Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions

MATHEMATICAL MODELS AND PHYSICAL REALITY FROM CLASSICAL TO QUANTUM PHYSICS

Arcangelo Rossi

Published Jun 1, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The concept of physical object in twentieth century's physical theories (relativity and quanta) turns from intuitive-substantial to formal-functional, that is to a relatively invariable properties system well beyond the intuitive properties “carrier” typical of classical physics (CP). Anyway, the autonomous heuristic fecundity of this formal mathematical model neither was fully shown before the twentieth century nor, moreover, is independent of the properties it correlates. In quantum mechanics (QM) the turn to such purely functional correlation, which is nevertheless irreducible to mere information related to measurements, is historically evidenced by the fact that the formalization of the theory as an operator calculus in Hilbert space came before its physical interpretation. Dirac, moreover, asserted the irreducibility of quantum properties to mere measurements, just because this simply pragmatic reduction is poor and ambiguous in front of a mathematical formulation of linguistically expressible (even though not always experimentally decidable) properties. Neither a falsificationist interpretation of scientific theories, which makes them empirically decidable even though irreducible to mere instrumental theories, fits the purpose. It is then safer, and in better agreement with historical testimony, to admit not only the existence of properties which are measurable and reducible to instrumental operations, or at least falsifiable, but also the existence of properties which are physically inaccessible or empirically untestable, since properties of this kind are described and fruitfully implied by the mathematical model.

DOI
10.1142/9789812773258_0025

Related papers

The Art and Science of Experimentation in Quantum Physics

Arkady Plotnitsky, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Taking its historical point of departure in Heisenberg’s work, this article offers a view of quantum mechanics as, arguably, the first truly experimental and truly mathematical physical theory, that is, a theory concerned with experimenting with nature and mathematics alike. It is truly experimental because it is not, as in classical physics, merely the independent behavior of the system considered, in other words, what happens in any event, that we track, but what kind of experiments we perform that defines what happens. By the same token, the theory is also truly mathematical because, at least in the interpretation adopted here, its mathematical formalism does not stand in the service of a mathematical description of (quantum) physical processes in space and time in the way the formalism of classical physics does, but is only used to predict the outcomes of relevant experiments. It also follows that quantum theories experiment more freely with mathematics itself, since we invent predictive mathematical schemes, rather than proceed by refining mathematically our phenomenal representations of nature, which process constrains us in classical mechanics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

Are quantum-mechanical-like models possible, or necessary, outside quantum physics?

Arkady Plotnitsky

This article examines some experimental conditions that invite and possibly require recourse to quantum-mechanical-like mathematical models (QMLMs), models based on the key mathematical features of quantum mechanics, in scientific fields outside physics, such as biology, cognitive psychology, or economics. In particular, I consider whether the following two correlative features of quantum phenomena that were decisive for establishing the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics play similarly important roles in QMLMs elsewhere. The first is the individuality and discreteness of quantum phenomena, and the second is the irreducibly probabilistic nature of our predictions concerning them, coupled to the particular character of the probabilities involved, as different from the character of probabilities found in classical physics. I also argue that these features could be interpreted in terms of a particular form of epistemology that suspends and even precludes a causal and, in the first place, realist description of quantum objects and processes. This epistemology limits the descriptive capacity of quantum theory to the description, classical in nature, of the observed quantum phenomena manifested in measuring instruments. Quantum mechanics itself only provides descriptions, probabilistic in nature, concerning numerical data pertaining to such phenomena, without offering a physical description of quantum objects and processes. While QMLMs share their use of the quantum-mechanical or analogous mathematical formalism, they may differ by the roles, if any, the two features in question play in them and by different ways of interpreting the phenomena they considered and this formalism itself. This article will address those differences as well.

Physica Scripta•Dec 1, 2014•21 citations

On Mathematical Modeling Of Quantum Systems

P. Achuthan, Narayanankutty Karuppath, A. H. Siddiqi +2 more

The world of physical systems at the most fundamental levels is replete with efficient, interesting models possessing sufficient ability to represent the reality to a considerable extent. So far, quantum mechanics (QM) forming the basis of almost all natural phenomena, has found beyond doubt its intrinsic ingenuity, capacity and robustness to stand the rigorous tests of validity from and through appropriate calculations and experiments. No serious failures of quantum mechanical predictions have been reported, yet. However, Albert Einstein, the greatest theoretical physicist of the twentieth century and some other eminent men of science have stated firmly and categorically that QM, though successful by and large, is incomplete. There are classical and quantum reality models including those based on consciousness. Relativistic quantum theoretical approaches to clearly understand the ultimate nature of matter as well as radiation have still much to accomplish in order to qualify for a final theory of everything (TOE). Mathematical models of better, suitable character as also strength are needed to achieve satisfactory explanation of natural processes and phenomena. We, in this paper, discuss some of these matters with certain apt illustrations as well.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2009•1 citation

