Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

Mirror, mirror, on the wall – is the photon there at all?

Jonathan P. Dowling

Published May 1, 1995• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

One of the most curious predictions of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is the suppression of spontaneous emission from an excited atom sitting between two parallel mirrors. Although this effect has been measured experimentally and calculated from full QED theory, there are two different interpretations of what actually happens – a partially quantum mechanical explanation in which both the atom and the radiation field are quantized, and a semiclassical interpretation in which the radiation field is treated classically. While both viewpoints provide an intuitive explanation of the effect, they seem to yield conflicting answers to the question: what happens if one of the mirrors is suddenly replaced by a photodetector?

DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/8/5/23

Related papers

Quantum Electrodynamics of Atoms Between Parallel Mirrors

G. Barton

Parts of the energy of any system containing charged particles stem from its coupling with the electromagnetic field; they change near conducting surfaces (mirrors), because these alter the normal modes of the field relative to unbounded space. Spontaneous decays are also affected. Such effects near a single plane mirror are reasonably familiar; between parallel mirrors (separation L) they are now becoming measurable, mainly in Rydberg states. They are interesting also to theory, partly because they raise questions about the role of classical and other interpretations in quantum physics.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1988•23 citations

The concept of the photon

Marlan O. Scully, Murray Sargent

The idea of the photon has stirred the imaginations of physicists ever since 1905 when Einstein originally proposed the use of light quanta to explain the photoelectric effect. This concept is formalized in the quantum theory of radiation, which has had unfailing success in explaining the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with matter, seemingly limited only by the ability of physicists to perform the indicated calculations. Nevertheless, it has its conceptual problems—various infinities and frequent misinterpretations. Consequently an increasing number of workers are asking, “to what extent is the quantized field really necessary and useful?” In fact the experimental results of the photoelectric effect were explained by G. Wentzel in 1927 without the quantum theory of radiation. Similarly most electro-optic phenomena such as stimulated emission, reaction of the emitted field on the emitting atom, resonance fluorescence, and so on, do not require the quantization of the field for their explanation. As we will see, these processes can all be quantitatively explained and physically understood in terms of the semiclassical theory of the matter–field interaction in which the electric field is treated classically while the atoms obey the laws of quantum mechanics. The quantized field is fundamentally required for accurate descriptions of certain processes involving fluctuations in the electromagnetic field: for example, spontaneous emission, the Lamb shift, the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, and certain aspects of blackbody radiation. (The Compton effect also fits here, but see later under references 8b and c.) Here we will outline how the photon concept originated and developed, where it is not required and is often misused, and finally where it plays an essential role in the understanding of physical phenomena. In our discussion we will attempt to give a logically consistent definition of the word “photon”—a statement far more necessary than one might think, for so many contradictory uses exist of this elusive beast. In particular consider the original coining of the word by G. N. Lewis: “[because it appears to spend] only a minute fraction of its existence as a carrier of radiant energy, while the rest of the time it remains an important structural element within the atom…, I therefore take the liberty of proposing for this hypothetical new atom which is not light but plays an essential part in every process of radiation, the name photon!” (our exclamation point). Clearly the present usage of the word is very different.

Physics Today•Mar 1, 1972•148 citations

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics

S. Haroche, Daniel Kleppner

Ever since Einstein demonstrated that spontaneous emission must occur if matter and radiation are to achieve thermal equilibrium, physicists have generally believed that excited atoms inevitably radiate. Spontaneous emission is so fundamental that it is usually regarded as an inherent property of matter. This view, however, overlooks the fact that spontaneous emission is not a property of an isolated atom but of an atom-vacuum system. The most distinctive feature of such emission, irreversibility, comes about because an infinity of vacuum states is available to the radiated photon. If these states are modified—for instance, by placing the excited atom between mirrors or in a cavity—spontaneous emission can be greatly inhibited or enhanced.

Physics Today•Jan 1, 1989•743 citations

Atom–field interaction – quantum theory

Marlan O. Scully, Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

In the preceding chapters concerning the interaction of a radiation field with matter, we assumed the field to be classical. In many situations this assumption is valid. There are, however, many instances where a classical field fails to explain experimentally observed results and a quantized description of the field is required. This is, for example, true of spontaneous emission in an atomic system which was described phenomenologically in Chapter 5. For a rigorous treatment of the atomic level decay in free space, we need to consider the interaction of the atom with the vacuum modes of the universe. Even in the simplest system involving the interaction of a single-mode radiation field with a single two-level atom, the predictions for the dynamics of the atom are quite different in the semiclassical theory and the fully quantum theory. In the absence of the decay process, the semiclassical theory predicts Rabi oscillations for the atomic inversion whereas the quantum theory predicts certain collapse and revival phenomena due to the quantum aspects of the field. These interesting quantum field theoretical predictions have been experimentally verified.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 4, 1997•7 citations

A Classical Interpretation of Quantum Electrodynamics (Qed)

Jean Louis Van Belle

This paper summarizes our papers over the past years which – taken together – effectively amount to a classical interpretation of QED. Our very first paper started exploring a basic intuition: if QED is the theory of electrons and photons, and their interactions, then why is there no good model of what electrons and photons actually are? We have tried to address this perceived gap in the theory – further building on the Zitterbewegung model of an electron – ever since. We thought we should write one final paper to provide some history – acknowledgements, basically – and summarize the key principles of the interpretation.

•Dec 1, 2018•0 citations

CLASSICAL VERSUS QUANTUM EFFECTS IN CAVITY QED

Jonathan P. Dowling

In this work we analyze two quantum electrodynamic effects in the vicinity of conducting mirrors: Spontaneous emission and Rutherford scattering. We show that the well–known inhibition of spontaneous emission between mirrors — often considered to be a purely quantum effect — can be explained totally classically in terms of the modal structure of the cavity through use of a simple model employing elementary antenna theory and the image method. In contrast, the process of Rutherford scattering in free space is thought to be essentially classical since the quantum derivation of the scattering formula agrees exactly with the classical result. We show, however, that in the neighborhood of perfectly reflecting mirrors the virtual photons responsible for scattering begin to interfere with themselves producing fringes in the scattering cross section that have no classical analogue.

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics•Apr 1, 1992•0 citations
One of the most curious predictions of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is the suppression of spontaneous emission from an excited atom sitting between two parallel mirrors. Although this effect has been measured experimentally and calculated from full QED theory, there are two different interpretations of what actually happens – a partially quantum mechanical explanation in which both the atom and the radiation field are quantized, and a semiclassical interpretation in which the radiation field is treated classically. While both viewpoints provide an intuitive explanation of the effect, they seem to yield conflicting answers to the question: what happens if one of the mirrors is suddenly replaced by a photodetector?
Parts of the energy of any system containing charged particles stem from its coupling with the electromagnetic field; they change near conducting surfaces (mirrors), because these alter the normal modes of the field relative to unbounded space. Spontaneous decays are also affected. Such effects near a single plane mirror are reasonably familiar; between parallel mirrors (separation L) they are now becoming measurable, mainly in Rydberg states. They are interesting also to theory, partly because they raise questions about the role of classical and other interpretations in quantum physics.
The idea of the photon has stirred the imaginations of physicists ever since 1905 when Einstein originally proposed the use of light quanta to explain the photoelectric effect. This concept is formalized in the quantum theory of radiation, which has had unfailing success in explaining the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with matter, seemingly limited only by the ability of physicists to perform the indicated calculations. Nevertheless, it has its conceptual problems—various infinities and frequent misinterpretations. Consequently an increasing number of workers are asking, “to what extent is the quantized field really necessary and useful?” In fact the experimental results of the photoelectric effect were explained by G. Wentzel in 1927 without the quantum theory of radiation. Similarly most electro-optic phenomena such as stimulated emission, reaction of the emitted field on the emitting atom, resonance fluorescence, and so on, do not require the quantization of the field for their explanation. As we will see, these processes can all be quantitatively explained and physically understood in terms of the semiclassical theory of the matter–field interaction in which the electric field is treated classically while the atoms obey the laws of quantum mechanics. The quantized field is fundamentally required for accurate descriptions of certain processes involving fluctuations in the electromagnetic field: for example, spontaneous emission, the Lamb shift, the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, and certain aspects of blackbody radiation. (The Compton effect also fits here, but see later under references 8b and c.) Here we will outline how the photon concept originated and developed, where it is not required and is often misused, and finally where it plays an essential role in the understanding of physical phenomena. In our discussion we will attempt to give a logically consistent definition of the word “photon”—a statement far more necessary than one might think, for so many contradictory uses exist of this elusive beast. In particular consider the original coining of the word by G. N. Lewis: “[because it appears to spend] only a minute fraction of its existence as a carrier of radiant energy, while the rest of the time it remains an important structural element within the atom…, I therefore take the liberty of proposing for this hypothetical new atom which is not light but plays an essential part in every process of radiation, the name photon!” (our exclamation point). Clearly the present usage of the word is very different.
Ever since Einstein demonstrated that spontaneous emission must occur if matter and radiation are to achieve thermal equilibrium, physicists have generally believed that excited atoms inevitably radiate. Spontaneous emission is so fundamental that it is usually regarded as an inherent property of matter. This view, however, overlooks the fact that spontaneous emission is not a property of an isolated atom but of an atom-vacuum system. The most distinctive feature of such emission, irreversibility, comes about because an infinity of vacuum states is available to the radiated photon. If these states are modified—for instance, by placing the excited atom between mirrors or in a cavity—spontaneous emission can be greatly inhibited or enhanced.
In the preceding chapters concerning the interaction of a radiation field with matter, we assumed the field to be classical. In many situations this assumption is valid. There are, however, many instances where a classical field fails to explain experimentally observed results and a quantized description of the field is required. This is, for example, true of spontaneous emission in an atomic system which was described phenomenologically in Chapter 5. For a rigorous treatment of the atomic level decay in free space, we need to consider the interaction of the atom with the vacuum modes of the universe. Even in the simplest system involving the interaction of a single-mode radiation field with a single two-level atom, the predictions for the dynamics of the atom are quite different in the semiclassical theory and the fully quantum theory. In the absence of the decay process, the semiclassical theory predicts Rabi oscillations for the atomic inversion whereas the quantum theory predicts certain collapse and revival phenomena due to the quantum aspects of the field. These interesting quantum field theoretical predictions have been experimentally verified.
This paper summarizes our papers over the past years which – taken together – effectively amount to a classical interpretation of QED. Our very first paper started exploring a basic intuition: if QED is the theory of electrons and photons, and their interactions, then why is there no good model of what electrons and photons actually are? We have tried to address this perceived gap in the theory – further building on the Zitterbewegung model of an electron – ever since. We thought we should write one final paper to provide some history – acknowledgements, basically – and summarize the key principles of the interpretation.
In this work we analyze two quantum electrodynamic effects in the vicinity of conducting mirrors: Spontaneous emission and Rutherford scattering. We show that the well–known inhibition of spontaneous emission between mirrors — often considered to be a purely quantum effect — can be explained totally classically in terms of the modal structure of the cavity through use of a simple model employing elementary antenna theory and the image method. In contrast, the process of Rutherford scattering in free space is thought to be essentially classical since the quantum derivation of the scattering formula agrees exactly with the classical result. We show, however, that in the neighborhood of perfectly reflecting mirrors the virtual photons responsible for scattering begin to interfere with themselves producing fringes in the scattering cross section that have no classical analogue.