I would like to recall my experiences when I joined George Series when on study leave from the University of Otago in 1959. Like George, we had decided, some years previously, to pursue the line of research opened up by the double-resonance experiment of Brossel and Bitter. Up to that time both groups had been applying the new technique to traditional spectroscopic problems, those of measuring the fine structure, hyperhe structure, g -factors and nuclear moments. But here, in Oxford, was something new and exciting - experiments that studied the nature of light itself, questioning some long-held views. George had come to the view that, in a double-resonance experiment, one could demonstrate the inner coherence that could exist between superposition states of an atom. He, and his students Wilf Fox and Mike Taylor, had already obtained promising evidence; but he needed more definite results if he was going to allay the doubts and suspicions of some others in the Clarendon. At the time, people generally thought that light, being a superposition of radiations from many atoms with no obvious phase relation to each other, was an incoherent wave phenomenon. One could observe small scale coherence (for example, in the Young interference experiment) but it would be largely concealed by the incoherent nature of the radiation from many atoms in a source. In the experiments that had been performed the coherence was introduced between a pair of excited states (Zeeman sub-states) by the application of an oscillating magnetic field - was it not likely, according to the doubters, that the modulation observed in the fluorescence was due to "pick-up" in the amplifiers from the source of oscillations? George had to prove that this was not the cause. I well remember him saying at the time "I have a hunch that I am correct". That typified his approach to physics. The work of 1959 demonstrated beyond all doubt that substantial coherence, manifested as strong beats in the intensity of the light, could be obtained. The experiments demonstrated this to be the case. We also worked out the theory of the effect. In the theoretical explanation of the experiments, both George and I were impressed by the success of a semi-classical approach - i.e. by treating the atom as a quantum-mechanical structure and the light as an electromagnetic wave. This viewpoint dominated much of George's work in later times. As he stated in the Memoirs, "I came to the conclusion that the key problem in the interaction of electromagnetic fields and atoms was the nature of spontaneous emission. I accept the quantum field theory as giving an adequate mathematical explanation, but this seems to me to be deficient as a physical explanation". I think it is fair to say that George was always seeking a deeper physical meaning than was provided by a mere mathematical description. This philosophy certainly rubbed off on people who worked with him. That year, 1959, was also the year when coherence in light beams was being studied in other laboratories across the Atlantic. It was the year the laser was born. There was no doubt then about coherence in light. I would also like to mention the great regard that George had for S. Pancharatnam who came to work at the Clarendon in 1964. George and Panch spent many hours in discussions. Although they never published anything jointly, George recalled that, if he was doubtful about some point of physics, he would refer to Panch. As he wrote in a moving review for the Pancharatnam Memorial Issue of Current Science (Vol. 67, August 1994), "Panch was not easily moved from the conventional view [of the nature of the interactions of light and atoms]. I was more impetuous; Panch was generally right". George edited the collected works of Pancharatnam; he went to India as a Raman Visiting Professor in 1982 and was made an Honorary Fellow of the Indian Academy of Sciences in 1984. At Reading [from 1968 to 1982], he increasingly turned to spectroscopy with tuneable lasers, generally with the emphasis on understanding the underlying physics rather than accumulating data. He had a highly original mind, which showed both in his choice of research topics and in his method of approach. He did not follow fashion; his instinct for an interesting problem was at odds with the modem policy of direct funding and the identification of "growth areas". His applications for research grants were often unsuccessful, despite his high international standing and integrity. He was never interested in building up a large research team, and had comparatively few research students, but his enthusiasm and commitment to the quality of his science attracted a succession of overseas visitors to his laboratory. Following my own year at the Clarendon, and some subsequent visits both to Oxford and to Reading, there was a continuing strong association between the Clarendon and Otago Physics that continues until today. George Series was the William Evans Visiting Professor to Otago University in 1972. He never lost his interest in the fundamentals of physics inspired by his first researches into the structure of the hydrogen atom; he wrote on the Rydberg constant, the physics of spontaneous emission, and on the fine-structure constant α = e 2 / hc . He donated a garden seat to St Edmund Hall (Oxford), of which he was a Fellow. On it he placed a plaque* in recognition of the ubiquitous nature of this constant; it almost had magical significance for him. He served physics in many ways outside research. He was for a number of years the Editor of the European Journal of Physics and was also Editor of the Journal of Physics B: Atomic and Molecular Physics , He was also on the Editorial Board of a number of journals. He was elected to Fellowship of a number of physics societies. The Editorial Board of these Memorial Essays dedicate them to George's memory, and to his wife Annette and his family.
