Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.15628 · Results in Physics

Time evolution of the Husimi and Glauber–Sudarshan functions in terms of complementary Hamiltonian symbols

M. C. Tyagi, Simon Friederich

Published May 14, 2026• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a compact, systematic formulation of the dynamics of the Husimi Q- and Glauber–Sudarshan P-phase space distribution functions expressed in terms of their complementary Hamiltonian symbols: Anti-Wick for Q and Wick for P. In contrast to existing same-type-symbol formulations, the complementary-symbol evolution equations exhibit a transparent semiclassical hierarchy: the n th term corresponds to order ħ n , and takes the form of an n th order total phase-space derivative, acting on the product of the n th derivative of H a W with the Q-function. The leading ( n = 1 ) term is exactly the classical Liouvillian drift. For Hamiltonians no higher than quartic in the moduli of the complex phase space variables α i , the n = 2 term yields a Fokker–Planck diffusion with a traceless diffusion matrix, thereby recovering and clarifying recent results by Drummond. From this formulation we derive two further results. First, we obtain a transparent Ehrenfest theorem for Wick/Anti-Wick symbols of the operators representing dynamical observables. Second, we show that a previously reported nonclassical contribution to the Q-function drift for the anharmonic oscillator is an artifact of the quantization scheme used: with the natural anti-Wick Hamiltonian, the drift reduces to the classical Liouvillian. Our paper consolidates the formulation of the dynamics of the phase space distribution functions using complementary symbols and provides an efficient route to compute and interpret quantum phase space evolution.

DOI
10.1016/j.rinp.2026.108681

Related papers

Path-integral formulation of bosonic Markovian open quantum dynamics with Monte Carlo stochastic trajectories using the Glauber–Sudarshan P, Wigner, and Husimi Q functions and hybrids

Toma Yoneya, Kazuya Fujimoto, Yuki Kawaguchi

The Monte Carlo trajectory sampling of stochastic differential equations based on the quasiprobability distribution functions, such as the Glauber–Sudarshan P, Wigner, and Husimi Q functions, enables us to investigate bosonic open quantum many-body dynamics described by the Gorini–Kossakowski–Sudarshan–Lindblad (GKSL) equation. In this method, the Monte Carlo samplings for the initial distribution and stochastic noises incorporate quantum fluctuations, and thus, we can go beyond the mean-field approximation. However, description using stochastic differential equations is possible only when the corresponding Fokker–Planck equation has a positive-semidefinite diffusion matrix. In this work, we analytically derive the stochastic differential equations for arbitrary Hamiltonian and jump operators based on the path-integral formula, independently of the derivation of the Fokker–Planck equation. In the course of the derivation, we formulate the path-integral representation of the GKSL equation by using the s -ordered quasiprobability distribution function, which systematically describes the aforementioned quasiprobability distribution functions by changing the real parameter s . The essential point of this derivation is that we employ the Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation in the path integral, and its application is not always feasible. We find that the feasible condition of the Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation is identical to the positive-semidefiniteness condition of the diffusion matrix in the Fokker–Planck equation. In the benchmark calculations, we confirm that the Monte Carlo simulations of the obtained stochastic differential equations well reproduce the exact dynamics of physical quantities and non-equal time correlation functions of numerically solvable models, including the Bose–Hubbard model. This work clarifies the applicability of the approximation and gives systematic and simplified procedures to obtain the stochastic differential equations to be numerically solved.

arXiv:2508.01991•Annals of Physics•Dec 16, 2025•4 citations

Sharp values for all dynamical variables via Anti-Wick quantization

Simon Friederich

This paper proposes an approach to interpreting quantum expectation values that may help address the quantum measurement problem. Quantum expectation values are usually calculated via Hilbert space inner products and, thereby, differently from expectation values in classical mechanics, which are weighted phase-space integrals. It is shown that, by using Anti-Wick quantization to associate dynamical variables with self-adjoint linear operators, quantum expectation values can be interpreted as genuine weighted averages over phase space, paralleling their classical counterparts. This interpretation arises naturally in the Segal-Bargmann space, where creation and annihilation operators act as simple multiplication and differentiation operators. In this setting, the Husimi Q-function - the coherent-state representation of the quantum state - can be seen as a true probability density in phase space. Unlike Bohmian mechanics, the present approach retains the standard correspondence between dynamical variables and self-adjoint operators while paving the way for a classical-like probabilistic interpretation of quantum statistics.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07616•Physics Letters A•Dec 9, 2025•0 citations

The classical limit of the Heisenberg and time-dependent Hartree–Fock equations: the Wick symbol of the solution

Laurent Amour, Mohamed Khodja, Jean Nourrigat

This paper is concerned with the Wick symbol of time evolving quantum observables.The time dynamics is following either the Heisenberg equation relative to the Schrödinger Hamiltonian, or the time-dependent Hartree-Fock equation.Under very weak assumptions, we prove that the Wick symbol approximatively follows the classical mechanics laws when the semiclassical parameter h tends to zero.For the Heisenberg equation, this is a form of what is commonly called the Ehrenfest theorem.These statements have to be understood in a weaker sense than usual and in return, we do not assume that the Weyl symbol of the initial observable belongs to a class allowing the use of the Egorov theorem.

Mathematical Research Letters•Jan 1, 2013•24 citations

Effective classical Liouville-like evolution equation for the quantum phase-space dynamics

Omar Morandi

A model for the evolution of a quantum particle in the phase plane is derived. The quasi-distribution function is decomposed into a suitable over-complete basis of coherent states. In this approach, a coarse grain length scale is introduced by using the spread of the coherent states. The obtained evolution system is completely equivalent to the Wigner formulation of the quantum mechanics. It shows some analogy with the von Neumann approach and the particle in the cell method in classical plasma physics. Differing from the usual formulation of the quantum phase space, given in terms of infinite-order partial differential equations, in this model, the evolution equations of the second differential order are expressed by a hierarchy of coupled functions (the first term being the Husimi function). The resulting formulation reveals itself to be particularly close to the classical description of the particles motion. This formal analogy is useful to gain new physical insights and to profit from numerical methods developed for classical systems.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 23, 2010•22 citations

Causality and propagation in the Wigner, Husimi, Glauber, and Kirkwood phase-space representations

Bilha Segev

Time evolution is considered in phase space in terms of evolution kernels for various phase-space quasi-distributions. The propagators for the Wigner function, the standard-ordered function, the Kirkwood (antistandard-ordered) function, the Glauber P and Q functions, and the Husimi function are explicitly written as bilinear transforms of the evolution operator. Free propagation, propagation in dispersive media, and scattering, are studied, and manifestations of causality and interference are analyzed. It is shown that free propagation and scattering in the Husimi, Glauber, and Kirkwood representations with the underlying dynamics of the Schr\"odinger equation involve divergent evolution kernels connecting distant phase-space points at all times. The time evolution is much simpler in the Wigner representation where (i) free propagation is a simple classical translation involving no interference, and (ii) analytical properties of the scattering matrix restrict the velocities of propagation so that no information can travel due to scattering faster than free motion. As an example, a correlation is found between the coordinate and momentum of particles detected after they are released from a box. Propagators with relativistic dispersion relations of free photons or Klein-Gordon particles are briefly discussed in an Appendix.

Physical Review A•Apr 19, 2001•8 citations

Semiclassical Ehrenfest paths in open quantum systems

Xiao-Kan Guo

We study the semiclassical Ehrenfest trajectories in open quantum systems. We first give a self-contained derivation of the Fokker--Planck equation that governs the time evolution of the mixing measure for a Gaussian mixture. Then, we embed the generalized Ehrenfest theorem recently obtained for open quantum systems into this phase-space picture to study the time evolution of the expectations of observables with respect to the Gaussian mixture. We show how the coherent and irreversible contributions are separated in the frictionless harmonic regime relevant to the semiclassical approximation. Our work provides a transparent phase-space interpretation of the emergence of classical trajectories in open quantum dynamics.

