Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Solid state

Extended universality of the Ising model

Douglas S. Ritchie, Donald D. Betts

Published Apr 1, 1975• 35 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An extension of the critical-phenomena universality hypothesis assumed previously to be valid for less singular terms is shown to be invalid. A reformulated extension of the universality hypothesis is found to be valid exactly for the spin-1/2 Ising model on the triangular, square, and honeycomb lattices, and, further support is supplied by high- and low-temperature expansions for the susceptibility. The extension fails however for the Ising model on the kagome\r{} lattice and for the spherical model. At present there are insufficient data to test the extended principle for other models or for experimental systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.11.2559

Related papers

Critical parameters and universal amplitude ratios of two-dimensional spin-SIsing models using high- and low-temperature expansions

P. Butera, M. Comi, Anthony John Guttmann

For the study of Ising models of general spin S on the square lattice, we have combined our recently extended high-temperature expansions with the low-temperature expansions derived some time ago by Enting, Guttmann, and Jensen. We have computed various critical parameters and improved the estimates of others. Moreover, the properties of hyperscaling and of universality (spin-S independence) of exponents and of various dimensionless amplitude combinations have been verified accurately. Assuming the validity of the lattice-lattice scaling, from our estimates of critical amplitudes for the square lattice we have also obtained estimates of the corresponding amplitudes for the spin-S Ising model on the triangular, honeycomb, and kagom\'e lattices.

arXiv:hep-lat/0302010•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 5, 2003•12 citations

Susceptibility amplitudes for the two-dimensional Ising model

Anthony John Guttmann

The recent critical amplitude calculation of Barouch, McCoy, and Wu for the susceptibility of the Ising model on a square lattice is extended to yield amplitudes for the triangular, honeycomb, and kagom\'e lattices. The extension assumes the validity of the generalized law of corresponding states---as first postulated by Betts, Guttmann, and Joyce---for the two-dimensional Ising model.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Jun 1, 1974•14 citations

One—Scale-Factor Universality for Critical Phenomena

Donald D. Betts, Douglas S. Ritchie

An extended universality hypothesis is proposed for critical phenomena in simple systems. The hypothesis implies the invariance of ${V}_{X}=\frac{{n}_{X}{q}_{X}{{K}_{C}}^{X}}{{g}_{X}{l}_{X}}$, where ${q}_{X}$ is the coordination number, ${{K}_{C}}^{X}$ is the dimensionless inverse critical temperature, and ${n}_{X}$, ${g}_{X}$, and ${l}_{X}$ are the universality scale factors. ${V}_{X}$ is an exact invariant for the two-dimensional $S=\frac{1}{2}$ Ising model and invariant to high precision for several three-dimensional models. For the spherical model, however, $\frac{{V}_{X}}{{l}_{X}}$ is an exact invariant.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 31, 1975•3 citations

Updated tests of scaling and universality for spin-spin correlations in the two- and three- dimensional spin- S Ising models using high-temperature expansions

P. Butera, M. Comi

We have extended, from order 12 through order 25, the high-temperature series expansions (in zero magnetic field) for the spin-spin correlations of the spin-$S$ Ising models on the square, simple-cubic and body-centered-cubic lattices. On the basis of this large set of data, we confirm accurately the validity of the scaling and universality hypotheses by resuming several tests which involve the correlation function, its moments and the exponential or the second-moment correlation lengths.

arXiv:hep-lat/0406035•Physical Review B•May 19, 2004•9 citations

Critical universality and hyperscaling revisited for Ising models of general spin using extended high-temperature series

P. Butera, M. Comi

We have extended through ${\ensuremath{\beta}}^{23}$ the high-temperature expansion of the second field derivative of the susceptibility for Ising models of general spin, with nearest-neighbor interactions, on the simple cubic and the body-centered cubic lattices. Moreover, the expansions for the nearest-neighbor correlation function, the susceptibility, and the second correlation moment have been extended up to ${\ensuremath{\beta}}^{25}.$ Taking advantage of these new data, we can improve the accuracy of direct estimates of critical exponents and of hyperuniversal combinations of critical amplitudes such as the renormalized four-point coupling ${g}_{r}$ or the quantity usually denoted by ${R}_{\ensuremath{\xi}}^{+}.$ In particular, we obtain $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1.2371(1),$ $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.6299(2),$ ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{4}=4.3647(20),$ ${g}_{r}=1.404(3),$ and ${R}_{\ensuremath{\xi}}^{+}=0.2668(5).$ We have used a variety of series extrapolation procedures and, in some of the analyses, we have assumed that the leading correction-to-scaling exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$ is universal and roughly known. We have also verified, to high precision, the validity of the hyperscaling relation and of the universality property both with regard to the lattice structure and to the value of the spin.

arXiv:hep-lat/0112049•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 2, 2002•99 citations

Spin- S Ising susceptibility on the triangular lattice

J. P. Van Dyke, William J. Camp

The high-temperature susceptibility of the spin-$S$ Ising model on the triangular net is analyzed as a function of $S$ using tenth-order high-temperature series expansions. In particular the spin dependence of the critical temperature and the amplitude of the dominant singularity are obtained by assuming a universal value $\ensuremath{\gamma}=\frac{7}{4}$ for the critical exponent of the susceptibility. The results, for the critical temperature particularly, provide a valuable guidepost in judging the convergence of recent nonlinear renormalization-group calculations for these models.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Aug 1, 1975•2 citations
An extension of the critical-phenomena universality hypothesis assumed previously to be valid for less singular terms is shown to be invalid. A reformulated extension of the universality hypothesis is found to be valid exactly for the spin-1/2 Ising model on the triangular, square, and honeycomb lattices, and, further support is supplied by high- and low-temperature expansions for the susceptibility. The extension fails however for the Ising model on the kagome\r{} lattice and for the spherical model. At present there are insufficient data to test the extended principle for other models or for experimental systems.
For the study of Ising models of general spin S on the square lattice, we have combined our recently extended high-temperature expansions with the low-temperature expansions derived some time ago by Enting, Guttmann, and Jensen. We have computed various critical parameters and improved the estimates of others. Moreover, the properties of hyperscaling and of universality (spin-S independence) of exponents and of various dimensionless amplitude combinations have been verified accurately. Assuming the validity of the lattice-lattice scaling, from our estimates of critical amplitudes for the square lattice we have also obtained estimates of the corresponding amplitudes for the spin-S Ising model on the triangular, honeycomb, and kagom\'e lattices.
An extended universality hypothesis is proposed for critical phenomena in simple systems. The hypothesis implies the invariance of VX=nXqXKCXgXlX{V}_{X}=\frac{{n}_{X}{q}_{X}{{K}_{C}}^{X}}{{g}_{X}{l}_{X}}VX​=gX​lX​nX​qX​KC​X​, where qX{q}_{X}qX​ is the coordination number, KCX{{K}_{C}}^{X}KC​X is the dimensionless inverse critical temperature, and nX{n}_{X}nX​, gX{g}_{X}gX​, and lX{l}_{X}lX​ are the universality scale factors. VX{V}_{X}VX​ is an exact invariant for the two-dimensional S=12S=\frac{1}{2}S=21​ Ising model and invariant to high precision for several three-dimensional models. For the spherical model, however, VXlX\frac{{V}_{X}}{{l}_{X}}lX​VX​​ is an exact invariant.
We have extended, from order 12 through order 25, the high-temperature series expansions (in zero magnetic field) for the spin-spin correlations of the spin-SSS Ising models on the square, simple-cubic and body-centered-cubic lattices. On the basis of this large set of data, we confirm accurately the validity of the scaling and universality hypotheses by resuming several tests which involve the correlation function, its moments and the exponential or the second-moment correlation lengths.
We have extended through ${\ensuremath{\beta}}^{23}$ the high-temperature expansion of the second field derivative of the susceptibility for Ising models of general spin, with nearest-neighbor interactions, on the simple cubic and the body-centered cubic lattices. Moreover, the expansions for the nearest-neighbor correlation function, the susceptibility, and the second correlation moment have been extended up to ${\ensuremath{\beta}}^{25}.$ Taking advantage of these new data, we can improve the accuracy of direct estimates of critical exponents and of hyperuniversal combinations of critical amplitudes such as the renormalized four-point coupling gr{g}_{r}gr​ or the quantity usually denoted by ${R}_{\ensuremath{\xi}}^{+}.$ In particular, we obtain $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1.2371(1),$ $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.6299(2),$ ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{4}=4.3647(20),$ gr=1.404(3),{g}_{r}=1.404(3),gr​=1.404(3), and ${R}_{\ensuremath{\xi}}^{+}=0.2668(5).$ We have used a variety of series extrapolation procedures and, in some of the analyses, we have assumed that the leading correction-to-scaling exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$ is universal and roughly known. We have also verified, to high precision, the validity of the hyperscaling relation and of the universality property both with regard to the lattice structure and to the value of the spin.
The high-temperature susceptibility of the spin-SSS Ising model on the triangular net is analyzed as a function of SSS using tenth-order high-temperature series expansions. In particular the spin dependence of the critical temperature and the amplitude of the dominant singularity are obtained by assuming a universal value $\ensuremath{\gamma}=\frac{7}{4}$ for the critical exponent of the susceptibility. The results, for the critical temperature particularly, provide a valuable guidepost in judging the convergence of recent nonlinear renormalization-group calculations for these models.