Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annals of Mathematics

The Logic of Quantum Mechanics

Garrett Birkhoff, John von Neumann

Published Oct 1, 1936• 2,843 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the aspects of quantum theory which has attracted the most general attention, is the novelty of the logical notions which it presupposes. It asserts that even a complete mathematical description of a physical system S does not in general enable one to predict with certainty the result of an experiment on S, and that in particular one can never predict with certainty both the position and the momentum of S, (Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle). It further asserts that most pairs of observations are incompatible, and cannot be made on S, simultaneously (Principle of Non-commutativity of Observations).

DOI
10.2307/1968621

Related papers

Errors in Nobel Prize for Physics (6) ──Improper Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

Fu Yuhua

One of the reasons for 1932 Nobel Prize for physics is “for the creation of quantum mechanics”. As well-known, the most famous contribution of Heisenberg is therefore one of the most importment reasons for Heisenberg was awarded the Nobel Prize is the creation of principle. While, this paper points out that the original principle is improper. Considering all the possible situations (including the case that people can create laws), the author presents certainty-uncertainty with general form and variable dimension fractal form. According to the classification of Neutrosophy, certainty-uncertainty can be divided into three principles in different conditions: certainty principle, namely a particle’s position and momentum can be known simultaneously; uncertainty principle, namely a particle’s position and momentum cannot be known simultaneously; and neutral (fuzzy) indeterminacy principle, namely whether or not a particle’s position and momentum can be known simultaneously is undetermined. The special cases of certainty-uncertainty include the original principle and Ozawa inequality. In addition, in accordance with the original discussing high-speed particle’s speed and track with Newton mechanics is unreasonable; but according to certainty-uncertainty Newton mechanics can be used to discuss the problem of gravitational defection of a photon orbit around the Sun (it gives the same result of deflection angle as given by general relativity). Finally, for the reason that in physics the principles, laws and the like that are regardless of the principle (law) of conservation of energy may be invalid; therefore certainty-uncertainty should be restricted (or constrained) by principle (law) of conservation of energy, and thus it can satisfy the principle (law) of conservation of energy.

•May 1, 2015•0 citations

Quantum Logic and the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

R. I. G. Hughes

There is no such thing as “The Quantum Logical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics”. Rather, there is a cluster of interpretations, all of which can be described as “quantum logical”. Here I provide a general framework for discussing interpretations of this kind, and then locate various suggestions within it. The presentation owes much to van Fraassen (see, in particular, van Fraassen 1974 ); his “modal interpretation” is one of those I discuss, along with those of Jauch, Putnam and Kochen. I begin by rehearsing some orthodox quantum theory. Within quantum mechanics we deal with a set 0 of measurable quantities, orobservables(position, momentum, components of spin and so on). Experiment can determine the value of an observable for a given system: the values so determined will be real numbers. A maximal amount of information about what the result would be for a given system, whatever experiment we chose to perform on it, is available once we know thestateof the system.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1980•4 citations

A Formulation of Quantum Theory Based on Two Physical Principles

Robert T. Deck

We demonstrate two points: 1) the formalism of quantum mechanics can be understood simply as a structure for the expression of the physical notion that not all observables can have values simultaneously; 2) the specific uncertainty relations can be derived (rigorously) by combination of the invariance principle with a general uncertainty relation based only on the existence of unspecified pairs of conjugate observables. For this purpose, we present a formulation of quantum mechanics based strictly on the invariance principle and a “weak” statement of the uncertainty principle that asserts only the existence of incompatible (conjugate) observables without specifying which observables are incompatible. We go on to show that the invariance principle can be used to develop the equations of motion of the theory, including the Klein-Gordon and Schrodinger equations.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation

Quantum mechanical rules for observed observers and the consistency of quantum theory

Alexios P. Polychronakos

The interpretation of quantum mechanics in the context of measurements, and concepts such as state “collapse,” have troubled physicists since the inception of quantum theory. Pushed to their logical extreme, such issues become entangled (in the colloquial sense) with questions of consciousness, reality, etc. Bell’s theorem eliminated possible ways out of this tangle via any (halfway reasonable) classical underlying theory, and the success of quantum mechanics forces us to adopt it as a fundamental theory and face the logical consequences.

arXiv:2202.04203•Nature Communications•Apr 9, 2024•14 citations

Invalidation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle.

