Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Interactions and Inequality

Philip Pearle

Published Aug 31, 2016• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

John Bell was a staunch supporter of the dynamical wave function collapse approach to making a well-defined quantum theory. Through letters from him, I reminisce on my handful of interactions with him, all of which were memorable tome. Then I discuss nonlocality, violation of Bell's inequality and some further implications within the framework of the CSL (continuous spontaneous localization) model of dynamical collapse. Interactions I was an instructor at Harvard with a newly minted Ph.D. from MIT, earned with an indifferent thesis on particle theory. It took me two years to come to terms with, dare I say it, the fact that I did not care about the S-matrix. I was going to be out of a job anyway in 1966 so, in the fall of 1965, I put my full energy into writing my very first paper, about what I did care: that, to my eyes there was something deeply wrong with the quantum theory I had been taught; that the rules of how to use it were inadequate. The title of the paper [1] was “Elimination of the reduction postulate from quantum theory and a framework for hidden variable theories.” It was a long title, because it was really two rather separate papers. The first was based upon the perceived inadequacy that the collapse (reduction) postulate of the theory is ill-defined. The second stated some postulates I thought a good hidden variable theory ought to obey, and gave a model for their satisfaction in a two-dimensional (i.e., spin-1/2) Hilbert space. Try as I might, I was not able to generalize my model to a higher-dimensional (i.e., spin-1) Hilbert space, but I put it out there for someone more clever than I to achieve. I sent the paper to a very few people who I thought might be interested. One was John Bell, and he replied (see Figure 23.1)! So someone more clever than I pointed out that generalizing my model could not be achieved. I therefore excised the model and, after rewriting and retitling, published my very first paper [2]! After a three-year stint at Case Institute of Technology, which graduated to become Case Western Reserve University while I was there, in 1969 I became ensconced at Hamilton College.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9781316219393.025

Related papers

John Bell's Varying Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics: Memories and Comments

H. D. Zeh

Various interpretations of quantum mechanics, favored (or neglected) by John Bell in the context of his nonlocality theorem, are compared and discussed. Varenna 1970 I met John Bell for the first time at the Varenna conference of 1970 [1]. I had been invited on the suggestion of Eugene P. Wigner, who had already helped me to publish my first paper on the concept that was later called decoherence – to appear in the first issue of Foundations of Physics a few months after the conference [2]. This concept arose from my conviction, based on many applications of quantum mechanics to composite systems under various conditions, that Schrödinger's wave function in configuration space, or more generally the superposition principle, is universally valid and applicable. In particular, stable narrow wavepackets can represent classical configurations, while their superpositions define novel individual properties – such as “momentum,” defined as a plane wave superposition of different positions. Superpositions of macroscopically different properties, on the other hand, are regularly irreversibly “dislocalized” (distributed over many degrees of freedom) by means of interactions described by the Schrödinger equation. The corresponding disappearance of certain local superpositions (“decoherence”) seems to explain the phenomenon of a classical world as well as the apparent occurrence of quantum jumps or stochastic “events” – see Sect. 20.4 or [3] for a historical overview of the conceptual development of quantum theory. So I had never felt any motivation to think of “hidden variables” or any other physics behind the successful wave function. Therefore, I was very surprised on my arrival in Varenna to hear everybody discuss Bell's inequality. It had been published a few years before the conference, but I had either not noticed it or not regarded it as particularly remarkable until then. As this inequality demonstrates that the predictions of quantum theory would require any conceivable reality possibly underlying the nonlocal wave function to be nonlocal itself, I simply found my conviction that the latter describes individual reality confirmed. For example, I had often discussed the conservation of total spin or angular momentum in an individual decay process, which requires nonlocal entanglement between the fragments at any distance in a form that was later called a “Bell state”.

arXiv:1402.5498•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 31, 2016•4 citations

