Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Sudden Replacement of a Mirror by a Detector in Cavity QED: Are Photons Counted Immediately?

H. Fearn, Richard J. Cook, Peter W. Milonni

Published Feb 20, 1995• 18 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We consider an excited atom in a cavity such that spontaneous emission is inhibited, and address the question of whether a sudden replacement of one of the cavity mirrors by a detector can result in a photon count immediately or only after some retardation time. The feasibility of an experiment of this type has led to considerable discussion as to its outcome. Following a brief summary of the conflicting arguments, we show that it is possible to count a photon immediately following the substitution of a photodetector for a mirror.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.74.1327

Related papers

Experimental detection of photons emitted during inhibited spontaneous emission

David A. Branning, Alan L. Migdall, Paul G. Kwiat

We present an experimental realization of a "sudden mirror replacement" thought experiment, in which a mirror that is inhibiting spontaneous emission is quickly replaced by a photodetector. The question is, can photons be counted immediately, or only after a retardation time that allows the emitter to couple to the changed modes of the cavity, and for light to propagate to the detector? Our results, obtained with a parametric downconverter, are consistent with the cavity QED prediction that photons can be counted immediately, and are in conflict with the retardation time prediction.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 26, 2007•1 citation

Mirror, mirror, on the wall – is the photon there at all?

Jonathan P. Dowling

One of the most curious predictions of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is the suppression of spontaneous emission from an excited atom sitting between two parallel mirrors. Although this effect has been measured experimentally and calculated from full QED theory, there are two different interpretations of what actually happens – a partially quantum mechanical explanation in which both the atom and the radiation field are quantized, and a semiclassical interpretation in which the radiation field is treated classically. While both viewpoints provide an intuitive explanation of the effect, they seem to yield conflicting answers to the question: what happens if one of the mirrors is suddenly replaced by a photodetector?

Physics World•May 1, 1995•1 citation

Frustrated Two-Photon Creation in a Time-Dependent Cavity

David A. Branning, Luigi Accardi, Guillaume Adenier +5 more

In the process of parametric downconversion, a high‐energy photon is annihilated to create a pair of lower‐energy photons within a nonlinear dielectric material. It was shown some years ago that this process can be modified by quantum interference, by reflecting the high‐energy and low‐energy light back into the dielectric. The suppression or enhancement of the downconversion rate is analogous to the phenomenon of inhibited spontaneous emission that occurs when an excited atom is placed in a cavity whose allowed modes cannot support the spontaneous emission. In this case, the atom remains excited—but then, how does it interact with the cavity? If the cavity mirror were replaced by a detector, could photons be counted immediately, or only after some time delay? Our experiment uses spontaneous downconversion, a 2‐m long cavity, and a fast optical switch to obtain the answer.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2009•1 citation

Time-Dependent Inhibited Spontaneous Emission

David A. Branning, Y. H. Shin, Sarthak Khanal +1 more

The spontaneous emission rate of photon pairs in a parametric downconverter can be inhibited by a cavity mirror. Using a fast switch, we detect photons within the cavity during times when the emission was inhibited.

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Visible spontaneous emission by atoms in an optical resonator

Daniel J. Heinzen, James Childs, Michael S. Feld

Recently, we observed enhancement and inhibition of visible spontaneous emission by atoms in a confocal resonator.1 In these experiments, the partial emission rate of the atom into the resonator modes is modified by a factor of 1/(1 − R), where R is the mirror reflectivity. The change in the total spontaneous emission rate is proportional to the solid angle ΔΩ subtended by the mirrors; the change was small (+1.6%, −0.5%) because ΔΩ ≈ 0.04 sr was small. Currently we are conducting experiments in which atoms are placed in a concentric resonator of large solid angle ΔΩ ≈ 3.6 sr and finesse of ~10. We estimate that a 30% decrease and 300% increase should be observable in the total spontaneous emission rate, when the resonator is tuned off or on-resonance, respectively. Results of this new experiment are presented. In addition to studying spontaneous processes, one can also consider the stimulated emission which occurs when a cavity field builds up which contains more than one photon. We have formulated a model which describes both the spontaneous and stimulated emission by the atom into the cavity and clarifies the relationship between enhanced spontaneous emission and stimulated emission.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1987•0 citations

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics

S. Haroche, Daniel Kleppner

Ever since Einstein demonstrated that spontaneous emission must occur if matter and radiation are to achieve thermal equilibrium, physicists have generally believed that excited atoms inevitably radiate. Spontaneous emission is so fundamental that it is usually regarded as an inherent property of matter. This view, however, overlooks the fact that spontaneous emission is not a property of an isolated atom but of an atom-vacuum system. The most distinctive feature of such emission, irreversibility, comes about because an infinity of vacuum states is available to the radiated photon. If these states are modified—for instance, by placing the excited atom between mirrors or in a cavity—spontaneous emission can be greatly inhibited or enhanced.