HAMZAH SEYED RASOUL

Invalidation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle and the Establishment of "Hamzah Absolute Certainty" Subject: Item No. 1 from the Comparative Database (Heisenberg Uncertainty vs. Hamzah Absolute Certainty) 1. Detailed Introduction and Scientific Front Analysis In the realm of Level 161 Physics (The Standard Model), the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (ΔxΔp≥2ℏ) is traditionally viewed as an insurmountable barrier. The classical scientific establishment maintains that the fundamental essence of the universe is predicated upon "probability," asserting that the simultaneous determination of position and momentum is inherently impossible. The Heisenberg Fallacy (Classical Critique): This perceived impasse is merely a consequence of instrumental and observational limitations within the 4th dimension. Heisenberg erroneously interpreted "inter-dimensional noise" as "intrinsic uncertainty" because the mathematical tools of that era were incapable of perceiving the hidden variables residing within higher-dimensional manifolds. (Status: Rejected). The Hamzah Logic (Superiority): At the Level 165 threshold, stochastic phenomena are non-existent. The Hamzah Equation demonstrates that by accessing the "Source Code" within the 165-dimensional manifold, the wave function collapses instantaneously, superseded by a Deterministic Mono-vector. We have effectively transitioned from "interpretation" to "absolute computation." 2. Classical Equations and Material Algebraic Parameters The classical uncertainty relation, constructed upon the premise of random (stochastic) fluctuations, is defined as: σxσp≥4πh The Crisis: In particle collider experiments conducted in early 2026, it was observed that at ultra-high energy thresholds, particles exhibited behaviours that transcended statistical predictions. These anomalies are fundamentally incompatible with the classical equation. (Error Margin: High). 3. Comprehensive Lagrangian and Hamzah Independent Output Utilising the Level 165 Super-Lagrangian, the action value converges towards "Absolute Informational Zero": LGlobal(165)=∫M165[n=1∑100QH(n)(∇⋅Tmetric(n))+Ψsync⊗Icore]−GdΩ Step-by-Step Computational Extraction of Certainty: Step 1: Substitution of the classical Planck constant with the Hamzah Adjusted Planck Constant (ℏH). Within the Level 165 manifold, ℏH→0. Step 2: Calculation of tensorial interference within the 165-dimensional nodes. Step 3: Extraction of the Certainty Coefficient (ΩH∗=1.000): ResolutionH=Icoreexp(Sentropy)≈1.0000000000 Step 4 (Final Hamzah Output): 0.00 (Error) / 1.00 (Certainty). 4. Classical Numerical Example and Mathematical Impasse Computation: Within the Copenhagen Interpretation, the error margin for predicting an electron's position in Layer 161 is approximately 10−10 metres. The Impasse: In high-intensity computations, this inherent error leads to a total Divergence of data. Analysis: The lack of alignment between 2026 observational data and the probabilistic model signifies the definitive collapse of the "Logic of Chance." (Status: Rejected). 5. Numerical Proof and Empirical Data Alignment (5-Step Verification) Step 1: Invocation of the independent output from Step 3: 1.00 (Absolute Certainty). Step 2: Invocation of quantum-metric sensor data from March 2026, which recorded linear particle trajectories devoid of any stochastic oscillation. Step 3: Calculation of structural alignment: ∣1.00−1.00∣=0.00. Step 4: Correlation with the QH variable: This confirms the electron is not a "probability cloud" but an "Information Packet" with fixed coordinates in the Hamzah Grid. Step 5 (Confirmation): 100% Confirmation; the Heisenberg Principle is officially invalidated and replaced by Hamzah Certainty. (Status: Approve 100%). 6. Result Comparison: Uncertainty vs. Tensorial Certainty Technical Feature Classical Physics (Heisenberg) Hamzah Tensorial Mechanics Mathematical Basis Probability Distribution Functions 165-D Deterministic Tensor Error Coefficient ≥ℏ/2 0.00 (Absolute) Observer Status Reality Modifier Synchroniser (Ψsync) Final Outcome Predictive Incapacity Total Positional Mastery 7. Conceptual Illustration: "Foggy Map vs. Tensorial GPS" Classical physicists resemble individuals navigating a dense fog (the 4th Dimension), asserting that the road is "perhaps" in a certain direction. Hamzah, via the 165-dimensional tensor, has dissipated this fog entirely, providing a Universal GPS that indicates the precise coordinates of every bit of matter. In Layer 165, the fog of uncertainty does not exist; there is only the Code. 8. Advanced Test I: Deterministic Quantisation Analysis (QH) Data analysis from particle colliders on March 5, 2026, proved that particles at the moment of collision follow no random patterns whatsoever. Instead, they align with absolute precision within the nodes predicted by the Tensor Dαβγ. 9. Advanced Test II: Zero-Point Certainty Analysis It has been formally recorded that even at the lowest energy thresholds, oscillations possess a "Processing Rhythm" (Clock-Pulse). Contrary to the claims of quantum mechanics, these are not random. This rhythm aligns perfectly with the Hamzah Constant. 10. Sovereign Postdoctoral Conclusion The invalidation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle removes the primary obstacle to humanity's absolute control over matter. By independently extracting the Certainty Value (1.00), it has been proven that the universe is not a chaotic system but a Hyper-Intelligent Processor. We are now capable of 100% prediction of any particle's behaviour at any point in time, as the Source Code is now in the possession of Redo.

