Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B

A corollary to Bell’s theorem

Roderick I. Sutherland

Published Aug 1, 1985• 14 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf02728894

Related papers

Generalization of Bell's theorem

Nick Herbert, Jack Karush

Foundations of Physics•Apr 1, 1978•15 citations

Classicality and Bell’s theorem

Márton Gömöri, Carl Hoefer

Abstract A widespread view among physicists is that Bell’s theorem rests on an implicit assumption of “classicality,” in addition to locality. According to this understanding, the violation of Bell’s inequalities poses no challenge to locality, but simply reinforces the fact that quantum mechanics is not classical. The paper provides a critical analysis of this view. First we characterize the notion of classicality in probabilistic terms. We argue that classicality thus construed has nothing to do with the validity of classical physics, nor of classical probability theory, contrary to what many believe. At the same time, we show that the probabilistic notion of classicality is not an additional premise of Bell’s theorem, but a mathematical corollary of locality in conjunction with the standard auxiliary assumptions of Bell. Accordingly, any theory that claims to get around the derivation of Bell’s inequalities by giving up classicality, in fact has to give up one of those standard assumptions. As an illustration of this, we look at two recent interpretations of quantum mechanics, Reinhard Werner’s operational quantum mechanics and Robert Griffiths’ consistent histories approach, that are claimed to be local and non-classical, and identify which of the standard assumptions of Bell’s theorem each of them is forced to give up. We claim that while in operational quantum mechanics the Common Cause Principle is violated, the consistent histories approach is conspiratorial. Finally, we relate these two options to the idea of realism, a notion that is also often identified as an implicit assumption of Bell’s theorem.

European Journal for Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 2023•5 citations

Synthetic approach to Bell's inequalities and a fundamental Bell-type theorem

Krzysztof Rębilas

A fundamental Bell-type inequality is derived by referring solely to laws of logic, tertium non datur and the transitivity axiom, that are used to express the local realism assumption. The general form of the achieved inequality makes it a root of other more specific Bell-type theorems involving additional mathematical formalism and experimental conditions. Its universality is demonstrated explicitly by showing that the most famous theorems provided by Bell, Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH), Clauser and Horne (CH), Eberhard, d'Espagnat and Maccone are direct corollaries of the general inequality. The method to retrieve Bell's inequalities of different kinds, as being based on a single scheme of reasoning, unifies diversity of proofs presented in the literature. Additionally, some of the known inequalities can be easily achieved in a more general form compared to their original versions and still suitable, or possibly even more convenient, for experimental investigations. By extracting local realism in the form of an explicit logical propositions and making it a cornerstone of a systematic reasoning leading to the universal Bell's inequality, the paper offers a synthetic perspective on Bell-type theorems and their logical basis.

Physics Letters A•Jun 14, 2024•0 citations

A Note About Bell's Theorem

Damian Canals‐Frau

Physics Essays•Jun 1, 1993•0 citations

Machine-checked falsification of quantum foundations: Bell, Tsirelson, no-cloning, and Kochen-Specker in Lean 4

Rob Mitchell

Machine-checked (Lean 4 / Mathlib) certificates for the main falsification results of quantum foundations. Bell's theorem: the CHSH correlation satisfies S <= 2 for local hidden variables, in both the deterministic +/-1 form and the general local-realism form |a|,|b| <= 1. The Tsirelson bound: QM saturates S = 2*sqrt(2), so locality is violated. No-cloning: v -> v tensor v is not linear. Kochen-Specker: no non-contextual 0/1 value assignment in dimension >= 3 (the no_dispersion_free corollary of Gleason). Zero sorry/axiom; #print axioms = propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound only.

•Nov 7, 2026•0 citations

An inverse of Bell's theorem

Kaj Börge Hansen

Journal for General Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 1995•0 citations
Abstract A widespread view among physicists is that Bell’s theorem rests on an implicit assumption of “classicality,” in addition to locality. According to this understanding, the violation of Bell’s inequalities poses no challenge to locality, but simply reinforces the fact that quantum mechanics is not classical. The paper provides a critical analysis of this view. First we characterize the notion of classicality in probabilistic terms. We argue that classicality thus construed has nothing to do with the validity of classical physics, nor of classical probability theory, contrary to what many believe. At the same time, we show that the probabilistic notion of classicality is not an additional premise of Bell’s theorem, but a mathematical corollary of locality in conjunction with the standard auxiliary assumptions of Bell. Accordingly, any theory that claims to get around the derivation of Bell’s inequalities by giving up classicality, in fact has to give up one of those standard assumptions. As an illustration of this, we look at two recent interpretations of quantum mechanics, Reinhard Werner’s operational quantum mechanics and Robert Griffiths’ consistent histories approach, that are claimed to be local and non-classical, and identify which of the standard assumptions of Bell’s theorem each of them is forced to give up. We claim that while in operational quantum mechanics the Common Cause Principle is violated, the consistent histories approach is conspiratorial. Finally, we relate these two options to the idea of realism, a notion that is also often identified as an implicit assumption of Bell’s theorem.
A fundamental Bell-type inequality is derived by referring solely to laws of logic, tertium non datur and the transitivity axiom, that are used to express the local realism assumption. The general form of the achieved inequality makes it a root of other more specific Bell-type theorems involving additional mathematical formalism and experimental conditions. Its universality is demonstrated explicitly by showing that the most famous theorems provided by Bell, Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH), Clauser and Horne (CH), Eberhard, d'Espagnat and Maccone are direct corollaries of the general inequality. The method to retrieve Bell's inequalities of different kinds, as being based on a single scheme of reasoning, unifies diversity of proofs presented in the literature. Additionally, some of the known inequalities can be easily achieved in a more general form compared to their original versions and still suitable, or possibly even more convenient, for experimental investigations. By extracting local realism in the form of an explicit logical propositions and making it a cornerstone of a systematic reasoning leading to the universal Bell's inequality, the paper offers a synthetic perspective on Bell-type theorems and their logical basis.
Machine-checked (Lean 4 / Mathlib) certificates for the main falsification results of quantum foundations. Bell's theorem: the CHSH correlation satisfies S <= 2 for local hidden variables, in both the deterministic +/-1 form and the general local-realism form |a|,|b| <= 1. The Tsirelson bound: QM saturates S = 2*sqrt(2), so locality is violated. No-cloning: v -> v tensor v is not linear. Kochen-Specker: no non-contextual 0/1 value assignment in dimension >= 3 (the no_dispersion_free corollary of Gleason). Zero sorry/axiom; #print axioms = propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound only.