Readers offer their own magic moments with John Bell

Robert B. Griffiths

Reinhold Bertlmann’s article “Magic moments with John Bell” was a pleasure to read. I add a note concerning some later developments that are significant for understanding the implications of Bell’s quantum foundations work.The crucial point is that under the Bell locality hypothesis for a joint measurement as given in the article,E(a,b)=∫dλρ(λ)A(a,λ)·B(b,λ)the quantity λ that represents the hidden variable(s) is a classical, not a quantum, object, and ρ(λ) is a classical probability distribution. Such expressions only make sense in the context of quantum theory when the operators of interest commute with each other, but that is not the case when this expression is used to derive a Bell inequality.Many years ago Arthur Fine pointed out that hidden variables and Bell inequalities were “imposing requirements to make well defined precisely those probability distributions for noncommuting observables whose rejection is the very essence of quantum mechanics.”11. A. Fine, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 291 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.48.291 Thus the real issue is not one of locality but, instead, the proper use of probabilities in quantum theory.Fine’s point has been confirmed by the later development of a fully consistent way of introducing probabilities in quantum mechanics.22. R. B. Griffiths, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2014); http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-consistent-histories. That approach has shown that when quantum mechanics is interpreted using subspaces of the Hilbert space rather than classical hidden variables to represent physical properties, it is local: There are no ghostly nonlocal influences.We cannot know how Bell would have responded to those new developments, which only came to full fruition after his untimely death. The reader willing to dig into my somewhat tedious discussion33. R. B. Griffiths, Consistent Quantum Theory, Cambridge U. Press (2002), sec. 23.4. of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen and Bohm situation will find an explicit proof that a measurement by Alice has not the slightest effect on the spin on Bob’s side. More recent is a general argument that quantum mechanics satisfies a principle of Einstein locality: What is done to system A has no effect on system B as long as there is no interaction between the two.44. R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5Those proofs of quantum locality begin by taking very seriously John von Neumann’s proposal that quantum properties correspond to Hilbert subspaces, whose projectors do not, in general, commute with one another.55. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Princeton U. Press (1955), sec. 3.5. Bell, though, assumed that such properties can be represented by classical hidden variables, which always commute. Thus Bell’s theorem teaches that if one uses classical hidden variables in place of quantum properties, the result will contradict quantum theory and disagree with experiment. Indeed, while Bell started off by pointing out deficiencies in von Neumann’s argument against hidden variables, the end result of his work is an even better and much more conclusive argument, backed by experiment, for rejecting classical hidden variables.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. A. Fine, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 291 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.48.291, Google ScholarCrossref2. R. B. Griffiths, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2014); http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-consistent-histories. Google Scholar3. R. B. Griffiths, Consistent Quantum Theory, Cambridge U. Press (2002), sec. 23.4. Google Scholar4. R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5, Google ScholarCrossref5. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Princeton U. Press (1955), sec. 3.5. Google Scholar© 2015 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 30, 2015•0 citations

Introduction to Dynamical Wave Function Collapse: Realism in Quantum Physics: Volume 1

Philip Pearle

Abstract This book describes one approach to resolving the ‘measurement problem’ of standard quantum theory (SQT), by changing the Schrodinger equation’s evolution of the wave function. The wave function of SQT does not describe reality. For example, the wave function corresponding to a completed experiment is the sum of terms describing the different experimental outcomes whereas one of these outcomes is what appears in Nature, The rules of SQT respond to this deficiency by imposing an ill-defined ‘collapse postulate.’ The prior smooth evolution of the wave function according to Schrodinger’s equation is replaced by an abrupt ‘jump’ to one of the outcomes. When, why, how are unanswered questions. I have added a term to Schrodinger’s equation, obtaining a theory (which I named the ‘Continuous Spontaneous Localization’ theory, or CSL) that answers these questions. The term has a random field in it: each field makes the sum of terms evolve to one of the terms. The collection of all possible fields produces the (Born rule) probabilistic predictions of SQT. Thus, CSL does something SQT does not: it describes the occurrence of events. But, it is a different theory than SQT, so it predicts different results for some carefully crafted experiments. CSL has now existed for over three decades. While no experiment as yet has proven CSL true, no experiment has conflicted with it either. In this book I have aimed to give a clear exposition of CSL and its consequences, accessible to anyone who has studied SQT.

