Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Applied Physics Research

Quantum Causality Threshold and Paradoxes

Florentín Smarandache

Published Oct 19, 2010• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper we consider two entangled particles and study all the possibilities: when both are immobile, or oneof them is immobile, or both are moving in different directions, or one of them is moving in a different direction.Then we study the causality between them and the paradoxes, which are generated. We define the CausalityThreshold of a particle A with respect to another particle B.

DOI
10.5539/apr.v2n2p41

Related papers

Quantum Causality

Sergey M. Korotaev, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko

The quantum extension of causal analysis has shown a rich picture of the subsystem causal connections, where the usual intuitive approach is hampered more commonly. The direction of causal connection is determined by the direction of irreversible information flow, and the measure of this connection, called the course of time c 2 , is determined as the velocity of such flow. The absence of causality corresponds to infinite c 2 , accordingly the degree of causal connection is inversely related to c 2 . This formal definition of causality is valid at any time direction. The possibilities of causal analysis have been demonstrated before by series of examples of the two- and three-qubit states. In this paper we consider the new applications. The first one is the application of quantum causal analysis to the asymmetric entangled state under decoherence. Three models of decoherence: dissipation, depolarization and dephasing are studied. For the all models the strength and the direction of induced causality has been computed. It turns out that the decoherence acting along original causality destroys entanglement to a lesser degree than it acting against this causality. The second application is the interaction between a two-level atom and infinite-dimensional quantized mode of a field by Jaynes-Cummings model. An analytical solution of von Neumann equation for different initial states is examined. The filed is considered initially to be in thermal mixed state, while atom – sequentially in excited, ground or thermal states. Negativity, mutual information and causal characteristics for different temperatures are computed. It is obtained that for high temperatures distinction between behaviors of different initial states smoothes over and the state turns out to be causal, entangled and “classical” in entropic sense. And the third application is the teleportation (three-particle protocol). Contrintuitively the teleported qubit is not an effect of the original one; it proves the common effect of both two other ones. But at the same time the result of Bell measurement constitutes a cause with respect to every qubits of entangled pair just since moment of their birth. The latter is manifestation of causality in reverse time.

International Symposium Honoring Mathematical Physicist Jean-Pierre Vigier•Oct 16, 2013•1 citation

Quantum Entanglement and Special Relativity: A Possible Solution to the Paradox?

Yoram Kirsh

Demonstrations of quantum entanglement which confirm the violation of Bell's inequality indicate that under certain conditions action at a distance is possible. This consequence seems to contradict the relativistic principle of causality, which asserts that an effect never precedes its cause, in any reference frame. By analyzing a numerical example of Bell's experiment with entangled pairs of photons, we show how observers in two inertial reference frames can disagree about the causality relation between two events. One observer claims that event 1 is the cause of event 2, while the other claims that event 1 is the result of event 2. The solution we suggest to the paradox is that in entangled systems, one can find pairs of "entangled events" which have symmetrical causality relations. Each of the events can serve as a cause or as an effect, depending on the frame of reference in which they are observed.

arXiv:1811.00378•Oct 29, 2018•0 citations

Entangled Causal Relation in Measurement by Two Measurement Devices Moving Mutually

Narumi Ohkawa

I want to show situations in which causal relation of two events is entangled and similar to time paradox, without employing time machines. Such situations will be obtained in measurement by two measurement devices moving mutually. According to the concept of the collapse of wave packet and the relativity of simultaneity, the causal relation of two measurements can be entangled.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703024•Mar 3, 2007•0 citations

Quantum interference of position and momentum: A particle propagation paradox

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

Optimal simultaneous control of position and momentum can be achieved by maximizing the probabilities of finding their experimentally observed values within two well-defined intervals. The assumption that particles move along straight lines in free space can then be tested by deriving a lower limit for the probability of finding the particle in a corresponding spatial interval at any intermediate time $t$. Here, it is shown that this lower limit can be violated by quantum superpositions of states confined within the respective position and momentum intervals. These violations of the particle propagation inequality show that quantum mechanics changes the laws of motion at a fundamental level, providing a different perspective on causality relations and time evolution in quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1706.04286•Physical Review A•Aug 28, 2017•17 citations

Quantifying Causality in Quantum and General Models

Ding Jia

In studies of entanglement, finding out if a state is entangled and quantifying the amount of entanglement contained in a state are related but different questions. Similarly in studies of causality, finding out the causal structures compatible with a model and quantifying the causal strengths are related but different questions. Recently much research have been directed towards the first question but considerably less attention is paid to the second one. In this paper we propose axioms for all reasonable quantitative measures of causality to obey. The axioms apply to a broad family of operational probabilistic theories with and without definite causal structure. For quantum models, we study causality measures based on one-shot quantum capacities in detail. These measures are used to define the notions of quantum signalling and quantum causality measures in order to quantify quantum causality.

arXiv:1801.06293•Jan 19, 2018•3 citations

Three Paradoxes of Quantum Information

Subhash C. Kak

Three paradoxes of quantum information are presented. These paradoxes concern the final state obtained by applying unitary transformations on a single qubit that belongs to an entangled pair. We show that certain operations appear to yield the same final state for different starting states. Given entangled particles, it is reasonable to apply unitary transformations on any single particle, obtaining the usual predictions for unentangled qubits. The requirements of invertibility mean that transformations on different initial states will lead to different final states. One may view the situation of the entangled particles from two perspectives. In the first, the state of the two particles is considered jointly. In the second perspective, one may consider each particle separately, without the knowledge that it is entangled with another particle. From this perspective, consistency demands that unitary transformations on any one particle will provide the same results as when the particles are unentangled. The paradoxes presented below follow from elementary operations on entangled particles. Some readers may not consider them as true paradoxes, taking them to arise from the manner of the derivation as an artifact of the representation. But the representation used here is the one commonly accepted in quantum information science[1]. The three paradoxes are related and may be considered versions of the same paradox; here I give them separately to highlight different aspects of the underlying problem. Paradox 1 Consider the entangled state 1 √ 2 (|00 〉 + |11〉). Both particles (qubits) have equal probability of being 0 or 1. We may assume that the particles have traveled apart so that one may operate on each separately, without influencing the other. Consider now the unitary transformation H = 1 []

