Paper 3.11: E. Yablonovitch, C. Flytzanis and N. Bloembergen, “Anistropic interference of three-wave and double two-wave frequency mixing in GaAs ,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 29, 865–868, 1972.
The terms “three-wave” and “double two-wave mixing” occurring in the title are no longer used. “Three-wave mixing” refers to a four-wave mixing process, based on a third-order linearity, χ (3) , with one incident frequency used twice. “Double two-wave mixing” refers to a cascade process in which second-order nonlinearity χ (2) is used in two separate stages. Already in the late sixties, a CO 2 laser facility had been built in our laboratory. It was used by my graduate student Jim Wynne to measure χ (2) in several III-V semiconductors by second harmonic generation in the far infrared (N. Bloembergen and J.J. Wynne, Phys. Rev. 188 , 1211–1220, 1969). Jim Wynne joined the IBM research laboratories, first in Zurich and then in Yorktown Heights. He was a very good squash player and was a member of the Harvard Squash team; he also started two teams for graduate students. I played on the second team as a substitute a few times. The teacher-student relationship in squash was the reverse of that in physics, but both were amicable. Jim Wynne was coauthor on another paper which describes infrared dispersion of the nonlinear response due to cyclotron resonance between Landau levels in n-InSb, (E. Yablonovitch, N. Bloembergen and J.J. Wynne, Phys. Rev. B3 , 2060–2062, 1971.) Unfortunately, only one note on nonlinear spectroscopy with CO 2 lasers could be included in this volume. It reports for the first time an interference between a third-order and a cascaded lower-order light scattering process. A similar interference was observed in an experiment carried out with a ruby and a dye laser in CuCl (“Interference of third-order light mixing and secondharmonic exciton generation in CuCl ,” S.D. Kramer, F.G. Parsons and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B9 , 1853–1856, 1974).
The terms “three-wave” and “double two-wave mixing” occurring in the title are no longer used. “Three-wave mixing” refers to a four-wave mixing process, based on a third-order linearity, χ (3) , with one incident frequency used twice. “Double two-wave mixing” refers to a cascade process in which second-order nonlinearity χ (2) is used in two separate stages. Already in the late sixties, a CO 2 laser facility had been built in our laboratory. It was used by my graduate student Jim Wynne to measure χ (2) in several III-V semiconductors by second harmonic generation in the far infrared (N. Bloembergen and J.J. Wynne, Phys. Rev. 188 , 1211–1220, 1969). Jim Wynne joined the IBM research laboratories, first in Zurich and then in Yorktown Heights. He was a very good squash player and was a member of the Harvard Squash team; he also started two teams for graduate students. I played on the second team as a substitute a few times. The teacher-student relationship in squash was the reverse of that in physics, but both were amicable. Jim Wynne was coauthor on another paper which describes infrared dispersion of the nonlinear response due to cyclotron resonance between Landau levels in n-InSb, (E. Yablonovitch, N. Bloembergen and J.J. Wynne, Phys. Rev. B3 , 2060–2062, 1971.) Unfortunately, only one note on nonlinear spectroscopy with CO 2 lasers could be included in this volume. It reports for the first time an interference between a third-order and a cascaded lower-order light scattering process. A similar interference was observed in an experiment carried out with a ruby and a dye laser in CuCl (“Interference of third-order light mixing and secondharmonic exciton generation in CuCl ,” S.D. Kramer, F.G. Parsons and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B9 , 1853–1856, 1974).
Dye lasers presented another technique which obviously would be very valuable for nonlinear optics research. In 1971, we had started building our own dye lasers, pumped either by a frequency doubled Nd-Glass laser or a nitrogen gas discharge laser. This paper describes the first use of the dye lasers to condensed matter spectroscopy. My work in the Division of Applied Sciences at Harvard University had always been focused primarily on solid state physics problems, while colleagues in the physics and chemistry departments concentrated their efforts on atomic and molecular spectroscopy. Marc Levenson had obtained his Ph.D. degree at Stanford University working with Arthur L. Schawlow. He is a highly motivated, enthusiastic worker with restless energy. After leaving Harvard, he became a professor of physics at the University of Southern California; he then joined the IBM research laboratories in San Jose and Almaden. More recently, he carried out research at a small private company and at the University of Colorado. With S.S. Kano, he is the author of a well-known textbook, Nonlinear Laser Spectroscopy , Academic Press, San Diego, 1988. I am pleased that this book is based on work he started at Harvard. Chris Flytzanis joined us after having obtained his Ph.D. degree in Paris. He wrote some extensive theoretical reviews on the calculation of nonlinear susceptibilities. I was a co-author on one of these, “Infrared dispersion of third-order susceptibilities in dielectrics,” N. Bloembergen and C. Flytzanis, Progress in Quantum Electronics , Vol. 4, Part 3, edited by J.H. Sanders and S. Stenholm, Pergamon, New York, 1976, pp. 271–300. Flytzanis returned to the Ecole Polytechnique near Paris, where he succeeded Jacques Ducuing as the director of the group on nonlinear optics. We developed the techniques for dispersion and polarization spectroscopy in condensed matter, further described in the following references, “Dispersion of nonlinear optical susceptibility tensor in centrosymmetric media,” N. Bloembergen and M.D. Levenson, Phys. Rev. B10 , 4446–4463, 1974, and “Dispersion of nonlinear optical susceptibilities of organic liquids and solutions,” N. Bloembergen and M.D. Levenson, J. Chem. Phys. 60 , 1323–1327, 1974.