Mixed States and POVMs

George Jaroszkiewicz

Introduction As the decades of the twentieth century rolled on, quantum mechanics (QM) became more and more sophisticated and mathematical. Understanding what this theory means intuitively was confounded not only by nonclassical concepts such as wave–particle duality and quantum interference, but also by issues to do with observation. The Newtonian classical mechanics (CM) paradigm of reality, wherein reductionist laws of physics describe observer-independent dynamics of systems under observation (SUOs) with observer-independent properties, was found to be inadequate. Quantum theorists were confronted with the measurement problem , which attempts to understand, explain, and rationalize the laws of QM that underpin the processes of observation that go on in the laboratory. They are not the same as those of CM in several puzzling respects. Historically, the first sign of the measurement problem was Planck's quantization of energy (Planck, 1900b) and the second was Bohr's veto on radiation damping in hydrogen (Bohr, 1913). These occurred in the first quarter of the twentieth century, a period in physics often referred to as Old Quantum Mechanics . Another indicator that intuition was inadequate was Born's interpretation of the squared modulus of the Schrödinger wave function as a probability density (Born, 1926). That interpretation has everything to do with observers and observation, because probability without an observer is a vacuous concept. Eventually, the projection-valued measure (PVM) formalism emerged, championed by von Neumann in an influential book on the mathematical formulation of QM (von Neumann, 1955). Subsequently, pioneers such as Ludwig (Ludwig, 1983a,b) and Kraus (Kraus, 1974, 1983) refined the theory into the general positive operator-valued measure (POVM) formalism that we shall discuss and use. The quantized detector network (QDN) approach to quantum experiments is most naturally expressed in the PVM formalism, as QDN focuses on the individual detectors in the laboratory. However, the POVM formalism is more general than the PVM formalism, giving a description of multiple detector processes similar to QDN. This raises the question of how the two approaches, QDN and POVM, are related. The aim of this chapter is to explore this relationship. Before we review the PVM and POVM formalisms, we review some essential mathematical concepts.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2017•0 citations

MINIMAL LENGTH, MODAL BOUNDARIES, AND PHYSICAL LOCALIZABILITY

Vidamor Cabannas

The 1995 article by Achim Kempf, Gianpiero Mangano, and Robert B. Mann, “Hilbert Space Representation of the Minimal Length Uncertainty Relation,” constitutes one of the most important formal constructions through which a nonzero minimal uncertainty in position can be incorporated into quantum mechanics. Rather than representing a fundamental length merely as a discrete lattice imposed upon ordinary space, Kempf, Mangano, and Mann modify the canonical commutation relation and construct a Hilbert- space representation in which arbitrarily precise physical localization is excluded. Their framework yields a minimal position uncertainty, modifies the mathematical status of exact-position states, introduces maximally localized states and a quasi-position representation, and, in multidimensional formulations, leads to noncommuting position coordinates. The original article was published in Physical Review D, volume 52, pages 1108–1118, DOI https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.52.1108 (Kempf, Mangano, and Mann, 1995). This article develops a critical–propositional analysis of that framework in dia- logue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO), particularly its Seven Absolute Truths, its interpretation of logical Nothingness, the concept of individualizing fields, the onto- logical status attributed to infinity, the role of boundaries and interfaces, nonhuman relational observation, compositional emergence, and the transcendent element under- stood in TO as knowledge or information produced in atomic relations and considered equivalent to atomic radiation. Special attention is given to the foundational TO work A Esfera Perfeita (The Perfect Sphere), because the KMM minimal-localization structure provides an especially useful mathematical dialogue partner for a TO conception of a limiting physical scale. The central thesis developed here is deliberately restricted. Kempf, Mangano, and Mann do not demonstrate the Theory of Objectivity, do not derive its cosmogony, do not establish the individual magnetic field asserted by its Second Absolute Truth, and do not reproduce the triadic relational condition associated with its Fifth Absolute Truth. Nevertheless, their work provides a productive structural analogy for several TO concepts: finite physical localizability, distinction between formal mathematical objects and physically realizable states, existence of a forbidden domain below a localization threshold, generation of geometrical properties by fundamental algebraic relations, and conversion of fundamental constraints into potentially observable consequences. The strongest scientific use of KMM by TO would therefore not consist in claiming retrospective confirmation. TO should instead attempt to derive, from its own modal and cosmogonic architecture, an effective deformation parameter and a nonzero localization scale. If such a derivation were independently obtained, the resulting theory could produce quantitative deviations from ordinary quantum mechanics and could thereby enter genuine empirical contact. The analysis consequently proposes a formal research program in which modal axioms are connected to operator algebra, spectral corrections, propagation relations, information constraints, and experimentally bounded parameters. Later developments in generalized uncertainty principle research are also considered, including qualifications of the KMM algebra concerning Jacobi identities and spin (Fadel and Maggiore, 2022). KMM should therefore be understood as a historically and mathematically impor- tant model of minimal-length quantum mechanics, rather than as an experimentally established universal description of fundamental physics. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; minimal length; generalized uncertainty principle; Kempf–Mangano–Mann algebra; modal ontology; Perfect Sphere; quantum gravity; physical localizability; information; atomic radiation; noncommutative geometry; In- ductive Effects; cosmology; modal necessity; operational bridges.

