Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Everlasting security in the bounded storage model

Yonatan Aumann, Yan Zong Ding, Michael O. Rabin

Published Jun 1, 2002• 136 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We address the problem of the-security of cryptographic protocols in face of future advances in computing technology and algorithmic research. The problem stems from the fact may be deemed that computations which at a given point in time may be deemed infeasible, can, in the course of years or decades, be made possible with improved hardware and/or breakthroughs in code-breaking algorithms. In such cases, the security of historical , but nonetheless highly confidential data may be in jeopardy. We present a scheme for efficient secure two-party communication with provable everlasting security. The security is guaranteed in face of any future technological advances, given the current state of of the art. Furthermore, the security of the messages is also guaranteed even if the secret encryption/decryption key is revealed in the future, The scheme is based on the bounded storage model and provides information-theoretic security in this model. The bounded storage model postulates an adversary who is computationally unbounded, and is only bounded in the amount of storage (not computation space) available to store the output of his computation. The bound on the storage can be arbitrarily large (e.g., 100 Tbytes), as long as it is fixed. Given this storage bound, our protocols guarantee that even a computationally all powerful adversary gains no information about a message (except with a probability that is exponentially small in the security parameter k). The bound on storage space need only hold at the time of the message transmission. Thereafter, no additional storage space or, computational power can help the adversary in deciphering the message. We present two protocols. The first protocol, which elaborates on the autoregressive (AR) protocol of Aumann and Rabin (see Advances in Cryptology-Crypto '99, p. 65-79, 1999), employs a short secret key whose size is independent of the length of the message, but uses many public random bits. The second protocol uses an optimal number of public random bits, but employs a longer secret key. Our proof of security utilizes a novel linear algebraic technique.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2002.1003845

Related papers

Provable everlasting security in the bounded storage model

Michael O. Rabin, Yan Zong Ding

Traditional modern cryptography relies on unproven complexity assumptions that certain problems, such as integer factorization, are computationally hard, and the adversary is bounded in computing power. However, advances in algorithms and computing technology may render current cryptosystems insecure, and lead to the decryption of past secret messages. On the other hand, Shannon's pessimistic negative result essentially implies that if the adversary is all-powerful and has complete access to the communication line, then efficient practical solutions for information-theoretic security do not exist. This thesis is a study of cryptography in the bounded storage model, where provable everlasting security can be achieved efficiently without any complexity assumption. It first presents an efficient scheme for encryption and authentication that is provably secure against strong adaptive attacks, by an adversary who is computationally unbounded and only storage-bounded. A major new result is that the shared secret key employed by the sender and the receiver can be re-used to send an exponential number of messages. Our encryption scheme further enjoys the surprising property that even if the secret key is captured by the adversary after the transmission of the ciphertext, the secrecy of the message is assured. The above is joint work with Michael Rabin. Oblivious transfer is a cryptographic protocol that can serve as a basic primitive for all of cryptography. This thesis presents an implementation of oblivious transfer in the bounded storage model, which is again provably secure without complexity assumption.

•Jan 1, 2001•7 citations

Perfect Secrecy in the Bounded Storage Model

Divyanshu Bhardwaj, Hamid R. Sadjadpour

In this paper, we propose a new provably secure cryptosystem for two party communication that provides security in the face of new technological breakthroughs. Most of the practical cryptosystems in use today can be breached in the future with new sophisticated methods. This jeopardizes the security of older but highly confidential messages. Our protocol is based on the bounded storage model first introduced in [1]. The protocol is secure as long as there is bound on the storage, however large it may be. We also suggest methods to extend the protocol to unbounded storage models where access to adversary is limited. Our protocol is a substantial improvement over previously known protocols and uses short key and optimal number of public random bits size of which is independent of message length. The smaller and constant length of key and public random string makes the scheme more practical. The protocol generates key using elements of the additive group$\mathbb{Z}_{\mathrm{n}}$. Our protocol is very generalized and the protocol in [1] is a special case of our protocol. Our protocol is a step forward in making provably secure cryptosystems practical. An important open problem raised in [2] was designing an algorithm with short key and size of public random string$O(\mathcal{B})$where$\mathcal{B}$bounds the storage of adversary. Our protocol satisfies the conditions and is easy to implement.