Physics Today•Jan 1, 1989•743 citations
We consider an excited atom in a cavity such that spontaneous emission is inhibited, and address the question of whether a sudden replacement of one of the cavity mirrors by a detector can result in a photon count immediately or only after some retardation time. The feasibility of an experiment of this type has led to considerable discussion as to its outcome. Following a brief summary of the conflicting arguments, we show that it is possible to count a photon immediately following the substitution of a photodetector for a mirror.
We present an experimental realization of a "sudden mirror replacement" thought experiment, in which a mirror that is inhibiting spontaneous emission is quickly replaced by a photodetector. The question is, can photons be counted immediately, or only after a retardation time that allows the emitter to couple to the changed modes of the cavity, and for light to propagate to the detector? Our results, obtained with a parametric downconverter, are consistent with the cavity QED prediction that photons can be counted immediately, and are in conflict with the retardation time prediction.
One of the most curious predictions of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is the suppression of spontaneous emission from an excited atom sitting between two parallel mirrors. Although this effect has been measured experimentally and calculated from full QED theory, there are two different interpretations of what actually happens – a partially quantum mechanical explanation in which both the atom and the radiation field are quantized, and a semiclassical interpretation in which the radiation field is treated classically. While both viewpoints provide an intuitive explanation of the effect, they seem to yield conflicting answers to the question: what happens if one of the mirrors is suddenly replaced by a photodetector?
In the process of parametric downconversion, a high‐energy photon is annihilated to create a pair of lower‐energy photons within a nonlinear dielectric material. It was shown some years ago that this process can be modified by quantum interference, by reflecting the high‐energy and low‐energy light back into the dielectric. The suppression or enhancement of the downconversion rate is analogous to the phenomenon of inhibited spontaneous emission that occurs when an excited atom is placed in a cavity whose allowed modes cannot support the spontaneous emission. In this case, the atom remains excited—but then, how does it interact with the cavity? If the cavity mirror were replaced by a detector, could photons be counted immediately, or only after some time delay? Our experiment uses spontaneous downconversion, a 2‐m long cavity, and a fast optical switch to obtain the answer.
Recently, we observed enhancement and inhibition of visible spontaneous emission by atoms in a confocal resonator.1 In these experiments, the partial emission rate of the atom into the resonator modes is modified by a factor of 1/(1 − R), where R is the mirror reflectivity. The change in the total spontaneous emission rate is proportional to the solid angle ΔΩ subtended by the mirrors; the change was small (+1.6%, −0.5%) because ΔΩ ≈ 0.04 sr was small. Currently we are conducting experiments in which atoms are placed in a concentric resonator of large solid angle ΔΩ ≈ 3.6 sr and finesse of ~10. We estimate that a 30% decrease and 300% increase should be observable in the total spontaneous emission rate, when the resonator is tuned off or on-resonance, respectively. Results of this new experiment are presented. In addition to studying spontaneous processes, one can also consider the stimulated emission which occurs when a cavity field builds up which contains more than one photon. We have formulated a model which describes both the spontaneous and stimulated emission by the atom into the cavity and clarifies the relationship between enhanced spontaneous emission and stimulated emission.
Ever since Einstein demonstrated that spontaneous emission must occur if matter and radiation are to achieve thermal equilibrium, physicists have generally believed that excited atoms inevitably radiate. Spontaneous emission is so fundamental that it is usually regarded as an inherent property of matter. This view, however, overlooks the fact that spontaneous emission is not a property of an isolated atom but of an atom-vacuum system. The most distinctive feature of such emission, irreversibility, comes about because an infinity of vacuum states is available to the radiated photon. If these states are modified—for instance, by placing the excited atom between mirrors or in a cavity—spontaneous emission can be greatly inhibited or enhanced.