Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Rocky Mountain Journal of Mathematics

A brief history of the quantum soliton with new results on the quantization of the Toda lattice

Bill Sutherland

Published Mar 1, 1978• 113 citations
Publisher

Abstract

I. Brief History.When I first learned of this conference, and saw the wide range of interests represented by the participants, I was certain that finally a common definition of that most intriguing concept-the soliton-would emerge.And I was anxious that this definition be broad enough to encompass solitons in both their classical and quantum versions.For recent work had convinced me that the general technique known as Bethe's ansatz for solving diverse one-dimensional quantum problems in fact was nothing more nor less than the quantum soliton.However, from conversations with conference participants, I discovered that many were not aware of this accumulated work on exactly soluble quantum systems.I even gained the impression that some feel quantum mechanics to be much harder than classical mechanics-an unnecessary complication.My own feeling, on the other hand, is that in many cases quantum mechanics clarifies matters.It forces one to immediately face problems that would eventually have to be faced in the corresponding classical case, problems such as the counting of states, to determine how important solitons really are.Anyway, the history of the quantum soliton is all to the greater glory of the soliton concept.And quite a respectable history it is.I would date the beginning at 1931 with a paper of H. Bethe [1] on magnetism; that is a total span of 45 years.Quantum mechanics itself has not been around all that much longer!It now seems my hopes for a consensus on a definition of the soliton were premature, and things are still fermenting.Nevertheless, here is my contribution to the conference in the form of a brief history for general interest, and a more original work on the quantization of the Toda lattice.Perhaps next time there will be some consolidation, and we can then decide just how particular and how general a concept is the soliton.1.We begin this historical account with the classic paper of H. Bethe [1], which introduced first the many-body wave function crucial

DOI
10.1216/rmj-1978-8-1-413

Related papers

A primer on the study of one dimensional systems, Bethe ansatz and integrability.

Daniel Pérez Cruz

In this work we will be introducing important concepts, techniques and procedures related to the study of one dimensional quantum many body systems. The study of this kind of systems started shortly after Schr¨odinger’s seminal paper (1926) with the work of Hans Bethe (1931). He introduced a novel technique, the Bethe ansatz, that would stay unrecognized until the paradigmatic work of Lieb and Liniger (1963). They were able to solve, without any approximation, a many body quantum system analytically, both for a finite system of bosons as well as in the thermodynamic limit. This opened a new research field that has helped to understand the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems as well as the dynamics of dilute gases. Moreover, the recent experimental realization of systems of this kind has fueled not just intense experimental efforts to reproduce more diverse one dimensional systems but also theoretical ones. The importance of dealing with one dimensional systems is that they exhibit exotic phenomena that are not present in 2D and 3D systems, as we shall see, in the process of fermionization. Moreover, one dimensional systems are more prone to admit an analytical solution, making it easier to understand the dynamics of the system. Another topic that we will be covering is integrability. Coming from the theory of classical Hamiltonian systems it has been an elusive topic for physicists, and some advances have been done with more mathematically-oriented purposes. Bethe’s method and its generalizations (Nested, Thermodynamic, Algebraic, Coordinate Bethe Ansatz) allow us to determine whether a system is integrable or not, because solvability by the ansatz is a clear signature of the system being integrable. The study of integrability in quantum systems has become a topic of great interest because of the deep implications it has in quantum statistical mechanics. The relation between integrability and thermalization is yet under study and the mechanisms that enable one or the other are to be discovered, although some hypothesis, as the Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, have been proposed. The main motivation of this work is to serve as an introduction to this vast topic. We begin with a brief review of scattering theory, introducing some useful results and how these can be used to solve one dimensional problems. The next step is an overview of the problem of thermalization: when should one expect a system to thermalize? Which mechanisms are responsible? The link between integrability, thermalization and quantum collisions is established here, qualitatively. Our following task is to study Bethe’s method, initially giving a general description and why it being a solution implies that the system is integrable. Then, we solve the problem of a system of N bosons in a ring with delta interaction [1], both for finite N and in the thermodynamic limit. We study the spectrum of this model and find some relations between the distribution of Bethe’s rapidities and the spectrum of random matrices, which serve us to introduce the concept of level repulsion and distribution of level spacing. After some calculations we proceed to study a slightly modified model for a system of three bosons, where we substitute the delta potential by a Gaussian. We repeat the same analysis as for the Lieb-Liniger model and analyze the similarities and differences between them. Theoretical research on this topic has found that the system is integrable for certain regimes. We study the statistics of the energy spectrum for different values of the parameters of the system, comparing the results with the integrable or non integrable expected results.

Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Analysis on the Development of Quantum Spin

Zhang Zi-hui

Spin, still a concept or property not fully exploited, has already impacted the world in many ways with its many applications. The history of how spin came to light and how it was interpreted and developed as investigations were conducted is of particular interest with the many odd outcomes of experiments concerning this intrinsic property. This article will sort out the historical outline of how spin was first indicated in theories and how it was eventually embraced as a fundamental property of quantum particles in an attempt to holistically review the process of recognition of this remarkable concept. Through this review, it becomes apparent how the recognition and development of a concept involves the intellect of a broad range of physicists who are willing to view things from both classical and quantum perspectives particularly when it comes to new concepts as spin. How elements like luck and chance play a role will also be revealed. As it turns out, our intuitions about the world around us may not be the ultimate truth, especially when it comes to Quantum Mechanics. Space Quantization was once thought of as no more than a theoretical outcome, however, experiments anyway impose this reality on physicists requiring them to abandon stubborn biases. Admittedly, not every speculation was correct, the analogy of “Spin” was an unfortunate one. But this article shows that this is just how understanding the mysteries of the quantum world really unfolds.

International Forum on Electrical Engineering and Automation (IFEEA)•Sep 1, 2020•1 citation

A Brief History of Quantum-Mechanical Ideas

Jean Louis Van Belle

In this paper, we pick some less well-known contributions of great minds to the history of ideas from the proceedings of the Solvay Conferences. We hope to show there was nothing inevitable about the new physics winning out. In fact, we suggest modern-day physicists may usefully go back to some of the old ideas – most notably the idea that elementary particles do have some shape and size – and that they should, perhaps, try somewhat harder to explain intrinsic properties of these particles, such as angular momentum and their magnetic moment, in terms of classical physics. The contributions which we discuss are those of Ernest Rutherford, Joseph Larmor, Hendrik Antoon Lorentz and Louis de Broglie.

•May 1, 2020•0 citations

Solitons and Quantum Behavior

Ricardo A. Pakula

In applied physics and in engineering intuitive understanding is a boost for creativity and almost a necessity for efficient product improvement. The existence of soliton solutions to the quantum equations in the presence of self-interactions allows us to draw an intuitive picture of quantum mechanics. The purpose of this work is to compile a collection of models, some of which are simple, some are obvious, some have already appeared in papers and even in textbooks, and some are new. However this is the first time they are presented (to our knowledge) in a common place attempting to provide an intuitive physical description for one of the basic particles in nature: the electron. The soliton model applied to the electrons can be extended to the electromagnetic field providing an unambiguous description for the photon. In so doing a clear image of quantum mechanics emerges, including quantum optics, QED and field quantization. To our belief this description is of highly pedagogical value. We start with a traditional description of the old quantum mechanics, first quantization and second quantization. We describe an intuitive description of first and second quantization based on the concept of solitons, pioneered by the double solution of de Broglie in 1927. Many aspects of first and second quantization are clarified and visualized intuitively, including the so called vacuum fluctuations.

arXiv:1612.00110•Dec 1, 2016•2 citations

A Theory of Ether, Particles Andatoms: Introduction to the Reform of Modern Physics