•Oct 3, 2026•0 citations

Are quantum systems physical objects with physical properties?

Michel Paty

Despite its power as the conceptual basis for a huge range of physical phenomena in atomic and subatomic physics, quantum mechanics still suffers from a lack of clarity regarding the physical meaning of its fundamental theoretical concepts, such as those of quantum state and of quantum theoretical quantities or variables , dealt with by the known mathematical-theoretical rules. These concepts have generally been considered as not giving a direct description of physical systems, for they do not correspond to what is usually understood by `physical states' or `physical properties', notably characterized by definite numerical values such as those obtained from measurement. The situation has been tentatively expressed in terms of various `interpretations', conceived not only with regard to the physical meanings of mathematical quantities, but also in connection with philosophical statements about `physical reality'. The question of whether or not quantum theoretical quantities describe definite physical systems existing in nature has therefore generally been considered as beyond the possibilities of physics, because of the definitions that are commonly taken for `physical state' and `physical quantity'. We sketch the main ideas on this problem and propose a possible way out of the puzzle, in terms of an extension of the meaning given to the concepts of the physical state and physical quantity of a system, which would allow one, without any theoretical change in quantum mechanics, to speak consistently of real quantum systems as having definite physical properties .

European Journal of Physics•Nov 1, 1999•31 citations
The concept of physical object in twentieth century's physical theories (relativity and quanta) turns from intuitive-substantial to formal-functional, that is to a relatively invariable properties system well beyond the intuitive properties “carrier” typical of classical physics (CP). Anyway, the autonomous heuristic fecundity of this formal mathematical model neither was fully shown before the twentieth century nor, moreover, is independent of the properties it correlates. In quantum mechanics (QM) the turn to such purely functional correlation, which is nevertheless irreducible to mere information related to measurements, is historically evidenced by the fact that the formalization of the theory as an operator calculus in Hilbert space came before its physical interpretation. Dirac, moreover, asserted the irreducibility of quantum properties to mere measurements, just because this simply pragmatic reduction is poor and ambiguous in front of a mathematical formulation of linguistically expressible (even though not always experimentally decidable) properties. Neither a falsificationist interpretation of scientific theories, which makes them empirically decidable even though irreducible to mere instrumental theories, fits the purpose. It is then safer, and in better agreement with historical testimony, to admit not only the existence of properties which are measurable and reducible to instrumental operations, or at least falsifiable, but also the existence of properties which are physically inaccessible or empirically untestable, since properties of this kind are described and fruitfully implied by the mathematical model.
Taking its historical point of departure in Heisenberg’s work, this article offers a view of quantum mechanics as, arguably, the first truly experimental and truly mathematical physical theory, that is, a theory concerned with experimenting with nature and mathematics alike. It is truly experimental because it is not, as in classical physics, merely the independent behavior of the system considered, in other words, what happens in any event, that we track, but what kind of experiments we perform that defines what happens. By the same token, the theory is also truly mathematical because, at least in the interpretation adopted here, its mathematical formalism does not stand in the service of a mathematical description of (quantum) physical processes in space and time in the way the formalism of classical physics does, but is only used to predict the outcomes of relevant experiments. It also follows that quantum theories experiment more freely with mathematics itself, since we invent predictive mathematical schemes, rather than proceed by refining mathematically our phenomenal representations of nature, which process constrains us in classical mechanics.