Globecom•Dec 1, 2021•0 citations

On the Semantic Security in the General Bounded Storage Model: A New Proof

Mohammad Moltafet, Hamid R. Sadjadpour, Zouheir Rezki

In the bounded storage model introduced by Maurer, the adversary is computationally unbounded and has a bounded storage capacity. In this model, perfect secrecy is guaranteed by using a publicly available random string whose length is larger than the adversary storage capacity. The protocol proposed by Maurer is simple, from the perspective of implementation, and efficient, from the perspective of the initial secret key size and random string length. However, he provided the proof of the security for the case where the adversary can access a constant fraction of the random string and store onlyoriginal bitsof the random string. In this paper, we provide a new proof of the security of the protocol proposed by Maurer for the general bounded storage model, i.e., the adversary can access all bits of the random string, and store the output of any Boolean function on the string. We reaffirm that the protocol isabsolutely semantically securein the general bounded storage model.

arXiv:2403.18935•IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security•Jan 1, 2024•2 citations

Certified Everlasting Functional Encryption

Taiga Hiroka, Tomoyuki Morimae, Ryo Nishimaki +1 more

Computational security in cryptography has a risk that computational assumptions underlying the security are broken in the future. One solution is to construct information-theoretically-secure protocols, but many cryptographic primitives are known to be impossible (or unlikely) to have information-theoretical security even in the quantum world. A nice compromise (intrinsic to quantum) is certified everlasting security, which roughly means the following. A receiver with possession of quantum encrypted data can issue a certificate that shows that the receiver has deleted the encrypted data. If the certificate is valid, the security is guaranteed even if the receiver becomes computationally unbounded. Although several cryptographic primitives, such as commitments and zero-knowledge, have been made certified everlasting secure, there are many other important primitives that are not known to be certified everlasting secure. In this paper, we introduce certified everlasting FE. In this primitive, the receiver with the ciphertext of a message m and the functional decryption key of a function f can obtain f(m) and nothing else. The security holds even if the adversary becomes computationally unbounded after issuing a valid certificate. We, first, construct certified everlasting FE for P/poly circuits where only a single key query is allowed for the adversary. We, then, extend it to q-bounded one for NC1 circuits where q-bounded means that q key queries are allowed for the adversary with an a priori bounded polynomial q. For the construction of certified everlasting FE, we introduce and construct certified everlasting versions of secret-key encryption, public-key encryption, receiver non-committing encryption, and a garbling scheme, which are of independent interest.

arXiv:2207.13878•Jul 28, 2022•4 citations

The Bare Bounded-Storage Model: The Tight Bound on the Storage Requirement for Key Agreement

Stefan Dziembowski, Ueli M. Maurer

In the bounded-storage model (BSM) for information-theoretic secure encryption and key agreement, one makes use of a random string whose length is greater than the assumed bound on the adversary Eve's storage capacity. The legitimate parties, Alice and Bob, execute a protocol, over an authenticated channel accessible to Eve, to generate a secret key about which Eve has essentially no information even if she has infinite computing power. The string is either assumed to be accessible to all parties or communicated publicly from Alice to Bob. While in the BSM one often assumes that Alice and Bob initially share a short secret key, and the goal of the protocol is to generate a much longer key, in this communication, we consider the bare BSM without any initially shared secret key. It is proved that in the bare BSM, secret key agreement is impossible unless Alice and Bob have themselves very high storage capacity, namely, . This proves the optimality of a scheme proposed by Cachin and Maurer.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•May 29, 2008•13 citations

Keyless secrecy against bounded adversaries

Anne Broadbent, Upendra Kapshikar, Denis Rochette

We introduce a keyless coding/cryptographic primitive that asks for two guarantees at once: the receiver is never fooled into accepting a message other than the one sent, and the adversary learns nothing about the message unless the receiver aborts. Neither the sender nor the receiver holds a secret key, and no computational hardness is assumed. The only restriction is on the adversary's online computation: the receiver aborts if nothing arrives by a fixed deadline, so the adversary must forward something before it, and her map in that window is computed by a circuit of size (or depth) at most $p$; before and after, she is unbounded. For every polynomial $p$ we construct such an efficient quantum scheme, encoding $k$-bit messages into $n = O(k)$ qubits with circuits of size $\mathrm{poly}(n,p)$. No classical scheme achieves this type of everlasting security, at any choice of parameters. Our techniques also resolve open questions about universal tamper detection against families restricted in cardinality rather than in circuit size. We settle a question of Broadbent, Kapshikar and Rochette on relaxed tamper detection. As a corollary, we obtain the first efficient non-malleable code secure against global quantum tampering, with no split-state restriction, whereas the current constructions in the literature require the codeword to be split into non-communicating shares.

