Nonlocality and Interaction
Manfred Buth
Abstract
In order to understand nonlocal phenomena, the corresponding processes must be treated as scattering experiments and investigated in the frame of quantum eld theory. Quantum mechanics is not su cient for this task, because it is only concerned with the in uence of a potential on a physical object. But in processes with nonlocal e ects the role of interaction between physical objects must be su ciently respected. All this is shown rst of all for the special case of the spin-1/2-experiment, and then generalized to arbitrary scattering processes. 1. What is the problem? Nonlocal phenomena are discussed and analyzed, since Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen in their famous paper [1] have drawn attention to a di culty of quantum mechanics. By means of their also famous gedankenexperiment the three authors have demonstrated their thesis that quantum mechanics is incomplete. So called local theories were developed in order to repair this pretended fault. The work of Bell [2] consisted in describing mathematically a general kind of such theories, and inferring the inequality bearing his name from characteristic features of such theories by mere logical deduction. In quantum mechanics a corresponding condition can be given, too. These two inequalities are not compatible with one another. Hence it seems to be quite natural to decide between them by experiment. Since all results of experimental investigations from Aspect et al. [3, 4] up to Erven et al. [5] have shown that Bell's inequality is not compatible with the empirical results, local theories nowadays are quite generally refuted. On the other hand all these experiments are supporting the results of quantum mechanics. Hence one could infer that quantum mechanics is correct. But that would be an illegal conclusion, because the agreement with experiment is a necessary, but no su cient condition for the validity of a theory. Hence one would convert a double negation into a positive assertion. In this paper the thesis is claimed and proved that quantum mechanics, indeed, is incomplete, not on the philosophical level, where Bohr and Einstein were quarrelling, but in an immediately physical sense.