This elementary review paper presents the compelling evidence which supports the notion that quantum mechanics is much too simple a theory to adequately describe a complex world. Rigorous arguments based on algorithmic complexity theory are used to show that both the quantum Arnol’d cat and a broad category of finite, bounded, undriven, quantum systems do not obey the correspondence principle, implying that quantum mechanics is also not complete. An experiment, well within current laboratory capability, is proposed which can expose the inability of quantum mechanics to adequately describe macroscopic chaos. In its final section, this paper describes a theoretical framework that provides a proper setting for interpreting these surprising results.
This elementary review paper presents the compelling evidence which supports the notion that quantum mechanics is much too simple a theory to adequately describe a complex world. Rigorous arguments based on algorithmic complexity theory are used to show that both the quantum Arnol’d cat and a broad category of finite, bounded, undriven, quantum systems do not obey the correspondence principle, implying that quantum mechanics is also not complete. An experiment, well within current laboratory capability, is proposed which can expose the inability of quantum mechanics to adequately describe macroscopic chaos. In its final section, this paper describes a theoretical framework that provides a proper setting for interpreting these surprising results.
The true dynamical randomness is obtained as a natural fundamental property of deterministic quantum systems. It provides quantum chaos passing to the classical dynamical chaos under the ordinary semiclassical transition, which extends the correspondence principle to chaotic systems. In return one should accept the modified form of quantum formalism (presented by the Schroedinger equation) which, however, does not contradict the ordinary form and the main postulates of quantum mechanics. It introduces the principle of the fundamental dynamic multivaluedness (redundance) extending the quantum paradigm to complex dynamical behaviour. Moreover, a causal solution to the well-known problems of the foundation of quantum mechanics, those of quantum indeterminacy and wave reduction, is also found using the same method. The concept of the fundamental dynamic uncertainty thus established is universal in character and provides a unified scheme of the complete description of arbitrary complex system of any origin (physics/9806002). This scheme incorporates, in particular, universal definitions of complexity, (non)integrability, and general solution, as well as the physically complete notion of probability. One obtains thus a self-consistent hierarchic picture of the world characterised by a (high) non-zero complexity and containing the intrinsic causal randomness, where the causally extended quantum mechanics can be consistently interpreted as several lowest levels of complexity (quant-ph/990215,16).
Though not yet widely recognized, there is a growing body of evidence which strongly indicates that quantum mechanics does not adequately encompass chaos. Unfortunately this evidence, while striking, is not yet sufficient to establish that quantum mechanics is a theory of limited validity. Thus, we here present four problems which offer promise of definitively revealing the lack of chaos in quantum mechanics. Specifically, we suggest that judicious use of algorithmic complexity theory can provide rigorous proofs for the following assertions: 1. The algorithms which compute quantum mechanical eigenvalues and eigenfunctions have null complexity. 2. The time evolution of the wave function for any finite, bounded, conservative quantum system has null complexity no matter the smallness of ℏ > 0. 3. The time evolution of a specific time dependent Hamiltonian, known to be classically chaotic, has null complexity not only no matter how small ℏ > 0 but even in the limit as ℏ → 0. 4. An algorithm of null complexity exists for obtaining the time evolution of any quantum billiard confined within a polygon all of whose vertex angles are rational (mπ/n). Here, the term null complexity means that the problem can be solved using finite, recursive algorithms: 1. The algorithma which compute quantum mechanical eigenvalues and eigenfunctions have null complexity. 2. The time evolution of the wave function for any finite, bounded, conservative quantum system has null complexity no matter the smallness of ℏ > 0. 3. The time evolution of a specific time dependent Hamiltonian, known to be classically chaotic, has null complexity not only no matter how small ℏ > 0 but even in tlie limit as ℏ → 0. 4. An algorithm of null complexity exiats for obtaining the time evolution of any quantum billiard confined within a polygon all of whose vertex angles are rational (mπ/n). Here, the term null complexity means that the problem can be solved using finite, recursive algorithms.