quant-pharXiv:2609.12251•Sep 14, 2026•0 citations
We address the problem of the-security of cryptographic protocols in face of future advances in computing technology and algorithmic research. The problem stems from the fact may be deemed that computations which at a given point in time may be deemed infeasible, can, in the course of years or decades, be made possible with improved hardware and/or breakthroughs in code-breaking algorithms. In such cases, the security of historical , but nonetheless highly confidential data may be in jeopardy. We present a scheme for efficient secure two-party communication with provable everlasting security. The security is guaranteed in face of any future technological advances, given the current state of of the art. Furthermore, the security of the messages is also guaranteed even if the secret encryption/decryption key is revealed in the future, The scheme is based on the bounded storage model and provides information-theoretic security in this model. The bounded storage model postulates an adversary who is computationally unbounded, and is only bounded in the amount of storage (not computation space) available to store the output of his computation. The bound on the storage can be arbitrarily large (e.g., 100 Tbytes), as long as it is fixed. Given this storage bound, our protocols guarantee that even a computationally all powerful adversary gains no information about a message (except with a probability that is exponentially small in the security parameter k). The bound on storage space need only hold at the time of the message transmission. Thereafter, no additional storage space or, computational power can help the adversary in deciphering the message. We present two protocols. The first protocol, which elaborates on the autoregressive (AR) protocol of Aumann and Rabin (see Advances in Cryptology-Crypto '99, p. 65-79, 1999), employs a short secret key whose size is independent of the length of the message, but uses many public random bits. The second protocol uses an optimal number of public random bits, but employs a longer secret key. Our proof of security utilizes a novel linear algebraic technique.
Traditional modern cryptography relies on unproven complexity assumptions that certain problems, such as integer factorization, are computationally hard, and the adversary is bounded in computing power. However, advances in algorithms and computing technology may render current cryptosystems insecure, and lead to the decryption of past secret messages. On the other hand, Shannon's pessimistic negative result essentially implies that if the adversary is all-powerful and has complete access to the communication line, then efficient practical solutions for information-theoretic security do not exist. This thesis is a study of cryptography in the bounded storage model, where provable everlasting security can be achieved efficiently without any complexity assumption. It first presents an efficient scheme for encryption and authentication that is provably secure against strong adaptive attacks, by an adversary who is computationally unbounded and only storage-bounded. A major new result is that the shared secret key employed by the sender and the receiver can be re-used to send an exponential number of messages. Our encryption scheme further enjoys the surprising property that even if the secret key is captured by the adversary after the transmission of the ciphertext, the secrecy of the message is assured. The above is joint work with Michael Rabin. Oblivious transfer is a cryptographic protocol that can serve as a basic primitive for all of cryptography. This thesis presents an implementation of oblivious transfer in the bounded storage model, which is again provably secure without complexity assumption.
In this paper, we propose a new provably secure cryptosystem for two party communication that provides security in the face of new technological breakthroughs. Most of the practical cryptosystems in use today can be breached in the future with new sophisticated methods. This jeopardizes the security of older but highly confidential messages. Our protocol is based on the bounded storage model first introduced in [1]. The protocol is secure as long as there is bound on the storage, however large it may be. We also suggest methods to extend the protocol to unbounded storage models where access to adversary is limited. Our protocol is a substantial improvement over previously known protocols and uses short key and optimal number of public random bits size of which is independent of message length. The smaller and constant length of key and public random string makes the scheme more practical. The protocol generates key using elements of the additive groupZn\mathbb{Z}_{\mathrm{n}}Zn​. Our protocol is very generalized and the protocol in [1] is a special case of our protocol. Our protocol is a step forward in making provably secure cryptosystems practical. An important open problem raised in [2] was designing an algorithm with short key and size of public random stringO(B)O(\mathcal{B})O(B)whereB\mathcal{B}Bbounds the storage of adversary. Our protocol satisfies the conditions and is easy to implement.