This article examines some experimental conditions that invite and possibly require recourse to quantum-mechanical-like mathematical models (QMLMs), models based on the key mathematical features of quantum mechanics, in scientific fields outside physics, such as biology, cognitive psychology, or economics. In particular, I consider whether the following two correlative features of quantum phenomena that were decisive for establishing the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics play similarly important roles in QMLMs elsewhere. The first is the individuality and discreteness of quantum phenomena, and the second is the irreducibly probabilistic nature of our predictions concerning them, coupled to the particular character of the probabilities involved, as different from the character of probabilities found in classical physics. I also argue that these features could be interpreted in terms of a particular form of epistemology that suspends and even precludes a causal and, in the first place, realist description of quantum objects and processes. This epistemology limits the descriptive capacity of quantum theory to the description, classical in nature, of the observed quantum phenomena manifested in measuring instruments. Quantum mechanics itself only provides descriptions, probabilistic in nature, concerning numerical data pertaining to such phenomena, without offering a physical description of quantum objects and processes. While QMLMs share their use of the quantum-mechanical or analogous mathematical formalism, they may differ by the roles, if any, the two features in question play in them and by different ways of interpreting the phenomena they considered and this formalism itself. This article will address those differences as well.
The world of physical systems at the most fundamental levels is replete with efficient, interesting models possessing sufficient ability to represent the reality to a considerable extent. So far, quantum mechanics (QM) forming the basis of almost all natural phenomena, has found beyond doubt its intrinsic ingenuity, capacity and robustness to stand the rigorous tests of validity from and through appropriate calculations and experiments. No serious failures of quantum mechanical predictions have been reported, yet. However, Albert Einstein, the greatest theoretical physicist of the twentieth century and some other eminent men of science have stated firmly and categorically that QM, though successful by and large, is incomplete. There are classical and quantum reality models including those based on consciousness. Relativistic quantum theoretical approaches to clearly understand the ultimate nature of matter as well as radiation have still much to accomplish in order to qualify for a final theory of everything (TOE). Mathematical models of better, suitable character as also strength are needed to achieve satisfactory explanation of natural processes and phenomena. We, in this paper, discuss some of these matters with certain apt illustrations as well.
Introduction As the decades of the twentieth century rolled on, quantum mechanics (QM) became more and more sophisticated and mathematical. Understanding what this theory means intuitively was confounded not only by nonclassical concepts such as wave–particle duality and quantum interference, but also by issues to do with observation. The Newtonian classical mechanics (CM) paradigm of reality, wherein reductionist laws of physics describe observer-independent dynamics of systems under observation (SUOs) with observer-independent properties, was found to be inadequate. Quantum theorists were confronted with the measurement problem , which attempts to understand, explain, and rationalize the laws of QM that underpin the processes of observation that go on in the laboratory. They are not the same as those of CM in several puzzling respects. Historically, the first sign of the measurement problem was Planck's quantization of energy (Planck, 1900b) and the second was Bohr's veto on radiation damping in hydrogen (Bohr, 1913). These occurred in the first quarter of the twentieth century, a period in physics often referred to as Old Quantum Mechanics . Another indicator that intuition was inadequate was Born's interpretation of the squared modulus of the Schrödinger wave function as a probability density (Born, 1926). That interpretation has everything to do with observers and observation, because probability without an observer is a vacuous concept. Eventually, the projection-valued measure (PVM) formalism emerged, championed by von Neumann in an influential book on the mathematical formulation of QM (von Neumann, 1955). Subsequently, pioneers such as Ludwig (Ludwig, 1983a,b) and Kraus (Kraus, 1974, 1983) refined the theory into the general positive operator-valued measure (POVM) formalism that we shall discuss and use. The quantized detector network (QDN) approach to quantum experiments is most naturally expressed in the PVM formalism, as QDN focuses on the individual detectors in the laboratory. However, the POVM formalism is more general than the PVM formalism, giving a description of multiple detector processes similar to QDN. This raises the question of how the two approaches, QDN and POVM, are related. The aim of this chapter is to explore this relationship. Before we review the PVM and POVM formalisms, we review some essential mathematical concepts.
The 1995 article by Achim Kempf, Gianpiero Mangano, and Robert B. Mann, “Hilbert Space Representation of the Minimal Length Uncertainty Relation,” constitutes one of the most important formal constructions through which a nonzero minimal uncertainty in position can be incorporated into quantum mechanics. Rather than representing a fundamental length merely as a discrete lattice imposed upon ordinary space, Kempf, Mangano, and Mann modify the canonical commutation relation and construct a Hilbert- space representation in which arbitrarily precise physical localization is excluded. Their framework yields a minimal position uncertainty, modifies the mathematical status of exact-position states, introduces maximally localized states and a quasi-position representation, and, in multidimensional formulations, leads to noncommuting position coordinates. The original article was published in Physical Review D, volume 52, pages 1108–1118, DOI https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.52.1108 (Kempf, Mangano, and Mann, 1995). This article develops a critical–propositional analysis of that framework in dia- logue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO), particularly its Seven Absolute Truths, its interpretation of logical Nothingness, the concept of individualizing fields, the onto- logical status attributed to infinity, the role of boundaries and interfaces, nonhuman relational observation, compositional emergence, and the transcendent element under- stood in TO as knowledge or information produced in atomic relations and considered equivalent to atomic radiation. Special attention is given to the foundational TO work A Esfera Perfeita (The Perfect Sphere), because the KMM minimal-localization structure provides an especially useful mathematical dialogue partner for a TO conception of a limiting physical scale. The central thesis developed here is deliberately restricted. Kempf, Mangano, and Mann do not demonstrate the Theory of Objectivity, do not derive its cosmogony, do not establish the individual magnetic field asserted by its Second Absolute Truth, and do not reproduce the triadic relational condition associated with its Fifth Absolute Truth. Nevertheless, their work provides a productive structural analogy for several TO concepts: finite physical localizability, distinction between formal mathematical objects and physically realizable states, existence of a forbidden domain below a localization threshold, generation of geometrical properties by fundamental algebraic relations, and conversion of fundamental constraints into potentially observable consequences. The strongest scientific use of KMM by TO would therefore not consist in claiming retrospective confirmation. TO should instead attempt to derive, from its own modal and cosmogonic architecture, an effective deformation parameter and a nonzero localization scale. If such a derivation were independently obtained, the resulting theory could produce quantitative deviations from ordinary quantum mechanics and could thereby enter genuine empirical contact. The analysis consequently proposes a formal research program in which modal axioms are connected to operator algebra, spectral corrections, propagation relations, information constraints, and experimentally bounded parameters. Later developments in generalized uncertainty principle research are also considered, including qualifications of the KMM algebra concerning Jacobi identities and spin (Fadel and Maggiore, 2022). KMM should therefore be understood as a historically and mathematically impor- tant model of minimal-length quantum mechanics, rather than as an experimentally established universal description of fundamental physics. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; minimal length; generalized uncertainty principle; Kempf–Mangano–Mann algebra; modal ontology; Perfect Sphere; quantum gravity; physical localizability; information; atomic radiation; noncommutative geometry; In- ductive Effects; cosmology; modal necessity; operational bridges.
Despite its power as the conceptual basis for a huge range of physical phenomena in atomic and subatomic physics, quantum mechanics still suffers from a lack of clarity regarding the physical meaning of its fundamental theoretical concepts, such as those of quantum state and of quantum theoretical quantities or variables , dealt with by the known mathematical-theoretical rules. These concepts have generally been considered as not giving a direct description of physical systems, for they do not correspond to what is usually understood by `physical states' or `physical properties', notably characterized by definite numerical values such as those obtained from measurement. The situation has been tentatively expressed in terms of various `interpretations', conceived not only with regard to the physical meanings of mathematical quantities, but also in connection with philosophical statements about `physical reality'. The question of whether or not quantum theoretical quantities describe definite physical systems existing in nature has therefore generally been considered as beyond the possibilities of physics, because of the definitions that are commonly taken for `physical state' and `physical quantity'. We sketch the main ideas on this problem and propose a possible way out of the puzzle, in terms of an extension of the meaning given to the concepts of the physical state and physical quantity of a system, which would allow one, without any theoretical change in quantum mechanics, to speak consistently of real quantum systems as having definite physical properties .