Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

BETHE'S ANSATZ: NOW & THEN

Bill Sutherland

Published Sep 1, 2003• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present a simple lecture covering 35 years of research on exactly solvable one-dimensional quantum many-body systems — the Bethe's Ansatz — its generalizations and related developments. Although the selection of topics is my own, the work has been done by several others. Further, the contributions have built on one another in such a way that — to be honest — it is difficult to imagine one bit without the others. So, please see this talk as an appreciation of a long and fruitful history of cooperation, beginning with Bethe, and spanning generations.

DOI
10.1142/9789812795083_0009

Related papers

A primer on the study of one dimensional systems, Bethe ansatz and integrability.

Daniel Pérez Cruz

In this work we will be introducing important concepts, techniques and procedures related to the study of one dimensional quantum many body systems. The study of this kind of systems started shortly after Schr¨odinger’s seminal paper (1926) with the work of Hans Bethe (1931). He introduced a novel technique, the Bethe ansatz, that would stay unrecognized until the paradigmatic work of Lieb and Liniger (1963). They were able to solve, without any approximation, a many body quantum system analytically, both for a finite system of bosons as well as in the thermodynamic limit. This opened a new research field that has helped to understand the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems as well as the dynamics of dilute gases. Moreover, the recent experimental realization of systems of this kind has fueled not just intense experimental efforts to reproduce more diverse one dimensional systems but also theoretical ones. The importance of dealing with one dimensional systems is that they exhibit exotic phenomena that are not present in 2D and 3D systems, as we shall see, in the process of fermionization. Moreover, one dimensional systems are more prone to admit an analytical solution, making it easier to understand the dynamics of the system. Another topic that we will be covering is integrability. Coming from the theory of classical Hamiltonian systems it has been an elusive topic for physicists, and some advances have been done with more mathematically-oriented purposes. Bethe’s method and its generalizations (Nested, Thermodynamic, Algebraic, Coordinate Bethe Ansatz) allow us to determine whether a system is integrable or not, because solvability by the ansatz is a clear signature of the system being integrable. The study of integrability in quantum systems has become a topic of great interest because of the deep implications it has in quantum statistical mechanics. The relation between integrability and thermalization is yet under study and the mechanisms that enable one or the other are to be discovered, although some hypothesis, as the Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, have been proposed. The main motivation of this work is to serve as an introduction to this vast topic. We begin with a brief review of scattering theory, introducing some useful results and how these can be used to solve one dimensional problems. The next step is an overview of the problem of thermalization: when should one expect a system to thermalize? Which mechanisms are responsible? The link between integrability, thermalization and quantum collisions is established here, qualitatively. Our following task is to study Bethe’s method, initially giving a general description and why it being a solution implies that the system is integrable. Then, we solve the problem of a system of N bosons in a ring with delta interaction [1], both for finite N and in the thermodynamic limit. We study the spectrum of this model and find some relations between the distribution of Bethe’s rapidities and the spectrum of random matrices, which serve us to introduce the concept of level repulsion and distribution of level spacing. After some calculations we proceed to study a slightly modified model for a system of three bosons, where we substitute the delta potential by a Gaussian. We repeat the same analysis as for the Lieb-Liniger model and analyze the similarities and differences between them. Theoretical research on this topic has found that the system is integrable for certain regimes. We study the statistics of the energy spectrum for different values of the parameters of the system, comparing the results with the integrable or non integrable expected results.

Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Final Conclusion

V. E. Korepin, N. M. Bogoliubov, Anatoli G. Izergin

We have explained the theory of exactly solvable models on both the quantum and classical levels. We hope that the reader appreciates the beauty and perfection of the Bethe Ansatz. The theory of completely integrable nonlinear partial differential equations plays an equally important role in the book. It is deeply related to the Bethe Ansatz. We hope that our book can be used for further development of the theory of exactly solvable models (we think that the interested reader can find problems to work out in our book). Our book does not close the theory of the Bethe Ansatz; it opens new possibilities for further development.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 19, 1993•0 citations

A brief history of the quantum soliton with new results on the quantization of the Toda lattice

Bill Sutherland

I. Brief History.When I first learned of this conference, and saw the wide range of interests represented by the participants, I was certain that finally a common definition of that most intriguing concept-the soliton-would emerge.And I was anxious that this definition be broad enough to encompass solitons in both their classical and quantum versions.For recent work had convinced me that the general technique known as Bethe's ansatz for solving diverse one-dimensional quantum problems in fact was nothing more nor less than the quantum soliton.However, from conversations with conference participants, I discovered that many were not aware of this accumulated work on exactly soluble quantum systems.I even gained the impression that some feel quantum mechanics to be much harder than classical mechanics-an unnecessary complication.My own feeling, on the other hand, is that in many cases quantum mechanics clarifies matters.It forces one to immediately face problems that would eventually have to be faced in the corresponding classical case, problems such as the counting of states, to determine how important solitons really are.Anyway, the history of the quantum soliton is all to the greater glory of the soliton concept.And quite a respectable history it is.I would date the beginning at 1931 with a paper of H. Bethe [1] on magnetism; that is a total span of 45 years.Quantum mechanics itself has not been around all that much longer!It now seems my hopes for a consensus on a definition of the soliton were premature, and things are still fermenting.Nevertheless, here is my contribution to the conference in the form of a brief history for general interest, and a more original work on the quantization of the Toda lattice.Perhaps next time there will be some consolidation, and we can then decide just how particular and how general a concept is the soliton.1.We begin this historical account with the classic paper of H. Bethe [1], which introduced first the many-body wave function crucial

Rocky Mountain Journal of Mathematics•Mar 1, 1978•113 citations

The Bethe ansatz after 75 years

Murray T. Batchelor

A 1931 result that lay in obscurity for decades, Bethe’s solution to a quantum mechanical model now finds its way into everything from superconductors to string theory.

Physics Today•Jan 1, 2007•102 citations

Many-body theory of some one-dimensional systems by the method of Bethe's hypothesis

