Paper 3.13: N. Bloembergen, Y. Prior, A.R. Bogdan and M. Dagenais, “Pressure induced extra resonances in four-wave mixing,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 46, 111–114, 1981.
This note contains the first observation of a resonance of a χ (3) response of sodium vapor, when two incident frequencies have a difference corresponding to the fine structure separation in the 3P doublet. The intensity of this resonance increased with increasing pressure of the noble buffer gas. This so-called “collision-induced coherence” signal was initially met by surprise and disbelief from many colleagues. I used the following qualitative reasoning to convince them: There are many pathways, or Feynman diagrams, contributing to a χ (3) process. Sometimes three pathway combinations interfere destructively and yield a zero sum. The introduction of damping destroys the phase coherence which led to the destructive interference. Later papers showed explicitly that in the presence of collisional damping, right- and left-handed Feynman diagrams should be considered for the evolution of a state and its conjugate. My co-authors on this paper were two postdoctoral fellows and a graduate student. Yehaim Prior had obtained his Ph.D. degree at the University of California, Berkeley, working on a magnetic resonance problem with Alex Pines in the chemistry department. He wanted to do some optics work before returning to Israel, and correctly thought that I could judge his potential from his work in magnetic resonance. Prior later became a professor at the Weizmann Institute in Rehovoth, Israel. Our families have kept in touch. Mario Dagenais, a French Canadian, obtained his Ph.D. degree at the University of Rochester, where he worked on photon anti-bunching with Leon Mandel. He became a professor of electrical engineering at the University of Maryland in College Park. Again, we have kept in touch with him and his French wife, who is also a scientist. Andy Bogdan obtained his Ph.D. degree for his role in these pioneering experiments. He has since worked for various industrial research organizations.
This note contains the first observation of a resonance of a χ (3) response of sodium vapor, when two incident frequencies have a difference corresponding to the fine structure separation in the 3P doublet. The intensity of this resonance increased with increasing pressure of the noble buffer gas. This so-called “collision-induced coherence” signal was initially met by surprise and disbelief from many colleagues. I used the following qualitative reasoning to convince them: There are many pathways, or Feynman diagrams, contributing to a χ (3) process. Sometimes three pathway combinations interfere destructively and yield a zero sum. The introduction of damping destroys the phase coherence which led to the destructive interference. Later papers showed explicitly that in the presence of collisional damping, right- and left-handed Feynman diagrams should be considered for the evolution of a state and its conjugate. My co-authors on this paper were two postdoctoral fellows and a graduate student. Yehaim Prior had obtained his Ph.D. degree at the University of California, Berkeley, working on a magnetic resonance problem with Alex Pines in the chemistry department. He wanted to do some optics work before returning to Israel, and correctly thought that I could judge his potential from his work in magnetic resonance. Prior later became a professor at the Weizmann Institute in Rehovoth, Israel. Our families have kept in touch. Mario Dagenais, a French Canadian, obtained his Ph.D. degree at the University of Rochester, where he worked on photon anti-bunching with Leon Mandel. He became a professor of electrical engineering at the University of Maryland in College Park. Again, we have kept in touch with him and his French wife, who is also a scientist. Andy Bogdan obtained his Ph.D. degree for his role in these pioneering experiments. He has since worked for various industrial research organizations.
This note is an extension of the preceding one and deals with a zero-frequency resonance, distinguishable by the four different directions of the four light waves involved. Both theoretical and experimental investigations of collisional induced coherences in sodium vapor as a function of inert buffer gas pressure were quickly refined and reported in two subsequent short communications, “Quantitative characteristics of pressure induced four-wave mixing signals observed with c.w. laser beams,” N. Bloembergen, A.R. Bogdan and M.C. Downer, Phys. Rev. A24 , 623–626, 1981, and “Quantitative characteristics of pressure-induced degenerate frequency resonance in four-wave mixing with c.w. laser beams,” N. Bloembergen, A.R. Bogdan and M.C. Downer, Optics Letters 6 , 348–350, 1981.
