Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Violation of the Born Rule: Implications for Macroscopic Fields

Ruth E. Kastner

Published Jun 25, 2016• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

It is shown that violation of the Born Rule leads to a breakdown of the correspondence between the quantum electromagnetic field and its classical counterpart. Specifically, the relationship of the quantum coherent state to the classical electromagnetic field turns out to imply that if the Born Rule were violated, this could result in apparent deviations from the energy conservation law applying to the field and its sources (Poynting's Theorem). The result, which is fully general and independent of interpretations of quantum theory, suggests that the Born Rule is just as fundamental a law of Nature as are the field conservation laws.

Related papers

Violation of the Born Rule: Implications for the Classical Electromagnetic Field

Ruth E. Kastner

It is shown that violation of the Born Rule leads to a breakdown of the correspondence between the quantum electromagnetic field and its classical counterpart. Specifically, the relationship of the quantum coherent state to the classical electromagnetic field turns out to imply that if the Born Rule were violated, this could result in apparent deviations from the energy conservation law applying to the field and its sources (Poynting's Theorem). The result suggests that the Born Rule is just as fundamental a law of Nature as are the conservation laws.

arXiv:1603.05301•Mar 16, 2016•3 citations

Observations of wavefunction collapse and the retrospective application of the Born rule

Sivapalan Chelvaniththilan

In this paper I present a thought experiment that gives different results depending on whether or not the wavefunction collapses. Since the wavefunction does not obey the Schrodinger equation during the collapse, conservation laws are violated. This is the reason why the results are different. Quantities that are conserved if the wavefunction does not collapse might change if it does. I also show that using the Born Rule to derive probabilities of states before a measurement given the state after it (rather than the other way round as it is usually used) leads to the conclusion that the memories that an observer has about making measurements of quantum systems have a significant probability of being false memories.

arXiv:2010.15101•Oct 27, 2020•0 citations

Mathematics and physics of consistency of the Born rule with normal probability distribution

Alexey A. Kryukov

Abstract Newtonian and Scrödinger dynamics can be formulated in a physically meaningful way within the same Hilbert space framework. The resulting unexpected relation between classical and quantum motions goes beyond the results provided by the Ehrenfest theorem. The normal probability distribution and the Born rule turn out to be related. A dynamical mechanism responsible for the latter formula is proposed and applied to measurements of macroscopic and microscopic systems.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Sep 1, 2019•2 citations

Does Born Rule Imply Unitarity of Time Evolution in Quantum Mechanics?

Ali Mostafazadeh

The Born rule for computing probabilities of the outcomes of measurements is an indispensable ingredient of quantum mechanics. The standard textbook description of this rule gives the impression that it implies the unitarity of time evolution. This view relies on the argument that unless the dynamics is unitary, the probabilities of finding all possible outcomes of a measurement do not add up to 1, i.e., the total probability is not conserved. We show that this argument is flawed, and that the general expression for the Born rule ensures the conservation of total probabilities even when the dynamics of a quantum system is not unitary. This applies to the dynamics of ensembles of quantum systems in both pure and mixed states. We discuss the status of the local conservation of probabilities and the arguments against the plausibility of non-unitary time evolutions that are based on the identification of the Hamiltonian operator with the energy observable.

quant-pharXiv:2607.07560•Jul 9, 2026•1 citation

Born Rule: Quantum Probability as Classical Probability

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

Abstract I provide a simple derivation of the Born rule as giving a classical probability, that is, the ratio of the measure of favorable states of the system to the measure of its total possible states. In classical systems, the probability is due to the fact that the same macrostate can be realized in different ways as a microstate. Despite the radical differences between quantum and classical systems, I show that the same can be applied to quantum systems, and the result is the Born rule. This works only if the basis is continuous (an eigenbasis of observables with continuous spectra), but all known physically realistic measurements involve a continuous basis (the position basis). The continuous basis is not unique, and for subsystems it depends on the observable. But for the entire universe, there are continuous bases that give the Born rule for all measurements, because all measurements reduce to distinguishing macroscopic pointer states, and macroscopic observations commute. This allows for the possibility of a unique ontic basis for the entire universe. In the wavefunctional formulation, the basis can be chosen to consist of classical field configurations, and the coefficients $$\Psi [\phi ]$$ Ψ [ ϕ ] can be made real by absorbing them into a global U(1) gauge. For the many-worlds interpretation, this result gives the Born rule from micro-branch counting.

arXiv:2209.08621•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Apr 25, 2025•16 citations

On the Interpretation of Quantum Physics: Energy Transfer Between Field and Matter According to the “Pairwise Interference Model” and a Quantum-Physical Measurement Problem

Wolfgang Tiefenbrunner

In classical electrodynamic wave theory, the intensity of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the electric field; in quantum theory, according to the conventional interpretation, the probability of detecting a light particle (and hence, ultimately, the photon density) is given by the square of the probability amplitude (as prescribed by the Born rule, which itself lacks a deeper theoretical justification). A mathematical formulation equivalent to the path integral provides, within the framework of the Pairwise Interference Model (PIMOQ), an alternative interpretation that is mutually exclusive with the conventional one. According to this interpretation, quantum physics, within the scope considered here, describes the local (at the detector), intrinsically bidirectional, quantised energy transfer between field and matter (apart from quantisation this is in direct analogy with classical physics). In the case of constructive interference, this transfer is unidirectional, occurring exclusively from matter to the field, whereas in the case of destructive interference the two opposing energy fluxes are equal in magnitude. However, it appears that in the macroscopic world only the net balance of these two antagonistic and complementary fluxes is experimentally observable, whereas the individual contributions cannot be measured independently. This limitation is referred to here as a quantum-physical measurement problem. From this perspective, quantum physics constitutes a subdiscipline of thermodynamics with a correspondingly limited domain of applicability. Although the principle discussed is as fundamental as, for example, the principle of conservation of energy, this does not imply that the underlying physical processes must necessarily be identical in every situation in which the principle applies. This interpretation is further elaborated through a discussion of interference experiments employing coherent and incoherent light sources, as well as the generation of coherent light in the laser.

