Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics

Higher-order effects in non-Markovian theory of electronic relaxation in interacting electron-phonon systems

Vladislav Čápek

Published Jul 10, 1987• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A finite coupling generalised master equation theory of the electronic relaxation among electronic eigen-states is presented. When converted into a closed time-convolution form (TCGME) for just diagonal elements of the density matrix, the theory is appreciably non-Markovian with the memory kernel summed partially up to the infinite order in the electron-phonon coupling. On soluble examples, it is shown that: (a), higher-order effects may influence even the lowest-order relaxation rates; (b), weakness of the finite coupling is not sufficient for reducing the theory to the standard lowest-order form; (c), the Markov approximation to the TCGME is in general misleading; (d), the initial condition term may appreciably influence the long-time development of the relaxation; (e), the theory is able to yield quasi-coherent effects (quantum beats) due to the electron coupling to the bath; (f), very effective tunnelling through barriers between equivalent sites appears with non-zero tunnelling currents starting from the second order in the electron-phonon coupling. Limitations from above (below) for the time (frequency) are found for the theory to reduce to the standard lowest-order form.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3719/20/19/015

Related papers

Higher-order memory effects in phonon-assisted hopping

Vladislav Čápek

To lowest order in the electron-phonon coupling causing electron transitions among electronic eigenstates, the extent (on the time axis) of the memory functions wrs(t) governing the state population via the generalized master equations for the diagonal elements of the electron density matrix ρ(t) is independent of the coupling, being given by the decay time of the bath correlation functions. However, a typical reciprocal decay time of some higher-order contributions to wrs(t) has been found to be given by the reciprocal decay time of the off-diagonal elements of ρ(t), i.e. to be proportional to the square of the electron-phonon coupling constant. This feature makes such weakly damped contributions non-negligible even in lowest-order dynamics, as is illustrated on a dimer.

Philosophical Magazine B•Sep 1, 1986•5 citations

Fourth-order quantum master equation and its Markovian bath limit

Seogjoo Jang, Jianshu Cao, R. Silbey

Fourth-order quantum master equations (FQMEs) are derived in both time nonlocal and local forms for a general system Hamiltonian, with new detailed expressions for the fourth-order kernel, where the bath correlation functions are explicitly decoupled from the system superoperators. Further simplifications can be made for the model of linearly coupled harmonic oscillator bath. Consideration of the high temperature Ohmic bath limit leads to a general Markovian FQME with compact forms of time independent superoperators. Two examples of this equation are then considered. For the system of a quantum particle in a continuous potential field, the equation reduces to a known form of the quantum Fokker–Planck equation, except for a fourth-order potential renormalization term that can be neglected only in the weak system-bath interaction regime. For a two-level system with off-diagonal coupling to the bath, fourth-order corrections do not alter the relaxation characteristics of the second-order equation and introduce additional coherence terms in the equations for the off-diagonal elements.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 15, 2002•111 citations

Reduced-density-matrix descriptions for coherent electromagnetic interactions in quantized many-electron systems

V. L. Jacobs

A reduced-density-matrix description is developed for coherent linear and non-linear electromagnetic interactions of quantized electronic systems in the presence of environmental decoherence and relaxation phenomena. Applications of interest include many-electron atomic systems and semiconductor materials. Time-domain (equation-of-motion) and frequency-domain (resolvent-operator) formulations of the reduced-density-matrix approach are developed in a unified manner. The general non-Markovian formulations provide a rigorous foundation for the systematic introduction of the commonly used Born (lowest-order perturbation-theory) and Markov (short-memory-time) approximations. A preliminary semiclassical perturbation-theory treatment of the electromagnetic interaction is introduced, based on a coupled hierarchy of relationships for the field components of the reduced density operator.

