Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

CLASSICAL VERSUS QUANTUM EFFECTS IN CAVITY QED

Jonathan P. Dowling

Published Apr 1, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this work we analyze two quantum electrodynamic effects in the vicinity of conducting mirrors: Spontaneous emission and Rutherford scattering. We show that the well–known inhibition of spontaneous emission between mirrors — often considered to be a purely quantum effect — can be explained totally classically in terms of the modal structure of the cavity through use of a simple model employing elementary antenna theory and the image method. In contrast, the process of Rutherford scattering in free space is thought to be essentially classical since the quantum derivation of the scattering formula agrees exactly with the classical result. We show, however, that in the neighborhood of perfectly reflecting mirrors the virtual photons responsible for scattering begin to interfere with themselves producing fringes in the scattering cross section that have no classical analogue.

DOI
10.1142/9789814436687_0035

Related papers

Coulomb scattering near mirrors: Quantum corrections to the Rutherford formula

Jonathan P. Dowling

When Coulomb scattering takes place near mirrors, additional scattering amplitudes occur due to the reflection of virtual photons. Under certain conditions these amplitudes can interfere, in a purely quantum-mechanical fashion, giving rise to possibly observable fringes in the differential-scattering cross section. The effect is calculated here for a Coulomb potential near a single mirror and also between a pair of parallel mirrors. The experimental feasibility is then briefly discussed.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1992•1 citation

Cavity-modified spontaneous emission: From Rabi oscillations to exponential decay

H. Gie\Sen, Jill D. Berger, Georg Mohs +2 more

We revisit the problem of spontaneous emission by a two-level system in a cavity, concentrating in particular on those aspects associated with the finite propagation time of light between the atom and the cavity boundaries. We find that spontaneous emission always occurs first at the free space rate and there is then an abrupt change in these dynamics when light reflected by the cavity mirrors returns to the atom, leading to interference effects that result either in an enhancement or a reduction of this rate or in a periodic exchange of excitation between the atom and the cavity field. From this point of view, reversible spontaneous emission in terms of single-mode ``vacuum Rabi oscillations'' can be interpreted as resulting from the interference between the multimode partial waves reflected at the cavity mirrors and the instantaneously radiated light. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1996•49 citations

Molecular Raman effect in an optical microcavity: A classical approach

Michele Marrocco

Spontaneous Raman scattering is investigated theoretically by considering a completely classical description of the process that takes place within the mirrors of a microscopic Fabry-P\'erot cavity. This analysis is based on the image method within the framework of the classical theory of light scattering. In order to account for the finite reflectivities of the mirrors, the result for the scattered field is presently determined analytically only in the limit of low finesse of the optical cavity. This leads to a general expression for the cross section of the Stokes transition that explains the results recently reported in the literature [F. De Martini, M. Marrocco, C. Pastina, and F. Viti, Phys. Rev. A 53, 471 (1996)]. Therefore, in the limit of low finesse of the cavity, one must accept that this effect has a fundamentally classical nature. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1996•4 citations

Spontaneous emission in the presence of quantum mirrors

Kanu Sinha, Jennifer Parra-Contreras, Annyun Das +1 more

Abstract Arrays of atoms coupled to waveguides can behave as mirrors. We consider an array of three-level atoms, with one excited and two ground levels, assuming one of the ground levels to be decoupled from the other two. Preparing the atoms in the coupled or decoupled ground state leads to reflection or transmission of the guided electromagnetic field; a superposition of the two ground states thus corresponds to a coherent superposition of mirror-like and transparent boundary conditions. We analyze the spontaneous emission of an excited two-level atom in the presence of such a quantum mirror, and inside a cavity formed by quantum mirrors, demonstrating that the resulting dynamics of the excited atom can exhibit exotic features, e.g. a superposition of Rabi cycle and exponential decay. Our results pave the way for exploring quantum electrodynamics (QED) phenomena in a paradigm wherein boundary conditions can exhibit quantum superpositions and correlations.

arXiv:2402.10303•New Journal of Physics•May 1, 2025•5 citations

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics

The study of atoms and photons interacting in a confined space defined by mirrors, so-called “cavity quantum electrodynamics” (cavity QED), has been and continues to be of great interest both theoretically and experimentally (Haroche, 2013; Haroche et al ., 2020; Purcell et al ., 1946; Walther et al ., 2006). This interest was sparked by the realization that surrounding an atom with a cavity with no modes at the transition frequency could inhibit spontaneous emission. The field has since evolved to include modifications of the atomic energy levels and the oscillatory energy exchange between atoms and a cavity, leading to the creation of the “singleatom” maser, or micromaser. Cavity QED has proven itself a valuable platform for studying a variety of fundamental quantum effects, for example, superposition and entanglement, complementarity, and decoherence. Whereas much of the same physics can be studied in mesoscopic superconducting circuits, the focus here is on cavity QED experiments that employ Rydberg states. Several characteristics of Rydberg atoms point to their application in studies of atom–radiation coupling. They couple strongly to radiation fields and have long lifetimes against spontaneous decay. Their transitions lie in the millimeter-wave portion of the spectrum, allowing for the physical realization of low-order cavities whose size also permits reasonably long interaction times as the atoms pass through them.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Sep 10, 2018•34 citations

Mirror, mirror, on the wall – is the photon there at all?

