Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

States and effects

Teiko Heinosaari, Mário Ziman

Published Dec 15, 2011• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the main purposes of a physical theory is to describe and predict events observed in physical experiments. In this chapter we introduce the key physical concepts used in the description of quantum experiments and present their mathematical formalization as Hilbert space operators. Duality of states and effects Fundamental in quantum theory is the concept of a state, which is usually understood as a description of an ensemble of similarly prepared systems. An effect , on the other hand, is a measurement apparatus that produces either ‘yes’ or ‘no’ as an outcome. The concept of an effect was coined by Ludwig [96] and made popular by Kraus [89]. The duality of states and effects means, essentially, that when a state and an effect are specified we can calculate a probability distribution. This can be compared with the outcomes of real experiments, and it gives a physical meaning to the mathematical Hilbert space machinery. Basic statistical framework A basic situation in physics is the following: we have an object system under investigation, and we are trying to learn something about it by doing an experiment. As a result, a measurement outcome is registered. A statistical theory, such as quantum theory, does not in general predict which individual outcomes will occur in any particular measurement; it merely predicts their probabilities of occurrence. Hence, we take the output of an experiment (which consists of many measurement runs) to be a probability distribution on a set Ω of the possible measurement outcomes.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9781139031103.004

Related papers

Structure of Physical Theories

K. Kong Wan

This introductory chapter sets out a general structure of physical theories which is applicable to both classical and quantum mechanics. We start with measurable properties of a given physical system, be it classical or quantum. These properties are called observables . We then introduce a definition of the state of a physical system in terms of measured values of a sufficiently large set of observables. A theory to describe the system should consists of four basic components: Basic mathematical framework This comprises a set of elements endowed with some specific mathematical structure and properties. In mathematics such a set is generally known as a space . Description of states States are described by elements of the space in the chosen mathematical framework. For this reason the space is called the state space of the system. Description of observables Observables are to be described by quantities defined on the state space. The description should yield all possible values of observables. The relationship between observables and states should be explicitly stated. The following two cases are of particular interest: 2 For a deterministic theory like classical mechanics a state should determine the values of all observables. For a probabilistic theory like quantum mechanics a state should determine the probability distribution of the values of all observables. Description of time evolution (dynamics).

•Aug 27, 2020•6 citations

Quantum Probability

Heinz‐Peter Breuer, Francesco Petruccione

Abstract This chapter develops the fundamental notions and concepts of the probabilistic and statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. It begins with a brief review of the mathematical structure given by a Hilbert space of state vectors and an algebra of observables represented by selfadjoint operators. Special emphasis is laid on the connection between the spectral representation of a selfadjoint operator and a corresponding random variable that describes the possible measurement outcomes. The chapter further introduces the concepts of a composite quantum system, of the reduced density matrix, and of entangled quantum states. A section on quantum entropies is included, as well as the mathematical formulation of the generalized theory of quantum measurements in terms of completely positive quantum operations and effects.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 25, 2007•0 citations

Probability in Hilbert Space

Jochen Rau

This chapter introduces the mathematical framework, basic rules, and some key results of quantum theory. After a succinct overview of linear algebra and an introduction to complex Hilbert space, it investigates the correspondence between subspaces of Hilbert space and propositions, their logical structure, and how the pertinent probabilities are calculated. It discusses the mathematical representation of states, observables, and transformations, as well as the rules for calculating expectation values and uncertainties, and for updating states after a measurement. Particular attention is paid to two-level systems, or ‘qubits’, and the connection is made with experimental evidence about binary measurements. The properties of composite systems are discussed in detail, notably the phenomenon of entanglement. The chapter concludes with an investigation of conceptual issues regarding realism, non-contextuality, and locality, as well as the classical limit.

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 27, 2021•0 citations

What Does the Operator Algebra of Quantum Statistics Tell Us about the Objective Causes of Observable Effects?

Holger F. Hofmann

Quantum physics can only make statistical predictions about possible measurement outcomes, and these predictions originate from an operator algebra that is fundamentally different from the conventional definition of probability as a subjective lack of information regarding the physical reality of the system. In the present paper, I explore how the operator formalism accommodates the vast number of possible states and measurements by characterizing its essential function as a description of causality relations between initial conditions and subsequent observations. It is shown that any complete description of causality must involve non-positive statistical elements that cannot be associated with any directly observable effects. The necessity of non-positive elements is demonstrated by the uniquely defined mathematical description of ideal correlations which explains the physics of maximally entangled states, quantum teleportation and quantum cloning. The operator formalism thus modifies the concept of causality by providing a universally valid description of deterministic relations between initial states and subsequent observations that cannot be expressed in terms of directly observable measurement outcomes. Instead, the identifiable elements of causality are necessarily non-positive and hence unobservable. The validity of the operator algebra therefore indicates that a consistent explanation of the various uncertainty limited phenomena associated with physical objects is only possible if we learn to accept the fact that the elements of causality cannot be reconciled with a continuation of observable reality in the physical object.

arXiv:2005.03822•Entropy•Jun 9, 2020•5 citations

Are Quantum States Ontic or Epistemic? A Definitive Answer. English version.

Rudolf Lierenfeldt

Even after a hundred years of quantum theory, the true meaning of the quantum state has not yet been clearly understood. Does a pure quantum state, described by a wave function φ, represent a real physical quantity, comparable to position and momentum in classical mechanics, or does it, even as a pure state, only have a statistical significance, similar to a probability distribution? In this paper, we show that there is no contradiction between these two interpretations. Two concepts must be distinguished here: on the one hand, physical objects, which have a finite lifetime, and on the other hand, subsystems (i.e., tensor factors) of the Hilbert space of the universe. A complete description of an object at a point in time t is given by a linear subspace A of its Hilbert space, which, in the case of dim A = 1, can be specified by a wave function φ as A = [φ]. However, for every subsystem Q, for each point in time t, and for every condition B, the conditional quantum state W = W(Q,t|B) can be defined as a statistical operator on the Hilbert space of Q. Using W, certain (conditional) probabilities can be calculated. In the case of rank W = 1, the operator W can also be specified by a wave function φ, namely as W = |φ><φ|. It is the subsystems of the Hilbert space that play the role of "quantum systems" in the Copenhagen formalism, and the quantum states defined for them behave exactly as described by this formalism. If a wave function φ represents the description of a (quantum) object, then we are dealing with a real physical property, that is, φ plays an "ontic" role. However, if φ represents a quantum state, then its role is merely "statistical". If, in this case, condition B corresponds to the knowledge of a subject, φ plays an "epistemic" role. Additional Remarks The reasoning in this paper is largely based on a new systematic approach to solving the interpretation problem of quantum theory, which was originally published in 2018 (in German) under the title "Realistische Quantentheorie". A comprehensive account of this approach (in English) was published in February 2026 under the title "Realistic Quantum Theory: Solving the Interpretation Problem". It is available in the Zenodo repository (zenodo.18644694, see link below under "Related works" / "References"). The present document provides an English version of an earlier paper in German under the same title, which is also available in the Zenodo repository (zenodo.10694813, see link below).

•May 7, 2026•0 citations

The Art and Science of Experimentation in Quantum Physics

Arkady Plotnitsky, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Taking its historical point of departure in Heisenberg’s work, this article offers a view of quantum mechanics as, arguably, the first truly experimental and truly mathematical physical theory, that is, a theory concerned with experimenting with nature and mathematics alike. It is truly experimental because it is not, as in classical physics, merely the independent behavior of the system considered, in other words, what happens in any event, that we track, but what kind of experiments we perform that defines what happens. By the same token, the theory is also truly mathematical because, at least in the interpretation adopted here, its mathematical formalism does not stand in the service of a mathematical description of (quantum) physical processes in space and time in the way the formalism of classical physics does, but is only used to predict the outcomes of relevant experiments. It also follows that quantum theories experiment more freely with mathematics itself, since we invent predictive mathematical schemes, rather than proceed by refining mathematically our phenomenal representations of nature, which process constrains us in classical mechanics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations
One of the main purposes of a physical theory is to describe and predict events observed in physical experiments. In this chapter we introduce the key physical concepts used in the description of quantum experiments and present their mathematical formalization as Hilbert space operators. Duality of states and effects Fundamental in quantum theory is the concept of a state, which is usually understood as a description of an ensemble of similarly prepared systems. An effect , on the other hand, is a measurement apparatus that produces either ‘yes’ or ‘no’ as an outcome. The concept of an effect was coined by Ludwig [96] and made popular by Kraus [89]. The duality of states and effects means, essentially, that when a state and an effect are specified we can calculate a probability distribution. This can be compared with the outcomes of real experiments, and it gives a physical meaning to the mathematical Hilbert space machinery. Basic statistical framework A basic situation in physics is the following: we have an object system under investigation, and we are trying to learn something about it by doing an experiment. As a result, a measurement outcome is registered. A statistical theory, such as quantum theory, does not in general predict which individual outcomes will occur in any particular measurement; it merely predicts their probabilities of occurrence. Hence, we take the output of an experiment (which consists of many measurement runs) to be a probability distribution on a set Ω of the possible measurement outcomes.
This introductory chapter sets out a general structure of physical theories which is applicable to both classical and quantum mechanics. We start with measurable properties of a given physical system, be it classical or quantum. These properties are called observables . We then introduce a definition of the state of a physical system in terms of measured values of a sufficiently large set of observables. A theory to describe the system should consists of four basic components: Basic mathematical framework This comprises a set of elements endowed with some specific mathematical structure and properties. In mathematics such a set is generally known as a space . Description of states States are described by elements of the space in the chosen mathematical framework. For this reason the space is called the state space of the system. Description of observables Observables are to be described by quantities defined on the state space. The description should yield all possible values of observables. The relationship between observables and states should be explicitly stated. The following two cases are of particular interest: 2 For a deterministic theory like classical mechanics a state should determine the values of all observables. For a probabilistic theory like quantum mechanics a state should determine the probability distribution of the values of all observables. Description of time evolution (dynamics).
Abstract This chapter develops the fundamental notions and concepts of the probabilistic and statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. It begins with a brief review of the mathematical structure given by a Hilbert space of state vectors and an algebra of observables represented by selfadjoint operators. Special emphasis is laid on the connection between the spectral representation of a selfadjoint operator and a corresponding random variable that describes the possible measurement outcomes. The chapter further introduces the concepts of a composite quantum system, of the reduced density matrix, and of entangled quantum states. A section on quantum entropies is included, as well as the mathematical formulation of the generalized theory of quantum measurements in terms of completely positive quantum operations and effects.
This chapter introduces the mathematical framework, basic rules, and some key results of quantum theory. After a succinct overview of linear algebra and an introduction to complex Hilbert space, it investigates the correspondence between subspaces of Hilbert space and propositions, their logical structure, and how the pertinent probabilities are calculated. It discusses the mathematical representation of states, observables, and transformations, as well as the rules for calculating expectation values and uncertainties, and for updating states after a measurement. Particular attention is paid to two-level systems, or ‘qubits’, and the connection is made with experimental evidence about binary measurements. The properties of composite systems are discussed in detail, notably the phenomenon of entanglement. The chapter concludes with an investigation of conceptual issues regarding realism, non-contextuality, and locality, as well as the classical limit.
Quantum physics can only make statistical predictions about possible measurement outcomes, and these predictions originate from an operator algebra that is fundamentally different from the conventional definition of probability as a subjective lack of information regarding the physical reality of the system. In the present paper, I explore how the operator formalism accommodates the vast number of possible states and measurements by characterizing its essential function as a description of causality relations between initial conditions and subsequent observations. It is shown that any complete description of causality must involve non-positive statistical elements that cannot be associated with any directly observable effects. The necessity of non-positive elements is demonstrated by the uniquely defined mathematical description of ideal correlations which explains the physics of maximally entangled states, quantum teleportation and quantum cloning. The operator formalism thus modifies the concept of causality by providing a universally valid description of deterministic relations between initial states and subsequent observations that cannot be expressed in terms of directly observable measurement outcomes. Instead, the identifiable elements of causality are necessarily non-positive and hence unobservable. The validity of the operator algebra therefore indicates that a consistent explanation of the various uncertainty limited phenomena associated with physical objects is only possible if we learn to accept the fact that the elements of causality cannot be reconciled with a continuation of observable reality in the physical object.
Even after a hundred years of quantum theory, the true meaning of the quantum state has not yet been clearly understood. Does a pure quantum state, described by a wave function φ, represent a real physical quantity, comparable to position and momentum in classical mechanics, or does it, even as a pure state, only have a statistical significance, similar to a probability distribution? In this paper, we show that there is no contradiction between these two interpretations. Two concepts must be distinguished here: on the one hand, physical objects, which have a finite lifetime, and on the other hand, subsystems (i.e., tensor factors) of the Hilbert space of the universe. A complete description of an object at a point in time t is given by a linear subspace A of its Hilbert space, which, in the case of dim A = 1, can be specified by a wave function φ as A = [φ]. However, for every subsystem Q, for each point in time t, and for every condition B, the conditional quantum state W = W(Q,t|B) can be defined as a statistical operator on the Hilbert space of Q. Using W, certain (conditional) probabilities can be calculated. In the case of rank W = 1, the operator W can also be specified by a wave function φ, namely as W = |φ><φ|. It is the subsystems of the Hilbert space that play the role of "quantum systems" in the Copenhagen formalism, and the quantum states defined for them behave exactly as described by this formalism. If a wave function φ represents the description of a (quantum) object, then we are dealing with a real physical property, that is, φ plays an "ontic" role. However, if φ represents a quantum state, then its role is merely "statistical". If, in this case, condition B corresponds to the knowledge of a subject, φ plays an "epistemic" role. Additional Remarks The reasoning in this paper is largely based on a new systematic approach to solving the interpretation problem of quantum theory, which was originally published in 2018 (in German) under the title "Realistische Quantentheorie". A comprehensive account of this approach (in English) was published in February 2026 under the title "Realistic Quantum Theory: Solving the Interpretation Problem". It is available in the Zenodo repository (zenodo.18644694, see link below under "Related works" / "References"). The present document provides an English version of an earlier paper in German under the same title, which is also available in the Zenodo repository (zenodo.10694813, see link below).
Taking its historical point of departure in Heisenberg’s work, this article offers a view of quantum mechanics as, arguably, the first truly experimental and truly mathematical physical theory, that is, a theory concerned with experimenting with nature and mathematics alike. It is truly experimental because it is not, as in classical physics, merely the independent behavior of the system considered, in other words, what happens in any event, that we track, but what kind of experiments we perform that defines what happens. By the same token, the theory is also truly mathematical because, at least in the interpretation adopted here, its mathematical formalism does not stand in the service of a mathematical description of (quantum) physical processes in space and time in the way the formalism of classical physics does, but is only used to predict the outcomes of relevant experiments. It also follows that quantum theories experiment more freely with mathematics itself, since we invent predictive mathematical schemes, rather than proceed by refining mathematically our phenomenal representations of nature, which process constrains us in classical mechanics.