•Jan 30, 2024•1 citation

Bell Nonlocality, Hardy's Paradox and Hyperplane Dependence

Gordon N. Fleming

I begin with some reminiscences of my delayed appreciation of the significance of John Bell'swork. Preparatory remarks on my general perspective concerning the interpretation of quantum mechanics are presented. I argue against the conflation of hyperplane dependence with frame dependence, which occurs occasionally; and that the ‘elements of reality’ of Hardy's famous gedankenexperiment can retain their Lorentz invariance, i.e., their frame independence, if one recognizes the hyperplane dependence of their localization, which follows. Finally, I criticize a view of the nature of Lorentz transformations presented by Asher Peres and co-workers which conflicts with the view employed here. Initial Reactions to Bell's Work Like many others in the physics community, I was late to come to an appreciation of the significance of John Bell's papers on the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM). But unlike many of those, my indifference to Bell was not due to a dismissive attitude to foundational studies per se or to an intransigent commitment to some version of Copenhagenism. In 1971, for example, I was very much involved in the international conference on QM foundations at my home institution, where Bell presented the paper “On the hypothesis that the Schrödinger equation is exact,” published later as [1], but I paid minimal attention to his presentation. The cause of this poor judgment (as I eventually came to realize it was) was that I was already convinced that the Schrödinger equation was not exact in the sense Bell meant, but must be augmented with primordial state reductions. I was among those who, in the words of Bob Wald, as reported by Roger Penrose [2], were inclined to “take it seriously,” the QM state that is, and, consequently, could not “really believe in it,” i.e., really believe that purely unitary QM is a complete theory. I was delighted when the experimental tests of Bell's inequalities upheld the QM predictions. I was, furthermore, uninterested in hidden variable reconstructions of QM, such as Bohmian mechanics [3] and Many Worlds interpretations [4, 5], that were, in principle, not susceptible to empirical tests of their novel details.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 31, 2016•0 citations

In Praise and in Criticism of the Model of Continuous Spontaneous Localization of the Wave-Function

Sofia Wechsler

Different attempts to solve the measurement problem of the quantum me-chanics (QM) by denying the collapse principle, and replacing it with changes in the quantum formalism, failed because the changes in the formalism lead to contradictions with QM predictions. To the difference, Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber took the collapse as a real phenomenon, and proposed a calculus by which the wave-function should undergo a sudden localization. Later on, Ghirardi, Pearle and Rimini came with a change of this calculus into the CSL (continuous spontaneous localization) model of collapse. Both these proposals rely on the experimental fact that the reduction of the wave-function occurs when the microscopic system encounters a macroscopic object and involves a big amount of its particles. Both these proposals also change the quantum formalism by introducing in the Schr?dinger equation additional terms with noisy behavior. However, these terms have practically no influence as long as the studied system contains only one or a few components. Only when the amount of components is very big, these terms become significant and lead to the reduction of the wave-function to one of its components. The present work has two purposes: 1) proving that the collapse postulate is unavoidable; 2) ap-plying the CSL model to the process in a detector and showing step by step the modification of the wave-function, until reduction. As a side detail, it is argued here that the noise cannot originate in some classical field, contrary to the thought/hope of some physicists, because no classical field is tailored by the wave-functions of entanglements.

arXiv:2010.03392•Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2020•9 citations

