Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Bell's theorem and its optical tests

J. C. Garrison, R. Y. Chiao

Published Jun 5, 2008• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter begins with a review of the ideas of locality and realism which provide the basis for the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox. The general conditions defining a local, realistic theory are stated, and then used to prove Bell's theorem, which yields — for any local, realistic theory — an inequality satisfied by certain linear combinations of correlations. It is shown that this inequality is violated by quantum theory and by experiment. The chapter ends with a discussion of possible experimental loopholes and the alternative Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state, which would, in principle, make the use of statistical correlations unnecessary.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198508861.003.0020

Related papers

Bell Inequalities

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract This chapter presents a detailed discussion of Bell inequalities and their experimental tests. Starting from the Aharonov-Bohm version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, we review EPR’s criteria for realism and completeness and Bell’s locality condition, before deriving the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality. This is followed by an exposition on Bell’s original inequality and other Bell inequalities by Wigner, as well as Clauser and Horne. We then discuss the milestones in the experimental violation of Bell inequalities, from the experiment of Freedman and Clauser in the 1970s, to the efforts of Aspect et al. in the 1980s, the experiments by the teams of Zeilinger and Gisin in the 1990s, and culminating the loophole-free tests in 2015. Finally we turn to a brief discussion of the interpretations of quantum mechanics, focusing on contrasting the realist views held by, e.g., Einstein and Bell, and the informational views with proponents such as Brukner and Zeilinger

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2023•1 citation

Bell's Inequality: Excluding Local Realism from a Physical Theory of Nature

Jack H. Berg, Fredrik Brange

An overview of the history of Bell’s inequality is given, beginning with the so-called EPR paradox originally put forward by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen and the impossibility proof of von Neumann. Bell’s inequality, which ultimately shifted the discussion from arguments based on philosophically introduced postulates to the domain of experimental physics, is presented together with experimental attempts from the early 1970s to 2010s to violate this inequality. We introduce three historical loopholes in the experimental schemes which have prevented experimentalists from being able to fully disprove the possibility of a hidden-variables description of nature. Recent experimental data indicate that all the main loopholes are now closed for photons (albeit not simultaneously in one experiment). Besides the class of stochastic local realism that have been tested experimentally, some other possible classical interpretations are mentioned.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

More theorems

Franck Laloë

The Bell theorem can take the form of several inequalities, as we have seen in §4.2. Moreover, since it was discovered, the theorem has stimulated the discovery of several other mathematical contradictions between the predictions of quantum mechanics and those of local realism. We review a few of them in this chapter: GHZ contradictions (§5.1) and their generalization (§5.2), Cabello's inequality (§5.3), and Hardy's impossibilities (§5.4). Finally, in §5.5, we discuss the notion of contextuality and introduce the BKS theorem. GHZ contradiction For many years, everyone thought that Bell had basically exhausted the subject by considering all really interesting situations, and that two-spin systems provided the most spectacular quantum violations of local realism. It therefore came as a surprise to many when in 1989 Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger (GHZ) showed that systems containing more than two correlated particles may actually exhibit even more dramatic violations of local realism [188, 189]. They involve a sign contradiction (100% violation) for perfect correlations, while the BCHSH inequalities are violated by about 40% (Cirelson bound) and deal with situations where the results of measurements are not completely correlated. In this section, we discuss three-particle systems, but generalizations to N particles are possible (§5.2). Derivation GHZ contradictions may occur in various systems, not necessarily involving spins. Initially, they were introduced in the context of entanglement swapping (§6.3.2) for four particles [188] or entanglement of three spinless particles [189].

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 30, 2012•0 citations

Non-Locality and Quantum Theory: New Experimental Evidence

Luigi Accardi, Massimo Regoli

Starting from the late 60’s many experiments have been performed to verify the violation Bell’s inequality by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type correlations. The idea of these experiments being that: (i) Bell’s inequality is a consequence of locality, hence its experimental violation is an indication of non locality; (ii) this violation is a typical quantum phenomenon because any classical system making local choices (either deterministic or random) will produce correlations satisfying this inequality. Both statements (i) and (ii) have been criticized by quantum probability on theoretical grounds (not discussed in the present paper) and the experiment discussed below has been devised to support these theoretical arguments. We emphasize that the goal of our experiment is not to reproduce classically the EPR correlations but to prove that there exist perfectly local classical dynamical systems violating Bell’s inequality. The conclusions of the present experiment are: no contradiction between quantum theory and locality can be deduced from the violation of Bell’s inequality. The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum theory becomes quite reasonable and not metaphyisic if interpreted at the light of the chameleon effect. One can realize quantum entanglement by classical computers. In section (7) we prove that our experiment also provides a classical analogue of the type of logical (i.e. independent of statistics) incompatibilities pointed out by Greenberger, Home and Zeilinger. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Feb 24, 2006•14 citations

Loopholes in Bell inequality tests of local realism

Jan-Åke Larsson

Bell inequalities are intended to show that local realist theories cannot describe the world. A local realist theory is one where physical properties are defined prior to and independent of measurement, and no physical influence can propagate faster than the speed of light. Quantum-mechanical predictions for certain experiments violate the Bell inequality while a local realist theory cannot, and this shows that a local realist theory cannot give those quantum-mechanical predictions. However, because of unexpected circumstances or 'loopholes' in available experiment tests, local realist theories can reproduce the data from these experiments. This paper reviews such loopholes, what effect they have on Bell inequality tests, and how to avoid them in experiment. Avoiding all these simultaneously in one experiment, usually called a 'loophole-free' or 'definitive' Bell test, remains an open task, but is very important for technological tasks such as device-independent security of quantum cryptography, and ultimately for our understanding of the world. This article is part of a special issue of Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical devoted to '50 years of Bell's theorem'.

arXiv:1407.0363•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 9, 2014•274 citations

Extension of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox and Bell's theorem

J. D. Franson

In their original paper, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) questioned the probabilistic nature of the quantum theory using an argument based on the quantum-mechanical correlations between two distant particles which had once interacted. Bell later proved that the quantum theory and any local theory differ significantly in their predictions for these experimentally measurable correlations. It is shown that the arguments of EPR can be extended to apply equally well to certain properties of a single particle or system and that, in analogy with Bell's theorem, the predictions of the quantum theory for certain single-particle experiments are in disagreement with the predictions of any local theory. For example, based on either the quantum theory or existing experimental observations, it is possible to arrange for a photon to have a negligible probability of not being absorbed by some system of finite dimensions, such as one of a large number of atoms, within a finite time interval. It is shown that any local theory which satisfies this requirement must also require that negligible interference effects occur in an optical interferometer at sufficiently low intensities from an incoherent source in combination with sufficiently large separation $L$ between the two optical paths. Time-reversal invariance is used to estimate the requirement $L\ensuremath{\gg}\frac{3{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}}{4{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}{r}_{c}}$, where $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is the wavelength of the light and ${r}_{c}$ is the classical radius of the electron; at optical wavelengths this distance is on the order of 10 m. The same separation should also be required between the photon detectors in any optical experiment based on Bell's theorem. A review of the literature indicates that no existing experimental data, either from optical interferometers or experiments based on Bell's theorem, can be used to distinguish between the local and quantum theories. An investigation of low-intensity optical interference at large path separations is proposed for this purpose.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Aug 15, 1982•6 citations
This chapter begins with a review of the ideas of locality and realism which provide the basis for the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox. The general conditions defining a local, realistic theory are stated, and then used to prove Bell's theorem, which yields — for any local, realistic theory — an inequality satisfied by certain linear combinations of correlations. It is shown that this inequality is violated by quantum theory and by experiment. The chapter ends with a discussion of possible experimental loopholes and the alternative Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state, which would, in principle, make the use of statistical correlations unnecessary.
Abstract This chapter presents a detailed discussion of Bell inequalities and their experimental tests. Starting from the Aharonov-Bohm version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, we review EPR’s criteria for realism and completeness and Bell’s locality condition, before deriving the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality. This is followed by an exposition on Bell’s original inequality and other Bell inequalities by Wigner, as well as Clauser and Horne. We then discuss the milestones in the experimental violation of Bell inequalities, from the experiment of Freedman and Clauser in the 1970s, to the efforts of Aspect et al. in the 1980s, the experiments by the teams of Zeilinger and Gisin in the 1990s, and culminating the loophole-free tests in 2015. Finally we turn to a brief discussion of the interpretations of quantum mechanics, focusing on contrasting the realist views held by, e.g., Einstein and Bell, and the informational views with proponents such as Brukner and Zeilinger
An overview of the history of Bell’s inequality is given, beginning with the so-called EPR paradox originally put forward by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen and the impossibility proof of von Neumann. Bell’s inequality, which ultimately shifted the discussion from arguments based on philosophically introduced postulates to the domain of experimental physics, is presented together with experimental attempts from the early 1970s to 2010s to violate this inequality. We introduce three historical loopholes in the experimental schemes which have prevented experimentalists from being able to fully disprove the possibility of a hidden-variables description of nature. Recent experimental data indicate that all the main loopholes are now closed for photons (albeit not simultaneously in one experiment). Besides the class of stochastic local realism that have been tested experimentally, some other possible classical interpretations are mentioned.
The Bell theorem can take the form of several inequalities, as we have seen in §4.2. Moreover, since it was discovered, the theorem has stimulated the discovery of several other mathematical contradictions between the predictions of quantum mechanics and those of local realism. We review a few of them in this chapter: GHZ contradictions (§5.1) and their generalization (§5.2), Cabello's inequality (§5.3), and Hardy's impossibilities (§5.4). Finally, in §5.5, we discuss the notion of contextuality and introduce the BKS theorem. GHZ contradiction For many years, everyone thought that Bell had basically exhausted the subject by considering all really interesting situations, and that two-spin systems provided the most spectacular quantum violations of local realism. It therefore came as a surprise to many when in 1989 Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger (GHZ) showed that systems containing more than two correlated particles may actually exhibit even more dramatic violations of local realism [188, 189]. They involve a sign contradiction (100% violation) for perfect correlations, while the BCHSH inequalities are violated by about 40% (Cirelson bound) and deal with situations where the results of measurements are not completely correlated. In this section, we discuss three-particle systems, but generalizations to N particles are possible (§5.2). Derivation GHZ contradictions may occur in various systems, not necessarily involving spins. Initially, they were introduced in the context of entanglement swapping (§6.3.2) for four particles [188] or entanglement of three spinless particles [189].
Starting from the late 60’s many experiments have been performed to verify the violation Bell’s inequality by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type correlations. The idea of these experiments being that: (i) Bell’s inequality is a consequence of locality, hence its experimental violation is an indication of non locality; (ii) this violation is a typical quantum phenomenon because any classical system making local choices (either deterministic or random) will produce correlations satisfying this inequality. Both statements (i) and (ii) have been criticized by quantum probability on theoretical grounds (not discussed in the present paper) and the experiment discussed below has been devised to support these theoretical arguments. We emphasize that the goal of our experiment is not to reproduce classically the EPR correlations but to prove that there exist perfectly local classical dynamical systems violating Bell’s inequality. The conclusions of the present experiment are: no contradiction between quantum theory and locality can be deduced from the violation of Bell’s inequality. The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum theory becomes quite reasonable and not metaphyisic if interpreted at the light of the chameleon effect. One can realize quantum entanglement by classical computers. In section (7) we prove that our experiment also provides a classical analogue of the type of logical (i.e. independent of statistics) incompatibilities pointed out by Greenberger, Home and Zeilinger. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Bell inequalities are intended to show that local realist theories cannot describe the world. A local realist theory is one where physical properties are defined prior to and independent of measurement, and no physical influence can propagate faster than the speed of light. Quantum-mechanical predictions for certain experiments violate the Bell inequality while a local realist theory cannot, and this shows that a local realist theory cannot give those quantum-mechanical predictions. However, because of unexpected circumstances or 'loopholes' in available experiment tests, local realist theories can reproduce the data from these experiments. This paper reviews such loopholes, what effect they have on Bell inequality tests, and how to avoid them in experiment. Avoiding all these simultaneously in one experiment, usually called a 'loophole-free' or 'definitive' Bell test, remains an open task, but is very important for technological tasks such as device-independent security of quantum cryptography, and ultimately for our understanding of the world. This article is part of a special issue of Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical devoted to '50 years of Bell's theorem'.
In their original paper, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) questioned the probabilistic nature of the quantum theory using an argument based on the quantum-mechanical correlations between two distant particles which had once interacted. Bell later proved that the quantum theory and any local theory differ significantly in their predictions for these experimentally measurable correlations. It is shown that the arguments of EPR can be extended to apply equally well to certain properties of a single particle or system and that, in analogy with Bell's theorem, the predictions of the quantum theory for certain single-particle experiments are in disagreement with the predictions of any local theory. For example, based on either the quantum theory or existing experimental observations, it is possible to arrange for a photon to have a negligible probability of not being absorbed by some system of finite dimensions, such as one of a large number of atoms, within a finite time interval. It is shown that any local theory which satisfies this requirement must also require that negligible interference effects occur in an optical interferometer at sufficiently low intensities from an incoherent source in combination with sufficiently large separation LLL between the two optical paths. Time-reversal invariance is used to estimate the requirement $L\ensuremath{\gg}\frac{3{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{2}}{4{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}{r}_{c}}$, where $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is the wavelength of the light and rc{r}_{c}rc​ is the classical radius of the electron; at optical wavelengths this distance is on the order of 10 m. The same separation should also be required between the photon detectors in any optical experiment based on Bell's theorem. A review of the literature indicates that no existing experimental data, either from optical interferometers or experiments based on Bell's theorem, can be used to distinguish between the local and quantum theories. An investigation of low-intensity optical interference at large path separations is proposed for this purpose.