I would like to recall my experiences when I joined George Series when on study leave from the University of Otago in 1959. Like George, we had decided, some years previously, to pursue the line of research opened up by the double-resonance experiment of Brossel and Bitter. Up to that time both groups had been applying the new technique to traditional spectroscopic problems, those of measuring the fine structure, hyperhe structure, g -factors and nuclear moments. But here, in Oxford, was something new and exciting - experiments that studied the nature of light itself, questioning some long-held views. George had come to the view that, in a double-resonance experiment, one could demonstrate the inner coherence that could exist between superposition states of an atom. He, and his students Wilf Fox and Mike Taylor, had already obtained promising evidence; but he needed more definite results if he was going to allay the doubts and suspicions of some others in the Clarendon. At the time, people generally thought that light, being a superposition of radiations from many atoms with no obvious phase relation to each other, was an incoherent wave phenomenon. One could observe small scale coherence (for example, in the Young interference experiment) but it would be largely concealed by the incoherent nature of the radiation from many atoms in a source. In the experiments that had been performed the coherence was introduced between a pair of excited states (Zeeman sub-states) by the application of an oscillating magnetic field - was it not likely, according to the doubters, that the modulation observed in the fluorescence was due to "pick-up" in the amplifiers from the source of oscillations? George had to prove that this was not the cause. I well remember him saying at the time "I have a hunch that I am correct". That typified his approach to physics. The work of 1959 demonstrated beyond all doubt that substantial coherence, manifested as strong beats in the intensity of the light, could be obtained. The experiments demonstrated this to be the case. We also worked out the theory of the effect. In the theoretical explanation of the experiments, both George and I were impressed by the success of a semi-classical approach - i.e. by treating the atom as a quantum-mechanical structure and the light as an electromagnetic wave. This viewpoint dominated much of George's work in later times. As he stated in the Memoirs, "I came to the conclusion that the key problem in the interaction of electromagnetic fields and atoms was the nature of spontaneous emission. I accept the quantum field theory as giving an adequate mathematical explanation, but this seems to me to be deficient as a physical explanation". I think it is fair to say that George was always seeking a deeper physical meaning than was provided by a mere mathematical description. This philosophy certainly rubbed off on people who worked with him. That year, 1959, was also the year when coherence in light beams was being studied in other laboratories across the Atlantic. It was the year the laser was born. There was no doubt then about coherence in light. I would also like to mention the great regard that George had for S. Pancharatnam who came to work at the Clarendon in 1964. George and Panch spent many hours in discussions. Although they never published anything jointly, George recalled that, if he was doubtful about some point of physics, he would refer to Panch. As he wrote in a moving review for the Pancharatnam Memorial Issue of Current Science (Vol. 67, August 1994), "Panch was not easily moved from the conventional view [of the nature of the interactions of light and atoms]. I was more impetuous; Panch was generally right". George edited the collected works of Pancharatnam; he went to India as a Raman Visiting Professor in 1982 and was made an Honorary Fellow of the Indian Academy of Sciences in 1984. At Reading [from 1968 to 1982], he increasingly turned to spectroscopy with tuneable lasers, generally with the emphasis on understanding the underlying physics rather than accumulating data. He had a highly original mind, which showed both in his choice of research topics and in his method of approach. He did not follow fashion; his instinct for an interesting problem was at odds with the modem policy of direct funding and the identification of "growth areas". His applications for research grants were often unsuccessful, despite his high international standing and integrity. He was never interested in building up a large research team, and had comparatively few research students, but his enthusiasm and commitment to the quality of his science attracted a succession of overseas visitors to his laboratory. Following my own year at the Clarendon, and some subsequent visits both to Oxford and to Reading, there was a continuing strong association between the Clarendon and Otago Physics that continues until today. George Series was the William Evans Visiting Professor to Otago University in 1972. He never lost his interest in the fundamentals of physics inspired by his first researches into the structure of the hydrogen atom; he wrote on the Rydberg constant, the physics of spontaneous emission, and on the fine-structure constant α = e 2 / hc . He donated a garden seat to St Edmund Hall (Oxford), of which he was a Fellow. On it he placed a plaque* in recognition of the ubiquitous nature of this constant; it almost had magical significance for him. He served physics in many ways outside research. He was for a number of years the Editor of the European Journal of Physics and was also Editor of the Journal of Physics B: Atomic and Molecular Physics , He was also on the Editorial Board of a number of journals. He was elected to Fellowship of a number of physics societies. The Editorial Board of these Memorial Essays dedicate them to George's memory, and to his wife Annette and his family.