Igor S. Makarov

This work is the result of the research which I started independently late in the 60s in Russia and since August 1992 have proceeded with abroad. The subject of the research was initially chosen to be Systems Theory, because it seemed rather close to the theory of communications, the then field of my occupation, on the one hand, and because it sounded intriguing enough and worth attempting at, on the other. But there was no idea of how and where to start the research, and it was decided to begin with the simplest type of system – a linear system. The first step proved rather successful: there was found quite an elegant solution of the problem, imagined by myself, of determining the functional complexity of linear systems by their characteristics. That work was published in the 1969, No.2, issue of the Transactions of the Research Institute of Radio (Moscow) where I worked then. Although it was unclear how to proceed with that result, there was a vague indication in it to some connection between the abstract theory of linear systems and statistical physics, which seemed promising. To make that puzzle out, I set off to supplement my knowledge of theoretical physics, and soon the above indication became more articulate: there is indeed some deep connection between the problem of the synthesis of linear systems and quantum mechanics. Intrigued by that clue, I attempted for several years to apply the solutions of Schroedinger’s-like equations, with the potential determined by characteristics of the system, to its synthesis. However, the results were unsatisfactory: something essential was missing in comprehending both the objects of theoretical physic and linear systems. The solution came suddenly from where nobody could have expected it - from philosophy. Looking once through Hegel’s works, I was struck by a strangely close analogy between the conceptions of duality in dialectical logic and particle physics. That revelation triggered another stage of self-education, this time in dialectical philosophy. As a result, there arose conviction that Hegel's dialectical logic is actually the general theory of systems sought for, but the philosopher’s peculiar way of thinking and the extremely abstract language of that his work made its interpretation in scientific terms almost impossible, with the exception of some most simple cases. So I had no choice but to endeavor my own interpretation of the dialectical logic, on the one hand, and, simultaneously, a revision of some theories and principles of theoretical physics in accordance with that logic, on the other hand, which eventually resulted in the theory expounded in this book. The first rough results, such as the existence of ether, its composition and the phenomenon of spontaneous generation of neutrons in it, were achieved early in the 80s, but it took me about fifteen years more to complete this research in a sufficiently adequate and convincing form.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

QUANTUM SOLITONS

R. Bullough

Two themes are considered in this paper. First of all in the Introduction a comment is made about the Tzitzéica equation which occurred in the author's work as reported in [1]. Much recent work has referred to this equation and a representative bibliography is given in this paper with brief comments. The second theme of this paper is concerned with work surrounding Quantum Solitons and the author's talk at the ISLAND 2 meeting under the title ‘Quantum solitons’ is briefly summarised. An extended review of this subject matter has now appeared in [2] and as there the quantum soliton of the quantum attractive NLS model is seen as a ‘qubit’ for quantum information purposes. It is hoped that this summary and/or the reference [2] can help to stimulate further interest in this ‘quantum’ aspect of our subject in the solitons community. The actual observation of a quantum soliton is also reported and a proper theoretical description of it given. Reference is made to -boson lattices first as a simple example of the quantum inverse method in the Introduction and then as a subject matter in its own right at the end of the paper.