This note announces the first examples of dispersion in a multidimensional frequency space. Independently tunable dye lasers are used with two or three light beams incident on the sample. The intensity generated at the frequency ω 4 − ω 1 + ω 2 − ω 3 shows resonances when ω 1 − ω 3 and ω 2 − ω 3 are resonant with two different raman vibrations, or when ω 1 + ω 2 is near a two-photon transition and ω 1 − ω 3 near a vibrational resonance. The latter situation occurs in CuCl crystal, where two collective excitations are simultaneously enhanced, the Z 3 excitation at the sum frequency ω 1 + ω 2 in the near ultraviolet, and the resonance at w 1 − w 3 of the phonon–polariton in the infrared. Two full-length papers on this subject were published soon afterwards, “Third-order nonlinear optical spectroscopy in CuCl ,” S.D. Kramer and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B14 , 4654–4669, 1976, and “Interference between raman resonances in four-wave difference mixing,” Haim Lotem, R.T. Lynch, Jr. and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B14 , 1748–1754, 1976. Papers 3.9, 3.10, and 3.11 describe early examples of the general features of third-order nonlinear spectroscopy with three incident light beams with independent frequencies, directions of propagation and polarization vectors. At the same time that these developments in condensed matter spectroscopy took place, analogous methods evolved elsewhere in atomic spectroscopy. S.D. Kramer and R.T. Lynch, Jr. were both graduate students, while Haim Lotem was a postdoctoral research fellow from Israel. After obtaining his Ph.D. degree, Steve Kramer joined the Oak Ridge National Laboratory and Bob Lynch joined the IBM development laboratory near San Jose. Steve Kramer now works at the Institute for Defense Analyses near Washington, D.C. Haim Lotem returned to Israel, where he joined the Nuclear Research Facility near Beersheba. Soon after the Lotem family arrived in the United States, their son Zohar was born. Since sadly no one of their immediate family from Israel could be present, I was asked to serve as godparent at the circumcision ceremony in their Brooklyn apartment. I reminded Haim that I was not Jewish but he replied that it did not matter. Just before the ceremony, the rabbi, or mohel, had a talk with me about how I knew the Lotems, etc., and soon asked about the origin of my family name. When he found out the Protestant Christian background of my family, he disqualified me from entering the room where the circumcision would take place, much to the consternation of the anxious parents. A qualified replacement was immediately found in the person of my graduate student, Eli Yablonovitch. He had been born in Poland and raised in Canada where he obtained a Bachelor of Science degree at McGill University in Montreal. He was a confirmed bachelor at the time and he stated that the last circumcision ceremony he had attended was his own. He carried out this extracurricular duty with good humor. We have kept in close touch with the Lotem family. They returned to the United States several times on sabbatical leaves. Eli Yablonovitch and I attended a conference in Israel a few years later. On the El Al overnight flight to Israel, I was woken up by a group of men who were involved in an agitated discussion: they needed a tenth person to form a minion. I informed them that they had woken up a disqualified person and pointed out Eli Yablonovitch to them, who again performed the task without fail.
The generation of the combination frequency $2{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}$ in CuCl by two incident waves, at frequencies ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}$ and ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}$, respectively, is measured as a function of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}$. When $2{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}$ equals the frequency of the first longitudinal-exciton resonance, a resonant dispersive behavior in the production of the intensity at $2{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{2}$ is observed.
In the introduction to this section, the role of Lee R. Wilcox was mentioned as the one who called our attention to Franken's paper, of which he had received a preprint before its publication. Lee Wilcox had already accepted a teaching position at the American University in Beirut, Lebanon, and he did not stay as a member of our study group. He had told us that he did not consider the United States a safe place to live as the cold war confrontation with the Soviet Union reached its peak, threatening mutually assured destruction. Fortunately, he later returned to the United States before the conflagration in Lebanon started. He had a successful career as a professor of physics at the University of New York in Stony Brook until his premature death in 1995. I convinced John Armstrong to stay on at Harvard as a postdoctoral fellow. He had just received a Ph.D. degree with George B. Benedek on an experimental investigation of nuclear magnetic resonance at high pressures and was eager to join the emerging activity in optics. Jacques Ducuing had recently arrived from Paris for advanced graduate studies. He was on leave from the Campagnie Général de Té1égraphie sans Fils in Orsay. I assume that his original intent was to work on microwave masers and was glad he agreed to join our optics team instead. Peter S. Pershan had done his Ph.D. thesis work with me on cross -relaxation effects between nuclear spin systems in lithium fluoride. He had already stayed on as a postdoc for several years, involved not only with ongoing experiments in magnetic resonance, but also with microwave modulation of light. He was about to become an assistant professor and was keen on participating in the emerging field of nonlinear optics. I was fortunate to have these three young, extremely capable coworkers, who all continued on to have very successful scientific careers. John Armstrong joined the IBM research laboratories in Yorktown Heights, New York. He rose through the ranks to become vice-president for Research and Development for the IBM Corporation. Jacques Ducuing became a professor of physics at the Ecole Polytechnique in France, and later served as Director-General of the CNRS (Centre Nationale des Récherches Scientifiques) and as Chief Scientist of NATO in Brussels. Peter Pershan stayed on at Harvard University as Gordon McKay Professor of Applied Physics. In the summer and fall of 1961, we had regularly scheduled weekly group meetings to discuss our progress and to coordinate our efforts. The pace was so hectic that we had informal one-on-one discussions almost daily. I was well aware from lectures I had followed from Professor Leon Rosenfeld in Utrecht during World War II and from his booklet, Electron Physics, published in 1951, that electromagnetism is based on the microscopic Maxwell's equation in vacuum, and that the material is represented by moving charges, which are acted upon with Lorentz -type forces by the fields. The moving charges in turn serve as sources for these fields. I was also familiar with the relationship between the microscopic field of the vacuum and the macroscopic fields in media which occur in Maxwell's equations. I had emphasized these concepts in intermediate courses on electromagnetism I taught at Harvard. I always cautioned students that the engineering convention of introducing electric and magnetic permeabilities for the vacuum obscures the basic physics of the interaction between fields and matter. Thus, our starting point was that nonlinear polarizations produced by nonlineartities in the constitutive relations served as additional sources in Maxwell's equations. These nonlinearities are expressed in terms of second and third order nonlinear susceptibilities which could be calculated by higher order quantum mechanical perturbation theory. This procedure leads naturally to sets of coupled electromagnetic wave equations. General solutions were developed. My young associates were much more adept in carrying through the rather lengthy, detailed mathematical calculations than I was. We discovered with hindsight that the propagation of microwaves in guided structures, loaded periodically with nonlinear materials, had led to similar results. We also obtained Manley-Rowe relations and other integrals. In Sec. VIII of this paper, phase correction schemes for efficient harmonic generation in media with cubic media are discussed. I took out a patent on a method which became known as quasi-phase-matching. It is now widely used in periodically modulated optical wave guide geometries. Our work was supported by the Joint Services Electronics Program from the US. Department of Defense. I never wrote a formal proposal that our funding for magnetic resonance and masers in 1961 would be spent on work in optics. We reported our activity regularly in quarterly progress reports. Preprints of our work were widely distributed as JSEP Cruft Laboratory Technical Report 358 in March 1962. This paper was later designated as a “Citation Classic”. The entry in Current Contents , Volume 22, No. 6, February 11, 1991, is reproduced here to complement this commentary.
The general theory presented in papers 1.3 and 1.4 for the nonlinear susceptibilities in absorbing media show that these quantities are complex. This paper describes the first measurement of the phase of the complex quantity χ (2) . The real and imaginary are obtained from this phase and the amplitude, which is derived from the second harmonic intensity. The imaginary part is interpreted in paper 1.3 as an interference of one- and two-photon transitions between the same initial and final states. Richard Chang obtained his Ph.D. degree at Harvard on the work described in this and the following three papers. He joined the faculty at Yale University where he is a Professor of Applied Physics. Again, we have kept in touch with him and his wife up to the present. Lest the reader get the mistaken impression that all of our experimental work was limited to exploring reflections from absorbing media, one early contribution on the nonlinear susceptibility tensor of a transparent KDP crystal should be mentioned here. The temperature dependence of this tensor in the vicinity of the ferroelectric phase transition is described in “Temperature dependence of optical harmonic generation in KH2PO4 ferro-electrics” (J.P. van der Ziel and N. Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. 135 , A 1662–A1669, 1964). Jan van der Ziel, the son of fellow Dutch immigrant A. van der Ziel, an expert in electronic noise processes, went on to a successful research career in quantum electronics. After several decades at the Bell Telephone Research Laboratories, he now holds a Distinguished Chair in Electrical Engineering at the University of Texas in Dallas.
This note is an extension of the preceding one and deals with a zero-frequency resonance, distinguishable by the four different directions of the four light waves involved. Both theoretical and experimental investigations of collisional induced coherences in sodium vapor as a function of inert buffer gas pressure were quickly refined and reported in two subsequent short communications, “Quantitative characteristics of pressure induced four-wave mixing signals observed with c.w. laser beams,” N. Bloembergen, A.R. Bogdan and M.C. Downer, Phys. Rev. A24 , 623–626, 1981, and “Quantitative characteristics of pressure-induced degenerate frequency resonance in four-wave mixing with c.w. laser beams,” N. Bloembergen, A.R. Bogdan and M.C. Downer, Optics Letters 6 , 348–350, 1981.