Louis due de Broglie died on 19 March 1987.He was born on 15 August 1892 to a French noble family, the youngest of five children.A very gifted boy, he studied for five years at the Sorbonne, covering history, law and finally science.Drafted in 1913 into the radiotelegraphy corps, he worked throughout the first world war at the Eiffel tower emitter, and also became familiar with the theory of electromagnetic waves.After the war he joined the x-ray laboratory that his elder brother Maurice (a former naval officer) had installed in his mansion near the Champs Elysees in Paris.This was an active laboratory and Louis did some theoretical work on x-rays and atomic structure.He also carefully studied Einstein's work on special relativity and quantum physics.In 1922 he derived Planck's law from statistical physics (two years before Bose).Then came his bold discovery: in the preface to a new edition of his thesis (first written in 1924) he wrote 'After long reflection in solitude and meditation, I suddenly had the idea, during the year 1923, that the discovery made by Einstein in 1905 should be extended to all material particles'.His study of the waves associated with particles was published in two notes, Comptes Rendus Acad.Sci.Paris 177 pp507-10and pp548-50 (1923), in a letter to Nature (1923 112 p540) and in a paper in Phil.Mag.(1924 47 pp446-58).The condition for standing waves on a closed orbit yielded the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantisation.In the second note de Broglie wrote: 'An electron beam travelling through a small enough aperture would show a diffraction phenomenon.This might be the right direction to look for an experimental verification of our ideas'.Immediately Einstein used de Broglie's wave ideas in his paper on the quantum monatomic gas (1925 Sitz.Preuss.Akad.Wiss.p3).Schrodinger (1926 Phys.Zeit.27 p95) did not like the use of Bose statistics in this paper, but he wrote 'the de Broglie-Einstein waves should be taken seriously'.He did: his next paper was the famous one on the hydrogen atom, and soon he proved the equivalence of wave mechanics and quantum mechanics, created the year before by Heisenberg.Elsasser noted (1925) that the Ramsauer effect, and also the Davisson and Kunsman experiments, could be explained with de Broglie waves.Davisson and Germer carried out much more precise and convincing experiments, published in 1927.They were followed by many other experimenters: the first of the resulting publications was a letter to Nature from G P Thomson and A Reid in which de Broglie's name was not even mentioned.De Broglie received the Nobel prize in 1929, whilst Davisson and Thomson received theirs in 1937.Like Einstein and Schrodinger, de Broglie did not agree in 1927 about the nondeterministic interpretation of wave mechanics.Nevertheless, for 25 years he taught an advanced course on the new physics every year, each one being published in book form (many are excellent and several have been translated into English).He worked on a theory of light in which photons are composite particles, and from the age of 60 he again started work on a deterministic wave theory which (like his group of students) will probably be forgotten.De Broglie wrote excellent popular books on modern physics in beautiful French.He received many honours (membership of academies, including the Royal Society, and Honorary Fellowship of The Institute of Physics) and accepted many responsibilities in France, which he assumed with devotion.He led a very simple life, and never married.He felt a high duty to serve science: in 1949 his message to the Lausanne colloquium of the 'Mouvement Europeen' was an eloquent and very prophetic plea for a 'physics laboratory in which it would be possible to work outside and above the national frameworks.As a result of collaboration between a large number of European nations, this organism would have more important resources than national laboratories'.It was influential in the creation of CERN.first Ph D degree in forensic science by the University of Madras, India, for his thesis on aspects of skull identification and individualisation.