Two new associates continued the experimental investigations in sodium vapor with variable inert buffer gas pressure, concentrating on the low frequency resonance corresponding to a raman-type resonance between two Zeeman-sublevels of the electronic ground state and the polarization characteristics of a raman-type transition with vanishing Stokes shift between two degenerate Zeeman levels. The latter effect may be considered as a collision-induced Hanle-effect resonance and is the subject of this communication. Previously, two detailed papers on collision-induced resonances between non-degenerate hyperfine and Zeeman sublevels had been published, “High-resolution studies of collision-induced population grating resonances in optical four-wave mixing in sodium vapor,” (N. Bloembergen and L.J. Rothberg, Phys. Rev. A30 , 2327–2338, 1984) and “High resolution four-wave light-mixing studies of collision-induced coherence in Na vapor,” (N. Bloembergen and L.J. Rothberg, Phys. Rev. A30 , 820–830, 1984). Lewis Rotheberg obtained his Ph.D. degree from Harvard University on the basis of this work. He joined the AT&T Bell Telephone Laboratories, where he works on femtosecond biophysical processes. Ying-hua Zou, a professor of physics at Peking University in Beijing, China, joined our group as a visiting scholar under an exchange program between the American Physical Society and the Chinese Ministry of Education. He continued the detailed study of the collision-induced Hanle resonances. They were written up in a full-length paper, “Collision-enhanced four-wave light mixing in Na vapor,” (N. Bloembergen and Y.H. Zou, Phys. Rev. A33 , 1730–1742, 1986). We visited Y.H. Zou and his wife twice in our travels to China in 1989 and 1994, respectively. I visited his laboratory at the university, and we were also guests in his modest apartment, where the hospitality was inversely proportional to the physical space. In 1994, Professor Zou was our host companion on a five day trip up and down the gorges of the Yang-tse river. He was almost as surprised as we were by the contrast in living conditions between the burgeoning metropolis Beijing and the towns in interior China.
This note announces the first examples of dispersion in a multidimensional frequency space. Independently tunable dye lasers are used with two or three light beams incident on the sample. The intensity generated at the frequency ω 4 − ω 1 + ω 2 − ω 3 shows resonances when ω 1 − ω 3 and ω 2 − ω 3 are resonant with two different raman vibrations, or when ω 1 + ω 2 is near a two-photon transition and ω 1 − ω 3 near a vibrational resonance. The latter situation occurs in CuCl crystal, where two collective excitations are simultaneously enhanced, the Z 3 excitation at the sum frequency ω 1 + ω 2 in the near ultraviolet, and the resonance at w 1 − w 3 of the phonon–polariton in the infrared. Two full-length papers on this subject were published soon afterwards, “Third-order nonlinear optical spectroscopy in CuCl ,” S.D. Kramer and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B14 , 4654–4669, 1976, and “Interference between raman resonances in four-wave difference mixing,” Haim Lotem, R.T. Lynch, Jr. and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B14 , 1748–1754, 1976. Papers 3.9, 3.10, and 3.11 describe early examples of the general features of third-order nonlinear spectroscopy with three incident light beams with independent frequencies, directions of propagation and polarization vectors. At the same time that these developments in condensed matter spectroscopy took place, analogous methods evolved elsewhere in atomic spectroscopy. S.D. Kramer and R.T. Lynch, Jr. were both graduate students, while Haim Lotem was a postdoctoral research fellow from Israel. After obtaining his Ph.D. degree, Steve Kramer joined the Oak Ridge National Laboratory and Bob Lynch joined the IBM development laboratory near San Jose. Steve Kramer now works at the Institute for Defense Analyses near Washington, D.C. Haim Lotem returned to Israel, where he joined the Nuclear Research Facility near Beersheba. Soon after the Lotem family arrived in the United States, their son Zohar was born. Since sadly no one of their immediate family from Israel could be present, I was asked to serve as godparent at the circumcision ceremony in their Brooklyn apartment. I reminded Haim that I was not Jewish but he replied that it did not matter. Just before the ceremony, the rabbi, or mohel, had a talk with me about how I knew the Lotems, etc., and soon asked about the origin of my family name. When he found out the Protestant Christian background of my family, he disqualified me from entering the room where the circumcision would take place, much to the consternation of the anxious parents. A qualified replacement was immediately found in the person of my graduate student, Eli Yablonovitch. He had been born in Poland and raised in Canada where he obtained a Bachelor of Science degree at McGill University in Montreal. He was a confirmed bachelor at the time and he stated that the last circumcision ceremony he had attended was his own. He carried out this extracurricular duty with good humor. We have kept in close touch with the Lotem family. They returned to the United States several times on sabbatical leaves. Eli Yablonovitch and I attended a conference in Israel a few years later. On the El Al overnight flight to Israel, I was woken up by a group of men who were involved in an agitated discussion: they needed a tenth person to form a minion. I informed them that they had woken up a disqualified person and pointed out Eli Yablonovitch to them, who again performed the task without fail.
This note announces the beginning of a systematic investigation of the intensities and the polarization dependence of two-photon spectral lines within the 4f n configurations of rare-earth ions in crystals. The problem is reviewed in Paper 4.6 where more complete references to the pertinent literature and to the historic context are given. Mario Dagenais and Richard Neumann were postdoctoral research fellows. Dagenais became more involved with experiments on collision-induced coherence described in the preceding section. Neumann was a postdoctoral visitor for one year. He came to us from the University of Heidelberg and returned to Germany where he obtained an appointment at the University of Karlsruhe. My graduate student Mike Downer really pursued the subject in depth. In my opinion, he could have obtained two Ph.D. degrees, one for the theoretical part and one for the experimental part of his heavy-weight Ph.D. thesis. Since I did not feel competent to judge the theoretical part, I invited Professor B.R. Judd from Johns Hopkins University to serve on the Ph.D. examining committee. His name appears in the title of this note. Professor John H. van Vleck would have been interested in the subject had he lived a few years longer. Mike Downer became a professor of physics at the University of Texas in Austin where he leads a group in femtosecond nonlinear optics. We have kept in touch over the years.
The terms “three-wave” and “double two-wave mixing” occurring in the title are no longer used. “Three-wave mixing” refers to a four-wave mixing process, based on a third-order linearity, χ (3) , with one incident frequency used twice. “Double two-wave mixing” refers to a cascade process in which second-order nonlinearity χ (2) is used in two separate stages. Already in the late sixties, a CO 2 laser facility had been built in our laboratory. It was used by my graduate student Jim Wynne to measure χ (2) in several III-V semiconductors by second harmonic generation in the far infrared (N. Bloembergen and J.J. Wynne, Phys. Rev. 188 , 1211–1220, 1969). Jim Wynne joined the IBM research laboratories, first in Zurich and then in Yorktown Heights. He was a very good squash player and was a member of the Harvard Squash team; he also started two teams for graduate students. I played on the second team as a substitute a few times. The teacher-student relationship in squash was the reverse of that in physics, but both were amicable. Jim Wynne was coauthor on another paper which describes infrared dispersion of the nonlinear response due to cyclotron resonance between Landau levels in n-InSb, (E. Yablonovitch, N. Bloembergen and J.J. Wynne, Phys. Rev. B3 , 2060–2062, 1971.) Unfortunately, only one note on nonlinear spectroscopy with CO 2 lasers could be included in this volume. It reports for the first time an interference between a third-order and a cascaded lower-order light scattering process. A similar interference was observed in an experiment carried out with a ruby and a dye laser in CuCl (“Interference of third-order light mixing and secondharmonic exciton generation in CuCl ,” S.D. Kramer, F.G. Parsons and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B9 , 1853–1856, 1974).
This paper was presented at a conference in Paris dedicated to the memory of Alfred Kastler. It took place during a cold, snowy week in January 1985. Since Kastler himself had recognized the importance of Hanle's work for his development of optical polarization pumping, I felt it appropriate to review a novel variant on the Hanle effect. I consider this to be my last significant contribution to original physics research. In my talk, I sketched how we had arrived at the collision induced Hanle coherences as a degenerate case of resonant raman scattering. In the Hanle limit of zero magnetic field, it would, however, also be understood as an induced polarization grating of the Na atoms, with a life time limited by diffusion through the buffer gas. I had thus arrived, in a round-about way, at optically pumped polarization in Kastler's original language. Thus I felt like Mr. Jourdan in Molière's play “Le Bourgeois Gentilhomme”, who learned from his language instructor that he had been speaking in prose all his life. The polarization gratings in alkali vapors have become of great practical significance in the cooling of atoms by laser beams. Kastler's successor, Claude Cohen-Tannoudji, and his associates, played a major role in the startling new developments of the past decade which have recently culminated in the observation of Bose–Einstein condensation of atoms in momentum space. A few years after this conference, in 1987, I had the pleasure of meeting Professor Hanle himself, then almost ninety years of age. He was still keenly interested in the novel variations on his theme. I was glad to give him some of our reprints. The occasion was a dinner at the home of his daughter, who is married to Professor Scharfmann at the University of Giessen, Germany, where I spoke at a physics colloquium. I also knew Hanle's son, Helmut, very well, as he has an executive function in the Alexander von Humboldt foundation. I was a senior Humboldt fellow twice, in 1980 and in 1987, respectively. Both times, my principal host was Herbert Walther, one of the directors of the Max Planck Institute for Quantum Optics in Garching. I have always treasured my regular visits and interactions with many colleagues at the leading institutions on laser spectroscopy in the European continent, with centers of gravity in Munich and Paris, respectively.