Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics

Foundation for Fisher-information-based derivations of physical laws

B. Roy Frieden, W. J. Cocke

Published Jul 1, 1996• 26 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The principle of extreme physical information (EPI) places physics on an information-theoretic footing. It yields many of the fundamental wave equations of physics (of Klein-Gordon, Dirac, etc.). EPI is based upon the measurement of particle four-vectors ${\mathbf{\ensuremath{\theta}}}_{\mathit{n}}$ with random errors ${\mathbf{x}}_{\mathit{n}}$, n=1,...,N. This leads to an additive Fisher information form whose extremization provides the derivations. However, the model measurement procedure was, in the past, overly restrictive: the real and imaginary parts ${\mathit{q}}_{\mathit{n}}$(x), n=1,...,N of the probability amplitude functions for the fluctuations were required to have nonoverlapping support regions. Here we rederive the requisite information form without this restriction. Our model measurement procedure is simply the efficient collection of four-data, that is, N independent measurements of four-coordinates of particles of the field. In effect, each measurement defines a different degree of freedom ${\mathit{q}}_{\mathit{n}}$(x) of the scenario. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.54.257

Related papers

Derivation of Principle of Extreme Physical Information

B. Roy Frieden, Robert A. Gatenby

The unknown amplitude law q(x) defining an observed effect may be found using the principle of Extreme Physical Information. EPI is derived as follows. The observations follow an information flow J --> I, with J the information intrinsic to the source and I the Fisher information level in its data, obeying (i) I=4 Integral dx q' -squared. Here q'= dq/dx and p(x) = q(x)-squared is the probability. It was previously shown, using L. Hardy's 5 axioms defining physics, that I = max. Therefore, its variation (ii) delta I = 0. Note that I is generic, obeying (i) for all source effects, whereas J is specific to the particular effect. Hence, rather than having form (i), J obeys (iii) J = Integral dx j[q(x),s(x)] with j some function of its arguments and s(x) a known source, such as of mass, biological fitness, etc. Information I decreases under any irreversible operation such as measurement, so that I l.e. J or, equivalently, I = kJ where 0 l.e. k l.e. 1. Then the variation delta I = k delta J so that property (ii) gives (iv) delta J = 0 as well. Then combining (ii) and (iv), delta(I - J) = 0. Or, I - J = L = extremum. What kind of extremum? Eqs. (i) and (iii) give (v) L=4q'^2 - j[q(x),s(x)]. Differentiating (v), (d^2 L )/(dq'^2) = +8. Then by the Legendre condition the extremum is a minimum. The unknown source effect obeys (vi) I - J= minimum, EPI.

arXiv:1406.3615•Jun 11, 2014•0 citations

Introduction

B. Roy Frieden

Aims of the book The primary aim of this book is to develop a theory of measurement that incorporates the observer into the phenomenon under measurement. By this theory, the observer becomes both a collector of data and an activator of the phenomenon that gives rise to the data. These ideas have probably been best stated by J. A. Wheeler (1990; 1994): All things physical are information-theoretic in origin and this is a participatory universe … Observer participancy gives rise to information; and information gives rise to physics. The measurement theory that will be presented is largely, in fact, a quantification of these ideas. However, the reader might be surprised to find that the “information” that is used is not the usual Shannon or Boltzmann entropy measures, but one that is relatively unknown to physicists, that of R. A. Fisher. The measurement theory is simply a description of how Fisher information flows from a physical source effect to a data space. It therefore applies to all scenarios where quantitative data from repeatable experiments may be collected. This describes measurement scenarios of physics but, also, of science in general. The theory of measurement is found to define an analytical procedure for deriving all laws of science. The approach is called EPI, for “extreme physical information.” The secondary aim of the book is to show, by example, that most existing laws of science fit within the EPI framework. That is, they can be derived by its use. (Many can of course be derived by other approaches, but, apparently, no other single approach can derive all of them.) In this way the EPI approach unifies science under an umbrella of measurement and information.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 10, 2004•0 citations

Fisher information as the basis for relativistic quantum mechanics

B. Roy Frieden

The Klein–Gordon equation for spinless particles, as well as the Weyl–Pauli and Dirac equations for particles with spin, may be derived from one information-theoretic principle. Consider a gedanken experiment whereby the mean position of a particle in a central force field is to be estimated by means of one position measurement. An efficient (optimum) estimate obeys a condition of minimum Fisher information, or minimum precision, according to the second law of thermodynamics. When the Fisher information is minimized subject to a constraint on the mean-square kinetic energy for the particle, the solution is a probability law on position whose corresponding wave amplitude obeys the Klein-Gordon equation, the Weyl–Pauli equation, or the Dirac equation, depending on whether scalar (without spin) or vector (with spin) solutions are sought. The minimized Fisher information is proportional to the mean-square kinetic energy, minus the rest energy of the particle.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1990•0 citations

Principle of maximum Fisher information from Hardy's axioms applied to statistical systems

B. Roy Frieden, Robert A. Gatenby

Consider a finite-sized, multidimensional system in parameter state a. The system is either at statistical equilibrium or general nonequilibrium, and may obey either classical or quantum physics. L. Hardy's mathematical axioms provide a basis for the physics obeyed by any such system. One axiom is that the number N of distinguishable states a in the system obeys N=max. This assumes that N is known as deterministic prior knowledge. However, most observed systems suffer statistical fluctuations, for which N is therefore only known approximately. Then what happens if the scope of the axiom N=max is extended to include such observed systems? It is found that the state a of the system must obey a principle of maximum Fisher information, I=I(max). This is important because many physical laws have been derived, assuming as a working hypothesis that I=I(max). These derivations include uses of the principle of extreme physical information (EPI). Examples of such derivations were of the De Broglie wave hypothesis, quantum wave equations, Maxwell's equations, new laws of biology (e.g., of Coulomb force-directed cell development and of in situ cancer growth), and new laws of economic fluctuation and investment. That the principle I=I(max) itself derives from suitably extended Hardy axioms thereby eliminates its need to be assumed in these derivations. Thus, uses of I=I(max) and EPI express physics at its most fundamental level, its axiomatic basis in math.

arXiv:1405.0007•Physical Review E•Oct 28, 2013•29 citations

Constrained-likelihood quantum measurement theory

B. Roy Frieden

In preceding chapters, EPI has been used as a computational procedure for establishing the physical laws governing various measurement scenarios. We showed, by means of the optical measurement model of Sec. 3.8, that EPI is, as well, a physical process that is initiated by a measurement. Specifically, it arises out of the interaction of the measuring instrument's probe particle with the object under measurement. This perturbs the system probability amplitudes, which perturbs the informations I and J, etc., as indicated in Figs. 3.3 and 3.4. The result is that EPI derives the phenomenon's physics as it exists at the input space to the measuring device.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 10, 2004•0 citations

Constrained-likelihood quantum measurement theory

B. Roy Frieden

In preceding chapters, EPI has been used as a computational procedure for establishing the physical laws governing various measurement scenarios. We showed, by means of the optical measurement model of Sec. 3.8, that EPI is, as well, a physical process that is initiated by a measurement. Specifically, it arises out of the interaction of the measuring instrument's probe particle with the object under measurement. This perturbs the system probability amplitudes, which perturbs the informations I and J, etc., as indicated in Figs. 3.3 and 3.4. The result is that EPI derives the phenomenon's physics as it exists at the input space to the measuring device.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 10, 1998•1 citation
The principle of extreme physical information (EPI) places physics on an information-theoretic footing. It yields many of the fundamental wave equations of physics (of Klein-Gordon, Dirac, etc.). EPI is based upon the measurement of particle four-vectors \ensuremathθn{\mathbf{\ensuremath{\theta}}}_{\mathit{n}}\ensuremathθn​ with random errors xn{\mathbf{x}}_{\mathit{n}}xn​, n=1,...,N. This leads to an additive Fisher information form whose extremization provides the derivations. However, the model measurement procedure was, in the past, overly restrictive: the real and imaginary parts qn{\mathit{q}}_{\mathit{n}}qn​(x), n=1,...,N of the probability amplitude functions for the fluctuations were required to have nonoverlapping support regions. Here we rederive the requisite information form without this restriction. Our model measurement procedure is simply the efficient collection of four-data, that is, N independent measurements of four-coordinates of particles of the field. In effect, each measurement defines a different degree of freedom qn{\mathit{q}}_{\mathit{n}}qn​(x) of the scenario. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
The unknown amplitude law q(x) defining an observed effect may be found using the principle of Extreme Physical Information. EPI is derived as follows. The observations follow an information flow J --> I, with J the information intrinsic to the source and I the Fisher information level in its data, obeying (i) I=4 Integral dx q' -squared. Here q'= dq/dx and p(x) = q(x)-squared is the probability. It was previously shown, using L. Hardy's 5 axioms defining physics, that I = max. Therefore, its variation (ii) delta I = 0. Note that I is generic, obeying (i) for all source effects, whereas J is specific to the particular effect. Hence, rather than having form (i), J obeys (iii) J = Integral dx j[q(x),s(x)] with j some function of its arguments and s(x) a known source, such as of mass, biological fitness, etc. Information I decreases under any irreversible operation such as measurement, so that I l.e. J or, equivalently, I = kJ where 0 l.e. k l.e. 1. Then the variation delta I = k delta J so that property (ii) gives (iv) delta J = 0 as well. Then combining (ii) and (iv), delta(I - J) = 0. Or, I - J = L = extremum. What kind of extremum? Eqs. (i) and (iii) give (v) L=4q'^2 - j[q(x),s(x)]. Differentiating (v), (d^2 L )/(dq'^2) = +8. Then by the Legendre condition the extremum is a minimum. The unknown source effect obeys (vi) I - J= minimum, EPI.
Aims of the book The primary aim of this book is to develop a theory of measurement that incorporates the observer into the phenomenon under measurement. By this theory, the observer becomes both a collector of data and an activator of the phenomenon that gives rise to the data. These ideas have probably been best stated by J. A. Wheeler (1990; 1994): All things physical are information-theoretic in origin and this is a participatory universe … Observer participancy gives rise to information; and information gives rise to physics. The measurement theory that will be presented is largely, in fact, a quantification of these ideas. However, the reader might be surprised to find that the “information” that is used is not the usual Shannon or Boltzmann entropy measures, but one that is relatively unknown to physicists, that of R. A. Fisher. The measurement theory is simply a description of how Fisher information flows from a physical source effect to a data space. It therefore applies to all scenarios where quantitative data from repeatable experiments may be collected. This describes measurement scenarios of physics but, also, of science in general. The theory of measurement is found to define an analytical procedure for deriving all laws of science. The approach is called EPI, for “extreme physical information.” The secondary aim of the book is to show, by example, that most existing laws of science fit within the EPI framework. That is, they can be derived by its use. (Many can of course be derived by other approaches, but, apparently, no other single approach can derive all of them.) In this way the EPI approach unifies science under an umbrella of measurement and information.
The Klein–Gordon equation for spinless particles, as well as the Weyl–Pauli and Dirac equations for particles with spin, may be derived from one information-theoretic principle. Consider a gedanken experiment whereby the mean position of a particle in a central force field is to be estimated by means of one position measurement. An efficient (optimum) estimate obeys a condition of minimum Fisher information, or minimum precision, according to the second law of thermodynamics. When the Fisher information is minimized subject to a constraint on the mean-square kinetic energy for the particle, the solution is a probability law on position whose corresponding wave amplitude obeys the Klein-Gordon equation, the Weyl–Pauli equation, or the Dirac equation, depending on whether scalar (without spin) or vector (with spin) solutions are sought. The minimized Fisher information is proportional to the mean-square kinetic energy, minus the rest energy of the particle.
Consider a finite-sized, multidimensional system in parameter state a. The system is either at statistical equilibrium or general nonequilibrium, and may obey either classical or quantum physics. L. Hardy's mathematical axioms provide a basis for the physics obeyed by any such system. One axiom is that the number N of distinguishable states a in the system obeys N=max. This assumes that N is known as deterministic prior knowledge. However, most observed systems suffer statistical fluctuations, for which N is therefore only known approximately. Then what happens if the scope of the axiom N=max is extended to include such observed systems? It is found that the state a of the system must obey a principle of maximum Fisher information, I=I(max). This is important because many physical laws have been derived, assuming as a working hypothesis that I=I(max). These derivations include uses of the principle of extreme physical information (EPI). Examples of such derivations were of the De Broglie wave hypothesis, quantum wave equations, Maxwell's equations, new laws of biology (e.g., of Coulomb force-directed cell development and of in situ cancer growth), and new laws of economic fluctuation and investment. That the principle I=I(max) itself derives from suitably extended Hardy axioms thereby eliminates its need to be assumed in these derivations. Thus, uses of I=I(max) and EPI express physics at its most fundamental level, its axiomatic basis in math.
In preceding chapters, EPI has been used as a computational procedure for establishing the physical laws governing various measurement scenarios. We showed, by means of the optical measurement model of Sec. 3.8, that EPI is, as well, a physical process that is initiated by a measurement. Specifically, it arises out of the interaction of the measuring instrument's probe particle with the object under measurement. This perturbs the system probability amplitudes, which perturbs the informations I and J, etc., as indicated in Figs. 3.3 and 3.4. The result is that EPI derives the phenomenon's physics as it exists at the input space to the measuring device.
In preceding chapters, EPI has been used as a computational procedure for establishing the physical laws governing various measurement scenarios. We showed, by means of the optical measurement model of Sec. 3.8, that EPI is, as well, a physical process that is initiated by a measurement. Specifically, it arises out of the interaction of the measuring instrument's probe particle with the object under measurement. This perturbs the system probability amplitudes, which perturbs the informations I and J, etc., as indicated in Figs. 3.3 and 3.4. The result is that EPI derives the phenomenon's physics as it exists at the input space to the measuring device.