One way of reading this book is as an epilogue-or (more precisely) as a denouement-to a book I wrote more than thirty years ago, which was called Quantum Mechanics and Experience.That earlier book was meant to do two things:1) To introduce its readers to the elementary nuts and bolts of the foundations of quantum mechanics-the idea of superposition, the basics of the standard mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, the argument of Einstein and Podolsky and Rosen to the effect that that formalism, considered as a description of the fundamental real ity of the world, must be somehow incomplete, Bell's extension of that argument into a general and power ful theorem about locality, the elaboration (by figures like Erwin Schrödinger, and John von Neumann, and Eugene Wigner) of the quantum-mechanical mea surement prob lem, and vari ous proposals (theories of the spontaneous collapse of the wave-function, Bohmian mechanics, the so-called many-worlds interpretations of quantum mechanics, and so on) for solving it.2) To show how the above-mentioned proposals for solving the mea sure ment prob lem, taken together, amount to a
I thank Rodger Walser and his colleagues for organizing this conference to celebrate George \nSudarshan’s birthday and landmark achievements in science. It is an honor for me to be here and \nalso a great pleasure to be back in Austin to join the chorus of the FOGS. \nI would like begin with a brief historical introduction and then turn to topics that we \nhaven’t heard so much about thus far in the symposium, namely experiments in Quantum Optics. \nLet me remind you that blackbody radiation has had a profound impact on physics since the time \nof Planck. However, even in more modern times after the development of quantum mechanics \nand quantum electrodynamics, one really did not know how to describe the underlying field \nfluctuations as required for diverse interference phenomena. Emil Wolf laid critical foundations \nfor this enterprise with his theory of classical coherence developed in collaboration with Max \nBorn in their classic book Principles of Optics. \nA great challenge to the physics community was the experiment by R. H. Brown and R. \nQ. Twiss in 1956 [1], which led to a confusing and controversial time for photons and fields. In \n1958 Leonard Mandel helped to resolve the controversy by explaining how light fluctuations are \nconverted to photocurrents in the detection process, albeit in with a classical description of the \nfield [2]. The confusion arose from the effort to understand, on the one hand, interference \nphenomena that are expressed in terms of the complex amplitude of the electromagnetic field, for \nwhich only a classical description was available. On the other hand, quantum electrodynamics \nhad been developed based upon energy eigenstates (i.e., Fock states) with photons as quanta. It \nwas really difficult to understand how the electric and magnetic fields behave in terms of these \nquantum states. For example, the expectation value of any electromagnetic field is zero in a Fock \nstate. The confusion was compounded by the historic invention of the maser and laser and by the \npressing need for quantum theories of the dynamical processes of these and other laboratory \nadvances.
In the introduction to this section, the role of Lee R. Wilcox was mentioned as the one who called our attention to Franken's paper, of which he had received a preprint before its publication. Lee Wilcox had already accepted a teaching position at the American University in Beirut, Lebanon, and he did not stay as a member of our study group. He had told us that he did not consider the United States a safe place to live as the cold war confrontation with the Soviet Union reached its peak, threatening mutually assured destruction. Fortunately, he later returned to the United States before the conflagration in Lebanon started. He had a successful career as a professor of physics at the University of New York in Stony Brook until his premature death in 1995. I convinced John Armstrong to stay on at Harvard as a postdoctoral fellow. He had just received a Ph.D. degree with George B. Benedek on an experimental investigation of nuclear magnetic resonance at high pressures and was eager to join the emerging activity in optics. Jacques Ducuing had recently arrived from Paris for advanced graduate studies. He was on leave from the Campagnie Général de Té1égraphie sans Fils in Orsay. I assume that his original intent was to work on microwave masers and was glad he agreed to join our optics team instead. Peter S. Pershan had done his Ph.D. thesis work with me on cross -relaxation effects between nuclear spin systems in lithium fluoride. He had already stayed on as a postdoc for several years, involved not only with ongoing experiments in magnetic resonance, but also with microwave modulation of light. He was about to become an assistant professor and was keen on participating in the emerging field of nonlinear optics. I was fortunate to have these three young, extremely capable coworkers, who all continued on to have very successful scientific careers. John Armstrong joined the IBM research laboratories in Yorktown Heights, New York. He rose through the ranks to become vice-president for Research and Development for the IBM Corporation. Jacques Ducuing became a professor of physics at the Ecole Polytechnique in France, and later served as Director-General of the CNRS (Centre Nationale des Récherches Scientifiques) and as Chief Scientist of NATO in Brussels. Peter Pershan stayed on at Harvard University as Gordon McKay Professor of Applied Physics. In the summer and fall of 1961, we had regularly scheduled weekly group meetings to discuss our progress and to coordinate our efforts. The pace was so hectic that we had informal one-on-one discussions almost daily. I was well aware from lectures I had followed from Professor Leon Rosenfeld in Utrecht during World War II and from his booklet, Electron Physics, published in 1951, that electromagnetism is based on the microscopic Maxwell's equation in vacuum, and that the material is represented by moving charges, which are acted upon with Lorentz -type forces by the fields. The moving charges in turn serve as sources for these fields. I was also familiar with the relationship between the microscopic field of the vacuum and the macroscopic fields in media which occur in Maxwell's equations. I had emphasized these concepts in intermediate courses on electromagnetism I taught at Harvard. I always cautioned students that the engineering convention of introducing electric and magnetic permeabilities for the vacuum obscures the basic physics of the interaction between fields and matter. Thus, our starting point was that nonlinear polarizations produced by nonlineartities in the constitutive relations served as additional sources in Maxwell's equations. These nonlinearities are expressed in terms of second and third order nonlinear susceptibilities which could be calculated by higher order quantum mechanical perturbation theory. This procedure leads naturally to sets of coupled electromagnetic wave equations. General solutions were developed. My young associates were much more adept in carrying through the rather lengthy, detailed mathematical calculations than I was. We discovered with hindsight that the propagation of microwaves in guided structures, loaded periodically with nonlinear materials, had led to similar results. We also obtained Manley-Rowe relations and other integrals. In Sec. VIII of this paper, phase correction schemes for efficient harmonic generation in media with cubic media are discussed. I took out a patent on a method which became known as quasi-phase-matching. It is now widely used in periodically modulated optical wave guide geometries. Our work was supported by the Joint Services Electronics Program from the US. Department of Defense. I never wrote a formal proposal that our funding for magnetic resonance and masers in 1961 would be spent on work in optics. We reported our activity regularly in quarterly progress reports. Preprints of our work were widely distributed as JSEP Cruft Laboratory Technical Report 358 in March 1962. This paper was later designated as a “Citation Classic”. The entry in Current Contents , Volume 22, No. 6, February 11, 1991, is reproduced here to complement this commentary.
D URING MY FIRST YEAR as a student at the Ecole Normale Supérieure in Paris, our professor, Eugene Bloch, introduced us to quantum physics, which was seldom taught in France at that time. Like him, I was from Alsace and spoke German. He strongly advised me to read Arnold Sommerfeld's excellent book Atombau und Spektrallinien. When reading this book, I was particularly interested in the application of the principle of conservation of angular momentum in interactions between electromagnetic radiation and matter—an application that guided A. Rubinowicz to the interpretation of the selection rules for the angular momentum quantum number and for polarization in the Zeeman effect. On the assumption of light quanta, this principle led to attributing an angular momentum to the photons +h/2π or −h/2π, according to whether the light was circularly polarized to the right (σ+) or to the left (σ−), natural light being a mixture of the two types of photon.