•Apr 9, 2003•1 citation
In this paper we consider two entangled particles and study all the possibilities: when both are immobile, or oneof them is immobile, or both are moving in different directions, or one of them is moving in a different direction.Then we study the causality between them and the paradoxes, which are generated. We define the CausalityThreshold of a particle A with respect to another particle B.
The quantum extension of causal analysis has shown a rich picture of the subsystem causal connections, where the usual intuitive approach is hampered more commonly. The direction of causal connection is determined by the direction of irreversible information flow, and the measure of this connection, called the course of time c 2 , is determined as the velocity of such flow. The absence of causality corresponds to infinite c 2 , accordingly the degree of causal connection is inversely related to c 2 . This formal definition of causality is valid at any time direction. The possibilities of causal analysis have been demonstrated before by series of examples of the two- and three-qubit states. In this paper we consider the new applications. The first one is the application of quantum causal analysis to the asymmetric entangled state under decoherence. Three models of decoherence: dissipation, depolarization and dephasing are studied. For the all models the strength and the direction of induced causality has been computed. It turns out that the decoherence acting along original causality destroys entanglement to a lesser degree than it acting against this causality. The second application is the interaction between a two-level atom and infinite-dimensional quantized mode of a field by Jaynes-Cummings model. An analytical solution of von Neumann equation for different initial states is examined. The filed is considered initially to be in thermal mixed state, while atom – sequentially in excited, ground or thermal states. Negativity, mutual information and causal characteristics for different temperatures are computed. It is obtained that for high temperatures distinction between behaviors of different initial states smoothes over and the state turns out to be causal, entangled and “classical” in entropic sense. And the third application is the teleportation (three-particle protocol). Contrintuitively the teleported qubit is not an effect of the original one; it proves the common effect of both two other ones. But at the same time the result of Bell measurement constitutes a cause with respect to every qubits of entangled pair just since moment of their birth. The latter is manifestation of causality in reverse time.
Demonstrations of quantum entanglement which confirm the violation of Bell's inequality indicate that under certain conditions action at a distance is possible. This consequence seems to contradict the relativistic principle of causality, which asserts that an effect never precedes its cause, in any reference frame. By analyzing a numerical example of Bell's experiment with entangled pairs of photons, we show how observers in two inertial reference frames can disagree about the causality relation between two events. One observer claims that event 1 is the cause of event 2, while the other claims that event 1 is the result of event 2. The solution we suggest to the paradox is that in entangled systems, one can find pairs of "entangled events" which have symmetrical causality relations. Each of the events can serve as a cause or as an effect, depending on the frame of reference in which they are observed.
Optimal simultaneous control of position and momentum can be achieved by maximizing the probabilities of finding their experimentally observed values within two well-defined intervals. The assumption that particles move along straight lines in free space can then be tested by deriving a lower limit for the probability of finding the particle in a corresponding spatial interval at any intermediate time ttt. Here, it is shown that this lower limit can be violated by quantum superpositions of states confined within the respective position and momentum intervals. These violations of the particle propagation inequality show that quantum mechanics changes the laws of motion at a fundamental level, providing a different perspective on causality relations and time evolution in quantum mechanics.
In studies of entanglement, finding out if a state is entangled and quantifying the amount of entanglement contained in a state are related but different questions. Similarly in studies of causality, finding out the causal structures compatible with a model and quantifying the causal strengths are related but different questions. Recently much research have been directed towards the first question but considerably less attention is paid to the second one. In this paper we propose axioms for all reasonable quantitative measures of causality to obey. The axioms apply to a broad family of operational probabilistic theories with and without definite causal structure. For quantum models, we study causality measures based on one-shot quantum capacities in detail. These measures are used to define the notions of quantum signalling and quantum causality measures in order to quantify quantum causality.
Three paradoxes of quantum information are presented. These paradoxes concern the final state obtained by applying unitary transformations on a single qubit that belongs to an entangled pair. We show that certain operations appear to yield the same final state for different starting states. Given entangled particles, it is reasonable to apply unitary transformations on any single particle, obtaining the usual predictions for unentangled qubits. The requirements of invertibility mean that transformations on different initial states will lead to different final states. One may view the situation of the entangled particles from two perspectives. In the first, the state of the two particles is considered jointly. In the second perspective, one may consider each particle separately, without the knowledge that it is entangled with another particle. From this perspective, consistency demands that unitary transformations on any one particle will provide the same results as when the particles are unentangled. The paradoxes presented below follow from elementary operations on entangled particles. Some readers may not consider them as true paradoxes, taking them to arise from the manner of the derivation as an artifact of the representation. But the representation used here is the one commonly accepted in quantum information science[1]. The three paradoxes are related and may be considered versions of the same paradox; here I give them separately to highlight different aspects of the underlying problem. Paradox 1 Consider the entangled state 1 √ 2 (|00 〉 + |11〉). Both particles (qubits) have equal probability of being 0 or 1. We may assume that the particles have traveled apart so that one may operate on each separately, without influencing the other. Consider now the unitary transformation H = 1 []