Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

John Bell and Bell's Theorem

Sheldon Goldstein, Roderich Tumulka, Nino Zangh�

Published Jan 1, 2004• 2 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

John Stewart Bell (1928-1990), a truly deep and serious thinker, was one of the leading physi-cists of the 20th century. He became famous for his discovery that quantum mechanics impliesthat nature is nonlocal, i.e., that there are physical inuences between events that propagatefaster than light.From 1960 until his death Bell worked at CERN in Geneva on the physics of particle accel-erators, making a number of important contributions to high-energy physics and quantum eldtheory. Noteworthy was his discovery in 1969, together with Roman Jackiw, of the so-called\Bell-Jackiw-Adler anomaly (discovered independently by Stephen Adler), a mechanism ex-plaining physical e ects such as neutral pion decay (which are unexplainable on the basis of thesymmetries of the classical eld Lagrangian), in terms of an \anomalous term arising from therenormalization of quantum eld theory. Since then this mechanism has become an importantcornerstone of quantum eld theory. Another important contribution was the argument he gavein 1967 for why weak interactions should be described using a gauge theory.John Bell was one of the leading experts|perhaps the leading expert|on the foundations ofquantum mechanics. The book collecting his articles on this subject, Speakable and unspeakablein quantum mechanics, is unsurpassed for clarity and depth and it is still the best reference forwhoever wishes to learn about the eld [4].Bell strongly opposed the \Copenhagen interpretation of quantum physics, according towhich macroscopic objects, such as chairs and planets, do exist out there, but electrons andother microscopic particles do not. According to the Copenhagen view, the world is divided intotwo realms, macro and micro, \classical and \quantum, logical and contradictory|or, as Bellput it in one of his essays, into \speakable and \unspeakable. Along with Albert Einstein,Erwin Schrodinger, Louis de Broglie and !David Bohm, Bell was one of the few physicistscompelled by his conscience to reject the Copenhagen interpretation.Bell emphasized that the empirical facts of quantum physics do not at all force us to renouncerealism. There is, in fact, a realist theory (!Bohmian mechanics, also known as the de Broglie-Bohm theory) that accounts|insofar as the nonrelativistic theory is concerned|for all of thesefacts in a most elegant way. This theory describes a world in which electrons, quarks andthe like are point particles, always having positions that move in a manner dictated by thewave function. It should be taught to students, Bell insisted, as a legitimate alternative tothe prevailing orthodoxy. After GianCarlo Ghirardi, Alberto Rimini, and Tullio Weber in 1986succeeded in formulating a second kind of realist theory, Bell encouraged the further developmentof this theory as well [4, p. 201]. He thought that such a theory contained the seeds of a1

Related papers

John Stewart Bell and Twentieth-Century Physics: Vision and Integrity

Andrew Charles Whitaker

John Stewart Bell (1928-1990) was one of the most important figures in twentieth-century physics, famous for his work on the fundamental aspects of the century's most important theory, quantum mechanics. While the debate over quantum theory between the supremely famous physicists, Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr, appeared to have become sterile in the 1930s, Bell was able to revive it and to make crucial advances - Bell's Theorem or Bell's Inequalities. He was able to demonstrate a contradiction between quantum theory and essential elements of pre-quantum theory - locality and causality. The book gives a non-mathematical account of Bell's relatively impoverished upbringing in Belfast and his education. It describes his major contributions to quantum theory, but also his important work in the physics of accelerators, and nuclear and elementary particle physics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 16, 2016•18 citations

Some Personal Reflections on Quantum Nonlocality and the Contributions of John Bell

Basil J. Hiley

I present the background of the Bohm approach that led John Bell to a study of quantum nonlocality, from which his famous inequalities emerged. I recall the early experiments done at Birkbeck with the aim of exploring the possibility of ‘spontaneous collapse’, a way suggested by Schrödinger to avoid the conclusion that quantum mechanics is grossly nonlocal. I also review some of the work that John did which directly impinged on my own investigations into the foundations of quantum mechanics and report some new investigations towards a more fundamental theory. Introduction My first encounter with quantum nonlocality was in discussions with David Bohm when I joined him as an assistant lecturer at Birkbeck in the sixties. Although my PhD thesis had been in condensed matter physics under the supervision of Cyril Domb, I had always been fascinated and puzzled by quantum phenomena, and when the opportunity to study the subject with Bohm came up, I took it. I would listen to the discussions between Bohm and Roger Penrose, who was at Birkbeck at the time, and it soon became clear that the prescribed interpretation of quantum mechanics that I was taught as an undergraduate left too many questions unanswered. At that time there was a very strange atmosphere in the physics community. I was often informed that there were no problems with the interpretation of the quantum formalism. If I did not follow the well-prescribed rules of the quantum algorithm, I would be ‘wasting my time’. There was no alternative, just do it! But Louis de Broglie and David Bohm had shown there was another way. However, their views were strongly opposed by many, and as far as I could judge their reasons did not seem to be based on mathematics or on logic, but on a preconceived notion that the formalism was, in principle, the best we could do. The experimental data were bizarre when looked upon from the standpoint of classical physics, but the uncertainty principle somehow prevented us from examining the actual process in detail. Reality was somehow veiled (see [1]).Were we condemned to use a mere algorithm or was there an underlying ontology?

arXiv:1412.0594•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 31, 2016•1 citation

The 1960s

Andrew Charles Whitaker

During the 1960s, Bell produced his seminal work on the foundations of quantum theory, first showing that, contrary to von Neumann’s argument, hidden variable theories were allowed but then that they had to be non-local. Thus, he showed that quantum theory did not respect local causality, and he outlined experiments that could be used to test whether the assumption of local realism was true in quantum theory: Bell’s theorem, or Bell’s inequality, or Bell’s inequalities. His work was followed up by John Clauser, Abner Shimony, Michael Horne, and Richard Holt, who produced the CHSH inequality. Bell had moved to CERN, where he worked on the theory of neutrino experiments, and on nuclear and elementary particle physics, making crucial suggestions concerning the use of gauge theory for each type of physical force and also producing the Adler–Bell–Jackiw anomaly, or the ABJ anomaly.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 16, 2016•0 citations

Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy

James S. Bell, Alain Aspect

John Bell, FRS was one of the leading expositors and interpreters of modern quantum theory. He is particularly famous for his discovery of the crucial difference between the predictions of conventional quantum mechanics and the implications of local causality, a concept insisted on by Einstein. John Bell's work played a major role in the development of our current understanding of the profound nature of quantum concepts and of the fundamental limitations they impose on the applicability of the classical ideas of space, time and locality. This book includes all of John Bell's published and unpublished papers on the conceptual and philosophical problems of quantum mechanics, including two papers that appeared after the first edition was published. The book includes a short Preface written by the author for the first edition, and also an introduction by Alain Aspect that puts into context John Bell's enormous contribution to the quantum philosophy debate.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 3, 2004•1,609 citations

A Critical Analysis of the Quantum Nonlocality Problem: On the Polemic Assessment of What Bell Did

Justo Pastor Lambare

Through a historical analysis of John Stewart Bell's works, we confront a stance that distorts his views on the nature of quantum theory, more concretely, on quantum nonlocality. We briefly analyze Bell's arguments for quantum nonlocality as he developed them from 1964 until his sudden and unexpected death in 1990. As is well known, the alleged nonlocal character of quantum mechanics is inextricably related to the formulation of the Bell theorem. However, the departure from the clear line of reasoning that John Bell tried to convey has led to a polarization of part of the scientific community into radical irreconcilable positions. We show how the correct appreciation of Bell's work calls for reinterpreting the usual significance given to the Bell theorem yielding a more rational perspective of the problem. We formalize the correct argument sustaining the nonlocal character of quantum mechanics and comment on alternatives that may justify considering quantum mechanics as a local theory.

•Apr 6, 2023•0 citations

John S. Bell’s concept of local causality

Travis Norsen

John Stewart Bell’s famous theorem is widely regarded as one of the most important developments in the foundations of physics. Yet even as we approach the 50th anniversary of Bell’s discovery, its meaning and implications remain controversial. Many workers assert that Bell’s theorem refutes the possibility suggested by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) of supplementing ordinary quantum theory with “hidden” variables that might restore determinism and/or some notion of an observer-independent reality. But Bell himself interpreted the theorem very differently—as establishing an “essential conflict” between the well-tested empirical predictions of quantum theory and relativistic local causality. Our goal is to make Bell’s own views more widely known and to explain Bell’s little-known formulation of the concept of relativistic local causality on which his theorem rests. We also show precisely how Bell’s formulation of local causality can be used to derive an empirically testable Bell-type inequality and to recapitulate the EPR argument.

arXiv:0707.0401•American Journal of Physics•Nov 29, 2011•157 citations
John Stewart Bell (1928-1990), a truly deep and serious thinker, was one of the leading physi-cists of the 20th century. He became famous for his discovery that quantum mechanics impliesthat nature is nonlocal, i.e., that there are physical inuences between events that propagatefaster than light.From 1960 until his death Bell worked at CERN in Geneva on the physics of particle accel-erators, making a number of important contributions to high-energy physics and quantum eldtheory. Noteworthy was his discovery in 1969, together with Roman Jackiw, of the so-called\Bell-Jackiw-Adler anomaly (discovered independently by Stephen Adler), a mechanism ex-plaining physical e ects such as neutral pion decay (which are unexplainable on the basis of thesymmetries of the classical eld Lagrangian), in terms of an \anomalous term arising from therenormalization of quantum eld theory. Since then this mechanism has become an importantcornerstone of quantum eld theory. Another important contribution was the argument he gavein 1967 for why weak interactions should be described using a gauge theory.John Bell was one of the leading experts|perhaps the leading expert|on the foundations ofquantum mechanics. The book collecting his articles on this subject, Speakable and unspeakablein quantum mechanics, is unsurpassed for clarity and depth and it is still the best reference forwhoever wishes to learn about the eld [4].Bell strongly opposed the \Copenhagen interpretation of quantum physics, according towhich macroscopic objects, such as chairs and planets, do exist out there, but electrons andother microscopic particles do not. According to the Copenhagen view, the world is divided intotwo realms, macro and micro, \classical and \quantum, logical and contradictory|or, as Bellput it in one of his essays, into \speakable and \unspeakable. Along with Albert Einstein,Erwin Schrodinger, Louis de Broglie and !David Bohm, Bell was one of the few physicistscompelled by his conscience to reject the Copenhagen interpretation.Bell emphasized that the empirical facts of quantum physics do not at all force us to renouncerealism. There is, in fact, a realist theory (!Bohmian mechanics, also known as the de Broglie-Bohm theory) that accounts|insofar as the nonrelativistic theory is concerned|for all of thesefacts in a most elegant way. This theory describes a world in which electrons, quarks andthe like are point particles, always having positions that move in a manner dictated by thewave function. It should be taught to students, Bell insisted, as a legitimate alternative tothe prevailing orthodoxy. After GianCarlo Ghirardi, Alberto Rimini, and Tullio Weber in 1986succeeded in formulating a second kind of realist theory, Bell encouraged the further developmentof this theory as well [4, p. 201]. He thought that such a theory contained the seeds of a1
John Stewart Bell (1928-1990) was one of the most important figures in twentieth-century physics, famous for his work on the fundamental aspects of the century's most important theory, quantum mechanics. While the debate over quantum theory between the supremely famous physicists, Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr, appeared to have become sterile in the 1930s, Bell was able to revive it and to make crucial advances - Bell's Theorem or Bell's Inequalities. He was able to demonstrate a contradiction between quantum theory and essential elements of pre-quantum theory - locality and causality. The book gives a non-mathematical account of Bell's relatively impoverished upbringing in Belfast and his education. It describes his major contributions to quantum theory, but also his important work in the physics of accelerators, and nuclear and elementary particle physics.