實 高橋

•Jan 1, 1972•0 citations

New quasi-exactly solvable systems from SUSYQM and Bethe Ansatz

Siyu Li, Ian Marquette, Yao-Zhong Zhang

We give a systematic construction of new quasi-exactly solvable systems via Bethe ansatz and supersymmetric quantum mechanics (SUSYQM). Methods based on the intertwining of supercharges have been extensively used in the literature for exactly solvable systems. We generalize the state-deleting (Krein-Adler) supersymmetric transformations to quasi-exactly exactly solvable (QES) systems building on the Bethe ansatz method and related Bethe roots. This enables us to construct superpartners for a wide class of known QES systems classified previously through a hidden $sl(2)$ algebra. We present our constructions of factorizations and intertwining relations related to 1st-order SUSYQM and the $n=1$ state for 10 nonequivalent types, denoted I,...,X. In order to have a unified treatment we rely on their ODE standard form as this is also the appropriate setting to obtain the Bethe ansatz equations which constrain the polynomial solutions. This setting also allows one to deal with systems with $n$ states in a unified manner, using analysis based on the Bethe ansatz equations to build the supersymmetric transformations in terms of the Bethe ansatz roots. We derive the Schrödinger potentials for the $n=1$ superpartners of the 10 QES cases and give closed-form solutions for the spectra and wavefunctions of the corresponding QES SUSYQM systems. Furthermore, we present numerical results for higher excited states up to the $n=10$ level. The results obtained may have wider applicability as our framework is built on ODEs with polynomial coefficients.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2511.21412•Nov 27, 2025
We present a simple lecture covering 35 years of research on exactly solvable one-dimensional quantum many-body systems — the Bethe's Ansatz — its generalizations and related developments. Although the selection of topics is my own, the work has been done by several others. Further, the contributions have built on one another in such a way that — to be honest — it is difficult to imagine one bit without the others. So, please see this talk as an appreciation of a long and fruitful history of cooperation, beginning with Bethe, and spanning generations.
In this work we will be introducing important concepts, techniques and procedures related to the study of one dimensional quantum many body systems. The study of this kind of systems started shortly after Schr¨odinger’s seminal paper (1926) with the work of Hans Bethe (1931). He introduced a novel technique, the Bethe ansatz, that would stay unrecognized until the paradigmatic work of Lieb and Liniger (1963). They were able to solve, without any approximation, a many body quantum system analytically, both for a finite system of bosons as well as in the thermodynamic limit. This opened a new research field that has helped to understand the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems as well as the dynamics of dilute gases. Moreover, the recent experimental realization of systems of this kind has fueled not just intense experimental efforts to reproduce more diverse one dimensional systems but also theoretical ones. The importance of dealing with one dimensional systems is that they exhibit exotic phenomena that are not present in 2D and 3D systems, as we shall see, in the process of fermionization. Moreover, one dimensional systems are more prone to admit an analytical solution, making it easier to understand the dynamics of the system. Another topic that we will be covering is integrability. Coming from the theory of classical Hamiltonian systems it has been an elusive topic for physicists, and some advances have been done with more mathematically-oriented purposes. Bethe’s method and its generalizations (Nested, Thermodynamic, Algebraic, Coordinate Bethe Ansatz) allow us to determine whether a system is integrable or not, because solvability by the ansatz is a clear signature of the system being integrable. The study of integrability in quantum systems has become a topic of great interest because of the deep implications it has in quantum statistical mechanics. The relation between integrability and thermalization is yet under study and the mechanisms that enable one or the other are to be discovered, although some hypothesis, as the Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, have been proposed. The main motivation of this work is to serve as an introduction to this vast topic. We begin with a brief review of scattering theory, introducing some useful results and how these can be used to solve one dimensional problems. The next step is an overview of the problem of thermalization: when should one expect a system to thermalize? Which mechanisms are responsible? The link between integrability, thermalization and quantum collisions is established here, qualitatively. Our following task is to study Bethe’s method, initially giving a general description and why it being a solution implies that the system is integrable. Then, we solve the problem of a system of N bosons in a ring with delta interaction [1], both for finite N and in the thermodynamic limit. We study the spectrum of this model and find some relations between the distribution of Bethe’s rapidities and the spectrum of random matrices, which serve us to introduce the concept of level repulsion and distribution of level spacing. After some calculations we proceed to study a slightly modified model for a system of three bosons, where we substitute the delta potential by a Gaussian. We repeat the same analysis as for the Lieb-Liniger model and analyze the similarities and differences between them. Theoretical research on this topic has found that the system is integrable for certain regimes. We study the statistics of the energy spectrum for different values of the parameters of the system, comparing the results with the integrable or non integrable expected results.
We have explained the theory of exactly solvable models on both the quantum and classical levels. We hope that the reader appreciates the beauty and perfection of the Bethe Ansatz. The theory of completely integrable nonlinear partial differential equations plays an equally important role in the book. It is deeply related to the Bethe Ansatz. We hope that our book can be used for further development of the theory of exactly solvable models (we think that the interested reader can find problems to work out in our book). Our book does not close the theory of the Bethe Ansatz; it opens new possibilities for further development.
I. Brief History.When I first learned of this conference, and saw the wide range of interests represented by the participants, I was certain that finally a common definition of that most intriguing concept-the soliton-would emerge.And I was anxious that this definition be broad enough to encompass solitons in both their classical and quantum versions.For recent work had convinced me that the general technique known as Bethe's ansatz for solving diverse one-dimensional quantum problems in fact was nothing more nor less than the quantum soliton.However, from conversations with conference participants, I discovered that many were not aware of this accumulated work on exactly soluble quantum systems.I even gained the impression that some feel quantum mechanics to be much harder than classical mechanics-an unnecessary complication.My own feeling, on the other hand, is that in many cases quantum mechanics clarifies matters.It forces one to immediately face problems that would eventually have to be faced in the corresponding classical case, problems such as the counting of states, to determine how important solitons really are.Anyway, the history of the quantum soliton is all to the greater glory of the soliton concept.And quite a respectable history it is.I would date the beginning at 1931 with a paper of H. Bethe [1] on magnetism; that is a total span of 45 years.Quantum mechanics itself has not been around all that much longer!It now seems my hopes for a consensus on a definition of the soliton were premature, and things are still fermenting.Nevertheless, here is my contribution to the conference in the form of a brief history for general interest, and a more original work on the quantization of the Toda lattice.Perhaps next time there will be some consolidation, and we can then decide just how particular and how general a concept is the soliton.1.We begin this historical account with the classic paper of H. Bethe [1], which introduced first the many-body wave function crucial
We give a systematic construction of new quasi-exactly solvable systems via Bethe ansatz and supersymmetric quantum mechanics (SUSYQM). Methods based on the intertwining of supercharges have been extensively used in the literature for exactly solvable systems. We generalize the state-deleting (Krein-Adler) supersymmetric transformations to quasi-exactly exactly solvable (QES) systems building on the Bethe ansatz method and related Bethe roots. This enables us to construct superpartners for a wide class of known QES systems classified previously through a hidden sl(2)sl(2)sl(2) algebra. We present our constructions of factorizations and intertwining relations related to 1st-order SUSYQM and the n=1n=1n=1 state for 10 nonequivalent types, denoted I,...,X. In order to have a unified treatment we rely on their ODE standard form as this is also the appropriate setting to obtain the Bethe ansatz equations which constrain the polynomial solutions. This setting also allows one to deal with systems with nnn states in a unified manner, using analysis based on the Bethe ansatz equations to build the supersymmetric transformations in terms of the Bethe ansatz roots. We derive the Schrödinger potentials for the n=1n=1n=1 superpartners of the 10 QES cases and give closed-form solutions for the spectra and wavefunctions of the corresponding QES SUSYQM systems. Furthermore, we present numerical results for higher excited states up to the n=10n=10n=10 level. The results obtained may have wider applicability as our framework is built on ODEs with polynomial coefficients.