In the bounded storage model introduced by Maurer, the adversary is computationally unbounded and has a bounded storage capacity. In this model, perfect secrecy is guaranteed by using a publicly available random string whose length is larger than the adversary storage capacity. The protocol proposed by Maurer is simple, from the perspective of implementation, and efficient, from the perspective of the initial secret key size and random string length. However, he provided the proof of the security for the case where the adversary can access a constant fraction of the random string and store onlyoriginal bitsof the random string. In this paper, we provide a new proof of the security of the protocol proposed by Maurer for the general bounded storage model, i.e., the adversary can access all bits of the random string, and store the output of any Boolean function on the string. We reaffirm that the protocol isabsolutely semantically securein the general bounded storage model.
Computational security in cryptography has a risk that computational assumptions underlying the security are broken in the future. One solution is to construct information-theoretically-secure protocols, but many cryptographic primitives are known to be impossible (or unlikely) to have information-theoretical security even in the quantum world. A nice compromise (intrinsic to quantum) is certified everlasting security, which roughly means the following. A receiver with possession of quantum encrypted data can issue a certificate that shows that the receiver has deleted the encrypted data. If the certificate is valid, the security is guaranteed even if the receiver becomes computationally unbounded. Although several cryptographic primitives, such as commitments and zero-knowledge, have been made certified everlasting secure, there are many other important primitives that are not known to be certified everlasting secure. In this paper, we introduce certified everlasting FE. In this primitive, the receiver with the ciphertext of a message m and the functional decryption key of a function f can obtain f(m) and nothing else. The security holds even if the adversary becomes computationally unbounded after issuing a valid certificate. We, first, construct certified everlasting FE for P/poly circuits where only a single key query is allowed for the adversary. We, then, extend it to q-bounded one for NC1 circuits where q-bounded means that q key queries are allowed for the adversary with an a priori bounded polynomial q. For the construction of certified everlasting FE, we introduce and construct certified everlasting versions of secret-key encryption, public-key encryption, receiver non-committing encryption, and a garbling scheme, which are of independent interest.
In the bounded-storage model (BSM) for information-theoretic secure encryption and key agreement, one makes use of a random string whose length is greater than the assumed bound on the adversary Eve's storage capacity. The legitimate parties, Alice and Bob, execute a protocol, over an authenticated channel accessible to Eve, to generate a secret key about which Eve has essentially no information even if she has infinite computing power. The string is either assumed to be accessible to all parties or communicated publicly from Alice to Bob. While in the BSM one often assumes that Alice and Bob initially share a short secret key, and the goal of the protocol is to generate a much longer key, in this communication, we consider the bare BSM without any initially shared secret key. It is proved that in the bare BSM, secret key agreement is impossible unless Alice and Bob have themselves very high storage capacity, namely, . This proves the optimality of a scheme proposed by Cachin and Maurer.
We introduce a keyless coding/cryptographic primitive that asks for two guarantees at once: the receiver is never fooled into accepting a message other than the one sent, and the adversary learns nothing about the message unless the receiver aborts. Neither the sender nor the receiver holds a secret key, and no computational hardness is assumed. The only restriction is on the adversary's online computation: the receiver aborts if nothing arrives by a fixed deadline, so the adversary must forward something before it, and her map in that window is computed by a circuit of size (or depth) at most ppp; before and after, she is unbounded. For every polynomial ppp we construct such an efficient quantum scheme, encoding kkk-bit messages into n=O(k)n = O(k)n=O(k) qubits with circuits of size poly(n,p)\mathrm{poly}(n,p)poly(n,p). No classical scheme achieves this type of everlasting security, at any choice of parameters. Our techniques also resolve open questions about universal tamper detection against families restricted in cardinality rather than in circuit size. We settle a question of Broadbent, Kapshikar and Rochette on relaxed tamper detection. As a corollary, we obtain the first efficient non-malleable code secure against global quantum tampering, with no split-state restriction, whereas the current constructions in the literature require the codeword to be split into non-communicating shares.