Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entanglement in a World with Closed Timelike Curves

Subhayan Roy Moulick, Prasanta Kumar Panigrahi

Published Nov 2, 2015• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

We study the nature of entanglement in presence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and we observe that qubits traveling along a CTC allow unambiguous discrimination of Bell states with Local Operations and Classical Communications (LOCC), and can be further generalized to allow unambiguous discrimination of any finite set of bipartite entangled states using just LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible. This enables one to create entanglement using just LOCC. Furthermore, we point out how the existence of CTCs would imply entanglement can be polygamous, and thus contradicting the prior known notions of monogamy of entanglement.

Related papers

Timelike curves can increase entanglement with LOCC

Subhayan Roy Moulick, Prasanta Kumar Panigrahi

We study the nature of entanglement in presence of Deutschian closed timelike curves (D-CTCs) and open timelike curves (OTCs) and find that existence of such physical systems in nature would allow us to increase entanglement using local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This is otherwise in direct contradiction with the fundamental definition of entanglement. We study this problem from the perspective of Bell state discrimination, and show how D-CTCs and OTCs can unambiguously distinguish between four Bell states with LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible.

arXiv:1511.00538•Scientific Reports•Nov 29, 2016•8 citations

Paradox-free classical non-causality and unambiguous non-locality without entanglement are equivalent

Hippolyte Dourdent, Kyrylo Simonov, Andreas Leitherer +5 more

Closed timelike curves (CTCs) challenge our conception of causality by allowing information to loop back into its own past. Any consistent description of such scenarios must avoid time-travel paradoxes while respecting the no-new-physics principle, which requires that the set of operations available within any local spacetime region remain unchanged, irrespective of whether CTCs exist elsewhere. Within an information-theoretic framework, this leads to process functions: deterministic classical communication structures that remain logically consistent under arbitrary local operations, yet can exhibit correlations incompatible with any definite causal order - a phenomenon known as non-causality. In this work, we establish a correspondence between process functions and unambiguous complete product bases, i.e. product bases in which every local state belongs to a unique local basis. This equivalence implies that non-causality of process functions is exactly mirrored by quantum nonlocality without entanglement (QNLWE) - the impossibility of perfectly distinguishing separable states using local operations and causal classical communication - for such bases. Our results generalize previous special cases to arbitrary local dimensions and any number of parties, enable systematic constructions of non-causal process functions and unambiguous QNLWE bases, and implies, inter alia, that bipartite unambiguous QNLWE bases do not exist. Finally, this work reveals an unexpected connection between causal and non-signaling inequalities: every process function both maximally violates an associated causal inequality and yields a corresponding Bell inequality that admits no violation.

quant-pharXiv:2512.23599•Dec 30, 2025•5 citations

Quantum States, Entanglement and Closed Timelike Curves

Arun Kumar Pati, Indranil Chakrabarty, Pankaj Agrawal +3 more

We discuss the nature of quantum states (density operators) and entanglement in quantum theory with closed timelike curves. One of the key concepts in the standard quantum theory is that given any mixed state we can always purify it in an enlarged Hilbert space by bringing an ancillary system. The purified state does not depend on the state of any extraneous system with which the mixed state is going to interact and on the physical interaction. Here, we prove that it is not possible to purify a mixed state that traverses a closed time like curve (CTC) and allowed to interact in a consistent way with a causality‐respecting (CR) quantum system. Thus, in general for arbitrary interactions between the CR and the CTC systems there is no universal ‘Church of the larger Hilbert space’ for mixed states with CTC. This shows that in quantum theory with CTCs there can exist ‘proper’ and ‘improper’ mixtures. Also, we suggest what kind of entangled states are allowed in the presence of CTCs. We argue that the nature of entanglement can be different in the presence of such exotic objects. Towards the end we discuss how the no‐hiding theorem in the presence of CTCs may allow quantum information pop‐up.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Can Closed Timelike Curves or Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics Improve Quantum State Discrimination or Help Solve Hard Problems?

Charles H. Bennett, Debbie Leung, Graeme Smith +1 more

We study the power of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and other nonlinear extensions of quantum mechanics for distinguishing nonorthogonal states and speeding up hard computations. If a CTC-assisted computer is presented with a labeled mixture of states to be distinguished--the most natural formulation--we show that the CTC is of no use. The apparent contradiction with recent claims that CTC-assisted computers can perfectly distinguish nonorthogonal states is resolved by noting that CTC-assisted evolution is nonlinear, so the output of such a computer on a mixture of inputs is not a convex combination of its output on the mixture's pure components. Similarly, it is not clear that CTC assistance or nonlinear evolution help solve hard problems if computation is defined as we recommend, as correctly evaluating a function on a labeled mixture of orthogonal inputs.

arXiv:0908.3023•Physical Review Letters•Oct 21, 2009•88 citations

Closed timelike curves make quantum and classical computing equivalent

Scott Aaronson, John Watrous

While closed timelike curves (CTCs) are not known to exist, studying their consequences has led to non-trivial insights into general relativity, quantum information and other areas. In this paper, we show that, if CTCs existed, quantum computers would be no more powerful than classical computers: both would have the (extremely large) power of the complexity class polynomial space ( ), consisting of all problems solvable by a conventional computer using a polynomial amount of memory. This solves an open problem proposed by one of us in 2005, and gives an essentially complete understanding of computational complexity in the presence of CTCs. Following the work of Deutsch, we treat a CTC as simply a region of spacetime where a ‘causal consistency’ condition is imposed, meaning that nature has to produce a (probabilistic or quantum) fixed point of some evolution operator. Our conclusion is then a consequence of the following theorem: given any quantum circuit (not necessarily unitary), a fixed point of the circuit can be (implicitly) computed in . This theorem might have independent applications in quantum information.

arXiv:0808.2669•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 11, 2008•109 citations

Entanglement of minimal dimension and a class of local state discrimination problems

Saronath Halder, Suchetana Goswami

In this work, we construct small sets of bipartite orthogonal pure states that cannot be perfectly distinguished by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We mention that not all the states within the constructed sets are necessarily entangled. However, such a set contains at least one entangled state which cannot be conclusively identified by LOCC (with nonzero probability). Then, we show that the states of any such set can be perfectly distinguished by LOCC using a minimal-dimensional entangled resource state. Clearly, here the entangled resource state provides an advantage irrespective of the dimension of the given set. Using this result, we also prove that any pure entangled state is useful as a resource to distinguish the states of any present set unambiguously with nonzero probability under LOCC. These sets exist in all two-qudit Hilbert spaces. Furthermore, it is possible to decrease the average entanglement content of such a set or to increase the cardinality of the set without changing certain properties of the same.

quant-pharXiv:2603.28284•Mar 31, 2026•0 citations
We study the nature of entanglement in presence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and we observe that qubits traveling along a CTC allow unambiguous discrimination of Bell states with Local Operations and Classical Communications (LOCC), and can be further generalized to allow unambiguous discrimination of any finite set of bipartite entangled states using just LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible. This enables one to create entanglement using just LOCC. Furthermore, we point out how the existence of CTCs would imply entanglement can be polygamous, and thus contradicting the prior known notions of monogamy of entanglement.
We study the nature of entanglement in presence of Deutschian closed timelike curves (D-CTCs) and open timelike curves (OTCs) and find that existence of such physical systems in nature would allow us to increase entanglement using local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This is otherwise in direct contradiction with the fundamental definition of entanglement. We study this problem from the perspective of Bell state discrimination, and show how D-CTCs and OTCs can unambiguously distinguish between four Bell states with LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible.
Closed timelike curves (CTCs) challenge our conception of causality by allowing information to loop back into its own past. Any consistent description of such scenarios must avoid time-travel paradoxes while respecting the no-new-physics principle, which requires that the set of operations available within any local spacetime region remain unchanged, irrespective of whether CTCs exist elsewhere. Within an information-theoretic framework, this leads to process functions: deterministic classical communication structures that remain logically consistent under arbitrary local operations, yet can exhibit correlations incompatible with any definite causal order - a phenomenon known as non-causality. In this work, we establish a correspondence between process functions and unambiguous complete product bases, i.e. product bases in which every local state belongs to a unique local basis. This equivalence implies that non-causality of process functions is exactly mirrored by quantum nonlocality without entanglement (QNLWE) - the impossibility of perfectly distinguishing separable states using local operations and causal classical communication - for such bases. Our results generalize previous special cases to arbitrary local dimensions and any number of parties, enable systematic constructions of non-causal process functions and unambiguous QNLWE bases, and implies, inter alia, that bipartite unambiguous QNLWE bases do not exist. Finally, this work reveals an unexpected connection between causal and non-signaling inequalities: every process function both maximally violates an associated causal inequality and yields a corresponding Bell inequality that admits no violation.
We discuss the nature of quantum states (density operators) and entanglement in quantum theory with closed timelike curves. One of the key concepts in the standard quantum theory is that given any mixed state we can always purify it in an enlarged Hilbert space by bringing an ancillary system. The purified state does not depend on the state of any extraneous system with which the mixed state is going to interact and on the physical interaction. Here, we prove that it is not possible to purify a mixed state that traverses a closed time like curve (CTC) and allowed to interact in a consistent way with a causality‐respecting (CR) quantum system. Thus, in general for arbitrary interactions between the CR and the CTC systems there is no universal ‘Church of the larger Hilbert space’ for mixed states with CTC. This shows that in quantum theory with CTCs there can exist ‘proper’ and ‘improper’ mixtures. Also, we suggest what kind of entangled states are allowed in the presence of CTCs. We argue that the nature of entanglement can be different in the presence of such exotic objects. Towards the end we discuss how the no‐hiding theorem in the presence of CTCs may allow quantum information pop‐up.
We study the power of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and other nonlinear extensions of quantum mechanics for distinguishing nonorthogonal states and speeding up hard computations. If a CTC-assisted computer is presented with a labeled mixture of states to be distinguished--the most natural formulation--we show that the CTC is of no use. The apparent contradiction with recent claims that CTC-assisted computers can perfectly distinguish nonorthogonal states is resolved by noting that CTC-assisted evolution is nonlinear, so the output of such a computer on a mixture of inputs is not a convex combination of its output on the mixture's pure components. Similarly, it is not clear that CTC assistance or nonlinear evolution help solve hard problems if computation is defined as we recommend, as correctly evaluating a function on a labeled mixture of orthogonal inputs.
While closed timelike curves (CTCs) are not known to exist, studying their consequences has led to non-trivial insights into general relativity, quantum information and other areas. In this paper, we show that, if CTCs existed, quantum computers would be no more powerful than classical computers: both would have the (extremely large) power of the complexity class polynomial space ( ), consisting of all problems solvable by a conventional computer using a polynomial amount of memory. This solves an open problem proposed by one of us in 2005, and gives an essentially complete understanding of computational complexity in the presence of CTCs. Following the work of Deutsch, we treat a CTC as simply a region of spacetime where a ‘causal consistency’ condition is imposed, meaning that nature has to produce a (probabilistic or quantum) fixed point of some evolution operator. Our conclusion is then a consequence of the following theorem: given any quantum circuit (not necessarily unitary), a fixed point of the circuit can be (implicitly) computed in . This theorem might have independent applications in quantum information.
In this work, we construct small sets of bipartite orthogonal pure states that cannot be perfectly distinguished by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We mention that not all the states within the constructed sets are necessarily entangled. However, such a set contains at least one entangled state which cannot be conclusively identified by LOCC (with nonzero probability). Then, we show that the states of any such set can be perfectly distinguished by LOCC using a minimal-dimensional entangled resource state. Clearly, here the entangled resource state provides an advantage irrespective of the dimension of the given set. Using this result, we also prove that any pure entangled state is useful as a resource to distinguish the states of any present set unambiguously with nonzero probability under LOCC. These sets exist in all two-qudit Hilbert spaces. Furthermore, it is possible to decrease the average entanglement content of such a set or to increase the cardinality of the set without changing certain properties of the same.