Readers offer their own magic moments with John Bell

N. Bykovetz

I greatly enjoyed reading Reinhold Bertlmann’s article “Magic moments with John Bell.” Sprinkled with levity, it discussed Bell’s life, work, and outstanding insights and achievements in the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM). In my view, the reading should also make one acutely aware that scientists, despite our expectations of them, are sometimes still prone to the same failings that beset the rest of humanity.Bertlmann outlines very nicely Bell’s theorem and inequalities and the consequences of their violation; that work led to the subsequent startling experimental results on “entangled” quantum mechanical states, which, Bertlmann writes, showed “that nature contains a nonlocality in its structure.” Nonlocality, in Bell’s conception of it, is clearly a violation of special relativity (SR), so we have a problem. The startling thing for me is that Bell actually does appear to solve the problem, at least in principle, but at the same time he seems afraid to say so and, in fact, distances himself from the proposed solution.The essence of his ambivalence is conveyed in the following paragraph, quoted by Bertlmann:It may be that we have to admit that causal influences do go faster than light. The role of Lorentz invariance in the completed theory would then be very problematic. An “ether” would be the cheapest solution. But the unobservability of this ether would be disturbing. So would be the impossibility of “messages” faster than light.Clearly, faster-than-light propagation is not possible in SR. But it is permissible in the approximately 100-year-old ether-based Lorentzian theory of relativity (LR), developed by Joseph Larmor, Hendrik Lorentz, Henri Poincaré, and others. Bell was explicitly cognizant of LR and discussed it in his book Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics (2nd edition, Cambridge University Press, 2004). It is well known that LR and SR are totally congruent in their kinematics and dynamics, for speeds equal to or less than c. All predictions are identical. However—though one cannot find this in any standard textbooks—the LR ether theory differs from SR by allowing, without contradiction, speeds greater than c.Historically, Einstein’s SR gained ascendancy, and LR was relegated to the scrap heap of history for many reasons, but I think predominantly for the following. SR was viewed as being far more elegant and simple to develop—from the perspective of theory formation—because it followed deductively from Einstein’s two simple axioms. On the other hand, LR theory was developed from a realism perspective, where waves were thought to need a medium to wave in (the luminiferous ether).Considering that Bell was clearly aware of LR and was entertaining the idea, albeit reluctantly, of “causal influences [going] faster than light”—that is, being consonant with LR—I find it difficult to understand his expressions in the quote above about cheap solutions and disturbing features. It seems to be part of human psychology that once a set of ideas or a theory is accepted as valid for a long enough time by a community of people, as has been the case for SR, it gets transformed into belief, psychologically not unlike religious belief. Once that happens, those who would question the established dogma are treated as if the questioning was ill-intentioned, if not downright sacrilegious.© 2015 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 30, 2015•0 citations
John Bell was a staunch supporter of the dynamical wave function collapse approach to making a well-defined quantum theory. Through letters from him, I reminisce on my handful of interactions with him, all of which were memorable tome. Then I discuss nonlocality, violation of Bell's inequality and some further implications within the framework of the CSL (continuous spontaneous localization) model of dynamical collapse. Interactions I was an instructor at Harvard with a newly minted Ph.D. from MIT, earned with an indifferent thesis on particle theory. It took me two years to come to terms with, dare I say it, the fact that I did not care about the S-matrix. I was going to be out of a job anyway in 1966 so, in the fall of 1965, I put my full energy into writing my very first paper, about what I did care: that, to my eyes there was something deeply wrong with the quantum theory I had been taught; that the rules of how to use it were inadequate. The title of the paper [1] was “Elimination of the reduction postulate from quantum theory and a framework for hidden variable theories.” It was a long title, because it was really two rather separate papers. The first was based upon the perceived inadequacy that the collapse (reduction) postulate of the theory is ill-defined. The second stated some postulates I thought a good hidden variable theory ought to obey, and gave a model for their satisfaction in a two-dimensional (i.e., spin-1/2) Hilbert space. Try as I might, I was not able to generalize my model to a higher-dimensional (i.e., spin-1) Hilbert space, but I put it out there for someone more clever than I to achieve. I sent the paper to a very few people who I thought might be interested. One was John Bell, and he replied (see Figure 23.1)! So someone more clever than I pointed out that generalizing my model could not be achieved. I therefore excised the model and, after rewriting and retitling, published my very first paper [2]! After a three-year stint at Case Institute of Technology, which graduated to become Case Western Reserve University while I was there, in 1969 I became ensconced at Hamilton College.
Various interpretations of quantum mechanics, favored (or neglected) by John Bell in the context of his nonlocality theorem, are compared and discussed. Varenna 1970 I met John Bell for the first time at the Varenna conference of 1970 [1]. I had been invited on the suggestion of Eugene P. Wigner, who had already helped me to publish my first paper on the concept that was later called decoherence – to appear in the first issue of Foundations of Physics a few months after the conference [2]. This concept arose from my conviction, based on many applications of quantum mechanics to composite systems under various conditions, that Schrödinger's wave function in configuration space, or more generally the superposition principle, is universally valid and applicable. In particular, stable narrow wavepackets can represent classical configurations, while their superpositions define novel individual properties – such as “momentum,” defined as a plane wave superposition of different positions. Superpositions of macroscopically different properties, on the other hand, are regularly irreversibly “dislocalized” (distributed over many degrees of freedom) by means of interactions described by the Schrödinger equation. The corresponding disappearance of certain local superpositions (“decoherence”) seems to explain the phenomenon of a classical world as well as the apparent occurrence of quantum jumps or stochastic “events” – see Sect. 20.4 or [3] for a historical overview of the conceptual development of quantum theory. So I had never felt any motivation to think of “hidden variables” or any other physics behind the successful wave function. Therefore, I was very surprised on my arrival in Varenna to hear everybody discuss Bell's inequality. It had been published a few years before the conference, but I had either not noticed it or not regarded it as particularly remarkable until then. As this inequality demonstrates that the predictions of quantum theory would require any conceivable reality possibly underlying the nonlocal wave function to be nonlocal itself, I simply found my conviction that the latter describes individual reality confirmed. For example, I had often discussed the conservation of total spin or angular momentum in an individual decay process, which requires nonlocal entanglement between the fragments at any distance in a form that was later called a “Bell state”.
Reinhold Bertlmann’s article “Magic moments with John Bell” was a pleasure to read. I add a note concerning some later developments that are significant for understanding the implications of Bell’s quantum foundations work.The crucial point is that under the Bell locality hypothesis for a joint measurement as given in the article,E(a,b)=∫dλρ(λ)A(a,λ)·B(b,λ)the quantity λ that represents the hidden variable(s) is a classical, not a quantum, object, and ρ(λ) is a classical probability distribution. Such expressions only make sense in the context of quantum theory when the operators of interest commute with each other, but that is not the case when this expression is used to derive a Bell inequality.Many years ago Arthur Fine pointed out that hidden variables and Bell inequalities were “imposing requirements to make well defined precisely those probability distributions for noncommuting observables whose rejection is the very essence of quantum mechanics.”11. A. Fine, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 291 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.48.291 Thus the real issue is not one of locality but, instead, the proper use of probabilities in quantum theory.Fine’s point has been confirmed by the later development of a fully consistent way of introducing probabilities in quantum mechanics.22. R. B. Griffiths, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2014); http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-consistent-histories. That approach has shown that when quantum mechanics is interpreted using subspaces of the Hilbert space rather than classical hidden variables to represent physical properties, it is local: There are no ghostly nonlocal influences.We cannot know how Bell would have responded to those new developments, which only came to full fruition after his untimely death. The reader willing to dig into my somewhat tedious discussion33. R. B. Griffiths, Consistent Quantum Theory, Cambridge U. Press (2002), sec. 23.4. of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen and Bohm situation will find an explicit proof that a measurement by Alice has not the slightest effect on the spin on Bob’s side. More recent is a general argument that quantum mechanics satisfies a principle of Einstein locality: What is done to system A has no effect on system B as long as there is no interaction between the two.44. R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5Those proofs of quantum locality begin by taking very seriously John von Neumann’s proposal that quantum properties correspond to Hilbert subspaces, whose projectors do not, in general, commute with one another.55. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Princeton U. Press (1955), sec. 3.5. Bell, though, assumed that such properties can be represented by classical hidden variables, which always commute. Thus Bell’s theorem teaches that if one uses classical hidden variables in place of quantum properties, the result will contradict quantum theory and disagree with experiment. Indeed, while Bell started off by pointing out deficiencies in von Neumann’s argument against hidden variables, the end result of his work is an even better and much more conclusive argument, backed by experiment, for rejecting classical hidden variables.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. A. Fine, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 291 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.48.291, Google ScholarCrossref2. R. B. Griffiths, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2014); http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-consistent-histories. Google Scholar3. R. B. Griffiths, Consistent Quantum Theory, Cambridge U. Press (2002), sec. 23.4. Google Scholar4. R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5, Google ScholarCrossref5. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Princeton U. Press (1955), sec. 3.5. Google Scholar© 2015 American Institute of Physics.
Abstract This book describes one approach to resolving the ‘measurement problem’ of standard quantum theory (SQT), by changing the Schrodinger equation’s evolution of the wave function. The wave function of SQT does not describe reality. For example, the wave function corresponding to a completed experiment is the sum of terms describing the different experimental outcomes whereas one of these outcomes is what appears in Nature, The rules of SQT respond to this deficiency by imposing an ill-defined ‘collapse postulate.’ The prior smooth evolution of the wave function according to Schrodinger’s equation is replaced by an abrupt ‘jump’ to one of the outcomes. When, why, how are unanswered questions. I have added a term to Schrodinger’s equation, obtaining a theory (which I named the ‘Continuous Spontaneous Localization’ theory, or CSL) that answers these questions. The term has a random field in it: each field makes the sum of terms evolve to one of the terms. The collection of all possible fields produces the (Born rule) probabilistic predictions of SQT. Thus, CSL does something SQT does not: it describes the occurrence of events. But, it is a different theory than SQT, so it predicts different results for some carefully crafted experiments. CSL has now existed for over three decades. While no experiment as yet has proven CSL true, no experiment has conflicted with it either. In this book I have aimed to give a clear exposition of CSL and its consequences, accessible to anyone who has studied SQT.
I begin with some reminiscences of my delayed appreciation of the significance of John Bell'swork. Preparatory remarks on my general perspective concerning the interpretation of quantum mechanics are presented. I argue against the conflation of hyperplane dependence with frame dependence, which occurs occasionally; and that the ‘elements of reality’ of Hardy's famous gedankenexperiment can retain their Lorentz invariance, i.e., their frame independence, if one recognizes the hyperplane dependence of their localization, which follows. Finally, I criticize a view of the nature of Lorentz transformations presented by Asher Peres and co-workers which conflicts with the view employed here. Initial Reactions to Bell's Work Like many others in the physics community, I was late to come to an appreciation of the significance of John Bell's papers on the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM). But unlike many of those, my indifference to Bell was not due to a dismissive attitude to foundational studies per se or to an intransigent commitment to some version of Copenhagenism. In 1971, for example, I was very much involved in the international conference on QM foundations at my home institution, where Bell presented the paper “On the hypothesis that the Schrödinger equation is exact,” published later as [1], but I paid minimal attention to his presentation. The cause of this poor judgment (as I eventually came to realize it was) was that I was already convinced that the Schrödinger equation was not exact in the sense Bell meant, but must be augmented with primordial state reductions. I was among those who, in the words of Bob Wald, as reported by Roger Penrose [2], were inclined to “take it seriously,” the QM state that is, and, consequently, could not “really believe in it,” i.e., really believe that purely unitary QM is a complete theory. I was delighted when the experimental tests of Bell's inequalities upheld the QM predictions. I was, furthermore, uninterested in hidden variable reconstructions of QM, such as Bohmian mechanics [3] and Many Worlds interpretations [4, 5], that were, in principle, not susceptible to empirical tests of their novel details.