Ever since the advent of quantum mechanics, it has been clear that the atoms composing matter do not obey Newton's laws. Instead, their behavior is described by the Schroedinger equation. Surprisingly though, until recently, no clear explanation was given for why everyday objects, which are merely collections of atoms, are observed to obey Newton's laws. It would seem that, if quantum mechanics explains all the properties of atoms accurately, they, too, should obey quantum mechanics. This reasoning led some scientists to believe in a distinct macroscopic, or ``big and complicated,'' world in which quantum mechanics fails and classical mechanics takes over, although there has never been experimental evidence for such a failure. Even those who insisted that Newtonian mechanics would somehow emerge from the underlying quantum mechanics as the system became increasingly macroscopic were hindered by the lack of adequate experimental and theoretical tools. In the last decade, however, this quantum-to-classical transition has become accessible to experimental study and quantitative description, and the resulting insights are the subject of this article.
The relation between determinism and predictability is the central issue in the study of 'deterministic chaos'. Much knowledge has been accumulated in the past 10 years about the chaotic dynamics of macroscopic (classical) systems. Our intention is to examine the implications of chaos in the microscopic quantum world – in other words, how to reconcile the correspondence principle with the inherent uncertainties which reflect the wave nature of quantum dynamics. Some rather surprising and counterintuitive results emerge from this effort which bear an intriguing similarity to a phenomenon associated with electric conductivity in disordered solids, namely 'Anderson localisation'. It is very rewarding that these developments do not remain in the lofty realms of abstract theoretical physics. Indeed, recent atomic physics experiments demonstrate clearly that chaos is relevant to the microscopic world. In particular, such experiments emphasise the urgent need to clarify the genuine quantum mechanism which imposes severe limitations on quantum dynamics, and renders it so very different from its classical counterpart.
The intrinsic multivaluedness of interaction process, revealed in Part I of this series of papers, is interpreted as the origin of the true dynamical (in particular, quantum) chaos. The latter is causally deduced as unceasing series of transitions, dynamically probabilistic by their origin, between the equally real, but incompatible 'realisations' (modes of interaction) of a system. The obtained set of realisations form the causally derived, intrinsically complete "space of events" providing the crucial extension of the notion of probability and the method of its first-principle calculation. The fundamental dynamic uncertainty thus revealed is specified for Hamiltonian quantum systems and applied to quantum chaos description in periodically perturbed systems. The ordinary semiclassical transition in our quantum-mechanical results leads to exact reproduction of the main features of chaotic behaviour of the system known from classical mechanics, which permits one to "re-establish" the correspondence principle for chaotic systems (inevitably lost in any their conventional, single-valued description). The causal dynamical randomness in the extended quantum mechanics is not restricted, however, to semiclassical conditions and generically occurs also in essentially quantum regimes, even though partial "quantum suppression of chaos" does exist and is specified in our description, as well as other particular types of the quantum (truly) chaotic behaviour.
A conception of the Correspondence Principle which Bohr deployed implicitly in developing a new theory of atomic constitution in 1913, is made explicit through an extensive examination of his classic paper of that year. Arguments are considered which purport to show that the application of the principle must be restricted to few isolated cases. These arguments are either defused or rejected. In particular an extensive review of issues concerning the interpretation of Quantum Mechanics is made to counter the claims that an insurmountable conceptual gap exits between the tenets of this theory and those of Classical Mechanics which makes it logically impossible for the latter to be regarded as the 'limiting case' of the former. In the light of a particular interpretation adopted and defended, a proposal is made that suggests that the Hamilton-Jacobi formulation of Classical Mechanics, as well as Maxwell's electromagnetic theory, can be viewed as 'limiting cases' of Quantum Mechanics. Having established a case for the global validity of the requirement imposed on physics by the Correspondence Principle, it is then argued that this requirement is indispensable if a particular brand of realism is adopted for the interpretation of theories in physics. Taking on board the assumption that an ultimate theory exists which mirrors the underlying physical constitution of the world, it is subsequently argued that the intertheory order established by the global imposition of the principle in physics, can be used to solve the problem of rational theory choice for this brand of realism.