Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Three Paradoxes of Quantum Information

Subhash C. Kak

Published Apr 9, 2003• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

Three paradoxes of quantum information are presented. These paradoxes concern the final state obtained by applying unitary transformations on a single qubit that belongs to an entangled pair. We show that certain operations appear to yield the same final state for different starting states. Given entangled particles, it is reasonable to apply unitary transformations on any single particle, obtaining the usual predictions for unentangled qubits. The requirements of invertibility mean that transformations on different initial states will lead to different final states. One may view the situation of the entangled particles from two perspectives. In the first, the state of the two particles is considered jointly. In the second perspective, one may consider each particle separately, without the knowledge that it is entangled with another particle. From this perspective, consistency demands that unitary transformations on any one particle will provide the same results as when the particles are unentangled. The paradoxes presented below follow from elementary operations on entangled particles. Some readers may not consider them as true paradoxes, taking them to arise from the manner of the derivation as an artifact of the representation. But the representation used here is the one commonly accepted in quantum information science[1]. The three paradoxes are related and may be considered versions of the same paradox; here I give them separately to highlight different aspects of the underlying problem. Paradox 1 Consider the entangled state 1 √ 2 (|00 〉 + |11〉). Both particles (qubits) have equal probability of being 0 or 1. We may assume that the particles have traveled apart so that one may operate on each separately, without influencing the other. Consider now the unitary transformation H = 1 []

Related papers

Paradox of Quantum Information

Subhash C. Kak

The notion of quantum information related to the two different perspectives of the global and local states is examined. There is circularity in the definition of quantum information because we can speak only of the information of systems that have been specifically prepared. In particular, we examine the final state obtained by applying unitary transformations on a single qubit that belongs to an entangled pair.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304060•Apr 9, 2003•1 citation

Quantum information processing

Stephen Mark Barnett

We have seen how information can be encoded onto a quantum system by selecting the state in which it is prepared. Retrieving the information is achieved by performing a measurement, and the optimal measurement in any given situation is usually a generalized measurement. In between preparation and measurement, the information resides in the quantum state of the system, which evolves in a manner determined by the Hamiltonian. The associated unitary transformation may usefully be viewed as quantum information processing; if we can engineer an appropriate Hamiltonian then we can use the quantum evolution to assist in performing computational tasks. Our objective in quantum information processing is to implement a desired unitary transformation. Typically this will mean coupling together a number, perhaps a large number, of qubits and thereby generating highly entangled states. It is fortunate, although by no means obvious, that we can realize any desired multiqubit unitary transformation as a product of a small selection of simple transformations and, moreover, that each of these need only act on a single qubit or on a pair of qubits. The situation is reminiscent of digital electronics, in which logic operations are decomposed into actions on a small number of bits. If we can realize and control a very large number of such operations in a single device then we have a computer. Similar control of a large number of qubits will constitute a quantum computer. It is the revolutionary potential of quantum computers, more than any other single factor, that has fuelled the recent explosion of interest in our subject. We shall examine the remarkable properties of quantum computers in the next chapter. In digital electronics, we represent bit values by voltages: the logical value 1 is a high voltage (typically +5 V) and 0 is the ground voltage (0 V). The voltage bits are coupled and manipulated by transistor-based devices, or gates. The simplest gates act on only one bit or combine two bits to generate a single new bit, the value of which is determined by the two input bits. For a single bit, with value 0 or 1, the only possible operations are the identity (which does not require a gate) and the bit flip.

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 28, 2009•11 citations

Quantum teleportation of two types of three-qubit states via the W class states

I Nengah Artawan, Agus Purwanto

We propose a quantum teleportation protocol to transmit two types of three-qubit states in the form of both specific three-qubit unentangled states and three-qubit entangled states_by using twofold of three-qubit W class states with Bob’s ancillary particle. This paper shows that Bob’s unitary transformation is performed in two steps. Firstly, we utilize two unitary operations into Bob’s particle. Lastly, a unitary transformation is applied to reconstruct Bob’s information. Both the success probability and fidelity of the protocol can attain the values of one.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2019•1 citation

Two Qubits and Entanglement

Thus far, we have seen how to manipulate, represent, and measure single qubits using linear algebra. However, a single qubit is not useful in itself for solving the difficult problems that quantum computing may be able to tackle. While superposition is an interesting property of qubits, superposition exists classically with waves. Now that we have a better understanding of how quantum mechanics works, we are ready to tackle perhaps one of the strangest phenomena in quantum physics: entanglement. This aspect of quantum computing is completely non-classical and holds the key to solving difficult problems more efficiently. The main goal of this chapter is to discuss the concept of entanglement and see how we can generate Bell states, which are the maximally entangled two-qubit states. Finally, we discuss the famous EPR paradox, which is an interesting thought experiment about entanglement, Bell’s theorem and the resolution to the paradox.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2024•0 citations

About the Nature of Quantum Information

Olímpia Lombardi

Although the interpretation of the concept of information is not clear, even in the classical framework, new interpretive problems have arisen with the advent of the so-called quantum information, which combine the difficulties in understanding the concept of information with the well-known foundational puzzles derived from quantum mechanics itself. The aim of this paper is to consider some arguments traditionally put forward to support the idea that quantum information is qualitatively different from classical information. The final conclusion is that there are no reasons to admit the existence of quantum information as qualitatively different from classical information: there is only one kind of information, physically neutral, which can be encoded by means of classical or quantum states.

International Society for the Study of Information Summit (IS4SI Summit)•Sep 19, 2021•0 citations

