of the data. This second, independent, line of argument also shows that violation of Bell's inequality is only evidence that Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle cannot be ignored.
This paper explores how experiments influence the reception of interpretations of quantum mechanics, and also other relations between experiments and interpretations in that field. We start by surveying the struggle of different schools of philosophy of science in the 19th and early 20th centuries to adapt to the scientific advances, and then give a brief overview of realist and antirealist interpretations in quantum mechanics. Eight different types of relations between interpretations and experiments are then examined, with case studies from the history of quantum mechanics. (1) Many interpretations agree with all of the predictions of the instrumentalist interpretation, which is a good strategy for survival. (2) Some interpretations make different predictions that are not testable. (3) Other interpretations constitute ‘a different theory’ and are testable, although sometimes this is not anticipated by the interpretation. (4) Some interpretations have generated many variations, by adjustment of parameters or hypotheses, and part of these variations have been tested and ruled out by experiment. (5) At times experiments reinforce an interpretation. (6) Some experiments lead to a refinement of the interpretation. (7) There are experiments that suggest the creation of an interpretation. (8) And there are cases in which experiments are suggested by an interpretation, while not affecting its rivals.
One of the aspects of quantum theory which has attracted the most general attention, is the novelty of the logical notions which it presupposes. It asserts that even a complete mathematical description of a physical system S does not in general enable one to predict with certainty the result of an experiment on S, and that in particular one can never predict with certainty both the position and the momentum of S, (Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle). It further asserts that most pairs of observations are incompatible, and cannot be made on S, simultaneously (Principle of Non-commutativity of Observations).
This chapter makes readers to gain knowledge on the properties of de Broglie's plane waves and on the physical contents of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. It makes the connection between light wave–particle duality and matter wave–particle duality, and distinguishes between light wave dispersion relation and matter wave dispersion relation. The chapter also provides an interpretation of the experiments of Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer, and explains the physical contents of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. Heisenberg's spatial uncertainty relations express the inequalities, indicating the higher precision limit attainable during simultaneous measurements of position and momentum variables. The variables satisfying Heisenberg's uncertainty relations are known as complementary variables. Heisenberg's microscope is in fact a thought experiment. It was elaborated by Heisenberg, as an argument in support of his uncertainty principle. This microscope is constituted of an objective lens and an eyepiece.
In two articles, the authors claim that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle limits the precision of simultaneous measurements of the position and velocity of a particle and refer to experimental evidence that supports their claim. It is true that ever since the inception of quantum mechanics, the uncertainty relation that corresponds to a pair of observables represented by non-commuting operators is interpreted by many scientists and engineers, including Heisenberg himself, as a limitation on the accuracy with which observables can be measured. However, such a limitation cannot be deduced from the postulates and theorems of quantum thermodynamics.