•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations
It is shown that violation of the Born Rule leads to a breakdown of the correspondence between the quantum electromagnetic field and its classical counterpart. Specifically, the relationship of the quantum coherent state to the classical electromagnetic field turns out to imply that if the Born Rule were violated, this could result in apparent deviations from the energy conservation law applying to the field and its sources (Poynting's Theorem). The result, which is fully general and independent of interpretations of quantum theory, suggests that the Born Rule is just as fundamental a law of Nature as are the field conservation laws.
It is shown that violation of the Born Rule leads to a breakdown of the correspondence between the quantum electromagnetic field and its classical counterpart. Specifically, the relationship of the quantum coherent state to the classical electromagnetic field turns out to imply that if the Born Rule were violated, this could result in apparent deviations from the energy conservation law applying to the field and its sources (Poynting's Theorem). The result suggests that the Born Rule is just as fundamental a law of Nature as are the conservation laws.
In this paper I present a thought experiment that gives different results depending on whether or not the wavefunction collapses. Since the wavefunction does not obey the Schrodinger equation during the collapse, conservation laws are violated. This is the reason why the results are different. Quantities that are conserved if the wavefunction does not collapse might change if it does. I also show that using the Born Rule to derive probabilities of states before a measurement given the state after it (rather than the other way round as it is usually used) leads to the conclusion that the memories that an observer has about making measurements of quantum systems have a significant probability of being false memories.
The Born rule for computing probabilities of the outcomes of measurements is an indispensable ingredient of quantum mechanics. The standard textbook description of this rule gives the impression that it implies the unitarity of time evolution. This view relies on the argument that unless the dynamics is unitary, the probabilities of finding all possible outcomes of a measurement do not add up to 1, i.e., the total probability is not conserved. We show that this argument is flawed, and that the general expression for the Born rule ensures the conservation of total probabilities even when the dynamics of a quantum system is not unitary. This applies to the dynamics of ensembles of quantum systems in both pure and mixed states. We discuss the status of the local conservation of probabilities and the arguments against the plausibility of non-unitary time evolutions that are based on the identification of the Hamiltonian operator with the energy observable.
Abstract I provide a simple derivation of the Born rule as giving a classical probability, that is, the ratio of the measure of favorable states of the system to the measure of its total possible states. In classical systems, the probability is due to the fact that the same macrostate can be realized in different ways as a microstate. Despite the radical differences between quantum and classical systems, I show that the same can be applied to quantum systems, and the result is the Born rule. This works only if the basis is continuous (an eigenbasis of observables with continuous spectra), but all known physically realistic measurements involve a continuous basis (the position basis). The continuous basis is not unique, and for subsystems it depends on the observable. But for the entire universe, there are continuous bases that give the Born rule for all measurements, because all measurements reduce to distinguishing macroscopic pointer states, and macroscopic observations commute. This allows for the possibility of a unique ontic basis for the entire universe. In the wavefunctional formulation, the basis can be chosen to consist of classical field configurations, and the coefficients Ψ[ϕ]\Psi [\phi ]Ψ[ϕ] Ψ [ ϕ ] can be made real by absorbing them into a global U(1) gauge. For the many-worlds interpretation, this result gives the Born rule from micro-branch counting.
In classical electrodynamic wave theory, the intensity of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the electric field; in quantum theory, according to the conventional interpretation, the probability of detecting a light particle (and hence, ultimately, the photon density) is given by the square of the probability amplitude (as prescribed by the Born rule, which itself lacks a deeper theoretical justification). A mathematical formulation equivalent to the path integral provides, within the framework of the Pairwise Interference Model (PIMOQ), an alternative interpretation that is mutually exclusive with the conventional one. According to this interpretation, quantum physics, within the scope considered here, describes the local (at the detector), intrinsically bidirectional, quantised energy transfer between field and matter (apart from quantisation this is in direct analogy with classical physics). In the case of constructive interference, this transfer is unidirectional, occurring exclusively from matter to the field, whereas in the case of destructive interference the two opposing energy fluxes are equal in magnitude. However, it appears that in the macroscopic world only the net balance of these two antagonistic and complementary fluxes is experimentally observable, whereas the individual contributions cannot be measured independently. This limitation is referred to here as a quantum-physical measurement problem. From this perspective, quantum physics constitutes a subdiscipline of thermodynamics with a correspondingly limited domain of applicability. Although the principle discussed is as fundamental as, for example, the principle of conservation of energy, this does not imply that the underlying physical processes must necessarily be identical in every situation in which the principle applies. This interpretation is further elaborated through a discussion of interference experiments employing coherent and incoherent light sources, as well as the generation of coherent light in the laser.