Different attempts to solve the measurement problem of the quantum me-chanics (QM) by denying the collapse principle, and replacing it with changes in the quantum formalism, failed because the changes in the formalism lead to contradictions with QM predictions. To the difference, Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber took the collapse as a real phenomenon, and proposed a calculus by which the wave-function should undergo a sudden localization. Later on, Ghirardi, Pearle and Rimini came with a change of this calculus into the CSL (continuous spontaneous localization) model of collapse. Both these proposals rely on the experimental fact that the reduction of the wave-function occurs when the microscopic system encounters a macroscopic object and involves a big amount of its particles. Both these proposals also change the quantum formalism by introducing in the Schr?dinger equation additional terms with noisy behavior. However, these terms have practically no influence as long as the studied system contains only one or a few components. Only when the amount of components is very big, these terms become significant and lead to the reduction of the wave-function to one of its components. The present work has two purposes: 1) proving that the collapse postulate is unavoidable; 2) ap-plying the CSL model to the process in a detector and showing step by step the modification of the wave-function, until reduction. As a side detail, it is argued here that the noise cannot originate in some classical field, contrary to the thought/hope of some physicists, because no classical field is tailored by the wave-functions of entanglements.
I greatly enjoyed reading Reinhold Bertlmann’s article “Magic moments with John Bell.” Sprinkled with levity, it discussed Bell’s life, work, and outstanding insights and achievements in the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM). In my view, the reading should also make one acutely aware that scientists, despite our expectations of them, are sometimes still prone to the same failings that beset the rest of humanity.Bertlmann outlines very nicely Bell’s theorem and inequalities and the consequences of their violation; that work led to the subsequent startling experimental results on “entangled” quantum mechanical states, which, Bertlmann writes, showed “that nature contains a nonlocality in its structure.” Nonlocality, in Bell’s conception of it, is clearly a violation of special relativity (SR), so we have a problem. The startling thing for me is that Bell actually does appear to solve the problem, at least in principle, but at the same time he seems afraid to say so and, in fact, distances himself from the proposed solution.The essence of his ambivalence is conveyed in the following paragraph, quoted by Bertlmann:It may be that we have to admit that causal influences do go faster than light. The role of Lorentz invariance in the completed theory would then be very problematic. An “ether” would be the cheapest solution. But the unobservability of this ether would be disturbing. So would be the impossibility of “messages” faster than light.Clearly, faster-than-light propagation is not possible in SR. But it is permissible in the approximately 100-year-old ether-based Lorentzian theory of relativity (LR), developed by Joseph Larmor, Hendrik Lorentz, Henri Poincaré, and others. Bell was explicitly cognizant of LR and discussed it in his book Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics (2nd edition, Cambridge University Press, 2004). It is well known that LR and SR are totally congruent in their kinematics and dynamics, for speeds equal to or less than c. All predictions are identical. However—though one cannot find this in any standard textbooks—the LR ether theory differs from SR by allowing, without contradiction, speeds greater than c.Historically, Einstein’s SR gained ascendancy, and LR was relegated to the scrap heap of history for many reasons, but I think predominantly for the following. SR was viewed as being far more elegant and simple to develop—from the perspective of theory formation—because it followed deductively from Einstein’s two simple axioms. On the other hand, LR theory was developed from a realism perspective, where waves were thought to need a medium to wave in (the luminiferous ether).Considering that Bell was clearly aware of LR and was entertaining the idea, albeit reluctantly, of “causal influences [going] faster than light”—that is, being consonant with LR—I find it difficult to understand his expressions in the quote above about cheap solutions and disturbing features. It seems to be part of human psychology that once a set of ideas or a theory is accepted as valid for a long enough time by a community of people, as has been the case for SR, it gets transformed into belief, psychologically not unlike religious belief. Once that happens, those who would question the established dogma are treated as if the questioning was ill-intentioned, if not downright sacrilegious.© 2015 American Institute of Physics.