Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Machine-checked falsification of quantum foundations: Bell, Tsirelson, no-cloning, and Kochen-Specker in Lean 4

Rob Mitchell

Published Nov 7, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Machine-checked (Lean 4 / Mathlib) certificates for the main falsification results of quantum foundations. Bell's theorem: the CHSH correlation satisfies S <= 2 for local hidden variables, in both the deterministic +/-1 form and the general local-realism form |a|,|b| <= 1. The Tsirelson bound: QM saturates S = 2*sqrt(2), so locality is violated. No-cloning: v -> v tensor v is not linear. Kochen-Specker: no non-contextual 0/1 value assignment in dimension >= 3 (the no_dispersion_free corollary of Gleason). Zero sorry/axiom; #print axioms = propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound only.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24027301

Related papers

The Constructive Cost of Quantum Entanglement: Tsirelson Bound and Bell State Entropy in Lean 4

Paul Chun-Kit Lee

Paper 11 in the Constructive Reverse Mathematics of Mathematical Physics series. We provide a complete Lean 4 formalization of two foundational results in quantum information theory: Part A — Tsirelson bound: For any self-adjoint involutions A, A', B, B' on ℂ² and unit vector ψ ∈ ℂ² ⊗ ℂ², the CHSH operator satisfies ‖Cψ‖² ≤ 8, equivalently |⟨ψ, Cψ⟩| ≤ 2√2. Part B — Bell state entropy: The partial trace of the Bell singlet density matrix yields the maximally mixed state ρ_A = (1/2)I with von Neumann entropy S(ρ_A) = log 2. The formalization comprises 639 lines of Lean 4 across 8 modules, compiles with zero sorry, zero errors, and zero warnings. All theorems carry the axiom profile [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound] — standard Mathlib infrastructure axioms only. No custom axioms are introduced. Within the constructive reverse mathematics (CRM) programme, these results calibrate the compositional layer of quantum mechanics — tensor products, entanglement, correlations — establishing that Bell nonlocality and entanglement entropy are constructively accessible at the BISH level. This extends the calibration table from companion papers (Papers 2, 7, 8, 9) to cover relational quantum structure. Key finding: All logical costs arise from infinite-dimensional idealization, not from quantum compositional structure. Entanglement is constructively free. Archive contents: Lean 4 source code, LaTeX source, compiled PDF (20 pages), build instructions. Build: lake exe cache get && lake build — requires elan and ~8 GB disk space.

•Feb 8, 2026•0 citations

From Primitives to the Bell–Tsirelson Bound

Allen Proxmire

In 1964, John Bell showed that any local hidden‑variable theory must satisfy a specific inequality on correlations between distant measurements. In its CHSH form (Clauser, Horne, Shimony, Holt 1969), the inequality reads |S| = |E(a,b) + E(a,b′) + E(a′,b) − E(a′,b′)| ≤ 2, where E(a,b) is the correlation between measurement outcomes at two separated parties using settings a and b. Any local realist theory respects this bound. Quantum mechanics violates it. Experiments confirm the violation. The standard quantum prediction for a maximally entangled state with optimal measurement angles is |S| = 2√2 ≈ 2.828. In 1980, Boris Tsirelson proved that 2√2 is not just one quantum prediction — it is the *maximum* value any quantum correlation can produce. No quantum state, no measurement scheme, no clever protocol can push |S| beyond 2√2. The bound is sharp, the value is exact, and it has been measured in laboratories around the world to experimental precision. The Tsirelson bound is one of the deepest empirical structures in physics. It tells us that quantum correlations exceed classical correlations by a specific, finite amount — there is room to violate Bell’s inequality, but only so much room. The number 2√2 has no obvious physical interpretation. It does not appear in the formulation of quantum mechanics. It emerges from the mathematics of the bipartite Hilbert space when the CHSH operator is constructed and bounded. The question is where it comes from. In standard QM, the answer is that it falls out of the Hilbert‑space structure plus Cauchy–Schwarz plus an operator‑norm bound on the CHSH operator. Technically correct, and Tsirelson’s 1980 proof remains the canonical derivation — but it leaves the deeper structure unanswered. The Hilbert space is postulated. The inner product that makes Cauchy–Schwarz available is postulated. The bipartite tensor‑product structure on H_A ⊗ H_B is postulated. The 2√2 value is what those postulates produce when run through the CHSH operator. This walkthrough shows how the Event Density framework derives the Tsirelson bound from a smaller set of structural commitments. The Hilbert‑space structure, the inner product, and the bipartite tensor‑product structure all emerge as forced consequences of the substrate ontology rather than being postulated. With those structures forced rather than assumed, Tsirelson’s 1980 argument applies directly, and the 2√2 value is no longer the output of a chain of postulates but the output of a chain of derived theorems. Like Heisenberg, Bell–Tsirelson is a place where the framework’s contribution is upstream. The bound itself is mathematical physics already in the literature; what changes is the foundational status of the structures the argument requires. ED does not produce a new derivation step beyond standard QM here — it removes the postulational status of the structures the standard derivation already uses. The 2√2 value is now a derived consequence of the substrate ontology, all the way down.

