The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Relativity, Quantum Entanglement, Counterfactuals, and Causation
Luke Fenton-Glynn, Thomas Kroedel
Abstract
We investigate whether standard counterfactual analyses of causation (CACs) imply that the outcomes of space-like separated measurements on entangled particles are causally related. Although it has sometimes been claimed that standard CACs imply such a causal relation, we argue that a careful examination of David Lewis’s influential counterfactual semantics casts doubt on this. We discuss ways in which Lewis’s semantics and standard CACs might be extended to the case of space-like correlations. 1 Introduction2 Measurement Outcomes and Counterfactual Analyses of Causation3 Lewis’s Analysis 1 of Counterfactuals (‘Asymmetry-by-Fiat’) 3.1 Analysis 1 3.2 A frame-relative reading of Analysis 1 3.3 Frame-invariant readings of Analysis 1 3.4 Discussion4 Lewis’s Analysis 2 of Counterfactuals (‘Closest Worlds’)5 Extending the Everyday Concept of Cause6 Conclusion