Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Comment on "TIME OPERATOR": THE CHALLENGE PERSISTS

Jerzy Kijowski, Centrum Fizyki, Teoretycznej Pan

Published Jan 1, 2005• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The criticism formulated by Mielnik and Torres-Vega in their paper, does not apply to my derivation of the time of ar-rival in Quantum Mechanics but to our present understanding of the quantum measurement theory. In paper [1] I have expressed the following opinion: Although, there is no room to modify the mathematically unique definition of the probability QI×D(ψ) within the standard mathemati-cal framework of Quantum Mechanics (spectral measures, self-adjoint operators etc.), the problem is still open from the physical point of view. Indeed, the probabilistic interpretation of the quantum mechan-ics is based on “short ” measurements of the type “What is a proba-bility that the particle will be found within the three-dimensional vol-ume V precisely at a given time instant t? ” How to relate them with “long ” measurements, corresponding to time intervals rather than to time instants t is by no means obvious. Bogdan Mielnik and Gabino Torres-Vega propose a deep analy-sis of conceptual problems which arise when one starts to inter-

Related papers

The problem of time, locality and the interpretation of quantum mechanics

Thomas Thiemann

In this chapter we are going to address the famous ‘problem of time’ which has become the headline for all the physical interpretational problems of the mathematical formalism. Roughly speaking the problem of time is that there is none in GR: at least in the spatially compact case without boundaries the Hamiltonian vanishes on the physical, constraint surface. This is physically relevant because we seem to live in a universe with precisely that spatial topology. Since the Hamiltonian generates time translations in any canonical theory we arrive at the conclusion that ‘nothing moves’ in GR, which is in obvious contradiction to experiment. Since there is no time also the usual interpretation of quantum mechanical measurements at given moments of time breaks down. One can fill books about this issue and we will not even try to cover a substantial amount of the existing literature. A superb source of information on these conceptual problems is Carlo Rovelli's book [3]. Rather, what we will do in what follows is to collect various proposals for solutions to the problem of time taken from other authors, especially Rovelli's relational approach to classical and quantum physics and Hartle et al. 's consistent history interpretation, and combine them into a consistent picture. We do not want to suggest that the resulting picture is to be accepted, rather we want to draw attention to the problems involved and to develop a working hypothesis. The discussion on the interpretation of quantum mechanics is very alive and some authors such as Penrose [243] not only propose to alter the interpretational aspect of quantum mechanics but also the mathematical framework.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 13, 2007•0 citations

A collision problem in the wave mechanics

C. G. DARWIN

Abstract In the present work the wave mechanics are applied to the discussion of a collision problem of a more complicated type than has, I think, hitherto been done. Though there is nothing very new in the process it is rather interesting to see how a wave function behaves which involves two bodies, and is therefore outside our ordinary space intuitions. But the work had a much more general aim, as an attempt to see whether a sharper line of demarcation could be drawn between the particle-like and the wave-like properties of matter. Put briefly, I take a problem which would be regarded at first sight as irreconcilable with a pure wave theory, but thoroughly typical of the behaviour of particles, and show how in fact the correct result arises naturally from the consideration of wave alone. I have been led in this way to certain not very original speculation on the basis of the quantum theory and these are given at the end of the paper. These are not in the least intended to be a general formulation of the theory, but rather as an examination of a particular type of attempted formulation. I fear that the views expressed will be found partly obvious and perhaps partly inconsistent or even erroneous. My excuse for giving them is that the quantum theory seem already sufficiently developed for us to attempt something more than a mathematical formulation of it, and that a generally accepted physical understanding will be more quickly reached by agreement or disagreement with expressed opinions, than by waiting for the arrival of a full-grown theory. It has been an extraordinarily difficult task to express the ideas I intended, and I wish to thank Prof. D. R. Hartree for many valuable criticisms of my first attempts to do so, though he must be exonerated from all blame if the final result is unintelligible or erroneous. 1. The quantum mechanics have been expressed in a variety of ways, which place the emphasis differently, but it has been shown that they are all exactly equivalent, so what may choose which we will. I shall use the following description, limiting myself to the simpler cases which do not involve considerations of relativity. We take a partial differential equation of the wave type, set down according to certain rules depending on the particular system considered. We solve this subject to certain boundary conditions, expressive of all the limitations imposed by silts, mirrors, diffraction, gratings, moving shutters, etc., that may occur in the proposed system, and obtain as result the wave function Ψ, a function of all the co-ordinates of the system and of the time. From this we from a set of functions, of which the simplest is |Ψ|2; this process may be called taking the intensities. We next have to prepare for the particle aspect, by applying certain rules so as to normalise the intensities, a process entirely foreign to the idea of waves. Finally, we make the interpretation, in which we say that the normalised intensities measure the probability of the particles having such and such positions, momenta, energies, etc., and these are the results verified by observation.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Jun 4, 1929•49 citations

The bare necessities of a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory

Gerd Niestegge

What are the minimal requirements for a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory or a potential extension? In addressing this question, rather than relying on the generalized probabilistic theories or other usual approaches, we propose a reset based on the following fundamental features: transition probabilities, which are typical of quantum theory, and continuous reversible dynamical processes (e.g., represented by a Lie group), which play the same crucial role in classical as well as in quantum physics. In doing so, we get back to the very elementary transition probability space framework originally introduced by Bogdan Mielnik in 1968 and combine it with the continuous reversibility condition. The primary class of valid spaces arises from the irreducible atomic JBW algebras, which encompass the irreducible atomic von Neumann algebras and the Jordan matrix algebras. The von Neumann algebras represent the model of common quantum theory. Beyond these, there is a non-standard valid space, where the exceptional Lie group $E_6$ acts transitively. While $E_6$ has been proposed as a candidate for internal symmetries in particle physics, we highlight that this model deviates from standard quantum theory in critical ways. Specifically, it fails to guarantee the existence of post-measurement states in all situations. Though the above postulates are powerful, they still allow for some physically meaningless models. A further feature of quantum theory (the correspondence between the pure states and the minimal projections) leads us to an additional requirement that rules out these models. However, a complete classification of the valid models remains one of the open issues, pointed out in the paper, which is intended for the mathematical and physical experts, inspiring them to tackle these problems.

quant-pharXiv:2607.24474•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations

"Time operator": the challenge persists

Bogdan Mielnik, Gabino Torres-Vega

Contrary to the conviction expressed by J. Kijowski [Phys. Rev. A 59, 897 (1999)] and shared in some other papers, the reasons to look for the 'time operator' in the context of the standard quantum doctrine of orthogonal projectors and self-adjoint observables are highly questionable. Some improved solutions in terms of POV measures invite critical discussions as well.

arXiv:1112.4198•Dec 18, 2011•18 citations

On Time in Quantum Physics

Jeremy Butterfield

First, I briefly review the different conceptions of time held by three rival interpretations of quantum theory: the collapse of the wave-packet, the pilot-wave interpretation, and the Everett interpretation (Section 2). Then I turn to a much less controversial task: to expound the recent understanding of the time-energy uncertainty principle, and indeed of uncertainty principles in general, that has been established by such authors as Busch, Hilgevoord and Uffink. Although this may at first seem a narrow topic, I point out connections to other conceptual topics about time in quantum theory: for example, the question under what circumstances there is a time operator (Section 4.3).

arXiv:1406.4745•Wiley eBooks•Jan 29, 2013•31 citations

Wavefunctions on phase space

T B Smith

Theories of Torres-Vega and Fredrick (1993 J. Chem. Phys. 98 3103), Harriman (1994 J. Chem. Phys. 100 3651) and of Ban (1998 J. Math. Phys. 39 1744), in which phase space points ( p , q ) are used as configurational variables to formulate quantum mechanics are considered from the standpoint of a class of quantization schemes associating phase space functions with operators. The connection between these schemes and the theories given in Torres-Vega and Fredrick (1993 J. Chem. Phys. 98 3103), Harriman (1994 J. Chem. Phys. 100 3651), Dirac (1930 The Principles of Quantum Mechanics (Oxford: Oxford University Press)), Møller, Jørgensen and Torres-Vega (1997 J. Chem. Phys. 106 7228), Klauder and Skagerstam (1985 Coherent States: Applications in Physics and Mathematical Physics (Singapore: World Scientific)), Li, Wei and Lü (2004 Phys. Rev. A 70 022105), Ban (1998 J. Math. Phys. 39 1744) is made by means of augmented wavefunctions ψ (λ) σ ( p , q ; t ), where λ = 0 corresponds to the ordering of Wigner and Weyl. For that case we use these functions to define a family of positive operator-valued measures for the phase angle of an harmonic oscillator.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 24, 2006•12 citations
The criticism formulated by Mielnik and Torres-Vega in their paper, does not apply to my derivation of the time of ar-rival in Quantum Mechanics but to our present understanding of the quantum measurement theory. In paper [1] I have expressed the following opinion: Although, there is no room to modify the mathematically unique definition of the probability QI×D(ψ) within the standard mathemati-cal framework of Quantum Mechanics (spectral measures, self-adjoint operators etc.), the problem is still open from the physical point of view. Indeed, the probabilistic interpretation of the quantum mechan-ics is based on “short ” measurements of the type “What is a proba-bility that the particle will be found within the three-dimensional vol-ume V precisely at a given time instant t? ” How to relate them with “long ” measurements, corresponding to time intervals rather than to time instants t is by no means obvious. Bogdan Mielnik and Gabino Torres-Vega propose a deep analy-sis of conceptual problems which arise when one starts to inter-
In this chapter we are going to address the famous ‘problem of time’ which has become the headline for all the physical interpretational problems of the mathematical formalism. Roughly speaking the problem of time is that there is none in GR: at least in the spatially compact case without boundaries the Hamiltonian vanishes on the physical, constraint surface. This is physically relevant because we seem to live in a universe with precisely that spatial topology. Since the Hamiltonian generates time translations in any canonical theory we arrive at the conclusion that ‘nothing moves’ in GR, which is in obvious contradiction to experiment. Since there is no time also the usual interpretation of quantum mechanical measurements at given moments of time breaks down. One can fill books about this issue and we will not even try to cover a substantial amount of the existing literature. A superb source of information on these conceptual problems is Carlo Rovelli's book [3]. Rather, what we will do in what follows is to collect various proposals for solutions to the problem of time taken from other authors, especially Rovelli's relational approach to classical and quantum physics and Hartle et al. 's consistent history interpretation, and combine them into a consistent picture. We do not want to suggest that the resulting picture is to be accepted, rather we want to draw attention to the problems involved and to develop a working hypothesis. The discussion on the interpretation of quantum mechanics is very alive and some authors such as Penrose [243] not only propose to alter the interpretational aspect of quantum mechanics but also the mathematical framework.
Abstract In the present work the wave mechanics are applied to the discussion of a collision problem of a more complicated type than has, I think, hitherto been done. Though there is nothing very new in the process it is rather interesting to see how a wave function behaves which involves two bodies, and is therefore outside our ordinary space intuitions. But the work had a much more general aim, as an attempt to see whether a sharper line of demarcation could be drawn between the particle-like and the wave-like properties of matter. Put briefly, I take a problem which would be regarded at first sight as irreconcilable with a pure wave theory, but thoroughly typical of the behaviour of particles, and show how in fact the correct result arises naturally from the consideration of wave alone. I have been led in this way to certain not very original speculation on the basis of the quantum theory and these are given at the end of the paper. These are not in the least intended to be a general formulation of the theory, but rather as an examination of a particular type of attempted formulation. I fear that the views expressed will be found partly obvious and perhaps partly inconsistent or even erroneous. My excuse for giving them is that the quantum theory seem already sufficiently developed for us to attempt something more than a mathematical formulation of it, and that a generally accepted physical understanding will be more quickly reached by agreement or disagreement with expressed opinions, than by waiting for the arrival of a full-grown theory. It has been an extraordinarily difficult task to express the ideas I intended, and I wish to thank Prof. D. R. Hartree for many valuable criticisms of my first attempts to do so, though he must be exonerated from all blame if the final result is unintelligible or erroneous. 1. The quantum mechanics have been expressed in a variety of ways, which place the emphasis differently, but it has been shown that they are all exactly equivalent, so what may choose which we will. I shall use the following description, limiting myself to the simpler cases which do not involve considerations of relativity. We take a partial differential equation of the wave type, set down according to certain rules depending on the particular system considered. We solve this subject to certain boundary conditions, expressive of all the limitations imposed by silts, mirrors, diffraction, gratings, moving shutters, etc., that may occur in the proposed system, and obtain as result the wave function Ψ, a function of all the co-ordinates of the system and of the time. From this we from a set of functions, of which the simplest is |Ψ|2; this process may be called taking the intensities. We next have to prepare for the particle aspect, by applying certain rules so as to normalise the intensities, a process entirely foreign to the idea of waves. Finally, we make the interpretation, in which we say that the normalised intensities measure the probability of the particles having such and such positions, momenta, energies, etc., and these are the results verified by observation.
What are the minimal requirements for a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory or a potential extension? In addressing this question, rather than relying on the generalized probabilistic theories or other usual approaches, we propose a reset based on the following fundamental features: transition probabilities, which are typical of quantum theory, and continuous reversible dynamical processes (e.g., represented by a Lie group), which play the same crucial role in classical as well as in quantum physics. In doing so, we get back to the very elementary transition probability space framework originally introduced by Bogdan Mielnik in 1968 and combine it with the continuous reversibility condition. The primary class of valid spaces arises from the irreducible atomic JBW algebras, which encompass the irreducible atomic von Neumann algebras and the Jordan matrix algebras. The von Neumann algebras represent the model of common quantum theory. Beyond these, there is a non-standard valid space, where the exceptional Lie group E6E_6E6​ acts transitively. While E6E_6E6​ has been proposed as a candidate for internal symmetries in particle physics, we highlight that this model deviates from standard quantum theory in critical ways. Specifically, it fails to guarantee the existence of post-measurement states in all situations. Though the above postulates are powerful, they still allow for some physically meaningless models. A further feature of quantum theory (the correspondence between the pure states and the minimal projections) leads us to an additional requirement that rules out these models. However, a complete classification of the valid models remains one of the open issues, pointed out in the paper, which is intended for the mathematical and physical experts, inspiring them to tackle these problems.
First, I briefly review the different conceptions of time held by three rival interpretations of quantum theory: the collapse of the wave-packet, the pilot-wave interpretation, and the Everett interpretation (Section 2). Then I turn to a much less controversial task: to expound the recent understanding of the time-energy uncertainty principle, and indeed of uncertainty principles in general, that has been established by such authors as Busch, Hilgevoord and Uffink. Although this may at first seem a narrow topic, I point out connections to other conceptual topics about time in quantum theory: for example, the question under what circumstances there is a time operator (Section 4.3).
Theories of Torres-Vega and Fredrick (1993 J. Chem. Phys. 98 3103), Harriman (1994 J. Chem. Phys. 100 3651) and of Ban (1998 J. Math. Phys. 39 1744), in which phase space points ( p , q ) are used as configurational variables to formulate quantum mechanics are considered from the standpoint of a class of quantization schemes associating phase space functions with operators. The connection between these schemes and the theories given in Torres-Vega and Fredrick (1993 J. Chem. Phys. 98 3103), Harriman (1994 J. Chem. Phys. 100 3651), Dirac (1930 The Principles of Quantum Mechanics (Oxford: Oxford University Press)), Møller, Jørgensen and Torres-Vega (1997 J. Chem. Phys. 106 7228), Klauder and Skagerstam (1985 Coherent States: Applications in Physics and Mathematical Physics (Singapore: World Scientific)), Li, Wei and Lü (2004 Phys. Rev. A 70 022105), Ban (1998 J. Math. Phys. 39 1744) is made by means of augmented wavefunctions ψ (λ) σ ( p , q ; t ), where λ = 0 corresponds to the ordering of Wigner and Weyl. For that case we use these functions to define a family of positive operator-valued measures for the phase angle of an harmonic oscillator.