•May 12, 2026•0 citations

The Bell Test Crisis: A Formal Machine - Lean 4 - Verified Refutation of the 1982-2018 Experimental Paradigm of Non-Locality

Garcia Lecaros Eduardo Andres

This research presents a formal critique of the primary experimental foundations of quantum non-locality. Utilizing Lean 4 machine-verified proofs and stochastic Python simulations, we demonstrate that the standard CHSH bound S ≤ 2 is mathematically inapplicable to the experimental designs of Aspect (1982), Delft (2015), and the Big Bell Test (2018) when their exclusionary assumptions are relaxed. Purely classical Local Hidden-Variable (LHV) models can reproduce the reported correlations through statistical survivorship bias and finite-sample fluctuations, as evidenced by Delft's marginal p = 0.039. These findings indicate that LHV frameworks retain full mathematical viability under the examined conditions.

•Mar 17, 2026•0 citations

Experimental Tests of Multiplicative Bell Inequalities

Dilip Paneru

This thesis is the synthesis of theoretical and experimental works performed in the area of quantum foundations, particularly on quantum correlations and experimental tests of multiplicative Bell inequalities. First we begin with a comprehensive theoretical work performed on the foundations of quantum mechanics, focusing on the puzzling concepts of quantum entanglement, and hidden variable theories. Specifically, we present a broad overview of different classes of hidden variable theories such as local, crypto-nonlocal, contextual and non-local theories, along with several Bell like inequalities for these theories, providing theoretical proofs based on quantum mechanics for the falsification of some of these theories. Second we present a body of experimental, and theoretical works performed on a new class of Bell inequalities, i.e., the multiplicative Bell inequalities. We experimentally report the observation of the Bell parameters close to the Tsirelson (quantum) limit, upto a large number of measurement devices $(n)$, and compare the results with a particular deterministic strategy. We also obtain classical bounds for some $n$, and report the experimental violation of these classical limits. We theoretically derive new richer bounds on the CHSH inequality (named after John Clauser, Michael Horne, Abnor Shimony and Richard Holt) and the multiplicative Bell parameter for $n=2$, based on the principle of ``relativistic independence'', and experimentally observe the distribution of Bell parameters as predicted by these bounds.

•Jan 7, 2021•0 citations

Hidden variable model for the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt test based on the Bell-Kochen-Specker model for a qubit

F. De Zela

The validity of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (Bell-CHSH) inequality for hidden-variable models of the Bell type and the quantum prediction that said inequality can be violated are two indisputable assertions. However, one can prove wrong the assertion that no hidden-variable model is able to reproduce quantum predictions about the Bell-CHSH test. Here, we reproduce all quantum predictions of Bell-CHSH tests by means of the Bell-Kochen-Specker hidden-variable model for a qubit plus Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen “criterion of physical reality”.

Physics Letters A•Jul 17, 2026•0 citations

Kochen-Specker Theorem and Games

Laura Mančinska

One of the statements one would hear pretty early in any quantum mechanics course is that for quantum particles there are properties which do not have definite values. For example, if we measure |+〉 in standard basis, the best we can do to describe the outcome is to say, that with probability 1/2 we will get 0 and with probability 1/2 we will get 1. Yet one could wonder, is this really the way things are or is it just because our description of this quantum particle is incomplete, but in fact there are some hidden variables inside every quantum system that contain enough information to tell the outcome of measurement (see Fig. 1). However, many people disdain the idea of hidden variables, so there has been rather long history of theorems that forbid theories involving hidden variables. Usually if one wants to prove some no hidden variables theorem he has to assume something about the hidden variables theories he is going to forbid. One of such assumptions is non-contextuality, which means that the outcome we get after measuring with an observable is the same regardless of what other observables we choose to measure at the same time. The first theorem forbidding hidden variables theories is due to von Neumann in 1932. Then for a third of a century everyone cited von Neumann’s work carelessly, till Bell in 1966 indicated that there was an unreasonable assumption in von Neumann’s proof and urged for further examination of the problem (see [6] and [1] for more historical details). Bell also constructed a hidden variables model for one qubit that could assign the outcome of any observable in a way consistent with quantum mechanics. He also proved two theorems that forbid non-contextual hidden variables theories using counterexamples with larger quantum systems. Yet surprisingly he himself thought that hidden variables do exists and considered these theorems only as characterizations of the hidden variables theory we should look for. In this essay we will discuss several versions of one of the two Bell’s theorems. The theorem we will consider was also independently proven by Kochen and Specker in 1967 (see [5]), hence it is called Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem. For shortness and in order not to mix this theorem with another Bell’s theorem from now on we will refer to it as Kochen-Specker theorem. We will be interested in proving several versions of this theorem and the following lemma will turn out to be of great use:

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations
Machine-checked (Lean 4 / Mathlib) certificates for the main falsification results of quantum foundations. Bell's theorem: the CHSH correlation satisfies S <= 2 for local hidden variables, in both the deterministic +/-1 form and the general local-realism form |a|,|b| <= 1. The Tsirelson bound: QM saturates S = 2*sqrt(2), so locality is violated. No-cloning: v -> v tensor v is not linear. Kochen-Specker: no non-contextual 0/1 value assignment in dimension >= 3 (the no_dispersion_free corollary of Gleason). Zero sorry/axiom; #print axioms = propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound only.
Paper 11 in the Constructive Reverse Mathematics of Mathematical Physics series. We provide a complete Lean 4 formalization of two foundational results in quantum information theory: Part A — Tsirelson bound: For any self-adjoint involutions A, A', B, B' on ℂ² and unit vector ψ ∈ ℂ² ⊗ ℂ², the CHSH operator satisfies ‖Cψ‖² ≤ 8, equivalently |⟨ψ, Cψ⟩| ≤ 2√2. Part B — Bell state entropy: The partial trace of the Bell singlet density matrix yields the maximally mixed state ρ_A = (1/2)I with von Neumann entropy S(ρ_A) = log 2. The formalization comprises 639 lines of Lean 4 across 8 modules, compiles with zero sorry, zero errors, and zero warnings. All theorems carry the axiom profile [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound] — standard Mathlib infrastructure axioms only. No custom axioms are introduced. Within the constructive reverse mathematics (CRM) programme, these results calibrate the compositional layer of quantum mechanics — tensor products, entanglement, correlations — establishing that Bell nonlocality and entanglement entropy are constructively accessible at the BISH level. This extends the calibration table from companion papers (Papers 2, 7, 8, 9) to cover relational quantum structure. Key finding: All logical costs arise from infinite-dimensional idealization, not from quantum compositional structure. Entanglement is constructively free. Archive contents: Lean 4 source code, LaTeX source, compiled PDF (20 pages), build instructions. Build: lake exe cache get && lake build — requires elan and ~8 GB disk space.
In 1964, John Bell showed that any local hidden‑variable theory must satisfy a specific inequality on correlations between distant measurements. In its CHSH form (Clauser, Horne, Shimony, Holt 1969), the inequality reads |S| = |E(a,b) + E(a,b′) + E(a′,b) − E(a′,b′)| ≤ 2, where E(a,b) is the correlation between measurement outcomes at two separated parties using settings a and b. Any local realist theory respects this bound. Quantum mechanics violates it. Experiments confirm the violation. The standard quantum prediction for a maximally entangled state with optimal measurement angles is |S| = 2√2 ≈ 2.828. In 1980, Boris Tsirelson proved that 2√2 is not just one quantum prediction — it is the *maximum* value any quantum correlation can produce. No quantum state, no measurement scheme, no clever protocol can push |S| beyond 2√2. The bound is sharp, the value is exact, and it has been measured in laboratories around the world to experimental precision. The Tsirelson bound is one of the deepest empirical structures in physics. It tells us that quantum correlations exceed classical correlations by a specific, finite amount — there is room to violate Bell’s inequality, but only so much room. The number 2√2 has no obvious physical interpretation. It does not appear in the formulation of quantum mechanics. It emerges from the mathematics of the bipartite Hilbert space when the CHSH operator is constructed and bounded. The question is where it comes from. In standard QM, the answer is that it falls out of the Hilbert‑space structure plus Cauchy–Schwarz plus an operator‑norm bound on the CHSH operator. Technically correct, and Tsirelson’s 1980 proof remains the canonical derivation — but it leaves the deeper structure unanswered. The Hilbert space is postulated. The inner product that makes Cauchy–Schwarz available is postulated. The bipartite tensor‑product structure on H_A ⊗ H_B is postulated. The 2√2 value is what those postulates produce when run through the CHSH operator. This walkthrough shows how the Event Density framework derives the Tsirelson bound from a smaller set of structural commitments. The Hilbert‑space structure, the inner product, and the bipartite tensor‑product structure all emerge as forced consequences of the substrate ontology rather than being postulated. With those structures forced rather than assumed, Tsirelson’s 1980 argument applies directly, and the 2√2 value is no longer the output of a chain of postulates but the output of a chain of derived theorems. Like Heisenberg, Bell–Tsirelson is a place where the framework’s contribution is upstream. The bound itself is mathematical physics already in the literature; what changes is the foundational status of the structures the argument requires. ED does not produce a new derivation step beyond standard QM here — it removes the postulational status of the structures the standard derivation already uses. The 2√2 value is now a derived consequence of the substrate ontology, all the way down.
