Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mathematical Research Letters

The classical limit of the Heisenberg and time-dependent Hartree–Fock equations: the Wick symbol of the solution

Laurent Amour, Mohamed Khodja, Jean Nourrigat

Published Jan 1, 2013• 24 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper is concerned with the Wick symbol of time evolving quantum observables.The time dynamics is following either the Heisenberg equation relative to the Schrödinger Hamiltonian, or the time-dependent Hartree-Fock equation.Under very weak assumptions, we prove that the Wick symbol approximatively follows the classical mechanics laws when the semiclassical parameter h tends to zero.For the Heisenberg equation, this is a form of what is commonly called the Ehrenfest theorem.These statements have to be understood in a weaker sense than usual and in return, we do not assume that the Weyl symbol of the initial observable belongs to a class allowing the use of the Egorov theorem.

DOI
10.4310/mrl.2013.v20.n1.a11

Related papers

The semi-classical limit of the time dependent Hartree-Fock equation. II. The Wick symbol of the solution

Laurent Amour, Khodja, Mohamed, Jean Nourrigat

We study the Wick symbol of a solution of the time dependent Hartree Fock equation, under weaker hypotheses than those needed for the Weyl symbol in the first paper with thesame title. With similar, we prove some kind of Ehrenfest theorem for observables that are not pseudo-differential operators.

arXiv:1112.6186•Dec 28, 2011•0 citations

Time evolution of the Husimi and Glauber–Sudarshan functions in terms of complementary Hamiltonian symbols

M. C. Tyagi, Simon Friederich

We present a compact, systematic formulation of the dynamics of the Husimi Q- and Glauber–Sudarshan P-phase space distribution functions expressed in terms of their complementary Hamiltonian symbols: Anti-Wick for Q and Wick for P. In contrast to existing same-type-symbol formulations, the complementary-symbol evolution equations exhibit a transparent semiclassical hierarchy: the n th term corresponds to order ħ n , and takes the form of an n th order total phase-space derivative, acting on the product of the n th derivative of H a W with the Q-function. The leading ( n = 1 ) term is exactly the classical Liouvillian drift. For Hamiltonians no higher than quartic in the moduli of the complex phase space variables α i , the n = 2 term yields a Fokker–Planck diffusion with a traceless diffusion matrix, thereby recovering and clarifying recent results by Drummond. From this formulation we derive two further results. First, we obtain a transparent Ehrenfest theorem for Wick/Anti-Wick symbols of the operators representing dynamical observables. Second, we show that a previously reported nonclassical contribution to the Q-function drift for the anharmonic oscillator is an artifact of the quantization scheme used: with the natural anti-Wick Hamiltonian, the drift reduces to the classical Liouvillian. Our paper consolidates the formulation of the dynamics of the phase space distribution functions using complementary symbols and provides an efficient route to compute and interpret quantum phase space evolution.

arXiv:2510.15628•Results in Physics•May 14, 2026•3 citations

Mean Field Derivation of DNLS from the Bose–Hubbard Model

E. Picari, Antonio Ponno, Lorenzo Zanelli

Abstract We prove that the flow of the discrete nonlinear Schrödinger equation (DNLS) is the mean field limit of the quantum dynamics of the Bose–Hubbard model for N interacting particles. In particular, we show that the Wick symbol of the annihilation operators evolved in the Heisenberg picture converges, as N becomes large, to the solution of the DNLS. A quantitative $$L^p$$ L p -estimate, for any $$p \ge 1$$ p ≥ 1 , is obtained with a linear dependence on time due to a Gaussian measure on initial data coherent states.