I present the background of the Bohm approach that led John Bell to a study of quantum nonlocality, from which his famous inequalities emerged. I recall the early experiments done at Birkbeck with the aim of exploring the possibility of ‘spontaneous collapse’, a way suggested by Schrödinger to avoid the conclusion that quantum mechanics is grossly nonlocal. I also review some of the work that John did which directly impinged on my own investigations into the foundations of quantum mechanics and report some new investigations towards a more fundamental theory. Introduction My first encounter with quantum nonlocality was in discussions with David Bohm when I joined him as an assistant lecturer at Birkbeck in the sixties. Although my PhD thesis had been in condensed matter physics under the supervision of Cyril Domb, I had always been fascinated and puzzled by quantum phenomena, and when the opportunity to study the subject with Bohm came up, I took it. I would listen to the discussions between Bohm and Roger Penrose, who was at Birkbeck at the time, and it soon became clear that the prescribed interpretation of quantum mechanics that I was taught as an undergraduate left too many questions unanswered. At that time there was a very strange atmosphere in the physics community. I was often informed that there were no problems with the interpretation of the quantum formalism. If I did not follow the well-prescribed rules of the quantum algorithm, I would be ‘wasting my time’. There was no alternative, just do it! But Louis de Broglie and David Bohm had shown there was another way. However, their views were strongly opposed by many, and as far as I could judge their reasons did not seem to be based on mathematics or on logic, but on a preconceived notion that the formalism was, in principle, the best we could do. The experimental data were bizarre when looked upon from the standpoint of classical physics, but the uncertainty principle somehow prevented us from examining the actual process in detail. Reality was somehow veiled (see [1]).Were we condemned to use a mere algorithm or was there an underlying ontology?
During the 1960s, Bell produced his seminal work on the foundations of quantum theory, first showing that, contrary to von Neumann’s argument, hidden variable theories were allowed but then that they had to be non-local. Thus, he showed that quantum theory did not respect local causality, and he outlined experiments that could be used to test whether the assumption of local realism was true in quantum theory: Bell’s theorem, or Bell’s inequality, or Bell’s inequalities. His work was followed up by John Clauser, Abner Shimony, Michael Horne, and Richard Holt, who produced the CHSH inequality. Bell had moved to CERN, where he worked on the theory of neutrino experiments, and on nuclear and elementary particle physics, making crucial suggestions concerning the use of gauge theory for each type of physical force and also producing the Adler–Bell–Jackiw anomaly, or the ABJ anomaly.
John Bell, FRS was one of the leading expositors and interpreters of modern quantum theory. He is particularly famous for his discovery of the crucial difference between the predictions of conventional quantum mechanics and the implications of local causality, a concept insisted on by Einstein. John Bell's work played a major role in the development of our current understanding of the profound nature of quantum concepts and of the fundamental limitations they impose on the applicability of the classical ideas of space, time and locality. This book includes all of John Bell's published and unpublished papers on the conceptual and philosophical problems of quantum mechanics, including two papers that appeared after the first edition was published. The book includes a short Preface written by the author for the first edition, and also an introduction by Alain Aspect that puts into context John Bell's enormous contribution to the quantum philosophy debate.
Through a historical analysis of John Stewart Bell's works, we confront a stance that distorts his views on the nature of quantum theory, more concretely, on quantum nonlocality. We briefly analyze Bell's arguments for quantum nonlocality as he developed them from 1964 until his sudden and unexpected death in 1990. As is well known, the alleged nonlocal character of quantum mechanics is inextricably related to the formulation of the Bell theorem. However, the departure from the clear line of reasoning that John Bell tried to convey has led to a polarization of part of the scientific community into radical irreconcilable positions. We show how the correct appreciation of Bell's work calls for reinterpreting the usual significance given to the Bell theorem yielding a more rational perspective of the problem. We formalize the correct argument sustaining the nonlocal character of quantum mechanics and comment on alternatives that may justify considering quantum mechanics as a local theory.
John Stewart Bell’s famous theorem is widely regarded as one of the most important developments in the foundations of physics. Yet even as we approach the 50th anniversary of Bell’s discovery, its meaning and implications remain controversial. Many workers assert that Bell’s theorem refutes the possibility suggested by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) of supplementing ordinary quantum theory with “hidden” variables that might restore determinism and/or some notion of an observer-independent reality. But Bell himself interpreted the theorem very differently—as establishing an “essential conflict” between the well-tested empirical predictions of quantum theory and relativistic local causality. Our goal is to make Bell’s own views more widely known and to explain Bell’s little-known formulation of the concept of relativistic local causality on which his theorem rests. We also show precisely how Bell’s formulation of local causality can be used to derive an empirically testable Bell-type inequality and to recapitulate the EPR argument.