A concrete example is given which shows that the one-dimensional Ising and Gaussian model universality classes do not exhaust the universality classes of the one-dimensional continuous-spin Ising model. Thus the normal universality hypothesis fails in this simple, readily analyzable model.
An extension of the critical-phenomena universality hypothesis assumed previously to be valid for less singular terms is shown to be invalid. A reformulated extension of the universality hypothesis is found to be valid exactly for the spin-1/2 Ising model on the triangular, square, and honeycomb lattices, and, further support is supplied by high- and low-temperature expansions for the susceptibility. The extension fails however for the Ising model on the kagome\r{} lattice and for the spherical model. At present there are insufficient data to test the extended principle for other models or for experimental systems.
Following numerous earlier studies, extensive simulations and analyses were made on the continuous interaction distribution Gaussian model and the discrete bimodal interaction distribution Ising spin glass (ISG) models in two dimensions [Lundow and Campbell, Phys. Rev. E 93, 022119 (2016)1539-375510.1103/PhysRevE.93.022119]. Here we further analyze the bimodal and Gaussian data together with data on two other continuous interaction distribution two-dimensional ISG models, the uniform and the Laplacian models, and three other discrete interaction distribution models, a diluted bimodal model, an "antidiluted" model, and a more exotic symmetric Poisson model. Comparisons between the three continuous distribution models show that not only do they share the same exponent η≡0 but that to within the present numerical precision they share the same critical exponent ν also, and so lie in a single universality class. On the other hand the critical exponents of the four discrete distribution models are not the same as those of the continuous distributions, and the present data strongly indicate that they differ from one discrete distribution model to another. This is evidence that discrete distribution ISG models in two dimensions have nonzero values of the critical exponent η and do not lie in a single universality class.
An extended universality hypothesis is proposed for critical phenomena in simple systems. The hypothesis implies the invariance of VX=gXlXnXqXKCX, where qX is the coordination number, KCX is the dimensionless inverse critical temperature, and nX, gX, and lX are the universality scale factors. VX is an exact invariant for the two-dimensional S=21 Ising model and invariant to high precision for several three-dimensional models. For the spherical model, however, lXVX is an exact invariant.
Ising spin-glass models with bimodal, Gaussian, uniform, and Laplacian interaction distributions in dimension five are studied through detailed numerical simulations. The data are analyzed in both the finite-size scaling regime and the thermodynamic limit regime. It is shown that the values of critical exponents and of dimensionless observables at criticality are model dependent. Models in a single universality class have identical values for each of these critical parameters, so Ising spin-glass models in dimension five with different interaction distributions each lie in different universality classes. This result confirms conclusions drawn from measurements in dimension four and dimension two.