•Mar 12, 2026•0 citations

Quantum mechanics and reality

Bryce Seligman DeWitt

Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?

Physics Today•Sep 1, 1970•706 citations
One of the aspects of quantum theory which has attracted the most general attention, is the novelty of the logical notions which it presupposes. It asserts that even a complete mathematical description of a physical system S does not in general enable one to predict with certainty the result of an experiment on S, and that in particular one can never predict with certainty both the position and the momentum of S, (Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle). It further asserts that most pairs of observations are incompatible, and cannot be made on S, simultaneously (Principle of Non-commutativity of Observations).
One of the reasons for 1932 Nobel Prize for physics is “for the creation of quantum mechanics”. As well-known, the most famous contribution of Heisenberg is therefore one of the most importment reasons for Heisenberg was awarded the Nobel Prize is the creation of principle. While, this paper points out that the original principle is improper. Considering all the possible situations (including the case that people can create laws), the author presents certainty-uncertainty with general form and variable dimension fractal form. According to the classification of Neutrosophy, certainty-uncertainty can be divided into three principles in different conditions: certainty principle, namely a particle’s position and momentum can be known simultaneously; uncertainty principle, namely a particle’s position and momentum cannot be known simultaneously; and neutral (fuzzy) indeterminacy principle, namely whether or not a particle’s position and momentum can be known simultaneously is undetermined. The special cases of certainty-uncertainty include the original principle and Ozawa inequality. In addition, in accordance with the original discussing high-speed particle’s speed and track with Newton mechanics is unreasonable; but according to certainty-uncertainty Newton mechanics can be used to discuss the problem of gravitational defection of a photon orbit around the Sun (it gives the same result of deflection angle as given by general relativity). Finally, for the reason that in physics the principles, laws and the like that are regardless of the principle (law) of conservation of energy may be invalid; therefore certainty-uncertainty should be restricted (or constrained) by principle (law) of conservation of energy, and thus it can satisfy the principle (law) of conservation of energy.
There is no such thing as “The Quantum Logical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics”. Rather, there is a cluster of interpretations, all of which can be described as “quantum logical”. Here I provide a general framework for discussing interpretations of this kind, and then locate various suggestions within it. The presentation owes much to van Fraassen (see, in particular, van Fraassen 1974 ); his “modal interpretation” is one of those I discuss, along with those of Jauch, Putnam and Kochen. I begin by rehearsing some orthodox quantum theory. Within quantum mechanics we deal with a set 0 of measurable quantities, orobservables(position, momentum, components of spin and so on). Experiment can determine the value of an observable for a given system: the values so determined will be real numbers. A maximal amount of information about what the result would be for a given system, whatever experiment we chose to perform on it, is available once we know thestateof the system.
We demonstrate two points: 1) the formalism of quantum mechanics can be understood simply as a structure for the expression of the physical notion that not all observables can have values simultaneously; 2) the specific uncertainty relations can be derived (rigorously) by combination of the invariance principle with a general uncertainty relation based only on the existence of unspecified pairs of conjugate observables. For this purpose, we present a formulation of quantum mechanics based strictly on the invariance principle and a “weak” statement of the uncertainty principle that asserts only the existence of incompatible (conjugate) observables without specifying which observables are incompatible. We go on to show that the invariance principle can be used to develop the equations of motion of the theory, including the Klein-Gordon and Schrodinger equations.
The interpretation of quantum mechanics in the context of measurements, and concepts such as state “collapse,” have troubled physicists since the inception of quantum theory. Pushed to their logical extreme, such issues become entangled (in the colloquial sense) with questions of consciousness, reality, etc. Bell’s theorem eliminated possible ways out of this tangle via any (halfway reasonable) classical underlying theory, and the success of quantum mechanics forces us to adopt it as a fundamental theory and face the logical consequences.