Glasgow Mathematical Journal•Jun 1, 2005•2 citations
I. Brief History.When I first learned of this conference, and saw the wide range of interests represented by the participants, I was certain that finally a common definition of that most intriguing concept-the soliton-would emerge.And I was anxious that this definition be broad enough to encompass solitons in both their classical and quantum versions.For recent work had convinced me that the general technique known as Bethe's ansatz for solving diverse one-dimensional quantum problems in fact was nothing more nor less than the quantum soliton.However, from conversations with conference participants, I discovered that many were not aware of this accumulated work on exactly soluble quantum systems.I even gained the impression that some feel quantum mechanics to be much harder than classical mechanics-an unnecessary complication.My own feeling, on the other hand, is that in many cases quantum mechanics clarifies matters.It forces one to immediately face problems that would eventually have to be faced in the corresponding classical case, problems such as the counting of states, to determine how important solitons really are.Anyway, the history of the quantum soliton is all to the greater glory of the soliton concept.And quite a respectable history it is.I would date the beginning at 1931 with a paper of H. Bethe [1] on magnetism; that is a total span of 45 years.Quantum mechanics itself has not been around all that much longer!It now seems my hopes for a consensus on a definition of the soliton were premature, and things are still fermenting.Nevertheless, here is my contribution to the conference in the form of a brief history for general interest, and a more original work on the quantization of the Toda lattice.Perhaps next time there will be some consolidation, and we can then decide just how particular and how general a concept is the soliton.1.We begin this historical account with the classic paper of H. Bethe [1], which introduced first the many-body wave function crucial
In this work we will be introducing important concepts, techniques and procedures related to the study of one dimensional quantum many body systems. The study of this kind of systems started shortly after Schr¨odinger’s seminal paper (1926) with the work of Hans Bethe (1931). He introduced a novel technique, the Bethe ansatz, that would stay unrecognized until the paradigmatic work of Lieb and Liniger (1963). They were able to solve, without any approximation, a many body quantum system analytically, both for a finite system of bosons as well as in the thermodynamic limit. This opened a new research field that has helped to understand the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems as well as the dynamics of dilute gases. Moreover, the recent experimental realization of systems of this kind has fueled not just intense experimental efforts to reproduce more diverse one dimensional systems but also theoretical ones. The importance of dealing with one dimensional systems is that they exhibit exotic phenomena that are not present in 2D and 3D systems, as we shall see, in the process of fermionization. Moreover, one dimensional systems are more prone to admit an analytical solution, making it easier to understand the dynamics of the system. Another topic that we will be covering is integrability. Coming from the theory of classical Hamiltonian systems it has been an elusive topic for physicists, and some advances have been done with more mathematically-oriented purposes. Bethe’s method and its generalizations (Nested, Thermodynamic, Algebraic, Coordinate Bethe Ansatz) allow us to determine whether a system is integrable or not, because solvability by the ansatz is a clear signature of the system being integrable. The study of integrability in quantum systems has become a topic of great interest because of the deep implications it has in quantum statistical mechanics. The relation between integrability and thermalization is yet under study and the mechanisms that enable one or the other are to be discovered, although some hypothesis, as the Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, have been proposed. The main motivation of this work is to serve as an introduction to this vast topic. We begin with a brief review of scattering theory, introducing some useful results and how these can be used to solve one dimensional problems. The next step is an overview of the problem of thermalization: when should one expect a system to thermalize? Which mechanisms are responsible? The link between integrability, thermalization and quantum collisions is established here, qualitatively. Our following task is to study Bethe’s method, initially giving a general description and why it being a solution implies that the system is integrable. Then, we solve the problem of a system of N bosons in a ring with delta interaction [1], both for finite N and in the thermodynamic limit. We study the spectrum of this model and find some relations between the distribution of Bethe’s rapidities and the spectrum of random matrices, which serve us to introduce the concept of level repulsion and distribution of level spacing. After some calculations we proceed to study a slightly modified model for a system of three bosons, where we substitute the delta potential by a Gaussian. We repeat the same analysis as for the Lieb-Liniger model and analyze the similarities and differences between them. Theoretical research on this topic has found that the system is integrable for certain regimes. We study the statistics of the energy spectrum for different values of the parameters of the system, comparing the results with the integrable or non integrable expected results.
Spin, still a concept or property not fully exploited, has already impacted the world in many ways with its many applications. The history of how spin came to light and how it was interpreted and developed as investigations were conducted is of particular interest with the many odd outcomes of experiments concerning this intrinsic property. This article will sort out the historical outline of how spin was first indicated in theories and how it was eventually embraced as a fundamental property of quantum particles in an attempt to holistically review the process of recognition of this remarkable concept. Through this review, it becomes apparent how the recognition and development of a concept involves the intellect of a broad range of physicists who are willing to view things from both classical and quantum perspectives particularly when it comes to new concepts as spin. How elements like luck and chance play a role will also be revealed. As it turns out, our intuitions about the world around us may not be the ultimate truth, especially when it comes to Quantum Mechanics. Space Quantization was once thought of as no more than a theoretical outcome, however, experiments anyway impose this reality on physicists requiring them to abandon stubborn biases. Admittedly, not every speculation was correct, the analogy of “Spin” was an unfortunate one. But this article shows that this is just how understanding the mysteries of the quantum world really unfolds.
