Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.07014

Stability and Relaxation of Electron-Phonon Systems at Strong Coupling

Noga Bashan, Erez Berg

Published Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the kinetic properties of Migdal-Eliashberg theory (MET) for electron-phonon interactions at strong coupling. Previously, the system was found to be dynamically unstable at large couplings within a Markovian quantum Boltzmann approximation. Using the quasiclassical Kadanoff-Baym equation, we show that this instability is absent when non-Markovian effects are taken into account. We also analyze the long-time relaxation dynamics at strong-couplin, and find a clear imprint of the non-Markovian nature of the dynamics: in an intermediate temperature range between the Debye frequency and the coupling strength, the relaxation rate becomes linear in temperature with Planckian slope, while the leading relaxation mode acquires a large imaginary component, producing strongly oscillatory decay. Our results imply that any instability which preempts superconductivity must arise from effects beyond MET, such as phonon softening or polaronic effects at finite electronic bandwidth. This shows that the characteristic phonon frequency is not a fundamental bound on $T_c$, and leaves open a route to higher $T_c$ in multi-orbital electron-phonon systems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.07014

Related papers

Relevance of phonon dynamics in strongly correlated systems coupled to phonons: Dynamical mean-field theory analysis

Giorgio Sangiovanni, Massimo Capone, Claudio Castellani

The properties of the electron-phonon interaction in the presence of a sizable electronic repulsion at finite doping are studied by investigating the metallic phase of the Hubbard-Holstein model with dynamical mean-field theory. Analyzing the quasiparticle weight at finite doping, we find that a large Coulomb repulsion reduces the effect of electron-phonon coupling at low energy, while this reduction is not present at high energy. The renormalization of the electron-phonon coupling induced by the Hubbard repulsion depends in a surprisingly strong and nontrivial way on the phonon frequency. Our results suggest that phonon might affect differently high-energy and low-energy properties and this, together with the effect of phonon dynamics, should be carefully taken into account when the effects of the electron-phonon interaction in a strongly correlated system, like the superconducting cuprates, are discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0512020•Physical Review B•Apr 21, 2006•42 citations

Higher-order effects in non-Markovian theory of electronic relaxation in interacting electron-phonon systems

Vladislav Čápek

A finite coupling generalised master equation theory of the electronic relaxation among electronic eigen-states is presented. When converted into a closed time-convolution form (TCGME) for just diagonal elements of the density matrix, the theory is appreciably non-Markovian with the memory kernel summed partially up to the infinite order in the electron-phonon coupling. On soluble examples, it is shown that: (a), higher-order effects may influence even the lowest-order relaxation rates; (b), weakness of the finite coupling is not sufficient for reducing the theory to the standard lowest-order form; (c), the Markov approximation to the TCGME is in general misleading; (d), the initial condition term may appreciably influence the long-time development of the relaxation; (e), the theory is able to yield quasi-coherent effects (quantum beats) due to the electron coupling to the bath; (f), very effective tunnelling through barriers between equivalent sites appears with non-zero tunnelling currents starting from the second order in the electron-phonon coupling. Limitations from above (below) for the time (frequency) are found for the theory to reduce to the standard lowest-order form.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Jul 10, 1987•7 citations

Damping of the collective amplitude mode in superconductors with strong electron-phonon coupling

Yuta Murakami, Philipp Werner, Naoto Tsuji +1 more

We study the effect of strong electron-phonon interactions on the damping of the Higgs amplitude mode in superconductors by means of nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field simulations of the Holstein model. In contrast to the BCS dynamics, we find that the damping of the Higgs mode strongly depends on the temperature, becoming faster as the system approaches the transition temperature. The damping at low temperatures is well described by a power law, while near the transition temperature the damping shows exponential-like behavior. We explain this crossover in terms of a temperature-dependent quasiparticle lifetime caused by the strong electron-phonon coupling, which smears the superconducting gap edge and makes the relaxation of the Higgs mode into quasiparticles more efficient at elevated temperatures. We also reveal that the phonon dynamics can soften the Higgs mode, which results in a slower damping.

arXiv:1604.08073•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 12, 2016•18 citations

Limits of Validity for Migdal-Eliashberg Theory: Role of Polarons and Bipolarons

Nikolay V. Prokof'ev, Ilya Esterlis, Ar. Abanov +1 more

It is widely believed that in the adiabatic limit the Fermi liquid state of an electron-phonon system, described by Migdal-Eliashberg theory, remains stable until the dressed phonon softens. Our variational and analytic analysis of the prototypical Holstein model shows that, in a wide range of fillings both in 3D and 2D, a polaronic/bipolaronic state emerges before phonon softening; at small filling in 3D this happens already at weak coupling. We show that a polaronic/bipolaronic state emerges, upon increasing coupling, via an intermediate pseudogap-type mixed state, in which some fermions retain Fermi liquid behavior, yet Luttinger's theorem is violated. At even larger couplings the density of states gradually approaches its form in the atomic limit.

arXiv:2604.14293•Physical Review Letters•Jul 29, 2026•4 citations

Multiple amplitude modes in strongly coupled phonon-mediated superconductors

Yuta Murakami, Philipp Werner, Naoto Tsuji +1 more

We study collective amplitude modes of the superconducting order parameter in strongly coupled electron-phonon systems described by the Holstein model using the nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory with the self-consistent Migdal approximation as an impurity solver. The frequency of the Higgs amplitude mode is found to coincide with the superconducting gap even in the strongly coupled (beyond BCS) regime. Besides the Higgs mode, we find another collective mode involving the dynamics of both the phonons and the superconducting order parameter. The frequency of this mode, higher than twice the renormalized phonon frequency in the superconducting phase, is shown to reflect a strong electron-mediated phonon-phonon interaction. Both of collective modes are predicted to contribute to time-resolved photoemission spectra after a strong laser pump as vertex corrections to produce resonance peaks, which allows one to distinguish them from quasiparticle excitations.

arXiv:1511.06105•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 8, 2016•45 citations

Thermalization Fronts in the Hubbard-Holstein Model

Antonio Picano, Marco Schirò

We investigate the nonequilibrium dynamics of the weak-coupling Hubbard-Holstein model after a sudden switch-on of the electron-phonon interaction within nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). Using the self-consistent Migdal approximation for the electron-phonon coupling together with second-order perturbation theory for the electron-electron interaction, we show that the relaxation dynamics exhibits a crossover between electron-dominated and phonon-dominated regimes, extending to finite Hubbard interaction the scenario previously identified in the Holstein model. To investigate the microscopic buildup of the thermal state, we analyze the dynamics within the Step-by-Step DMFT framework. In the plane of real time and DMFT iteration number, thermalization is marked by a sharp propagating front. This front appears in electronic observables already for weak quenches within the simulated time window, whereas the phononic sector exhibits a visible front only at sufficiently strong coupling. Thus, at weak coupling the local dispersionless phonons show a delayed onset of front formation, while near and beyond the crossover the front develops on comparable timescales in both the electronic and phononic sectors. Whenever both fronts are resolved, they propagate with the same velocity, showing that thermalization spreads coherently through the coupled electron-phonon system.

arXiv:2604.10775•Apr 12, 2026•1 citation
We study the kinetic properties of Migdal-Eliashberg theory (MET) for electron-phonon interactions at strong coupling. Previously, the system was found to be dynamically unstable at large couplings within a Markovian quantum Boltzmann approximation. Using the quasiclassical Kadanoff-Baym equation, we show that this instability is absent when non-Markovian effects are taken into account. We also analyze the long-time relaxation dynamics at strong-couplin, and find a clear imprint of the non-Markovian nature of the dynamics: in an intermediate temperature range between the Debye frequency and the coupling strength, the relaxation rate becomes linear in temperature with Planckian slope, while the leading relaxation mode acquires a large imaginary component, producing strongly oscillatory decay. Our results imply that any instability which preempts superconductivity must arise from effects beyond MET, such as phonon softening or polaronic effects at finite electronic bandwidth. This shows that the characteristic phonon frequency is not a fundamental bound on TcT_cTc​, and leaves open a route to higher TcT_cTc​ in multi-orbital electron-phonon systems.
The properties of the electron-phonon interaction in the presence of a sizable electronic repulsion at finite doping are studied by investigating the metallic phase of the Hubbard-Holstein model with dynamical mean-field theory. Analyzing the quasiparticle weight at finite doping, we find that a large Coulomb repulsion reduces the effect of electron-phonon coupling at low energy, while this reduction is not present at high energy. The renormalization of the electron-phonon coupling induced by the Hubbard repulsion depends in a surprisingly strong and nontrivial way on the phonon frequency. Our results suggest that phonon might affect differently high-energy and low-energy properties and this, together with the effect of phonon dynamics, should be carefully taken into account when the effects of the electron-phonon interaction in a strongly correlated system, like the superconducting cuprates, are discussed.
A finite coupling generalised master equation theory of the electronic relaxation among electronic eigen-states is presented. When converted into a closed time-convolution form (TCGME) for just diagonal elements of the density matrix, the theory is appreciably non-Markovian with the memory kernel summed partially up to the infinite order in the electron-phonon coupling. On soluble examples, it is shown that: (a), higher-order effects may influence even the lowest-order relaxation rates; (b), weakness of the finite coupling is not sufficient for reducing the theory to the standard lowest-order form; (c), the Markov approximation to the TCGME is in general misleading; (d), the initial condition term may appreciably influence the long-time development of the relaxation; (e), the theory is able to yield quasi-coherent effects (quantum beats) due to the electron coupling to the bath; (f), very effective tunnelling through barriers between equivalent sites appears with non-zero tunnelling currents starting from the second order in the electron-phonon coupling. Limitations from above (below) for the time (frequency) are found for the theory to reduce to the standard lowest-order form.
We study the effect of strong electron-phonon interactions on the damping of the Higgs amplitude mode in superconductors by means of nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field simulations of the Holstein model. In contrast to the BCS dynamics, we find that the damping of the Higgs mode strongly depends on the temperature, becoming faster as the system approaches the transition temperature. The damping at low temperatures is well described by a power law, while near the transition temperature the damping shows exponential-like behavior. We explain this crossover in terms of a temperature-dependent quasiparticle lifetime caused by the strong electron-phonon coupling, which smears the superconducting gap edge and makes the relaxation of the Higgs mode into quasiparticles more efficient at elevated temperatures. We also reveal that the phonon dynamics can soften the Higgs mode, which results in a slower damping.
It is widely believed that in the adiabatic limit the Fermi liquid state of an electron-phonon system, described by Migdal-Eliashberg theory, remains stable until the dressed phonon softens. Our variational and analytic analysis of the prototypical Holstein model shows that, in a wide range of fillings both in 3D and 2D, a polaronic/bipolaronic state emerges before phonon softening; at small filling in 3D this happens already at weak coupling. We show that a polaronic/bipolaronic state emerges, upon increasing coupling, via an intermediate pseudogap-type mixed state, in which some fermions retain Fermi liquid behavior, yet Luttinger's theorem is violated. At even larger couplings the density of states gradually approaches its form in the atomic limit.
We study collective amplitude modes of the superconducting order parameter in strongly coupled electron-phonon systems described by the Holstein model using the nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory with the self-consistent Migdal approximation as an impurity solver. The frequency of the Higgs amplitude mode is found to coincide with the superconducting gap even in the strongly coupled (beyond BCS) regime. Besides the Higgs mode, we find another collective mode involving the dynamics of both the phonons and the superconducting order parameter. The frequency of this mode, higher than twice the renormalized phonon frequency in the superconducting phase, is shown to reflect a strong electron-mediated phonon-phonon interaction. Both of collective modes are predicted to contribute to time-resolved photoemission spectra after a strong laser pump as vertex corrections to produce resonance peaks, which allows one to distinguish them from quasiparticle excitations.
We investigate the nonequilibrium dynamics of the weak-coupling Hubbard-Holstein model after a sudden switch-on of the electron-phonon interaction within nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). Using the self-consistent Migdal approximation for the electron-phonon coupling together with second-order perturbation theory for the electron-electron interaction, we show that the relaxation dynamics exhibits a crossover between electron-dominated and phonon-dominated regimes, extending to finite Hubbard interaction the scenario previously identified in the Holstein model. To investigate the microscopic buildup of the thermal state, we analyze the dynamics within the Step-by-Step DMFT framework. In the plane of real time and DMFT iteration number, thermalization is marked by a sharp propagating front. This front appears in electronic observables already for weak quenches within the simulated time window, whereas the phononic sector exhibits a visible front only at sufficiently strong coupling. Thus, at weak coupling the local dispersionless phonons show a delayed onset of front formation, while near and beyond the crossover the front develops on comparable timescales in both the electronic and phononic sectors. Whenever both fronts are resolved, they propagate with the same velocity, showing that thermalization spreads coherently through the coupled electron-phonon system.