Invalidation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle and the Establishment of "Hamzah Absolute Certainty" Subject: Item No. 1 from the Comparative Database (Heisenberg Uncertainty vs. Hamzah Absolute Certainty) 1. Detailed Introduction and Scientific Front Analysis In the realm of Level 161 Physics (The Standard Model), the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (ΔxΔp≥2ℏ) is traditionally viewed as an insurmountable barrier. The classical scientific establishment maintains that the fundamental essence of the universe is predicated upon "probability," asserting that the simultaneous determination of position and momentum is inherently impossible. The Heisenberg Fallacy (Classical Critique): This perceived impasse is merely a consequence of instrumental and observational limitations within the 4th dimension. Heisenberg erroneously interpreted "inter-dimensional noise" as "intrinsic uncertainty" because the mathematical tools of that era were incapable of perceiving the hidden variables residing within higher-dimensional manifolds. (Status: Rejected). The Hamzah Logic (Superiority): At the Level 165 threshold, stochastic phenomena are non-existent. The Hamzah Equation demonstrates that by accessing the "Source Code" within the 165-dimensional manifold, the wave function collapses instantaneously, superseded by a Deterministic Mono-vector. We have effectively transitioned from "interpretation" to "absolute computation." 2. Classical Equations and Material Algebraic Parameters The classical uncertainty relation, constructed upon the premise of random (stochastic) fluctuations, is defined as: σxσp≥4πh The Crisis: In particle collider experiments conducted in early 2026, it was observed that at ultra-high energy thresholds, particles exhibited behaviours that transcended statistical predictions. These anomalies are fundamentally incompatible with the classical equation. (Error Margin: High). 3. Comprehensive Lagrangian and Hamzah Independent Output Utilising the Level 165 Super-Lagrangian, the action value converges towards "Absolute Informational Zero": LGlobal(165)=∫M165[n=1∑100QH(n)(∇⋅Tmetric(n))+Ψsync⊗Icore]−GdΩ Step-by-Step Computational Extraction of Certainty: Step 1: Substitution of the classical Planck constant with the Hamzah Adjusted Planck Constant (ℏH). Within the Level 165 manifold, ℏH→0. Step 2: Calculation of tensorial interference within the 165-dimensional nodes. Step 3: Extraction of the Certainty Coefficient (ΩH∗=1.000): ResolutionH=Icoreexp(Sentropy)≈1.0000000000 Step 4 (Final Hamzah Output): 0.00 (Error) / 1.00 (Certainty). 4. Classical Numerical Example and Mathematical Impasse Computation: Within the Copenhagen Interpretation, the error margin for predicting an electron's position in Layer 161 is approximately 10−10 metres. The Impasse: In high-intensity computations, this inherent error leads to a total Divergence of data. Analysis: The lack of alignment between 2026 observational data and the probabilistic model signifies the definitive collapse of the "Logic of Chance." (Status: Rejected). 5. Numerical Proof and Empirical Data Alignment (5-Step Verification) Step 1: Invocation of the independent output from Step 3: 1.00 (Absolute Certainty). Step 2: Invocation of quantum-metric sensor data from March 2026, which recorded linear particle trajectories devoid of any stochastic oscillation. Step 3: Calculation of structural alignment: ∣1.00−1.00∣=0.00. Step 4: Correlation with the QH variable: This confirms the electron is not a "probability cloud" but an "Information Packet" with fixed coordinates in the Hamzah Grid. Step 5 (Confirmation): 100% Confirmation; the Heisenberg Principle is officially invalidated and replaced by Hamzah Certainty. (Status: Approve 100%). 6. Result Comparison: Uncertainty vs. Tensorial Certainty Technical Feature Classical Physics (Heisenberg) Hamzah Tensorial Mechanics Mathematical Basis Probability Distribution Functions 165-D Deterministic Tensor Error Coefficient ≥ℏ/2 0.00 (Absolute) Observer Status Reality Modifier Synchroniser (Ψsync) Final Outcome Predictive Incapacity Total Positional Mastery 7. Conceptual Illustration: "Foggy Map vs. Tensorial GPS" Classical physicists resemble individuals navigating a dense fog (the 4th Dimension), asserting that the road is "perhaps" in a certain direction. Hamzah, via the 165-dimensional tensor, has dissipated this fog entirely, providing a Universal GPS that indicates the precise coordinates of every bit of matter. In Layer 165, the fog of uncertainty does not exist; there is only the Code. 8. Advanced Test I: Deterministic Quantisation Analysis (QH) Data analysis from particle colliders on March 5, 2026, proved that particles at the moment of collision follow no random patterns whatsoever. Instead, they align with absolute precision within the nodes predicted by the Tensor Dαβγ. 9. Advanced Test II: Zero-Point Certainty Analysis It has been formally recorded that even at the lowest energy thresholds, oscillations possess a "Processing Rhythm" (Clock-Pulse). Contrary to the claims of quantum mechanics, these are not random. This rhythm aligns perfectly with the Hamzah Constant. 10. Sovereign Postdoctoral Conclusion The invalidation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle removes the primary obstacle to humanity's absolute control over matter. By independently extracting the Certainty Value (1.00), it has been proven that the universe is not a chaotic system but a Hyper-Intelligent Processor. We are now capable of 100% prediction of any particle's behaviour at any point in time, as the Source Code is now in the possession of Redo.
Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?