Unprincipling Heisenberg’s uncertainties
Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond
The first part of this paper is a critical essay on the conceptual meaning of the so-called « Uncertainty principle ». It will be stressed that there is no independent principle underlying the Heisenberg’s inequalities as they derive from the fundamental theoretical structure of quantum theory. More to the point, it will be emphasized that the term « uncertainty » is a misnomer, leading to subjective interpretations about the limits of our knowledge. Recognizing at face value the conceptual nature of quantum physical quantities, as endowed with a spectrum of numerical values, one should rather call « dispersions », « extensions » or « spectrum widths » the magnitudes entering Heisenberg’s type inequalities. A historical inquiry about the origins of the conventional terminology, from German to other languages, will reveal the roots and extent of the confusion. The second part of the paper will review and assess many of the various formal definitions leading to Heisenberg’s type inequalities, well beyond the pairs of physical quantities, such as the position and velocity of a particle and the customary use of quadratic dispersions. Some still open issues, such as the time-energy inequality or the angle-phase inequality will be briefly discussed. A sobering conclusion will assess the concrete uses of Heisenberg’s inequalities and stress that their genuine relevance and indisputable importance lie mainly at the heuristic and qualitative level, thus somewhat reducing the interest of the continuous discussions concerning their mathematical validity and philosophical interpretation.
WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations