We prove here that the eigenvalues, eigenfunctions, and time evolutions for a broad class of spatially bounded, finite particle number, undriven, quantum systems can be computed by algorithms containing logarithmically less information than the quantities themselves. Algorithmic complexity theory asserts that such quantal systems are nonchaotic. These results are shown to be valid independent of the size of system parameters such as mass or Planck's constant, provided they are not set equal to zero or infinity. However, rather than confronting quantum mechanics with classical mechanics via the correspondence principle, we suggest a direct comparison of quantum mechanics with macroscopic laboratory reality. Specifically, we here propose the double pendulum---a simple, two-degree-of-freedom, macroscopic system exhibiting a transition to chaos as its amplitude increases---as a model suitable for testing whether a nonchaotic quantum mechanics can accurately predict laboratory observation. Neither theory nor experiment appears to offer insurmountable difficulties to the performance of this comparison.
We prove here that the eigenvalues, eigenfunctions, and time evolutions for a broad class of spatially bounded, finite particle number, undriven, quantum systems can be computed by algorithms containing logarithmically less information than the quantities themselves. Algorithmic complexity theory asserts that such quantal systems are nonchaotic. These results are shown to be valid independent of the size of system parameters such as mass or Planck's constant, provided they are not set equal to zero or infinity. However, rather than confronting quantum mechanics with classical mechanics via the correspondence principle, we suggest a direct comparison of quantum mechanics with macroscopic laboratory reality. Specifically, we here propose the double pendulum---a simple, two-degree-of-freedom, macroscopic system exhibiting a transition to chaos as its amplitude increases---as a model suitable for testing whether a nonchaotic quantum mechanics can accurately predict laboratory observation. Neither theory nor experiment appears to offer insurmountable difficulties to the performance of this comparison.
Though not yet widely recognized, there is a growing body of evidence which strongly indicates that quantum mechanics does not adequately encompass chaos. Unfortunately this evidence, while striking, is not yet sufficient to establish that quantum mechanics is a theory of limited validity. Thus, we here present four problems which offer promise of definitively revealing the lack of chaos in quantum mechanics. Specifically, we suggest that judicious use of algorithmic complexity theory can provide rigorous proofs for the following assertions: 1. The algorithms which compute quantum mechanical eigenvalues and eigenfunctions have null complexity. 2. The time evolution of the wave function for any finite, bounded, conservative quantum system has null complexity no matter the smallness of ℏ > 0. 3. The time evolution of a specific time dependent Hamiltonian, known to be classically chaotic, has null complexity not only no matter how small ℏ > 0 but even in the limit as ℏ → 0. 4. An algorithm of null complexity exists for obtaining the time evolution of any quantum billiard confined within a polygon all of whose vertex angles are rational (mπ/n). Here, the term null complexity means that the problem can be solved using finite, recursive algorithms: 1. The algorithma which compute quantum mechanical eigenvalues and eigenfunctions have null complexity. 2. The time evolution of the wave function for any finite, bounded, conservative quantum system has null complexity no matter the smallness of ℏ > 0. 3. The time evolution of a specific time dependent Hamiltonian, known to be classically chaotic, has null complexity not only no matter how small ℏ > 0 but even in tlie limit as ℏ → 0. 4. An algorithm of null complexity exiats for obtaining the time evolution of any quantum billiard confined within a polygon all of whose vertex angles are rational (mπ/n). Here, the term null complexity means that the problem can be solved using finite, recursive algorithms.
The quantum dynamics of a classically chaotic model are studied in the approach to the macroscopic limit. The quantum predictions are compared and contrasted with the classical predictions of both Newtonian and Liouville mechanics. The time-domain scaling of the optimal quantum-classical correspondence is analyzed in detail in the case of both classical theories. In both cases the correspondence for observable quantities is shown to break down on a time-scale that increases very slowly (logarithmically) with increasing system size. In the case of quantum-Liouville correspondence such a short time-scale does not imply a breakdown of correspondence since the largest quantum-Liouville differences reached on this time-scale decrease rapidly (as an inverse power) with increasing system size. Therefore the statistical properties of chaotic dynamics are, as expected, well described by quantum theory in the macroscopic limit. In contrast, the largest quantum-Newtonian differences reached on the log time-scale actually increase in proportion to the system size. Since the invariance properties of the Hamiltonian impose functional constraints on the time-varying chaotic coordinates, it is possible to show, moreover, that if the quantum predictions are believed to describe the coordinates of individual chaotic systems, then they also predict macroscopic violations of any kinematic or dynamic constants of the motion. These results for chaotic systems indicate that a valid description of the time-varying properties of individual macroscopic bodies is not available within the standard interpretive framework of quantum theory.
This elementary review paper presents the compelling evidence which supports the notion that quantum mechanics is much too simple a theory to adequately describe a complex world. Rigorous arguments based on algorithmic complexity theory are used to show that both the quantum Arnol’d cat and a broad category of finite, bounded, undriven, quantum systems do not obey the correspondence principle, implying that quantum mechanics is also not complete. An experiment, well within current laboratory capability, is proposed which can expose the inability of quantum mechanics to adequately describe macroscopic chaos. In its final section, this paper describes a theoretical framework that provides a proper setting for interpreting these surprising results.
In this thesis, a comparison between quantum and classical mechanics was made for two systems whose classical behaviour can be chaotic.The general correspondence between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics in the classical regime has always been assumed but never proved.Recent research in the field of quantum chaos has brought this assumption into question.For some systems, such as the kicked rotor in the classically chaotic regime, quantum mechanics does not display the classical behaviour of unbounded momentum.It has been suggested that quantum mechanics will fail to produce classical chaos for a broad range of simple systems.A comparison of quantum and classical mechanics was made using numerical simulations, without recourse to taking limits such as 7i going to zero.The two systems studied were a driven pendulum and a pair of pendula joined by a spring.The quantum and classical expectation values for a number of observables were computed, as were the probability distributions in phase space.For periodic motion of the driven pendulum it was found that the theories agreed well for times up to 150 driving periods.Similar agreement was found for initial conditions whose classical behaviour was chaotic, but only for times up to a few tens of driving periods.For longer times, it was found that the quantum system displayed a boundedness in position and/or momentum that was absent in the classical system.A possible explanation was given in terms of the quasienergy expansion.In the coupled-pendula system no such disagreements between the theories were found.I would like to thank Dr. Ballentine for his continued support during this project and his help in editing and revising this thesis.I would like to thank the members of my committee, Drs.Bechhoefer, Boa1 and Loss for their many suggestions.For many helpful discussions, I would like to thank Dominic Mimnagh and Jim Zibin.
Two approaches to quantum-classical correspondence are distinguished according to the classical dynamical theory with which quantum theory is compared. The first of these, Ehrenfest correspondence, defines a dynamical regime in which the quantum expectation values follow approximately a classical trajectory. The second of these, Liouville correspondence, applies when the quantum probability distributions remain well approximated by a density in the classical phase space. The former applies only for narrow states, whereas the latter may remain valid even for quantum states that have spread to the system size. A spin model is adopted for this correspondence study because the quantum state is discrete and finite- dimensional, and thus no artificial truncation of the Hilbert space is required. The quantum time-evolution is given by a discrete unitary mapping. The corresponding classical model is volume-preserving (non-dissipative) and the time-evolution is given by a symplectic map. In classically chaotic regimes, the widths of initially narrow quantum states grow, on average, exponentially with time, until saturation at the system size. This initial spreading rate is well approximated by the classical Lyapunov exponent when the accessible classical phase space is predominantly chaotic. Because of the exponential growth rate of the quantum variance, the Ehrenfest regime is delimited by a break-time that grows logarithmically with increasing quantum numbers. The small differences between quantum expectation values and corresponding Liouville averages of dynamical variables also grow exponentially, initially, if the classical behaviour is chaotic. This exponential rate is independent of h and consistently larger than the classical Lyapunov exponent by at least a factor of two. Interestingly, this exponential growth rate does not continue until these differences approach magnitudes of order the system size, but crosses over to power-law growth (or simply saturates), when the differences have reached magnitudes no larger than order ħ. Because of the exponential growth of these quantum-classical differences, the Liouville regime is also delimited by a break-time that grows logarithmically with increasing quantum numbers. However, due to the early saturation of the exponential growth of the differences, the Liouville log break-time applies only in a restricted domain. After spreading to the system size, the quantum states relax to an approximately time-independent state. This is characterised by equilibrium distributions that are subject to rapidly oscillating fluctuations about the coarse-grained classical steady-state. If the accessible classical phase space is predominantly chaotic, then the equilibrium quantum probability distributions are nearly microcanonical. Otherwise the steady-state quantum probability distributions accurately reflect the details of the KAM surfaces in the classical phase space. The equilibrium regime quantum fluctuations, which are quantum-classical differences, are shown to approach zero as a negative power of the quantum numbers. Since the differences between quantum expectation values and individual classical trajectories grow exponentially in time to a magnitude that scales with the system size, the Ehrenfest regime is delimited by an unrestricted log break-time. The log break-time may be short compared to experimental time-scales for some chaotic macroscopic bodies, and, as a result, an observable breakdown of Ehrenfest correspondence may arise for some macroscopic systems. Although the Liouville regime is also delimited by a log break-time, an observable breakdown of correspondence between quantum mechanics and Liouville mechanics for macroscopic bodies is not likely since their differences, expressed relative to the dimensions of the observable, approach zero in the limit of large quantum numbers.
The problems of chaos and relaxation have a fundamental importance in the study of many-body classical and quantum systems. We investigate some of the issues related to these problems numerically in classical and quantum spin systems. New results reported in this thesis include: (i) A remarkably simple algorithm for discriminating chaotic from nonchaotic behavior in classical systems using a time series of one macroscopic observable. The effectiveness of this algorithm stems from the qualitative differences in the power spectra of chaotic and nonchaotic systems. (ii) A modified version of the Onsager regression relation applicable to pure quantum states. (iii) An efficient algorithm for computing the infinitetemperature time correlation functions in systems with large Hilbert spaces. (iv) Absence of exponential sensitivity to small perturbations in macroscopic nonintegrable systems of spins 1/2 . Such a behavior is contrasted with the exponential sensitivity to small perturbations in chaotic classical spin systems. (v) Accurate numerical investigations of free induction decay and spin diffusion in certain spin lattices. The consequences of these results have implications for the foundations of statistical mechanics or practical problems such as computing the long-time behavior of the free induction decay in solids.