quant-pharXiv:2604.27328•May 1, 2026•0 citations
We present a compact, systematic formulation of the dynamics of the Husimi Q- and Glauber–Sudarshan P-phase space distribution functions expressed in terms of their complementary Hamiltonian symbols: Anti-Wick for Q and Wick for P. In contrast to existing same-type-symbol formulations, the complementary-symbol evolution equations exhibit a transparent semiclassical hierarchy: the n th term corresponds to order ħ n , and takes the form of an n th order total phase-space derivative, acting on the product of the n th derivative of H a W with the Q-function. The leading ( n = 1 ) term is exactly the classical Liouvillian drift. For Hamiltonians no higher than quartic in the moduli of the complex phase space variables α i , the n = 2 term yields a Fokker–Planck diffusion with a traceless diffusion matrix, thereby recovering and clarifying recent results by Drummond. From this formulation we derive two further results. First, we obtain a transparent Ehrenfest theorem for Wick/Anti-Wick symbols of the operators representing dynamical observables. Second, we show that a previously reported nonclassical contribution to the Q-function drift for the anharmonic oscillator is an artifact of the quantization scheme used: with the natural anti-Wick Hamiltonian, the drift reduces to the classical Liouvillian. Our paper consolidates the formulation of the dynamics of the phase space distribution functions using complementary symbols and provides an efficient route to compute and interpret quantum phase space evolution.
The Monte Carlo trajectory sampling of stochastic differential equations based on the quasiprobability distribution functions, such as the Glauber–Sudarshan P, Wigner, and Husimi Q functions, enables us to investigate bosonic open quantum many-body dynamics described by the Gorini–Kossakowski–Sudarshan–Lindblad (GKSL) equation. In this method, the Monte Carlo samplings for the initial distribution and stochastic noises incorporate quantum fluctuations, and thus, we can go beyond the mean-field approximation. However, description using stochastic differential equations is possible only when the corresponding Fokker–Planck equation has a positive-semidefinite diffusion matrix. In this work, we analytically derive the stochastic differential equations for arbitrary Hamiltonian and jump operators based on the path-integral formula, independently of the derivation of the Fokker–Planck equation. In the course of the derivation, we formulate the path-integral representation of the GKSL equation by using the s -ordered quasiprobability distribution function, which systematically describes the aforementioned quasiprobability distribution functions by changing the real parameter s . The essential point of this derivation is that we employ the Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation in the path integral, and its application is not always feasible. We find that the feasible condition of the Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation is identical to the positive-semidefiniteness condition of the diffusion matrix in the Fokker–Planck equation. In the benchmark calculations, we confirm that the Monte Carlo simulations of the obtained stochastic differential equations well reproduce the exact dynamics of physical quantities and non-equal time correlation functions of numerically solvable models, including the Bose–Hubbard model. This work clarifies the applicability of the approximation and gives systematic and simplified procedures to obtain the stochastic differential equations to be numerically solved.
This paper proposes an approach to interpreting quantum expectation values that may help address the quantum measurement problem. Quantum expectation values are usually calculated via Hilbert space inner products and, thereby, differently from expectation values in classical mechanics, which are weighted phase-space integrals. It is shown that, by using Anti-Wick quantization to associate dynamical variables with self-adjoint linear operators, quantum expectation values can be interpreted as genuine weighted averages over phase space, paralleling their classical counterparts. This interpretation arises naturally in the Segal-Bargmann space, where creation and annihilation operators act as simple multiplication and differentiation operators. In this setting, the Husimi Q-function - the coherent-state representation of the quantum state - can be seen as a true probability density in phase space. Unlike Bohmian mechanics, the present approach retains the standard correspondence between dynamical variables and self-adjoint operators while paving the way for a classical-like probabilistic interpretation of quantum statistics.
This paper is concerned with the Wick symbol of time evolving quantum observables.The time dynamics is following either the Heisenberg equation relative to the Schrödinger Hamiltonian, or the time-dependent Hartree-Fock equation.Under very weak assumptions, we prove that the Wick symbol approximatively follows the classical mechanics laws when the semiclassical parameter h tends to zero.For the Heisenberg equation, this is a form of what is commonly called the Ehrenfest theorem.These statements have to be understood in a weaker sense than usual and in return, we do not assume that the Weyl symbol of the initial observable belongs to a class allowing the use of the Egorov theorem.
A model for the evolution of a quantum particle in the phase plane is derived. The quasi-distribution function is decomposed into a suitable over-complete basis of coherent states. In this approach, a coarse grain length scale is introduced by using the spread of the coherent states. The obtained evolution system is completely equivalent to the Wigner formulation of the quantum mechanics. It shows some analogy with the von Neumann approach and the particle in the cell method in classical plasma physics. Differing from the usual formulation of the quantum phase space, given in terms of infinite-order partial differential equations, in this model, the evolution equations of the second differential order are expressed by a hierarchy of coupled functions (the first term being the Husimi function). The resulting formulation reveals itself to be particularly close to the classical description of the particles motion. This formal analogy is useful to gain new physical insights and to profit from numerical methods developed for classical systems.
Time evolution is considered in phase space in terms of evolution kernels for various phase-space quasi-distributions. The propagators for the Wigner function, the standard-ordered function, the Kirkwood (antistandard-ordered) function, the Glauber P and Q functions, and the Husimi function are explicitly written as bilinear transforms of the evolution operator. Free propagation, propagation in dispersive media, and scattering, are studied, and manifestations of causality and interference are analyzed. It is shown that free propagation and scattering in the Husimi, Glauber, and Kirkwood representations with the underlying dynamics of the Schr\"odinger equation involve divergent evolution kernels connecting distant phase-space points at all times. The time evolution is much simpler in the Wigner representation where (i) free propagation is a simple classical translation involving no interference, and (ii) analytical properties of the scattering matrix restrict the velocities of propagation so that no information can travel due to scattering faster than free motion. As an example, a correlation is found between the coordinate and momentum of particles detected after they are released from a box. Propagators with relativistic dispersion relations of free photons or Klein-Gordon particles are briefly discussed in an Appendix.
We study the semiclassical Ehrenfest trajectories in open quantum systems. We first give a self-contained derivation of the Fokker--Planck equation that governs the time evolution of the mixing measure for a Gaussian mixture. Then, we embed the generalized Ehrenfest theorem recently obtained for open quantum systems into this phase-space picture to study the time evolution of the expectations of observables with respect to the Gaussian mixture. We show how the coherent and irreversible contributions are separated in the frictionless harmonic regime relevant to the semiclassical approximation. Our work provides a transparent phase-space interpretation of the emergence of classical trajectories in open quantum dynamics.