In this paper, we pick some less well-known contributions of great minds to the history of ideas from the proceedings of the Solvay Conferences. We hope to show there was nothing inevitable about the new physics winning out. In fact, we suggest modern-day physicists may usefully go back to some of the old ideas – most notably the idea that elementary particles do have some shape and size – and that they should, perhaps, try somewhat harder to explain intrinsic properties of these particles, such as angular momentum and their magnetic moment, in terms of classical physics. The contributions which we discuss are those of Ernest Rutherford, Joseph Larmor, Hendrik Antoon Lorentz and Louis de Broglie.
In applied physics and in engineering intuitive understanding is a boost for creativity and almost a necessity for efficient product improvement. The existence of soliton solutions to the quantum equations in the presence of self-interactions allows us to draw an intuitive picture of quantum mechanics. The purpose of this work is to compile a collection of models, some of which are simple, some are obvious, some have already appeared in papers and even in textbooks, and some are new. However this is the first time they are presented (to our knowledge) in a common place attempting to provide an intuitive physical description for one of the basic particles in nature: the electron. The soliton model applied to the electrons can be extended to the electromagnetic field providing an unambiguous description for the photon. In so doing a clear image of quantum mechanics emerges, including quantum optics, QED and field quantization. To our belief this description is of highly pedagogical value. We start with a traditional description of the old quantum mechanics, first quantization and second quantization. We describe an intuitive description of first and second quantization based on the concept of solitons, pioneered by the double solution of de Broglie in 1927. Many aspects of first and second quantization are clarified and visualized intuitively, including the so called vacuum fluctuations.
This work is the result of the research which I started independently late in the 60s in Russia and since August 1992 have proceeded with abroad. The subject of the research was initially chosen to be Systems Theory, because it seemed rather close to the theory of communications, the then field of my occupation, on the one hand, and because it sounded intriguing enough and worth attempting at, on the other. But there was no idea of how and where to start the research, and it was decided to begin with the simplest type of system – a linear system. The first step proved rather successful: there was found quite an elegant solution of the problem, imagined by myself, of determining the functional complexity of linear systems by their characteristics. That work was published in the 1969, No.2, issue of the Transactions of the Research Institute of Radio (Moscow) where I worked then. Although it was unclear how to proceed with that result, there was a vague indication in it to some connection between the abstract theory of linear systems and statistical physics, which seemed promising. To make that puzzle out, I set off to supplement my knowledge of theoretical physics, and soon the above indication became more articulate: there is indeed some deep connection between the problem of the synthesis of linear systems and quantum mechanics. Intrigued by that clue, I attempted for several years to apply the solutions of Schroedinger’s-like equations, with the potential determined by characteristics of the system, to its synthesis. However, the results were unsatisfactory: something essential was missing in comprehending both the objects of theoretical physic and linear systems. The solution came suddenly from where nobody could have expected it - from philosophy. Looking once through Hegel’s works, I was struck by a strangely close analogy between the conceptions of duality in dialectical logic and particle physics. That revelation triggered another stage of self-education, this time in dialectical philosophy. As a result, there arose conviction that Hegel's dialectical logic is actually the general theory of systems sought for, but the philosopher’s peculiar way of thinking and the extremely abstract language of that his work made its interpretation in scientific terms almost impossible, with the exception of some most simple cases. So I had no choice but to endeavor my own interpretation of the dialectical logic, on the one hand, and, simultaneously, a revision of some theories and principles of theoretical physics in accordance with that logic, on the other hand, which eventually resulted in the theory expounded in this book. The first rough results, such as the existence of ether, its composition and the phenomenon of spontaneous generation of neutrons in it, were achieved early in the 80s, but it took me about fifteen years more to complete this research in a sufficiently adequate and convincing form.
Two themes are considered in this paper. First of all in the Introduction a comment is made about the Tzitzéica equation which occurred in the author's work as reported in [1]. Much recent work has referred to this equation and a representative bibliography is given in this paper with brief comments. The second theme of this paper is concerned with work surrounding Quantum Solitons and the author's talk at the ISLAND 2 meeting under the title ‘Quantum solitons’ is briefly summarised. An extended review of this subject matter has now appeared in [2] and as there the quantum soliton of the quantum attractive NLS model is seen as a ‘qubit’ for quantum information purposes. It is hoped that this summary and/or the reference [2] can help to stimulate further interest in this ‘quantum’ aspect of our subject in the solitons community. The actual observation of a quantum soliton is also reported and a proper theoretical description of it given. Reference is made to -boson lattices first as a simple example of the quantum inverse method in the Introduction and then as a subject matter in its own right at the end of the paper.