Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics-Uspekhi

Bell's theorem for trichotomic observables

Aleksandr V. Belinskii

Published Mar 31, 1997• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Bell's paradoxes, due to the fundamental properties of light and the nature of the photon, are discussed within a single framework with a view to checking the hypothesis that a stationary, non-negative, joint probability distribution function exists. This hypothesis, related to the local theory of hidden parameters as a possible interpretation of quantum theory, enables experimentally verifiable Bell's inequalities to be formulated. The dependence of these inequalities on the number of observers V is considered. Quantum theory predicts the breakdown of Bell's inequalities in optical experiments. It is shown that as V increases, the requirements on the quantum effectiveness of the detector, η, are reduced from η > 2/3 at V = 2 to η > 1/2 for V → ∞. Examples of joint probability distribution functions are given for illustrative purposes, and a way to resolve the Greenberg–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox is suggested.

DOI
10.1070/pu1997v040n03abeh000225

Related papers

Bell's theorem and its optical tests

J. C. Garrison, R. Y. Chiao

This chapter begins with a review of the ideas of locality and realism which provide the basis for the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox. The general conditions defining a local, realistic theory are stated, and then used to prove Bell's theorem, which yields — for any local, realistic theory — an inequality satisfied by certain linear combinations of correlations. It is shown that this inequality is violated by quantum theory and by experiment. The chapter ends with a discussion of possible experimental loopholes and the alternative Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state, which would, in principle, make the use of statistical correlations unnecessary.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 5, 2008•0 citations

Bell’s theorem: Critique of proofs with and without inequalities

K. Hess

Most of the standard proofs of the Bell theorem are based on the Kolmogorov axioms of probability theory. We show that these proofs contain mathematical steps that cannot be reconciled with the Kolmogorov axioms. Specifically we demonstrate that these proofs ignore the conclusion of a theorem of Vorob'ev on the consistency of joint distributions. As a consequence Bell's theorem stated in its full generality remains unproven, in particular, for extended parameter spaces that are still objective local and that include instrument parameters that are correlated by both time and instrument settings. Although the Bell theorem correctly rules out certain small classes of hidden variables, for these extended parameter spaces the standard proofs come to a halt. The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) approach is based on similar fallacious arguments. For this case we are able to present an objective local computer experiment that simulates the experimental test of GHZ performed by Pan, Bouwmeester, Daniell, Weinfurter and Zeilinger and that directly contradicts their claim that Einstein-local elements of reality can neither explain the results of quantum mechanical theory nor their experimental results.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410015•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2005•91 citations

Bell's theorem without the hypothesis of locality

Aleksandr V. Belinskii

One of the Bell's assumptions in the original derivation of his inequalities was the hypothesis of locality, i.e., of the absence of the influence of two remote measuring instruments on one another. That is why violations of these inequalities observed in experiments are often interpreted as a manifestation of the nonlocal nature of quantum mechanics, or a refutation of local realism. In this paper, Bell's inequality is derived in its traditional form, without resorting to the hypothesis of locality, the only assumption being that the probability distributions are nonnegative. These probability distributions are calculated, for a specific optical experiment, in the framework of quantum theory and it is shown that they can take on negative values. This can therefore be regarded as a rigorous proof that the hypothesis of locality is not relevant to violations of Bell's inequalities. The physical meaning of the obtained results is examined.

Physics-Uspekhi•Feb 28, 1994•12 citations

Extension of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox and Bell's theorem

J. D. Franson

In their original paper, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) questioned the probabilistic nature of the quantum theory using an argument based on the quantum-mechanical correlations between two distant particles which had once interacted. Bell later proved that the quantum theory and any local theory differ significantly in their predictions for these experimentally measurable correlations. It is shown that the arguments of EPR can be extended to apply equally well to certain properties of a single particle or system and that, in analogy with Bell's theorem, the predictions of the quantum theory for certain single-particle experiments are in disagreement with the predictions of any local theory. For example, based on either the quantum theory or existing experimental observations, it is possible to arrange for a photon to have a negligible probability of not being absorbed by some system of finite dimensions, such as one of a large number of atoms, within a finite time interval. It is shown that any local theory which satisfies this requirement must also require that negligible interference effects occur in an optical interferometer at sufficiently low intensities from an incoherent source in combination with sufficiently large separation $L$ between the two optical paths. Time-reversal invariance is used to estimate the requirement $L\ensuremath{\gg}\frac{3{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}}{4{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}{r}_{c}}$, where $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is the wavelength of the light and ${r}_{c}$ is the classical radius of the electron; at optical wavelengths this distance is on the order of 10 m. The same separation should also be required between the photon detectors in any optical experiment based on Bell's theorem. A review of the literature indicates that no existing experimental data, either from optical interferometers or experiments based on Bell's theorem, can be used to distinguish between the local and quantum theories. An investigation of low-intensity optical interference at large path separations is proposed for this purpose.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Aug 15, 1982•6 citations

Bell's paradoxes without the introduction of hidden variables

Aleksandr V. Belinskii

A hidden-variable theory is the traditional, but not unique, basis for constructing various types of Bell's theorem. The starting point may also be a recognition of the existence of a positive-definite probability distribution function. This assumption alone is used to formulate and prove Bell's paradoxes of different types. A specific example is used to show that a formal quantum calculation can sometimes give negative values of the joint probabilities that are used in the proof. An attempt is made to identify the physical meaning of this result and an algorithm for determination of negative joint probabilities of this type is proposed.

Physics-Uspekhi•Apr 30, 1994•19 citations

Bell theorem without inequalities for two particles. II. Inefficient detectors

Daniel M. Greenberger, Michael Horne, Anton Zeilinger +1 more

We again consider (as in a companion paper) an entangled two-particle state that is produced from two independent downconversion sources by the process of ``entanglement swapping,'' so that the particles have never met. We show that there is a natural extension of the Einstein-Pololsky-Rosen discussion of ``elements of reality'' to include inefficient detectors. We consider inefficient deterministic, local, realistic models of quantum theory that are ``robust,'' which we consider to be the minimum requirement for them to be taken seriously. By robust, we mean they satisfy the following three criteria: (a) they reproduce the quantum results for perfect correlations, if all particles are detected; (b) they produce some counts for every setting of the angles (so they do not describe some experiments that can easily be performed as ``impossible''); (c) all their hidden variables are relevant (they must each produce a detectable result in some experiment). For such models, we prove a Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger type theorem for arbitrary detection efficiencies, showing that any such theory is inconsistent with the quantum-mechanical perfect correlations. This theorem holds for individual events with no inequalities. As a result, the theorem is also independent of any random sampling hypothesis, and we take it as a refutation of such realistic theories, free of the detection efficiency and random sampling ``loopholes.'' The hidden variable analysis depends crucially on the use of two independent laser sources for the downconversions. We also investigate the necessity of using two independent sources versus a single source for all particles. Finally, we argue that the state we use can legitimately be considered as a two-particle state, and used as such in experiments.

arXiv:quant-ph/0510207•Physical Review A•Aug 22, 2008•19 citations
Bell's paradoxes, due to the fundamental properties of light and the nature of the photon, are discussed within a single framework with a view to checking the hypothesis that a stationary, non-negative, joint probability distribution function exists. This hypothesis, related to the local theory of hidden parameters as a possible interpretation of quantum theory, enables experimentally verifiable Bell's inequalities to be formulated. The dependence of these inequalities on the number of observers V is considered. Quantum theory predicts the breakdown of Bell's inequalities in optical experiments. It is shown that as V increases, the requirements on the quantum effectiveness of the detector, η, are reduced from η > 2/3 at V = 2 to η > 1/2 for V → ∞. Examples of joint probability distribution functions are given for illustrative purposes, and a way to resolve the Greenberg–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox is suggested.
This chapter begins with a review of the ideas of locality and realism which provide the basis for the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox. The general conditions defining a local, realistic theory are stated, and then used to prove Bell's theorem, which yields — for any local, realistic theory — an inequality satisfied by certain linear combinations of correlations. It is shown that this inequality is violated by quantum theory and by experiment. The chapter ends with a discussion of possible experimental loopholes and the alternative Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state, which would, in principle, make the use of statistical correlations unnecessary.
Most of the standard proofs of the Bell theorem are based on the Kolmogorov axioms of probability theory. We show that these proofs contain mathematical steps that cannot be reconciled with the Kolmogorov axioms. Specifically we demonstrate that these proofs ignore the conclusion of a theorem of Vorob'ev on the consistency of joint distributions. As a consequence Bell's theorem stated in its full generality remains unproven, in particular, for extended parameter spaces that are still objective local and that include instrument parameters that are correlated by both time and instrument settings. Although the Bell theorem correctly rules out certain small classes of hidden variables, for these extended parameter spaces the standard proofs come to a halt. The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) approach is based on similar fallacious arguments. For this case we are able to present an objective local computer experiment that simulates the experimental test of GHZ performed by Pan, Bouwmeester, Daniell, Weinfurter and Zeilinger and that directly contradicts their claim that Einstein-local elements of reality can neither explain the results of quantum mechanical theory nor their experimental results.
One of the Bell's assumptions in the original derivation of his inequalities was the hypothesis of locality, i.e., of the absence of the influence of two remote measuring instruments on one another. That is why violations of these inequalities observed in experiments are often interpreted as a manifestation of the nonlocal nature of quantum mechanics, or a refutation of local realism. In this paper, Bell's inequality is derived in its traditional form, without resorting to the hypothesis of locality, the only assumption being that the probability distributions are nonnegative. These probability distributions are calculated, for a specific optical experiment, in the framework of quantum theory and it is shown that they can take on negative values. This can therefore be regarded as a rigorous proof that the hypothesis of locality is not relevant to violations of Bell's inequalities. The physical meaning of the obtained results is examined.
In their original paper, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) questioned the probabilistic nature of the quantum theory using an argument based on the quantum-mechanical correlations between two distant particles which had once interacted. Bell later proved that the quantum theory and any local theory differ significantly in their predictions for these experimentally measurable correlations. It is shown that the arguments of EPR can be extended to apply equally well to certain properties of a single particle or system and that, in analogy with Bell's theorem, the predictions of the quantum theory for certain single-particle experiments are in disagreement with the predictions of any local theory. For example, based on either the quantum theory or existing experimental observations, it is possible to arrange for a photon to have a negligible probability of not being absorbed by some system of finite dimensions, such as one of a large number of atoms, within a finite time interval. It is shown that any local theory which satisfies this requirement must also require that negligible interference effects occur in an optical interferometer at sufficiently low intensities from an incoherent source in combination with sufficiently large separation LLL between the two optical paths. Time-reversal invariance is used to estimate the requirement $L\ensuremath{\gg}\frac{3{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}}{4{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}{r}_{c}}$, where $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is the wavelength of the light and rc{r}_{c}rc​ is the classical radius of the electron; at optical wavelengths this distance is on the order of 10 m. The same separation should also be required between the photon detectors in any optical experiment based on Bell's theorem. A review of the literature indicates that no existing experimental data, either from optical interferometers or experiments based on Bell's theorem, can be used to distinguish between the local and quantum theories. An investigation of low-intensity optical interference at large path separations is proposed for this purpose.
A hidden-variable theory is the traditional, but not unique, basis for constructing various types of Bell's theorem. The starting point may also be a recognition of the existence of a positive-definite probability distribution function. This assumption alone is used to formulate and prove Bell's paradoxes of different types. A specific example is used to show that a formal quantum calculation can sometimes give negative values of the joint probabilities that are used in the proof. An attempt is made to identify the physical meaning of this result and an algorithm for determination of negative joint probabilities of this type is proposed.
We again consider (as in a companion paper) an entangled two-particle state that is produced from two independent downconversion sources by the process of ``entanglement swapping,'' so that the particles have never met. We show that there is a natural extension of the Einstein-Pololsky-Rosen discussion of ``elements of reality'' to include inefficient detectors. We consider inefficient deterministic, local, realistic models of quantum theory that are ``robust,'' which we consider to be the minimum requirement for them to be taken seriously. By robust, we mean they satisfy the following three criteria: (a) they reproduce the quantum results for perfect correlations, if all particles are detected; (b) they produce some counts for every setting of the angles (so they do not describe some experiments that can easily be performed as ``impossible''); (c) all their hidden variables are relevant (they must each produce a detectable result in some experiment). For such models, we prove a Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger type theorem for arbitrary detection efficiencies, showing that any such theory is inconsistent with the quantum-mechanical perfect correlations. This theorem holds for individual events with no inequalities. As a result, the theorem is also independent of any random sampling hypothesis, and we take it as a refutation of such realistic theories, free of the detection efficiency and random sampling ``loopholes.'' The hidden variable analysis depends crucially on the use of two independent laser sources for the downconversions. We also investigate the necessity of using two independent sources versus a single source for all particles. Finally, we argue that the state we use can legitimately be considered as a two-particle state, and used as such in experiments.