Journal of Modern Optics•Nov 1, 2004•0 citations

Reduced-Density-Matrix Descriptions for Coherent Electromagnetic Interactions in Quantized Many-Electron Systems

V. L. Jacobs

Abstract A reduced-density-matrix description is developed for coherent linear and non-linear electromagnetic interactions of quantized electronic systems in the presence of environmental decoherence and relaxation phenomena. Applications of interest include many-electron atomic systems and semiconductor materials. Time-domain (equation-of-motion) and frequency-domain (resolvent-operator) formulations of the reduced-density-matrix approach are developed in a unified manner. The general non-Markovian formulations provide a rigorous foundation for the systematic introduction of the commonly used Born (lowest-order perturbation-theory) and Markov (short-memory-time) approximations. A preliminary semiclassical perturbation-theory treatment of the electromagnetic interaction is introduced, based on a coupled hierarchy of relationships for the field components of the reduced density operator.

APS•Mar 1, 2004•0 citations

Relaxation of quantum systems weakly coupled to a bath. I. Total-time-ordering-cumulant and partial-time-ordering-cumulant non-Markovian theories

J. Bretón, Arturo Hardisson, F. Mauricio +1 more

The present paper studies the formal aspects of the total-time-ordering-cumulant (TTOC) and the partial-time-ordering-cumulant (PTOC) relaxations of a quantum system, of few degrees of freedom, in weak interaction with a bath, both within and outside the Markovian limit. To this end, the general expressions connecting the matrix elements of the TTOC and PTOC relaxation superoperators with the bath correlation functions are determined. Special attention is paid to two particular cases: a system with a nonequidistant energy spectrum and a system with an equidistant energy spectrum. Discussions revolve mainly around the possibility of applying the secular approximation to the TTOC and PTOC master equations for the off-diagonal matrix elements of the reduced-density operator of the system.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1984•37 citations

Stability and Relaxation of Electron-Phonon Systems at Strong Coupling

Noga Bashan, Erez Berg

We study the kinetic properties of Migdal-Eliashberg theory (MET) for electron-phonon interactions at strong coupling. Previously, the system was found to be dynamically unstable at large couplings within a Markovian quantum Boltzmann approximation. Using the quasiclassical Kadanoff-Baym equation, we show that this instability is absent when non-Markovian effects are taken into account. We also analyze the long-time relaxation dynamics at strong-couplin, and find a clear imprint of the non-Markovian nature of the dynamics: in an intermediate temperature range between the Debye frequency and the coupling strength, the relaxation rate becomes linear in temperature with Planckian slope, while the leading relaxation mode acquires a large imaginary component, producing strongly oscillatory decay. Our results imply that any instability which preempts superconductivity must arise from effects beyond MET, such as phonon softening or polaronic effects at finite electronic bandwidth. This shows that the characteristic phonon frequency is not a fundamental bound on $T_c$, and leaves open a route to higher $T_c$ in multi-orbital electron-phonon systems.

arXiv:2611.07014•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations
A finite coupling generalised master equation theory of the electronic relaxation among electronic eigen-states is presented. When converted into a closed time-convolution form (TCGME) for just diagonal elements of the density matrix, the theory is appreciably non-Markovian with the memory kernel summed partially up to the infinite order in the electron-phonon coupling. On soluble examples, it is shown that: (a), higher-order effects may influence even the lowest-order relaxation rates; (b), weakness of the finite coupling is not sufficient for reducing the theory to the standard lowest-order form; (c), the Markov approximation to the TCGME is in general misleading; (d), the initial condition term may appreciably influence the long-time development of the relaxation; (e), the theory is able to yield quasi-coherent effects (quantum beats) due to the electron coupling to the bath; (f), very effective tunnelling through barriers between equivalent sites appears with non-zero tunnelling currents starting from the second order in the electron-phonon coupling. Limitations from above (below) for the time (frequency) are found for the theory to reduce to the standard lowest-order form.
To lowest order in the electron-phonon coupling causing electron transitions among electronic eigenstates, the extent (on the time axis) of the memory functions wrs(t) governing the state population via the generalized master equations for the diagonal elements of the electron density matrix ρ(t) is independent of the coupling, being given by the decay time of the bath correlation functions. However, a typical reciprocal decay time of some higher-order contributions to wrs(t) has been found to be given by the reciprocal decay time of the off-diagonal elements of ρ(t), i.e. to be proportional to the square of the electron-phonon coupling constant. This feature makes such weakly damped contributions non-negligible even in lowest-order dynamics, as is illustrated on a dimer.
Fourth-order quantum master equations (FQMEs) are derived in both time nonlocal and local forms for a general system Hamiltonian, with new detailed expressions for the fourth-order kernel, where the bath correlation functions are explicitly decoupled from the system superoperators. Further simplifications can be made for the model of linearly coupled harmonic oscillator bath. Consideration of the high temperature Ohmic bath limit leads to a general Markovian FQME with compact forms of time independent superoperators. Two examples of this equation are then considered. For the system of a quantum particle in a continuous potential field, the equation reduces to a known form of the quantum Fokker–Planck equation, except for a fourth-order potential renormalization term that can be neglected only in the weak system-bath interaction regime. For a two-level system with off-diagonal coupling to the bath, fourth-order corrections do not alter the relaxation characteristics of the second-order equation and introduce additional coherence terms in the equations for the off-diagonal elements.
A reduced-density-matrix description is developed for coherent linear and non-linear electromagnetic interactions of quantized electronic systems in the presence of environmental decoherence and relaxation phenomena. Applications of interest include many-electron atomic systems and semiconductor materials. Time-domain (equation-of-motion) and frequency-domain (resolvent-operator) formulations of the reduced-density-matrix approach are developed in a unified manner. The general non-Markovian formulations provide a rigorous foundation for the systematic introduction of the commonly used Born (lowest-order perturbation-theory) and Markov (short-memory-time) approximations. A preliminary semiclassical perturbation-theory treatment of the electromagnetic interaction is introduced, based on a coupled hierarchy of relationships for the field components of the reduced density operator.
Abstract A reduced-density-matrix description is developed for coherent linear and non-linear electromagnetic interactions of quantized electronic systems in the presence of environmental decoherence and relaxation phenomena. Applications of interest include many-electron atomic systems and semiconductor materials. Time-domain (equation-of-motion) and frequency-domain (resolvent-operator) formulations of the reduced-density-matrix approach are developed in a unified manner. The general non-Markovian formulations provide a rigorous foundation for the systematic introduction of the commonly used Born (lowest-order perturbation-theory) and Markov (short-memory-time) approximations. A preliminary semiclassical perturbation-theory treatment of the electromagnetic interaction is introduced, based on a coupled hierarchy of relationships for the field components of the reduced density operator.
The present paper studies the formal aspects of the total-time-ordering-cumulant (TTOC) and the partial-time-ordering-cumulant (PTOC) relaxations of a quantum system, of few degrees of freedom, in weak interaction with a bath, both within and outside the Markovian limit. To this end, the general expressions connecting the matrix elements of the TTOC and PTOC relaxation superoperators with the bath correlation functions are determined. Special attention is paid to two particular cases: a system with a nonequidistant energy spectrum and a system with an equidistant energy spectrum. Discussions revolve mainly around the possibility of applying the secular approximation to the TTOC and PTOC master equations for the off-diagonal matrix elements of the reduced-density operator of the system.
We study the kinetic properties of Migdal-Eliashberg theory (MET) for electron-phonon interactions at strong coupling. Previously, the system was found to be dynamically unstable at large couplings within a Markovian quantum Boltzmann approximation. Using the quasiclassical Kadanoff-Baym equation, we show that this instability is absent when non-Markovian effects are taken into account. We also analyze the long-time relaxation dynamics at strong-couplin, and find a clear imprint of the non-Markovian nature of the dynamics: in an intermediate temperature range between the Debye frequency and the coupling strength, the relaxation rate becomes linear in temperature with Planckian slope, while the leading relaxation mode acquires a large imaginary component, producing strongly oscillatory decay. Our results imply that any instability which preempts superconductivity must arise from effects beyond MET, such as phonon softening or polaronic effects at finite electronic bandwidth. This shows that the characteristic phonon frequency is not a fundamental bound on TcT_cTc​, and leaves open a route to higher TcT_cTc​ in multi-orbital electron-phonon systems.