Investigating entanglement transformations in three-qubit states

Jiayang Xiao

This thesis studies the manipulation of entanglement in three-qubit quantum systems. I consider the operational setting in which the qubits are distributed to three spatially separated parties. The parties act locally on their quantum systems and share classical communication with one another, a scenario commonly called local operations and classical communication (LOCC). In the LOCC setting, there are two different classes of entanglement in multipartite systems, called the GHZ and W classes, which are inequivalent in the sense that states from one class cannot be transformed into the other without the consumption of additional entanglement. In this thesis, I first show that the LOCC conversion of certain GHZ and W-class states becomes possible by using only one additional ebit (“entangled bit”) of shared entanglement. In many cases, this can be proven as the minimal amount of needed entanglement. I then consider the problem of one-way communication transformations from general three-qubit states into two-qubit maximally entangled states, known as EPR states. An optimal protocol in terms of success probability is provided for W-class states. The success probability of this protocol coincides with the optimal success probability if two of the parties are allowed to act jointly within the same laboratory. In other words, forcing the locality constraint on all three parties does not weaken their capabilities for obtaining bipartite entanglement when starting from a W-class state. I also present that this property holds for certain types of GHZ-class states as well.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations
Three paradoxes of quantum information are presented. These paradoxes concern the final state obtained by applying unitary transformations on a single qubit that belongs to an entangled pair. We show that certain operations appear to yield the same final state for different starting states. Given entangled particles, it is reasonable to apply unitary transformations on any single particle, obtaining the usual predictions for unentangled qubits. The requirements of invertibility mean that transformations on different initial states will lead to different final states. One may view the situation of the entangled particles from two perspectives. In the first, the state of the two particles is considered jointly. In the second perspective, one may consider each particle separately, without the knowledge that it is entangled with another particle. From this perspective, consistency demands that unitary transformations on any one particle will provide the same results as when the particles are unentangled. The paradoxes presented below follow from elementary operations on entangled particles. Some readers may not consider them as true paradoxes, taking them to arise from the manner of the derivation as an artifact of the representation. But the representation used here is the one commonly accepted in quantum information science[1]. The three paradoxes are related and may be considered versions of the same paradox; here I give them separately to highlight different aspects of the underlying problem. Paradox 1 Consider the entangled state 1 √ 2 (|00 〉 + |11〉). Both particles (qubits) have equal probability of being 0 or 1. We may assume that the particles have traveled apart so that one may operate on each separately, without influencing the other. Consider now the unitary transformation H = 1 []
We have seen how information can be encoded onto a quantum system by selecting the state in which it is prepared. Retrieving the information is achieved by performing a measurement, and the optimal measurement in any given situation is usually a generalized measurement. In between preparation and measurement, the information resides in the quantum state of the system, which evolves in a manner determined by the Hamiltonian. The associated unitary transformation may usefully be viewed as quantum information processing; if we can engineer an appropriate Hamiltonian then we can use the quantum evolution to assist in performing computational tasks. Our objective in quantum information processing is to implement a desired unitary transformation. Typically this will mean coupling together a number, perhaps a large number, of qubits and thereby generating highly entangled states. It is fortunate, although by no means obvious, that we can realize any desired multiqubit unitary transformation as a product of a small selection of simple transformations and, moreover, that each of these need only act on a single qubit or on a pair of qubits. The situation is reminiscent of digital electronics, in which logic operations are decomposed into actions on a small number of bits. If we can realize and control a very large number of such operations in a single device then we have a computer. Similar control of a large number of qubits will constitute a quantum computer. It is the revolutionary potential of quantum computers, more than any other single factor, that has fuelled the recent explosion of interest in our subject. We shall examine the remarkable properties of quantum computers in the next chapter. In digital electronics, we represent bit values by voltages: the logical value 1 is a high voltage (typically +5 V) and 0 is the ground voltage (0 V). The voltage bits are coupled and manipulated by transistor-based devices, or gates. The simplest gates act on only one bit or combine two bits to generate a single new bit, the value of which is determined by the two input bits. For a single bit, with value 0 or 1, the only possible operations are the identity (which does not require a gate) and the bit flip.
We propose a quantum teleportation protocol to transmit two types of three-qubit states in the form of both specific three-qubit unentangled states and three-qubit entangled states_by using twofold of three-qubit W class states with Bob’s ancillary particle. This paper shows that Bob’s unitary transformation is performed in two steps. Firstly, we utilize two unitary operations into Bob’s particle. Lastly, a unitary transformation is applied to reconstruct Bob’s information. Both the success probability and fidelity of the protocol can attain the values of one.
Thus far, we have seen how to manipulate, represent, and measure single qubits using linear algebra. However, a single qubit is not useful in itself for solving the difficult problems that quantum computing may be able to tackle. While superposition is an interesting property of qubits, superposition exists classically with waves. Now that we have a better understanding of how quantum mechanics works, we are ready to tackle perhaps one of the strangest phenomena in quantum physics: entanglement. This aspect of quantum computing is completely non-classical and holds the key to solving difficult problems more efficiently. The main goal of this chapter is to discuss the concept of entanglement and see how we can generate Bell states, which are the maximally entangled two-qubit states. Finally, we discuss the famous EPR paradox, which is an interesting thought experiment about entanglement, Bell’s theorem and the resolution to the paradox.
Although the interpretation of the concept of information is not clear, even in the classical framework, new interpretive problems have arisen with the advent of the so-called quantum information, which combine the difficulties in understanding the concept of information with the well-known foundational puzzles derived from quantum mechanics itself. The aim of this paper is to consider some arguments traditionally put forward to support the idea that quantum information is qualitatively different from classical information. The final conclusion is that there are no reasons to admit the existence of quantum information as qualitatively different from classical information: there is only one kind of information, physically neutral, which can be encoded by means of classical or quantum states.
This thesis studies the manipulation of entanglement in three-qubit quantum systems. I consider the operational setting in which the qubits are distributed to three spatially separated parties. The parties act locally on their quantum systems and share classical communication with one another, a scenario commonly called local operations and classical communication (LOCC). In the LOCC setting, there are two different classes of entanglement in multipartite systems, called the GHZ and W classes, which are inequivalent in the sense that states from one class cannot be transformed into the other without the consumption of additional entanglement. In this thesis, I first show that the LOCC conversion of certain GHZ and W-class states becomes possible by using only one additional ebit (“entangled bit”) of shared entanglement. In many cases, this can be proven as the minimal amount of needed entanglement. I then consider the problem of one-way communication transformations from general three-qubit states into two-qubit maximally entangled states, known as EPR states. An optimal protocol in terms of success probability is provided for W-class states. The success probability of this protocol coincides with the optimal success probability if two of the parties are allowed to act jointly within the same laboratory. In other words, forcing the locality constraint on all three parties does not weaken their capabilities for obtaining bipartite entanglement when starting from a W-class state. I also present that this property holds for certain types of GHZ-class states as well.