This research presents a formal critique of the primary experimental foundations of quantum non-locality. Utilizing Lean 4 machine-verified proofs and stochastic Python simulations, we demonstrate that the standard CHSH bound S ≤ 2 is mathematically inapplicable to the experimental designs of Aspect (1982), Delft (2015), and the Big Bell Test (2018) when their exclusionary assumptions are relaxed. Purely classical Local Hidden-Variable (LHV) models can reproduce the reported correlations through statistical survivorship bias and finite-sample fluctuations, as evidenced by Delft's marginal p = 0.039. These findings indicate that LHV frameworks retain full mathematical viability under the examined conditions.
This thesis is the synthesis of theoretical and experimental works performed in the area of quantum foundations, particularly on quantum correlations and experimental tests of multiplicative Bell inequalities. First we begin with a comprehensive theoretical work performed on the foundations of quantum mechanics, focusing on the puzzling concepts of quantum entanglement, and hidden variable theories. Specifically, we present a broad overview of different classes of hidden variable theories such as local, crypto-nonlocal, contextual and non-local theories, along with several Bell like inequalities for these theories, providing theoretical proofs based on quantum mechanics for the falsification of some of these theories. Second we present a body of experimental, and theoretical works performed on a new class of Bell inequalities, i.e., the multiplicative Bell inequalities. We experimentally report the observation of the Bell parameters close to the Tsirelson (quantum) limit, upto a large number of measurement devices (n)(n)(n), and compare the results with a particular deterministic strategy. We also obtain classical bounds for some nnn, and report the experimental violation of these classical limits. We theoretically derive new richer bounds on the CHSH inequality (named after John Clauser, Michael Horne, Abnor Shimony and Richard Holt) and the multiplicative Bell parameter for n=2n=2n=2, based on the principle of ``relativistic independence'', and experimentally observe the distribution of Bell parameters as predicted by these bounds.
The validity of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (Bell-CHSH) inequality for hidden-variable models of the Bell type and the quantum prediction that said inequality can be violated are two indisputable assertions. However, one can prove wrong the assertion that no hidden-variable model is able to reproduce quantum predictions about the Bell-CHSH test. Here, we reproduce all quantum predictions of Bell-CHSH tests by means of the Bell-Kochen-Specker hidden-variable model for a qubit plus Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen “criterion of physical reality”.
One of the statements one would hear pretty early in any quantum mechanics course is that for quantum particles there are properties which do not have definite values. For example, if we measure |+〉 in standard basis, the best we can do to describe the outcome is to say, that with probability 1/2 we will get 0 and with probability 1/2 we will get 1. Yet one could wonder, is this really the way things are or is it just because our description of this quantum particle is incomplete, but in fact there are some hidden variables inside every quantum system that contain enough information to tell the outcome of measurement (see Fig. 1). However, many people disdain the idea of hidden variables, so there has been rather long history of theorems that forbid theories involving hidden variables. Usually if one wants to prove some no hidden variables theorem he has to assume something about the hidden variables theories he is going to forbid. One of such assumptions is non-contextuality, which means that the outcome we get after measuring with an observable is the same regardless of what other observables we choose to measure at the same time. The first theorem forbidding hidden variables theories is due to von Neumann in 1932. Then for a third of a century everyone cited von Neumann’s work carelessly, till Bell in 1966 indicated that there was an unreasonable assumption in von Neumann’s proof and urged for further examination of the problem (see [6] and [1] for more historical details). Bell also constructed a hidden variables model for one qubit that could assign the outcome of any observable in a way consistent with quantum mechanics. He also proved two theorems that forbid non-contextual hidden variables theories using counterexamples with larger quantum systems. Yet surprisingly he himself thought that hidden variables do exists and considered these theorems only as characterizations of the hidden variables theory we should look for. In this essay we will discuss several versions of one of the two Bell’s theorems. The theorem we will consider was also independently proven by Kochen and Specker in 1967 (see [5]), hence it is called Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem. For shortness and in order not to mix this theorem with another Bell’s theorem from now on we will refer to it as Kochen-Specker theorem. We will be interested in proving several versions of this theorem and the following lemma will turn out to be of great use: