In this paper we study three aspects of generalized classical and operator theories, herein generically called deformations, which do not appear to have propagated in the rather vast literature in the field: (1) the first known studies on classical and operator deformations; (2) their rather serious physical and mathematical shortcomings due to lack of invariance when conventionally formulated; and (3) the ongoing efforts for the achievement of invariant formulations preserving the axiomatic consistency of the original theories. We begin by recalling the mathematical beauty, axiomatic consistency and experimental verifications of the special relativity at both classical and quantum levels, and its main axiomatic properties: universal invariance of the fundamental units of space and time; preservation of hermiticity-observability at all times; uniqueness and invariance of numerical predictions; and other known properties. We then review the first known, generally ignored, classical and operator deformations. We then study the generally ignored problematic aspects of classical and operator deformations in their current formulation which include: lack of invariance of the fundamental units of space and times with consequential inapplicability to real measurements; loss of observability in time; lack of uniqueness and invariance of numerical predictions; violation of causality and probability laws; and, above all, violation of Einstein's special relativity. We finally outline the generally ignored ongoing efforts for the resolutions of the above shortcomings, and show that they require the necessary use of new mathematics specifically constructed for the task. We finally present a systematic study for the identical reformulation of existing classical and operator deformations in an invariant form.
In this paper we study three aspects of generalized classical and operator theories, herein generically called deformations, which do not appear to have propagated in the rather vast literature in the field: (1) the first known studies on classical and operator deformations; (2) their rather serious physical and mathematical shortcomings due to lack of invariance when conventionally formulated; and (3) the ongoing efforts for the achievement of invariant formulations preserving the axiomatic consistency of the original theories. We begin by recalling the mathematical beauty, axiomatic consistency and experimental verifications of the special relativity at both classical and quantum levels, and its main axiomatic properties: universal invariance of the fundamental units of space and time; preservation of hermiticity-observability at all times; uniqueness and invariance of numerical predictions; and other known properties. We then review the first known, generally ignored, classical and operator deformations. We then study the generally ignored problematic aspects of classical and operator deformations in their current formulation which include: lack of invariance of the fundamental units of space and times with consequential inapplicability to real measurements; loss of observability in time; lack of uniqueness and invariance of numerical predictions; violation of causality and probability laws; and, above all, violation of Einstein's special relativity. We finally outline the generally ignored ongoing efforts for the resolutions of the above shortcomings, and show that they require the necessary use of new mathematics specifically constructed for the task. We finally present a systematic study for the identical reformulation of existing classical and operator deformations in an invariant form.
One of the unsolved problem in theoretical physics during some decades remains a construction of the complete and closed theory in which quantum mechanics and special relativity would be consistent without divergences and renormalization (Dirac, 1978). It may be assumed that divergences show conservation laws violation in the conventional theories, and a cause for it may be in turn violation of the group-theoretic principles in these theories, in accordance with the Noether theorems. A success of renormalization allows one to believe that the theory without divergences is possible. This paper is devoted to consideration of possibility to develop the consistent group-theoretic scheme of the quantum mechanics merely. It consists of Introduction, three parts, and Conclusion. The requirements which allow one to consider the quantum mechanics as a consistent group-theoretic theory are formulated in Introduction. The Noether theorems set one-to-one correspondence between conservation laws of the variables to be measured, i.e. observables (Dirac, 1958), and groups of symmetries of the solutions transformations of equations for complex wave functions, spinors, matrices and so on in which the space-time properties appear (Olver, 1986). These solutions do not obey to be an observables but the last ones may be constructed as the Hermitian forms corresponding to these observables on their basis. The mathematical tool to express the space-time symmetry properties is the group theory. Two circumstances connected with the stated above attract attention in the generally accepted schemes of the quantum mechanics. The exact conservation laws fulfilment is inconceivable in any theoretical scheme under absence of the complete set of the Hermitian forms, based on the main equations solutions and its derivatives, each of them would be corresponded to the observables. Some of these Hermitian forms have to be conserved, another have to be changed but all of them have to satisfy to some completeness condition expressed mathematically. The last subject has exceptional significance since if only some part of the unknown complete set of observables really existing is included into the theory, then both physical interpretation and conservation laws would be dependent on the Hermitian forms which are excluded from the theory. Of course, such theory can not be recognized to be the consecutive, complete and closed theory. One of the impressive consequence of the observables complete set and corresponding completeness condition absence is the well known question on the hidden parameters 13
This paper presents a comparison of the conceptual bases of the quantum theory and the theory of relativity, each considered as fundamental theories of elementary matter. From a study of the irreducible axiomatic bases of these respective approaches to elementary matter, it is concluded that they cannot peacefully co-exist because of logical incompatibility. Among the reasons discussed for this conclusion, one is the implication of the Hamiltonian form of quantum mechanics yielding an irreducible absolute frame of reference - that of the measuring apparatus - in the basic expression for the laws of elementary particles. This difficulty leads to logical inconsistency as well as a formulation of relativistic quantum field theory that is not demonstrably mathematically consistent. In spite of their logical incompatiability, it is argued that each of these theories logically requires the other, within its own framework. The conclusion is reached that, to make further progress in our understanding of elementary matter, it is necessary to abandon the axiomatic basis of one of these theories for the other, while keeping the formal structure of the abandoned theory as an accurate mathematical approximation (under special physical conditions) for a generalized form of the retained theory. An argument is presentedmore » for the author's retention of the theory of relativity as an authentic basis of elementary matter, and how its generalization is achieved by incorporating a fully (generally) covariant expression of the inertial manifestations of matter with its force manifestations.« less
This paper presents a complete and verifiable theoretical framework that unifies quantum mechanics and classical physics/general relativity under a single mathematical function: H(S,θ,K)=Fclassical(S)⋅Q(θ)+∇K⋅(ΠK[δS])H(S,θ,K)=Fclassical(S)⋅Q(θ)+∇K⋅(ΠK[δS]) We propose that quantum mechanics is not a fundamental separate theory, but rather a structural regulatory mechanism activated by specific boundary conditions within a fundamental continuous space-time. The theory introduces three core components: S: A unified continuous structural field representing both space-time and matter Q(θ): A context-dependent switching function that transitions between classical (Q=1) and quantum (Q=0) regimes K: An inherent geometric framework that governs all structural deformations The theory operates through three mathematically rigorous conditions: Pure Quantum Space (Q=0): Geometric deformations dominate via K Classical Physics + GR (Q=1): Reduces exactly to Einstein/Newton equations Local Quantum Effects (0<Q<1): Hybrid regime preserving fundamental constants Key innovations include: Resolution of the measurement problem through natural θ-transitions Preservation of all classical laws (c, G, ħ) as global constants Elimination of the quantum-gravity coupling problem Falsifiable predictions through approximate self-similarity analysis We propose three mathematical candidates for K (E₈ symmetry, Hodge-Laplacian, Spin Network) with specific experimental predictions in atomic spectra, optomechanics, and black hole entropy. The theory provides a concrete research program for 2026-2030, transitioning physics from fragmented descriptions to a unified dynamical system. This work represents not just an equation, but an ecosystem for unified physics—a testable speculative paradigm that enriches theoretical discourse regardless of its ultimate verification status.
Quantum mechanics (QM) is not just a theory of micro-objects: it is our current fundamental theory of motion. It expresses a deeper understanding of Nature than classical mechanics. Precisely as classical mechanics, the conventional formulation of QM describes evolution of states and observables in time. Precisely as classical mechanics, this is not sufficient to deal with general relativistic systems, because these systems do not describe evolution in time; they describe correlations between observables. Therefore, a formulation of QM slightly more general than the conventional one – or a quantum version of the relativistic classical mechanics discussed in the previous chapter – is needed. In this chapter I discuss the possibility of such a formulation. In the last section I discuss the general physical interpretation of QM.QM can be formulated in a number of more or less equivalent formalisms: canonical (Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators), covariant (Feynman's sum-over-histories), algebraic (states as linear functionals over an abstract algebra of observables) and others. Generally, but not always, we are able to translate these formalisms into one another, but often what is easy in one formulation is difficult in another. A generalrelativistic sum-over-histories formalism has been developed by Jim Hartle. Here I focus on the canonical formalism, because the canonical formalism has provided the mathematical completeness and precision needed to explicitly construct the mathematical apparatus of quantum gravity. Later I will consider alternative formalisms.
The concept of physical object in twentieth century's physical theories (relativity and quanta) turns from intuitive-substantial to formal-functional, that is to a relatively invariable properties system well beyond the intuitive properties “carrier” typical of classical physics (CP). Anyway, the autonomous heuristic fecundity of this formal mathematical model neither was fully shown before the twentieth century nor, moreover, is independent of the properties it correlates. In quantum mechanics (QM) the turn to such purely functional correlation, which is nevertheless irreducible to mere information related to measurements, is historically evidenced by the fact that the formalization of the theory as an operator calculus in Hilbert space came before its physical interpretation. Dirac, moreover, asserted the irreducibility of quantum properties to mere measurements, just because this simply pragmatic reduction is poor and ambiguous in front of a mathematical formulation of linguistically expressible (even though not always experimentally decidable) properties. Neither a falsificationist interpretation of scientific theories, which makes them empirically decidable even though irreducible to mere instrumental theories, fits the purpose. It is then safer, and in better agreement with historical testimony, to admit not only the existence of properties which are measurable and reducible to instrumental operations, or at least falsifiable, but also the existence of properties which are physically inaccessible or empirically untestable, since properties of this kind are described and fruitfully implied by the mathematical model.
Understanding whether the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics is fundamental or emergent remains a central question in the foundations of physics. In particular, the special role played by time in quantum theory, appearing as an external evolution parameter rather than a dynamical observable, suggests that the formalism itself may arise from deeper structural considerations. In this work, we investigate the emergence of quantum mechanical formalism from classical wave dynamics by adopting a dimensional framework in which time is treated as a +1 evolution parameter relative to the dimensions through which physical phenomena (fields or disturbances of a field) propagate and interact. Within this perspective, different fields may evolve with respect to different effective dimensions, while remaining embedded in a common higher-dimensional space, allowing time to acquire a relational and context-dependent role. This means that in our proposed model, time is not a fixed dimension which is experienced the same way for every field or field interaction of any dimensionality. In that sense, time for one physical phenomenon can behave as space for a higher dimensional physical phenomenon, whose time is a different +1 dimension. The central objective of this paper is to determine how a higher-dimensional deterministic field can be consistently represented by a lower-dimensional description that lacks direct access to its full set of evolution parameters and evolves through a spatial (for the higher-dimensional field) dimension. To this end, we introduce a general projection framework in which a higher-dimensional field is mapped to a reduced field through an interaction-based recording process. Crucially, we do not assume the form of this mapping a priori. Instead, we impose the requirement that it preserve the maximum amount of physically accessible information. In particular, we demand the faithful encoding of phase relations, interference structure, and spectral composition, including the relative contributions of different Fourier modes and their superposition. We first demonstrate, within a purely classical 3 + 1-dimensional wave framework that these constraints severely restrict the admissible form of the reduced description and naturally lead to complex amplitudes, linear superposition, Hilbert space structure, and canonical operator relations. This analysis provides an intuitive and mathematically explicit route to quantum-like descriptions without assuming quantum postulates. We then generalize the construction to a 4 + 1-dimensional framework, introducing an additional evolution parameter and showing that under the same information-preserving constraints, the Schrödinger equation appears as an effective low-energy description of the reduced dynamics, while a relativistic dispersion relation emerges simultaneously through the encoding of the hidden evolution parameter as an invariant frequency scale. In this way, within the restricted single-field and free-dynamical sector considered here, quantum-compatible kinematical structures and relativistic dispersion arise from the same underlying requirement: the consistent and information-preserving representation of higher-dimensional wave propagation in a lower-dimensional observational framework. The present construction motivates a complex linear state space, an invariant quadratic norm, translation-generated canonical operator relations, norm-preserving evolution, and a Schrödinger-type low-energy equation, while composite-system structure, particle statistics or interacting multiparticle dynamics remain necessary subjects for future development. The results suggest that the formal structure of quantum mechanics need not be postulated a priori, but may instead be understood as the unique mathematical language required to encode the observable remnant of a higher-dimensional deterministic dynamics under strict constraints of symmetry, invariance, and information preservation.