Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1511.00538 · Scientific Reports

Timelike curves can increase entanglement with LOCC

Subhayan Roy Moulick, Prasanta Kumar Panigrahi

Published Nov 29, 2016• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the nature of entanglement in presence of Deutschian closed timelike curves (D-CTCs) and open timelike curves (OTCs) and find that existence of such physical systems in nature would allow us to increase entanglement using local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This is otherwise in direct contradiction with the fundamental definition of entanglement. We study this problem from the perspective of Bell state discrimination, and show how D-CTCs and OTCs can unambiguously distinguish between four Bell states with LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible.

DOI
10.1038/srep37958

Related papers

Entanglement in a World with Closed Timelike Curves

Subhayan Roy Moulick, Prasanta Kumar Panigrahi

We study the nature of entanglement in presence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and we observe that qubits traveling along a CTC allow unambiguous discrimination of Bell states with Local Operations and Classical Communications (LOCC), and can be further generalized to allow unambiguous discrimination of any finite set of bipartite entangled states using just LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible. This enables one to create entanglement using just LOCC. Furthermore, we point out how the existence of CTCs would imply entanglement can be polygamous, and thus contradicting the prior known notions of monogamy of entanglement.

•Nov 2, 2015•1 citation

Quantum State Cloning Using Deutschian Closed Timelike Curves

Todd A. Brun, Mark M. Wilde, Andreas Winter

We show that it is possible to clone quantum states to arbitrary accuracy in the presence of a Deutschian closed timelike curve (D-CTC), with a fidelity converging to one in the limit as the dimension of the CTC system becomes large--thus resolving an open conjecture [Brun et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 210402 (2009)]. This result follows from a D-CTC-assisted scheme for producing perfect clones of a quantum state prepared in a known eigenbasis, and the fact that one can reconstruct an approximation of a quantum state from empirical estimates of the probabilities of an informationally complete measurement. Our results imply more generally that every continuous, but otherwise arbitrarily nonlinear map from states to states, can be implemented to arbitrary accuracy with D-CTCs. Furthermore, our results show that Deutsch's model for closed timelike curves is in fact a classical model, in the sense that two arbitrary, distinct density operators are perfectly distinguishable (in the limit of a large closed timelike curve system); hence, in this model quantum mechanics becomes a classical theory in which each density operator is a distinct point in a classical phase space.

arXiv:1306.1795•Physical Review Letters•Nov 4, 2013•36 citations

Quantum States, Entanglement and Closed Timelike Curves

Arun Kumar Pati, Indranil Chakrabarty, Pankaj Agrawal +3 more

We discuss the nature of quantum states (density operators) and entanglement in quantum theory with closed timelike curves. One of the key concepts in the standard quantum theory is that given any mixed state we can always purify it in an enlarged Hilbert space by bringing an ancillary system. The purified state does not depend on the state of any extraneous system with which the mixed state is going to interact and on the physical interaction. Here, we prove that it is not possible to purify a mixed state that traverses a closed time like curve (CTC) and allowed to interact in a consistent way with a causality‐respecting (CR) quantum system. Thus, in general for arbitrary interactions between the CR and the CTC systems there is no universal ‘Church of the larger Hilbert space’ for mixed states with CTC. This shows that in quantum theory with CTCs there can exist ‘proper’ and ‘improper’ mixtures. Also, we suggest what kind of entangled states are allowed in the presence of CTCs. We argue that the nature of entanglement can be different in the presence of such exotic objects. Towards the end we discuss how the no‐hiding theorem in the presence of CTCs may allow quantum information pop‐up.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Can Closed Timelike Curves or Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics Improve Quantum State Discrimination or Help Solve Hard Problems?

Charles H. Bennett, Debbie Leung, Graeme Smith +1 more

We study the power of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and other nonlinear extensions of quantum mechanics for distinguishing nonorthogonal states and speeding up hard computations. If a CTC-assisted computer is presented with a labeled mixture of states to be distinguished--the most natural formulation--we show that the CTC is of no use. The apparent contradiction with recent claims that CTC-assisted computers can perfectly distinguish nonorthogonal states is resolved by noting that CTC-assisted evolution is nonlinear, so the output of such a computer on a mixture of inputs is not a convex combination of its output on the mixture's pure components. Similarly, it is not clear that CTC assistance or nonlinear evolution help solve hard problems if computation is defined as we recommend, as correctly evaluating a function on a labeled mixture of orthogonal inputs.

arXiv:0908.3023•Physical Review Letters•Oct 21, 2009•88 citations

Distinguishability of Bell States

Sibasish Ghosh A, Guruprasad Kar, Anirban Roy +2 more

More than two multipartite orthogonal states cannot always be discriminated if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed. We show that four Bell states cannot be discriminated by LOCC, even probabilistically, using the separability properties of a four-party unlockable bound entangled state. Using an existing inequality among the measures of entanglement, we show that any three Bell states cannot be discriminated with certainty by LOCC. Exploiting the inequality, we calculate the distillable entanglement of a certain class of 4 multiply sign in circle 4 mixed states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0106148•Physical Review Letters•Dec 13, 2001•269 citations

Replicating the benefits of Deutschian closed timelike curves without breaking causality

Xiao Yuan, Syed M. Assad, Jayne Thompson +6 more

Abstract In general relativity, closed timelike curves can break causality with remarkable and unsettling consequences. At the classical level, they induce causal paradoxes disturbing enough to motivate conjectures that explicitly prevent their existence. At the quantum level such problems can be resolved through the Deutschian formalism, however this induces radical benefits—from cloning unknown quantum states to solving problems intractable to quantum computers. Instinctively, one expects these benefits to vanish if causality is respected. Here we show that in harnessing entanglement, we can efficiently solve NP-complete problems and clone arbitrary quantum states—even when all time-travelling systems are completely isolated from the past. Thus, the many defining benefits of Deutschian closed timelike curves can still be harnessed, even when causality is preserved. Our results unveil a subtle interplay between entanglement and general relativity, and significantly improve the potential of probing the radical effects that may exist at the interface between relativity and quantum theory.

arXiv:1412.5596•npj Quantum Information•Nov 23, 2015•22 citations
We study the nature of entanglement in presence of Deutschian closed timelike curves (D-CTCs) and open timelike curves (OTCs) and find that existence of such physical systems in nature would allow us to increase entanglement using local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This is otherwise in direct contradiction with the fundamental definition of entanglement. We study this problem from the perspective of Bell state discrimination, and show how D-CTCs and OTCs can unambiguously distinguish between four Bell states with LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible.
We study the nature of entanglement in presence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and we observe that qubits traveling along a CTC allow unambiguous discrimination of Bell states with Local Operations and Classical Communications (LOCC), and can be further generalized to allow unambiguous discrimination of any finite set of bipartite entangled states using just LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible. This enables one to create entanglement using just LOCC. Furthermore, we point out how the existence of CTCs would imply entanglement can be polygamous, and thus contradicting the prior known notions of monogamy of entanglement.
We show that it is possible to clone quantum states to arbitrary accuracy in the presence of a Deutschian closed timelike curve (D-CTC), with a fidelity converging to one in the limit as the dimension of the CTC system becomes large--thus resolving an open conjecture [Brun et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 210402 (2009)]. This result follows from a D-CTC-assisted scheme for producing perfect clones of a quantum state prepared in a known eigenbasis, and the fact that one can reconstruct an approximation of a quantum state from empirical estimates of the probabilities of an informationally complete measurement. Our results imply more generally that every continuous, but otherwise arbitrarily nonlinear map from states to states, can be implemented to arbitrary accuracy with D-CTCs. Furthermore, our results show that Deutsch's model for closed timelike curves is in fact a classical model, in the sense that two arbitrary, distinct density operators are perfectly distinguishable (in the limit of a large closed timelike curve system); hence, in this model quantum mechanics becomes a classical theory in which each density operator is a distinct point in a classical phase space.
We discuss the nature of quantum states (density operators) and entanglement in quantum theory with closed timelike curves. One of the key concepts in the standard quantum theory is that given any mixed state we can always purify it in an enlarged Hilbert space by bringing an ancillary system. The purified state does not depend on the state of any extraneous system with which the mixed state is going to interact and on the physical interaction. Here, we prove that it is not possible to purify a mixed state that traverses a closed time like curve (CTC) and allowed to interact in a consistent way with a causality‐respecting (CR) quantum system. Thus, in general for arbitrary interactions between the CR and the CTC systems there is no universal ‘Church of the larger Hilbert space’ for mixed states with CTC. This shows that in quantum theory with CTCs there can exist ‘proper’ and ‘improper’ mixtures. Also, we suggest what kind of entangled states are allowed in the presence of CTCs. We argue that the nature of entanglement can be different in the presence of such exotic objects. Towards the end we discuss how the no‐hiding theorem in the presence of CTCs may allow quantum information pop‐up.
We study the power of closed timelike curves (CTCs) and other nonlinear extensions of quantum mechanics for distinguishing nonorthogonal states and speeding up hard computations. If a CTC-assisted computer is presented with a labeled mixture of states to be distinguished--the most natural formulation--we show that the CTC is of no use. The apparent contradiction with recent claims that CTC-assisted computers can perfectly distinguish nonorthogonal states is resolved by noting that CTC-assisted evolution is nonlinear, so the output of such a computer on a mixture of inputs is not a convex combination of its output on the mixture's pure components. Similarly, it is not clear that CTC assistance or nonlinear evolution help solve hard problems if computation is defined as we recommend, as correctly evaluating a function on a labeled mixture of orthogonal inputs.
More than two multipartite orthogonal states cannot always be discriminated if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed. We show that four Bell states cannot be discriminated by LOCC, even probabilistically, using the separability properties of a four-party unlockable bound entangled state. Using an existing inequality among the measures of entanglement, we show that any three Bell states cannot be discriminated with certainty by LOCC. Exploiting the inequality, we calculate the distillable entanglement of a certain class of 4 multiply sign in circle 4 mixed states.
Abstract In general relativity, closed timelike curves can break causality with remarkable and unsettling consequences. At the classical level, they induce causal paradoxes disturbing enough to motivate conjectures that explicitly prevent their existence. At the quantum level such problems can be resolved through the Deutschian formalism, however this induces radical benefits—from cloning unknown quantum states to solving problems intractable to quantum computers. Instinctively, one expects these benefits to vanish if causality is respected. Here we show that in harnessing entanglement, we can efficiently solve NP-complete problems and clone arbitrary quantum states—even when all time-travelling systems are completely isolated from the past. Thus, the many defining benefits of Deutschian closed timelike curves can still be harnessed, even when causality is preserved. Our results unveil a subtle interplay between entanglement and general relativity, and significantly improve the potential of probing the radical effects that may exist at the interface between relativity and quantum theory.