Jonathan P. Dowling

One of the most curious predictions of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is the suppression of spontaneous emission from an excited atom sitting between two parallel mirrors. Although this effect has been measured experimentally and calculated from full QED theory, there are two different interpretations of what actually happens – a partially quantum mechanical explanation in which both the atom and the radiation field are quantized, and a semiclassical interpretation in which the radiation field is treated classically. While both viewpoints provide an intuitive explanation of the effect, they seem to yield conflicting answers to the question: what happens if one of the mirrors is suddenly replaced by a photodetector?

Physics World•May 1, 1995•1 citation
In this work we analyze two quantum electrodynamic effects in the vicinity of conducting mirrors: Spontaneous emission and Rutherford scattering. We show that the well–known inhibition of spontaneous emission between mirrors — often considered to be a purely quantum effect — can be explained totally classically in terms of the modal structure of the cavity through use of a simple model employing elementary antenna theory and the image method. In contrast, the process of Rutherford scattering in free space is thought to be essentially classical since the quantum derivation of the scattering formula agrees exactly with the classical result. We show, however, that in the neighborhood of perfectly reflecting mirrors the virtual photons responsible for scattering begin to interfere with themselves producing fringes in the scattering cross section that have no classical analogue.
We revisit the problem of spontaneous emission by a two-level system in a cavity, concentrating in particular on those aspects associated with the finite propagation time of light between the atom and the cavity boundaries. We find that spontaneous emission always occurs first at the free space rate and there is then an abrupt change in these dynamics when light reflected by the cavity mirrors returns to the atom, leading to interference effects that result either in an enhancement or a reduction of this rate or in a periodic exchange of excitation between the atom and the cavity field. From this point of view, reversible spontaneous emission in terms of single-mode ``vacuum Rabi oscillations'' can be interpreted as resulting from the interference between the multimode partial waves reflected at the cavity mirrors and the instantaneously radiated light. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
Spontaneous Raman scattering is investigated theoretically by considering a completely classical description of the process that takes place within the mirrors of a microscopic Fabry-P\'erot cavity. This analysis is based on the image method within the framework of the classical theory of light scattering. In order to account for the finite reflectivities of the mirrors, the result for the scattered field is presently determined analytically only in the limit of low finesse of the optical cavity. This leads to a general expression for the cross section of the Stokes transition that explains the results recently reported in the literature [F. De Martini, M. Marrocco, C. Pastina, and F. Viti, Phys. Rev. A 53, 471 (1996)]. Therefore, in the limit of low finesse of the cavity, one must accept that this effect has a fundamentally classical nature. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
Abstract Arrays of atoms coupled to waveguides can behave as mirrors. We consider an array of three-level atoms, with one excited and two ground levels, assuming one of the ground levels to be decoupled from the other two. Preparing the atoms in the coupled or decoupled ground state leads to reflection or transmission of the guided electromagnetic field; a superposition of the two ground states thus corresponds to a coherent superposition of mirror-like and transparent boundary conditions. We analyze the spontaneous emission of an excited two-level atom in the presence of such a quantum mirror, and inside a cavity formed by quantum mirrors, demonstrating that the resulting dynamics of the excited atom can exhibit exotic features, e.g. a superposition of Rabi cycle and exponential decay. Our results pave the way for exploring quantum electrodynamics (QED) phenomena in a paradigm wherein boundary conditions can exhibit quantum superpositions and correlations.
The study of atoms and photons interacting in a confined space defined by mirrors, so-called “cavity quantum electrodynamics” (cavity QED), has been and continues to be of great interest both theoretically and experimentally (Haroche, 2013; Haroche et al ., 2020; Purcell et al ., 1946; Walther et al ., 2006). This interest was sparked by the realization that surrounding an atom with a cavity with no modes at the transition frequency could inhibit spontaneous emission. The field has since evolved to include modifications of the atomic energy levels and the oscillatory energy exchange between atoms and a cavity, leading to the creation of the “singleatom” maser, or micromaser. Cavity QED has proven itself a valuable platform for studying a variety of fundamental quantum effects, for example, superposition and entanglement, complementarity, and decoherence. Whereas much of the same physics can be studied in mesoscopic superconducting circuits, the focus here is on cavity QED experiments that employ Rydberg states. Several characteristics of Rydberg atoms point to their application in studies of atom–radiation coupling. They couple strongly to radiation fields and have long lifetimes against spontaneous decay. Their transitions lie in the millimeter-wave portion of the spectrum, allowing for the physical realization of low-order cavities whose size also permits reasonably long interaction times as the atoms pass through them.
One of the most curious predictions of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is the suppression of spontaneous emission from an excited atom sitting between two parallel mirrors. Although this effect has been measured experimentally and calculated from full QED theory, there are two different interpretations of what actually happens – a partially quantum mechanical explanation in which both the atom and the radiation field are quantized, and a semiclassical interpretation in which the radiation field is treated classically. While both viewpoints provide an intuitive explanation of the effect, they seem to yield conflicting answers to the question: what happens if one of the mirrors is suddenly replaced by a photodetector?