Annales Henri Poincaré•Oct 1, 2021•2 citations

Atomism and quantization

Jürg Martin Fröhlich, Antti Knowles, Alessandro Pizzo

Within the framework of the theory of interacting classical and quantum gases, it is shown that the atomistic constitution of gases can be understood as a consequence of (second) quantization of a continuum theory of gases. In this paper, this is explained in some detail for the theory of non-relativistic interacting Bose gases, which can be viewed as the second quantization of a continuum theory whose dynamics is given by the Hartree equation. Conversely, the Hartree equation emerges from the theory of Bose gases in the mean-field limit. It is shown that, for such systems, the time evolution of 'observables' commutes with their Wick quantization, up to quantum corrections that tend to zero in the mean-field limit. This is an Egorov-type theorem.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 7, 2007•72 citations

Weyl Quantization and Coherent States

Didier Robert, Monique Combescure

It is well known from the work of Berezin [24] (Commun. Math. Phys. 40:153–174, 1975) in 1975 that the quantization problem of a classical mechanical system is closely related with coherent states. In particular coherent states help to understand the limiting behaviour of a quantum system when the Planck constant \(\hbar \) becomes negligible in macroscopic units. This problem is called the semi-classical limit problem. In this chapter we discuss properties of quantum systems when the configuration space is the Euclidean space \(\mathbb R^n\). So that in the Hamiltonian formalism, the phase space is \(\mathbb R^n\times \mathbb R^n\) with its canonical symplectic form \(\sigma \). The quantization problem has many solutions, so we choose a convient one, introduced by Weyl [259] (The Classical Groups, 1997) and Wigner [261] (Group Theory and Its Applications to Quantum Mechanics of Atomic Spectra, 1959). We study the symmetries of Weyl quantization, the operationnal calculus and applications to propagation of observables. We show that Wick quantization is a natural bridge between Weyl quantization and coherent states. Applications are given to the semi-classical limit after introducing an efficient modern tool: the semi-classical measures. We illustrate the general results proved in this chapter by explicit computations for the harmonic oscillator. More applications will be given in the following chapters, in particular concerning propagators and trace formulas for a large class of quantum systems.

Theoretical and mathematical physics•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Classical and semi-classical limits in phase space

Clay D. Spence

A semiclassical approximation is derived by using a family of wavepackets to map arbitrary wavefunctions into phase space. If the Hamiltonian can be approximated as linear over each individual wavepacket, as often done when presenting Ehrenfest's theorem, the resulting approximation is a linear first-order partial differential equation on phase space, which will be referred to as the Schrödinger-Ehrenfest or SE equation. This advectively transports wavefunctions along classical trajectories, so that as a trajectory is followed in time the amplitude remains constant while the phase changes by the action divided by $\hbar$. The wavefunction's squared-magnitude is a plausible phase space density and obeys Liouville's equation for the classical time evolution. This is a derivation of the Koopman-von~Neumann (KvN) formulation of classical mechanics, which previously was postulated but not derived. With the time-independent SE equation, continuity of the wavefunction requires the change of phase around any closed path in the torus covered by a classical trajectory to be an integer multiple of $2π$, giving a standing wave picture of old quantum mechanics. While this applies to any system, for separable systems it gives Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization.

arXiv:2305.18644•May 29, 2023•0 citations
This paper is concerned with the Wick symbol of time evolving quantum observables.The time dynamics is following either the Heisenberg equation relative to the Schrödinger Hamiltonian, or the time-dependent Hartree-Fock equation.Under very weak assumptions, we prove that the Wick symbol approximatively follows the classical mechanics laws when the semiclassical parameter h tends to zero.For the Heisenberg equation, this is a form of what is commonly called the Ehrenfest theorem.These statements have to be understood in a weaker sense than usual and in return, we do not assume that the Weyl symbol of the initial observable belongs to a class allowing the use of the Egorov theorem.
We present a compact, systematic formulation of the dynamics of the Husimi Q- and Glauber–Sudarshan P-phase space distribution functions expressed in terms of their complementary Hamiltonian symbols: Anti-Wick for Q and Wick for P. In contrast to existing same-type-symbol formulations, the complementary-symbol evolution equations exhibit a transparent semiclassical hierarchy: the n th term corresponds to order ħ n , and takes the form of an n th order total phase-space derivative, acting on the product of the n th derivative of H a W with the Q-function. The leading ( n = 1 ) term is exactly the classical Liouvillian drift. For Hamiltonians no higher than quartic in the moduli of the complex phase space variables α i , the n = 2 term yields a Fokker–Planck diffusion with a traceless diffusion matrix, thereby recovering and clarifying recent results by Drummond. From this formulation we derive two further results. First, we obtain a transparent Ehrenfest theorem for Wick/Anti-Wick symbols of the operators representing dynamical observables. Second, we show that a previously reported nonclassical contribution to the Q-function drift for the anharmonic oscillator is an artifact of the quantization scheme used: with the natural anti-Wick Hamiltonian, the drift reduces to the classical Liouvillian. Our paper consolidates the formulation of the dynamics of the phase space distribution functions using complementary symbols and provides an efficient route to compute and interpret quantum phase space evolution.
Abstract We prove that the flow of the discrete nonlinear Schrödinger equation (DNLS) is the mean field limit of the quantum dynamics of the Bose–Hubbard model for N interacting particles. In particular, we show that the Wick symbol of the annihilation operators evolved in the Heisenberg picture converges, as N becomes large, to the solution of the DNLS. A quantitative LpL^pLp L p -estimate, for any p≥1p \ge 1p≥1 p ≥ 1 , is obtained with a linear dependence on time due to a Gaussian measure on initial data coherent states.
Within the framework of the theory of interacting classical and quantum gases, it is shown that the atomistic constitution of gases can be understood as a consequence of (second) quantization of a continuum theory of gases. In this paper, this is explained in some detail for the theory of non-relativistic interacting Bose gases, which can be viewed as the second quantization of a continuum theory whose dynamics is given by the Hartree equation. Conversely, the Hartree equation emerges from the theory of Bose gases in the mean-field limit. It is shown that, for such systems, the time evolution of 'observables' commutes with their Wick quantization, up to quantum corrections that tend to zero in the mean-field limit. This is an Egorov-type theorem.
It is well known from the work of Berezin [24] (Commun. Math. Phys. 40:153–174, 1975) in 1975 that the quantization problem of a classical mechanical system is closely related with coherent states. In particular coherent states help to understand the limiting behaviour of a quantum system when the Planck constant ℏ\hbar ℏ becomes negligible in macroscopic units. This problem is called the semi-classical limit problem. In this chapter we discuss properties of quantum systems when the configuration space is the Euclidean space Rn\mathbb R^nRn. So that in the Hamiltonian formalism, the phase space is Rn×Rn\mathbb R^n\times \mathbb R^nRn×Rn with its canonical symplectic form σ\sigma σ. The quantization problem has many solutions, so we choose a convient one, introduced by Weyl [259] (The Classical Groups, 1997) and Wigner [261] (Group Theory and Its Applications to Quantum Mechanics of Atomic Spectra, 1959). We study the symmetries of Weyl quantization, the operationnal calculus and applications to propagation of observables. We show that Wick quantization is a natural bridge between Weyl quantization and coherent states. Applications are given to the semi-classical limit after introducing an efficient modern tool: the semi-classical measures. We illustrate the general results proved in this chapter by explicit computations for the harmonic oscillator. More applications will be given in the following chapters, in particular concerning propagators and trace formulas for a large class of quantum systems.
A semiclassical approximation is derived by using a family of wavepackets to map arbitrary wavefunctions into phase space. If the Hamiltonian can be approximated as linear over each individual wavepacket, as often done when presenting Ehrenfest's theorem, the resulting approximation is a linear first-order partial differential equation on phase space, which will be referred to as the Schrödinger-Ehrenfest or SE equation. This advectively transports wavefunctions along classical trajectories, so that as a trajectory is followed in time the amplitude remains constant while the phase changes by the action divided by ℏ\hbarℏ. The wavefunction's squared-magnitude is a plausible phase space density and obeys Liouville's equation for the classical time evolution. This is a derivation of the Koopman-von~Neumann (KvN) formulation of classical mechanics, which previously was postulated but not derived. With the time-independent SE equation, continuity of the wavefunction requires the change of phase around any closed path in the torus covered by a classical trajectory to be an integer multiple of 2π2π2π, giving a standing wave picture of old quantum mechanics. While this applies to any system, for separable systems it gives Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization.